Gloriously vague, but not dismissable, Sandy’s views on JTHJ

Saw the film today at Inox, was nearly 55-60 per cent full. The feeling I have is that the film is doing reasonably well, but clearly is no blockbuster success.

Personally I quite liked the film and I believe it will age well. I thought Shah Rukh was wonderful, very consistent and in character throughtout. This is one thing I have to hand him compared to the other Khans. As an actor I believe he has been the most effective and he tends to pitch his characters correctly, something which Aamir has not managed to do all the time.

The story too worked for me. I didnt find it puerile as some others did…perhaps my expectations were lower. I found the story perfectly plausible, but was let down severely by having a weak actress in the lead. Now the central love story required passionate lovers – no matter what the makers tried – making Kat gyrate, having her wear off shoulders, innumerable smooches, she cannot elicit the slightest bit of oomph. That’s the problem here. Zero sexuality and chemistry…and this is no fault of SRK. This weakens the premise a lot. When Kat makes a re entry, and the couple reunites it should have given the audience goosebumps (remember Amitabh-Rekha in Silsila, Rishi-Sri in Chandni, Ash-Salman in Hum Dil, or SRK-Kajol in DDLJ) . That doesn’t happen because Kat is incredibly dull as an actress. She looks beautiful of course but is very listless. This is felt most in scenes where Anushka and she share screen time. The former’s performance throbs with life, and though she’s getting repetitive and Im no fan of her overt smugness, Anushka knows how to act, how to say her dialogues..and pull off her role with elan.

I didnt mind the coincidences so much. It doesn’t outrage your sense of logic any more than the average 70s Bolllywood film does. I found Fanaa a bit more incredulous in fact. JTHJ stays engaging throughout and there is always the curiosity to know what will happen next. The most admirable aspect of the film is SRK’s character. Within the span of the film his role still remains a bit shadowy, but there is the right illusion of depth to his character. JTHJ actually has a story that could well have been a novel, because there seems to be a lot in the characters and situations that is left unsaid. For example the crucial parting scene and its strange circumstances. It might have seemed quite plausible if one read it in a book, as much of the happenings are in the characters’ minds! There is complexity befitting a book. As a film, there are limitations and not everything gets executed well. More explaination was needed about SRK leaving too. So the film kind of seems a bit ambigious. Continue reading

Sandy’s Review Of The Dirty Picture

The Dirty Picture

Starring: Vidya Balan, Naseeruddin Shah, Emraan Hashmi, Tusshar Kapoor

Director: Milan Luthria

By Sandhya Iyer

Ekta Kapoor and Milan Luthria, as producer and director respectively, get many things right about ‘The Dirty Picture’. Firstly, this was a smart subject to chose. When you make a bio pic on Silk Smitha, automatically a large part of the film’s screen time can legitimately belong to the lead’s heaving, bountiful breasts, that are captured in all its glory through its running time. Vidya Balan’s casting is another master-stroke. The actress, though a very attractive personality, has never been viewed as a sex symbol., and with her roles in ‘Paa’ and ‘Parineeta’, she’s always had a halo of respectability around her. ‘The Dirty Picture’ subverts this. So as soon as the promos came on television and people knew Vidya was playing Silk, gyrating lustily in a low-cut blouse and skirt to Bappi Lahiri’s blazing chart-buster, ‘Oo La La… Oo La La’, the public were on board from that minute.

‘The Dirty Picture’, for a good one hour, is a complete cracker of a film. It dodges well what could have been a potential pitfall. Normally filmmakers have no clue how to use a southern setting without compromising on the language that the characters speak. Here, the film does not transfer its 80s movie setting from Madras to Mumbai to justify use of Hindi. It keeps a Southern setting, certain names are Tamil etc, but there’s no great fuss. Continue reading

The Dark Room and The World Of Nagaraj – Share your favourite story by R K Narayan

http://sandyi.blogspot.com/2011/10/r-k-narayans-dark-room-and-world-of.html

Very few readers will dispute the talent that R K Narayan was. He was the first Indian writer in English to acquire such a name for himself both among native as well as foreigners readers.
V. S Naipaul has written how his image of India was entirely shaped by reading R K Narayan’s books and all that happens in Malgudi, the fictional small-town in South India that the author set his stories in. His tales came with a parochial delight, yet encompassed a world of human emotions and characters. This was enchanting as much as it was universal in appeal.
Still, every now and then one hears of a not-so-flattering comment about Narayan’s prose. At times it cannot be completely dismissed as it comes from say a Shashi Tharoor who in his wonderful book on his literary passions, Bookless In Baghdad writers candidly about Narayan’s weaknesses calling his style ‘flat and monotonous’
Tharoor writes, “Some of my friends felt I was wrong to focus on language – a writerly concern – and lose sight of the stories, which in many ways had an appeal that transcended language. But my point was that such pedestrian writing diminished Narayan’s stories, undermined the characters, trivialised their concerns.”

