Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image

NG | May 22, 2013

Scroll to top

Top



37 Comments

Kashmiri Girl Band Folds After Muslim Cleric Issues Fatwa


NEW DELHI — In Indian Kashmir, an all-girl rock band has called it quits after a Muslim cleric issued a fatwa calling on them to disband. Assurances of protection from the state government apparently failed to reassure the teenage girls.

The three high school girls had enthusiastically formed the rock band after winning an annual music contest held in the Kashmiri capital, Srinagar, in December. They called it “Praagaash”, which means from darkness to light. It was the Muslim majority state’s first all-girl music band.

But, it folded up a day after the chief Muslim cleric in Jammu and Kashmir, Bashiruddin Ahmad, said singing is un-Islamic and issued a fatwa calling for them to disband. His edict followed an online campaign of threats and hate messages targeting the teenage girls.

Amid the outcry which followed, the state’s chief minister, Omar Abdullah, extended assurances of police protection to the girls and hoped they would not allow a handful of “morons” to silence their music.

Politicians, artists and media across the country rallied to their support.

“We do hope that on this issue across the political spectrum in Jammu and Kashmir, there would be a degree of unanimity which would ensure that the freedom of speech and expression can be allowed to flourish without any curbs on it,” said Manish Tewari, the federal information and broadcasting minister.

The head of the opposition People’s Democratic Party in Kashmir, Mehbooba Mufti, says she is taken aback by the controversy because Kashmir boasts of a long line of successful women artists.

“Even I am surprised,” she admitted. “Kashmiris have admired their women singers.  We have great singers at this point of time and people really love their singing.  We have been listening to their songs all through our lives. This whole issue has kind of painted Kashmiris as if they are women haters, they live in some kind of stone age, which is contrary to what Kashmiris are, they are very emancipated.”

Mehbooba Mufti says the controversy is getting a lot of publicity.  She says following one religious ruling would only encourage further edicts.

“If we don’t put our foot down at this point of time, it has started with these three young girls. Tomorrow they will be dictating something else,” noted Mufti. “We need to stop it here. It is not about religion.”

The rock band initially also faced the ire of the separatist Hurriyat Conference in Kashmir, which said there is no room to nourish Western culture in the state. But, following the national outcry, it stepped back and said it had nothing to do with the fatwa.

Kashmir is a Muslim-majority state and hardline Islamists have tried to impose Islamic law since the onset of an anti-India insurgency in 1990. Last year, a Kashmiri religious group, the Jamaat-e-Islami, said tourists should follow a dress code and not move around in mini skirts and other objectionable dresses. It was largely ignored.

 

LINK – http://www.voanews.com/content/kashmiri-girl-band-folds-after-muslim-cleric-issues-fatwa/1597597.html

Comments

  1. rockie_Dabangg2

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

    I came to know about this news from one of my American office mate.
    This is next bad thing after the Delhi gang rape which is getting high visibility in US media.

    This really shows our country INDIA in bad light.

    —- :(

  2. rockie_Dabangg2

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

    Last year, a Kashmiri religious group, the Jamaat-e-Islami, said tourists should follow a dress code and not move around in mini skirts and other objectionable dresses. It was largely ignored.

    Lolzz…. :D

  3. rockie_Dabangg2

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

    Chief Muslim cleric in Jammu and Kashmir, Bashiruddin Ahmad, said singing is un-Islamic.

    —- Okay why did he suddenly realize this now??
    I mean this band is not the first time when any muslim is singing a song.

  4. rockie_Dabangg2

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

    http://news.yahoo.com/kashmir-.....59896.html

    Highlights …

    1) “They feel terribly scared and want an immediate end to this controversy once for all,” Mattoo said Tuesday. “First, the girls had decided to quit live performance due to an online hate campaign and concentrate on making an album. But after an edict by the government’s own cleric, these girls are saying goodbye to music.”

    2) The girl told the station that they respected the cleric’s decision because he was “more aware of our religion” and she pleaded with the media to stop reporting on the case.
    —- Now that is the fear talking .. :(

    3) Many commenters backed the girls, but others were abusive, calling them “sluts” and “prostitutes” and calling for them and their families to be expelled from the region.

  5. aravind_66

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

    can’t blame the girls for not speaking their mind….these a**holes made online threats about raping and beating them if they don’t stop singing….i mean WTF…???because of these nutcases millions of other innocent muslims are also put in a bad light….

  6. Superstar sam

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

    exactly & am completly agree with thiz fatwa.. Islam neither allow women to recite quran for women in loud voice in present of men bcoz hearing girl voice leads bad thought.. once u follow islam u should follow everysingle thng related to islam… Why crime rate is less in saudi arabia?? Bcoz of islamic law that states 1.girl should wear burkha.. 2. If u had illegal sex without marriage u should be killed. 3. If u drink wine(sharab) then 100 kodey(dnt knw eng word) 4. Head for head(if u kill other ur head should be cut) 5. Choori pe haath & many more..