It’s not completely unfair to say that Narayan’s writing had its flaws, but hardly anything so serious to make it any less enjoyable. His English was perfectly good by the standards of the day. In any case, one gets a perfect sense of what Narayan might want to convey.

Narayan’s writing for most part remains simple, yet profound, a feat not as easily achievable as he makes it look. His trilogy, Malgudi Days, The Bachelor Of Arts and The English Teacher are largely autobiographical, but also offer some of the most poignant and wonderful narratives. His stories bristle with the nestling beauty of warm domestic scenes. His characters grapple with seemingly trivial concerns, but to them, these are profoundly impacting and life-altering things. Continue reading

Sandy’s review of Mausam

An uninspiring Beauty

Mausam

Starring: Shahid Kapur, Sonam Kapoor, Aditi Sharma

Director: Pankaj Kapur

Stars: **1/2

Much was expected from Pankaj Kapur, given his own credentials as an intense actor and the meaningful films he’s been a part of. The promos of Mausam, though a bit affected, did evoke some curiosity, given that the film seemed to have been put together with a fair bit of effort, ensuring that it is a treat for the eyes. But this is one of the prime reasons for the film to also become unbearable to watch after a point.

Only a psychologist can perhaps analyse why Kapur might be so obsessed with framing pretty frames all the time. His whole focus seems to be to make a good-looking film. Even in scenes of deaths at graveyards, which are intended to evoke sadness, the director’s camera pans on dainty little flowers around. He seems to love having carriages, horses and flower beds everywhere. Needlessly, the film travels to Scotland, giving way to a bunch of implausible situations. The only rational explanation for this is because Kapur wanted to shoot in a beautiful place. Logically it makes no sense. Continue reading

Vital or fatal – Which way will ‘Ra. One’ go?

http://expressbuzz.com/entertainment/news/vital-or-fatal-which-way-will-%E2%80%98ra-one%E2%80%99-go/314217.html

Sandhya Iyer
Express News Service
Last Updated : 16 Sep 2011 01:27:19 PM IST

It happens once or twice in a decade that one witnesses a real epic, dream project. These ventures are generally so high-budget and so crazily-hyped that while under production they are viewed with a mix of curiosity, hope and skepticism.

As can be expected, a dream project always involves a top star or a veteran filmmaker, attempting something grand and unforgettable. It’s natural that every famous artist in his lifetime should desire to create an extraordinary piece of work, that posterity can remember him for. Continue reading

The Lion King (3 D) review

Sandhya Iyer

There is a great deal of nostalgia one attaches with The Lion King – Walt Disney’s animation film of 1994 that was hailed as an instant classic when it released. Over the years, the spell-binding music, story, characters have all became part of cinematic lore. The movie now returns with a 3 D makeover, and if this ends up introducing a fresh new generation to The Lion King – the effort would be completely worth it.

All it takes are a couple of scenes for a first-time watcher to realise he/she’s watching a great film. The rapier sharp wit, the nuanced characters, the simple but universal story-line — all make a deep and profound impression. Continue reading

Whimpers more than roars – Sandy’s review of Singham

Singham

Director: Rohit Shetty
Starring: Ajay Devgan, Kajal Aggarwal, Prakash Raj, Anant Jog, Sachin Khedekar, Sonali Kulkarni
Rating: **

Hindi
Sandhya Iyer

Even considering that South remakes are in vogue and have given
Bollywood huge hits by way of Ghajini and Wanted, the announcement of Singham did seem somewhat odd. The Tamil film that starred Suriya in the lead (he was the hero in the Ghajini original as well) was purely a showcase for the lead actor who has become a rage down South in the last few years. As is the case with such endeavours where the star is the point of the film, the Tamil Singham peddled an extremely workaday story that somehow passed muster thanks to the lead star’s appeal and a fairly well-pitched romantic track. But barring that, it is just too unremarkable a film to warrant a remake. Which is why one was curious to see how Rohit Shetty, who started his career with an actioner (Zameer – decent) before his Golmaal series’ success, would make it worthwhile.