  7. Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

    What a stupid thing to do!

    And then they want azaadi, uske baad kya kya hoga!

    While my friends niece Sarah Rizvi is the first muslim IPS officer in Gujarat !!!!
    Kuch seekho

  8. aravind_66

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

    @superstar sam:-these people also threatened to rape and abuse the girls if they didn’t disband…do you completely agree with that also…….????

  9. Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

    @Superstar Sam
    Not surprised at your thoughts, because i have read quran and i want everyone to go through it once If you can spend hundred of hours watching movies every week. There are justification of lot of acts which are uncalled for and can be considered heinous crimes in present society and this has become the reason of major conflict. But, one cant be blamed, if he has grew up with this ideology. That’s why i wanted discussion on this.

  10. Alfa.one

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

    @Superstarsam – Keep ur bullshit to u only and dont talk about Saudi Arabia and Arabs. They r the biggest Sharabi and AYYASH (womanisers). If u see them in their own house u will believe that they can put westerners in shame !!

    If sth is wrong say its bloody wrong, dont try to justify wrong into right.

    These are the bullshitters and bastards who are bringing shame to whole community. Grow up u guy !

    • Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

      well said alpha.one . and completely agree with u specially on saudi . one more thing i want to add is that violence against women is high in saudi .but the position of women is very worse in saudi .so i don’t think they can gather enough courage to even report against those crimes.

      @wall-d-replying to u is probably the last thing a man should do .but still i can’rt resist bcoz u brought Quran. Quran is very vast and i don’t know how much u read of it.it is just few days u have taken religion as ur new trolling object and i am assuming that u have read some selected portion. in spite of being a muslim and i’m far from finishing it. one thing i would like to suggest that reading quran and understanding quran is two very different thing.so u can try reading tafsirs . it is basically the explanation of different verse. i am sure u have enough spare time ,search the net u will get many free pdfs. or u can try hadith. it also explains quran .and if u start hadith try bukhari sharif first. all the best

      • Alfa.one

        Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

        CR7- PLEASE DO NOT REPLY OR CONVERSE WITH THIS GUY CALLED some D.
        I could have replied him in but thought better to ignore him as u said rightly, reading is one thing and understanding is different. Even some scholars are not able to inter-prate it rightly so who the hell is this some D who claim to have understood it.

      • Superstar sam

        Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

        @cr 7 since u r talking about bukhari, i want to clear u tat in bukhari itself says women should not read even quran in louder voice if men is near.. Then how can girl sell his voice???? It clearly explains in bukhari & muslim..

  11. Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

    If you are already infuriated, there is no point conversing with you. Wait for my post.

  12. Superstar sam

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

    @alfa one get ur fact rite..am nt talking about uae here which is one of the most aayash country where islamic law doesnt implies.. First visit saudi then talk.. Shaarab is band in saudi arabia & so are movies .. Saudi Also my main point here is islamic law which is followd only in saudi upto some extent where crime rate is least..

    @wall d completly agree.. Quran has everythng for everyone even for non muslims & it explains abt every religion & why ppl goes in wrong path…. One need to read it before pointing on islams..

  13. Superstar sam

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

    Also before blaming on ullamas & muftis first go & study islam & get wat is say & wat it permits.. When someone hurts hindu or any other religion feeling then they never thought about society.. Common grow up we are following our religion & no one has rite to interfere it…

  14. Alfa.one

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

    @superstar sam – I never said UAE or other gulf country but specifically KSA. As far as visiting KSA is concerned please know that I was there on work permit and stayed for long in very decent position and I dont think u know an iota about abrabs or KSA. Its better not to tell me about that country. I dont want u to wake up from ur dreams about KSA (Kingdom of Saudi Arabia).

    And let me tell u that u didnt even got what this …. D has said in that comment or what did u find praise worthy there in his comment !!! I pitty u MR. SUPERSTAR SAM

    • Superstar sam

      Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

      ha ha may be our family is diff ksa.. My family stays in alhassa.. Also i had told u my main point is about islamic law nt about any specific country…

      Secondly i praise D just on his point abt reading quran & its the most easiest book on earth to understand for common man with brains.. even though one cant go deeper without knowing islam..

  15. ank_16n

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

    yaar kya ab usa ke According India chalegi kya…

    jo koi aata hai….kehta hai….this news shows india in bad light…..

    abe kya….USA ke 10000000000 shooting Incidents hue….1000 doosre Scandels hue …toh kya USA Bankcorrupt country ho gayi kya…

    stop this NONSENSE ….This news will show india in Bad light….
    Phele USA walo ko bolo Improve ur perception in the world..!!