Now I believe any good film- whether it aims at classes or masses or both – must maintain a sense of plausibility to be truly enjoyable. If situations get too trite or exaggerated or facile, they slowly start to disengage. That is one of the central problems with Singham. It starts off with an incident of a police inspector shooting himself because he gets falsely victimised. Now this is a regular situation in a film. However, it is treated in such a cliché ridden manner – the kind where notes are stuffed into his car and everyone shouts ‘thief’ thief’ It’s easy to guess from some of these early scenes that Rohit Shetty’s version is not going to aim for the least bit of subtlety or originality. It tries to makes a virtue of all that is formulaic and unimaginative.
The Southern version was paying obeisance to its leading man in every shot, capturing his every moving hair in slow motion and morphing his face literally into that of a lion while he took on the baddies. Thankfully, Shetty and his writers act a bit saner. But the hero is still treated with much reverance in any case. There’s a grand scene where Devgan emerges from the waters, with temples and lights in the backdrop with chantings, followed by a Dabangg style song where random things go on, establishing what a regal lion he is. And just so that you don’t miss the title’s reference, the hero and the dancers make a strange claw-movement with their hands. There are plenty of such unintentionally funny moments in the film. Continue reading

Two beautiful songs from Shreya Goshal. Singham and Nauka Dubi

The first is from Singham. Music is by Marathi composers Atul-Ajay who are extremely popular after their score for Natrang – the National award winning film. This song is so lilting and the antara is one of the most sweetest Ive heard in a long time. And Shreya is easily the nightingale of this generation.

The second song is one of my favourites. It is from Nauka Dubi (Kashmakash), Manwa. Such pathos and melody.

zithromax chlamydia 500mg nexium 40mg n28 cialis 28 5 mg lexapro 80 mgs 10 mg brand cialis doxycycline 50 mg chlamydia generic levitra alcohol viagra 100mg apotheke xenical 120 mg funciona amoxil 875 mg tablet cialis 5 mg buy prednisone 5 mg dog harga nexium 40mg viagra pricing 50 mg liquid cialis online viagra online zoll kegunaan nexium 40 mg buy clomid citrate lasix 25 mg torrinomedica zithromax 500mg philippines buy 500 mg zithromax nolvadex kup online cialis 10mg preisvergleich tetracycline cheap cialis 20 mg yorum 500 mg generic viagra cheap cialis safe online viagra singapore 40mg levitra danger generic viagra compare doxycycline 100mg dose lasix cleaning 20 mg priligy australia buy celebrex 100 mg tablets generic viagra cheap 25 mg zoloft effective bactrim f 400mg phenergan dosage 25 mg amoxil tm 500 mg viagra 25mg boots generic viagra bkk doxycycline hyclate 1000mg xenical buy paypal generico do valtrex hydrochlorothiazide 12.5mg price take 2 levitra 10mg levitra 5 mg generico 20mg cialis erection lisinopril generic tablets cheap propecia prescription zoloft 12.5 mg artist fungsi glucophage 500 mg online viagra safe synthroid 50 mg comprar bactrim 40 mg 200 mg zoloft 100 mg levitra bucodispersable 10 mg prednisone christers 20 mg nexium 20 mg uses viagra generic tadalafil cheap professional cialis prix levitra 5mg propecia order online lasix cheap online xenical 120 mg posologie ordering metformin online cialis take 2 5mg prescription online viagra viagra 100mg fta 12 erythromycin 333 mg tab levitra online gambling cialis 20 mg yorumlari cheap cialis marbella prednisone 20 mg 5 days buy zithromax 1200 lisinopril abz 10mg buy 40 mg cialis viagra chicago buy cialis 20mg efeitos kamagra 100mg gb prednisone 10mg eczema 5mg cialis daily zovirax 400 mg tablet valtrex generic otc levitra online malaysia doxycycline 100mg pimples 2 cialis 5mg zithromax online ordering lisinopril 5 mg cena finax generic propecia cialis 20mg bestellen online viagra levitra generic viagra purchase 20 mg buspar pregnancy viagra 50mg dosage valtrex cheapest diflucan online shopping buy geniune viagra woman generic viagra online viagra buy turkiyede clomid 50mg valtrex buy canada australian online cialis buy prednisone without buy strattera cod doxycycline 200mg cost levitra generic cina generic propecia legal mail order cipro 150mg cheap viagra bugiardino lasix 25 mg zithromax azithromycin 500 mg buy cialis venezuela cheap cialis india prednisone 50 mg tablet generic clomid work cialis 2 5mg viagra 25 mg kaufen teva doxycycline 100mg lasix 150 mg injection zithromax 500mg preis cialis order uk generic priligy safe 20mg pink lisinopril online propranolol cheapest wellbutrin online online viagra legitimate canada cialis order cialis prijs 5mg zoloft berapa mg prezzo lasix 25 mg cialis 5 mg prices 25mg viagra experiences lisinopril 20 mg ratiopharm medication lisinopril 10 mg cialis tadalafil 10 mg half 50mg viagra viagra 50 mg erfahrungsberichte lisinopril buy europe cipro 500mg buy amoxil 250mg viagra professional online levitra generico 5 mg discount generic viagra kamagra online shop valtrex caplets 500mg levitra 10 mg bugiardino lasix online ordering lexapro 10 mg bijsluiter xenical 120 mg seattle kamagra gel 5mg viagra fiyati 25 mg strattera 50 mg buy 50 mg clomid cipla viagra 50 mg 150 mg canadan viagra lexapro 20 mg female Sale Levitra 10 mg cipro antibiotic 500 mg synthroid 0.125 mg viagra comparison online xenical online 120mg doxycycline 100mg sti cialis generic 40 mg. levitra 10 mg dosierung cheapest 5 mg cialis cheap cialis perfectpharmacyrx metformin bipolar disorder levitra generic discount order viagra trial doxycycline huc 100 mg cialis 5mg fta prednisone 20mg cancer amoxil bencard 500mg buy erythromycin 500mg buy viagra germany cheap clomid usa levitra 20mg nedir 5mgm cialis online rezepte viagra tetracycline antibiotics buy glucophage 500 mg vidal buying generic lexapro online clomid johannesburg celebrex generico genuine cialis online lexapro 5mg work 1000 mg cipro intravenous amoxil 250 mg syrup trustable generic viagra buy 200mg clomid levitra 180 pills online erythromycin 1000 mg db diflucan generic philippines strattera buy online buying cialis minnesota zoloft 100 mg classifications buy tetracycline 250 mg prednisone 20 mg nz prednisone 20 mg ingredients buying cialis dubai lasix 12.5mg cost erythromycin ec 250mg diflucan 150 mg reviews metformin mg doses cialis generica net cialis lilly 20mg costi cialis generico formula nexium 40mg buy clomid dbol cheap cialis 60mg alternative viagra online zithromax oral buy buy strattera cipla strattera generic dose safe buy cialis cipro 750 mg tab viagra dosage150 mg order viagra pakistan xenical buying buy levitra online 35008 lexapro not generic buy cipro india order diflucan online 25 mg dose zoloft buy metformin drug propecia generic 2013 price viagra online bali levitra 10mg women 1000 mg metformin pcos generic brazilian cialis prednisone 20mg effects generic viagra 100 synthroid brand generic cialis 10 mg confezioni phenergan 10mg dose cytotec online pharmacy doxycycline 50 mg cialis 2.5 mg sale viagra pills generics viagra to buy cipro xl mg nexium generic competition clomid 200 mg twins nolvadex online kopen cytotec tab 200 mg generic cialis erfahrung lexapro generico colombia nolvadex pct mg spain kamagra online usa generic viagra generic priligy cheap buy celebrex 200 