    • Superstar sam

      Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

      @ank exactly bad thng abt india is its media..
      Wat was our media doing for when shit like owaisi\togadias are barking???

      frankly i dont giv shit to thosebastard like owaaisis.. But wats wrong when ullamas are giving fatwa according to their religon?? why media hyping it??? doent muslim hav their right??Tats my point

      • ank_16n

        Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

        yaar….u understood my comment wrongly….
        I was saying that why we shud care about what people in USA are thinking before giving any news in media….
        if we have news we shud Telecast it …..let USA 1st clean its own image before thinking about others..!!

  16. ank_16n

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

    @Superstar sam- and as far as this case is concerned…..
    I follow Constitution of India(constitution of our country)….and constitution give Every citizen — Right to Freedom—–!!
    rest i don’t know islam ….so can’t say..!!

  17. Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

    @superstarsam – is watching films allowed in islkaam. why do u then watch movies (i am sure including porn ones ) ? shud u be blinded for that?

  18. Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

    @superstarsam – is watching films allowed in islaam. why do u then watch movies (i am sure including porn ones ) ? shud u be blinded for that?

  19. Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

    these ullema and muftis appear on TV for publicity while islam doesnt even allow photography and portrait paintings!

  20. Alfa.one

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

    @superstar sam – fine, alhassa may be a different KSA, u keep believing it that you live in different KSA when u dont want to accept the facts nothing more can be said. try finding sth about jeddah, dammam/khhobar and riyadh instead of restricting urself to alhassa.

    “its the most easiest book on earth to understand for common man with brains” – u are fantastic yaar, without doubt !!!

  21. rockie_Dabangg2

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

    @ank: Offcourse we have to worry about perception of our country. Continuous inflow of negative news in media will definitely hamper the number of tourists from across the globe visiting India.

    You don’t care about it doesn’t mean every one else is as careless as you are.

    Besides our country gets lot of IT/ITES business from US. It is def important for us to have good image.

    —-
    Bad things happening in US is also giving bad name to US but how does it relate here?
    There are bad things happening in India which needs to be stopped.
    —-

    • ank_16n

      Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

      “”Besides our country gets lot of IT/ITES business from US. It is def important for us to have good image. “”

      my friend u really need to follow USA Economy…..u really don’t have a iota of Idea how much Economy does USA generate from India…….if they have not even threatened by the new Tax policy….that’s bcoz if they shut their business in india….they will go back to 2008…..
      so these news don’t effect India(IT and ITES business from US)..!!

      • rockie_Dabangg2

        Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

        I don’t need to get lessons about US economy from others, and def not from you.
        Even if you are the last person remaining in this world.

        I would rather take lessons from a tree or a stone.

        Also why didn’t you comment about the effect on tourism industry in India?
        Conveniently skipped that.

        • ank_16n

          Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

          my friend if u will go by the data from the Tourism ministry which was published in Economics Times News paper(recently) u will understand that in the last 1 year tourism in india had increased by more than 60% from previous year..!!

          ___________

          and not to worry….chahe mera kamzor student mujhse padna chahe ya nhi main unka saath nhi chodhta…!! :)

          • rockie_Dabangg2

            Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

            Kamzor kaun hai yeh sab jaante hai. :D

        • ank_16n

          Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

          and another fact……the tourism going from india to USA have decreased at a rate of 30% in the past 1 year..!!

          hope next time u will have facts to talk about rather then just Rumors..!! :)

          • rockie_Dabangg2

            Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

            What facts have yo shown but blabbering some imaginary articles published in Economic times.

            Give me the link.

            – Most Akki fans have a habit of pulling percentages from I don’t know where.
            Here you claim 60%, 30% … Give some proof.

            There is another Akki fan Gorrilla on other thread claiming 75% of NG folks agree with him, which was exposed by Danish.

          • ank_16n

            Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

            sitting in USA and watching news channel to get info about India and claiming to have deep knowledge is not a good Habit ji..!! :)

          • rockie_Dabangg2

            Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

            @ank: “sitting in USA and watching news channel to get info about India and claiming to have deep knowledge is not a good Habit ji..!! ”

            Where did I claim I have deep knowledge??

            Infact its you who has claimed that you have all the knowledge of US economy –
            let me add this ….

            “Sitting in India you have all the knowledge about US economy”.
            :P

          • ank_16n

            Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

            yup i have deep knowledge about what USA earns from India..!! :)

  22. rockie_Dabangg2

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

    @Superstar Sam:
    Dude … issue is not about following a religion, but forcing others to follow it.

    If you want you follow it .. do not sing or booze or watch movies … .but why force others??


    This is not only for muslims… but there are many Hindu Khap’s in Rajasthan, Haryana who keep on bringing some idiotic FATWA’s in the name of religion. And they force people to follow it.

    —-

Submit a Comment

Read previous post:
Gadkari threatens I-T officials with revenge when BJP comes to power

Gadkari threatens I-T officials with revenge when BJP comes to power (Bhau, in logon se mat atakna. Bahut khatarnak log...Read More

Close

Coach Outlet