mg legit generic viagra obat erythromycin 500 mg 200 mg generic viagra cialis online polska 500mg doxycycline dosage online viagra germany buy viagra pretoria generic zovirax cream 5 cialis cuantos mg order viagra spain tadalafi cialis 500mg cialis france online strattera 10 mg hartkapseln viagra 50mg.es viagra generic medication buy Cialis 60 indikasi metformin 500 mg generic cialis ed lisinopril tabs 5mg clomid tem generico levitra 5mg erfahrung buy cialis berlin viagra online philippine prednisone anxiety disorders lexapro 10mg. viagra buy israel celebrex celecoxib 200mg 20 mg levitra online augmentin 125 mg syrup medicamento wellbutrin 150 mg india viagra online cialis mg strength acheter cialis 2.5mg generic viagra forums 2011 nolvadex 20mg uk legit viagra online buy cialis europe levitra 10 mg generika pure viagra online canine 40mg prednisone generic viagra levitra levitra brand 20mg wellbutrin overdose mg cialis tablet 5mg lasix 40 mg rezeptfrei cialis 200 mg zithromax 1000 mg buy doxycycline hydrochloride 200mg fake cialis 100mg augmentin 625 mg syrup dosierung viagra 50 mg sc100 viagra generic prednisone watson 20 mg buy priligy china propecia online india clomid dose 25 mg cialis bayer 20 mg prospect viagra 50 mg buy viagra kansas hydrochlorothiazide order citalopram generic philippines viagra 100mg pills celebrex 200 mg prospect augmentin 625 mg davkovanie zithromax 500 mg uses celebrex generic walgreens viagra 100 mg bijsluiter augmentin cpr 500 mg cialis 80 mg tadalafil buy uk clomid order cheap valtrex strattera 80 mg coupon 2012 buy valtrex cheap buy bactrim ds harga levitra 20 mg viagra masculino generico lasix tbl 20mg fungsi celebrex 100 mg 30 mg prednisone works cialis online china posologia clomid 50mg 100mg viagra directions viagra 50 mg tabletas kamagra buy online lexapro 5mg week 3 clomid 150mg follistim cytotec 0 2 mg cialis 5mg medication online eczane viagra viagra online billig 10 mg cialis effectiveness prednisone ratiopharm 5 mg buy lasix mumbai buying viagra ebay cost 40 mg nexium metformin bp 500mg metformin denk 500 mg generic viagra ciple lexapro generic effective ordering bactrim online manly viagra generic pharex erythromycin 500 mg celebrex purchase online zovirax generic canada valtrex 500 mg posologia buy kamagra singapore medicamento levitra 10 mg cialis 30 mg paypal lexapro 2.5 mg dose viagra cheap 150 cytotec buy lexapro 10 mg breastfeeding generic 10mg levitra cialis 40mg cipla doxycycline 100mg indonesia strattera 18 mg price 36 hour cialis mg viagra onlinesouth africa strattera generic adderall cialis 20 mg prospect lasix 160 mg lp viagra order free augmentin generic walmart diflucan 150 mg composizione generics biz viagra 500 mgram viagra uk buy online cialis uso viagra 100mg xenical cheap online buy lasix online amoxil forte 250 mg buy propecia paypal lisinopril sandoz 30 mg generic zoloft 50mg nexium 20 mg subsitution cialis 20 mg verschreibungspflichtig medication levitra 10 mg phenergan 25 mg injection diflucan fluconazole buy lexapro for cheap viagra online fiable xenical 120 mg capsule propecia coupon online zithromax 600mg i lisinopril 10 mg pricing hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg daily 600 mg celebrex lasix 60 mg tablet viagra online lipitor generico viagra dejavu buy cheap nolvadex nexium 40 mg controindicazioni buying zithromax 1 gram levitra cheap uk buy viagra pill reliable propecia online generic lisinopril hct propecia dosage 0.25mg online brand levitra buy clomid germany viagra 100mg efeitos genuine cialis 20mg levitra 5 mg prezzo viagra dokter online buy zithromax capsules viagra hrvatska 200 mg effets cialis 5mg cheap viagra banglore zovirax 500 mg cialis cvs generic zithromax chlamydia 1000mg cheapest xenical australia viagra online lloyds prednisone 20 mg cost viagra tablets order generic cialis fedex prednisone 5 mg withdrawal tablet lasix 50 mg phenergan seizure disorder taking 200 mg viagra price lisinopril 40 mg triamterene hydrochlorothiazide 50 25 mg cheaper than lexapro zoloft 50mgs viagra philippines buy strattera 18 mg uk viagra online stockists 40mg cialis dosage viagra 0.25 mg alegro cialis generico dogana zithromax cheap canada buy doxycycline hydrochloride buy viagra manchester lisinopril 10mg coupon cialis 5mgm prices cialis super 20mg cialis 5mg bayer generic of prednisone cheap viagra 200mg assunzione levitra 10 mg 75 mg zoloft lot levitra original 10mg branded viagra 100mg nexium 40 mg pharmacy cheap kamagra jelly perrigo prednisone 10 mg wellbutrin cyclothymic disorder generic cialis rating diflucan 150 mg indications cialis online order levitra 10 mg paypal 225 mg synthroid canadian viagra 100mg online cheap viagra 600 mg wellbutrin xl cialis 20mg .ch prospecto nexium 40 mg obat valtrex 500 mg cheapest propecia online .30 prospect celebrex 100 mg cialis cheaper cialis generico 20 mgrs. clomid buy visa 80mg cialis flashback chewable viagra 100mg erythromycin 125mg 5ml wellbutrin 150 mg prezzo 1 cheap viagra buy generic strattera pill lisinopril 5mg diflucan 200 mg tablets metformin lich 1000mg strattera 80 mg generic buyers generic viagra levitra 20mg longevity cheap viagra mexico cialis 5mg czech cialis besy buy diflucan 150 mg directions generic levitra de taking 2 150 mg wellbutrin 1000 mg of tetracycline buy augmentin 625 metformin 500 mg fertility amoxil brand generic cialis generic fast online kamagra sales