How talking the walk makes “it” big.

First there used to be stories, then came plays and then came screenplays. The transformation of paper to stage or reel is indeed a highly likable one. People could read the text and watch it as a motion picture and compare. Sometimes it worked better, sometimes it invited criticism. In other words walking the talk is indeed something that everyone would look forward to – just to see what became of it.
Another important and fascinating development that took place as stage plays and motion pictures became really big (so big that screenplays became original and scripts were written only so that a movie can be made on them) was the reviews, features and analytical pieces written in appreciation/criticism or even interpreting the films. From occasional sections in newspapers, to film journal regulars to dedicated reviews the “about movies” texts have come a long way. These days we have an IMDb where people fight it out based on their tastes and views on movies. There are question answer sections where people discuss their interpretations of the film or how they could or couldn’t get the hidden abstract meaning of something in the film or how the film is much bigger than what others think of it. There are thousands of movie blogs that do the same just like this one.

Now that I have given a long enough introduction, let me come to the point of this article. Just the other day I read a review of Gangs of Wasseypur by one of my favorite bloggers- GreatBong. What fascinated me was his real long introduction about Gang movies and the smooth comparison of GOW with Goodfellas. On a personal level I hated GOW-1 and loved GOW-2, but that is not the point here. What amazed me was the by the end of the article, I had started looking at GOW as something, I never really did. I literally had to think about the core idea of this article to shrug myself and get back to my original opinion of the movie. Yes I enjoyed the desi flavor of the film (part 2) and liked the raw dialog but at the end of it all it was just an entertaining film (part2) and I enjoyed it at the same level as Oye Lucky, Lucky Oye, but the way Greatbong had articulated his article did make me ride in his thoughts for some time. Talking the Walk had made it bigger.

Another remarkable example of this syndrome was when the movie Inception came out. Everyone had their own interpretation and it turned out to be a bigger IMDb hit than its actual reception. Just the fact the people wrote thousands of article on a dream story (a story about dreams, well!!) made it into something much bigger. Abstract became mysterious and hence fascinating. The sheer inquiry of what the fuss is all these texts about made the artwork bigger than what it was.

An important aspect here to note is, at the end of the day, an article, a speech, a review about a film is just someone’s opinion of the film but the fact that articulation and supposed prestige associated with the author/speaker/reviewer. Moreover, it becomes really difficult to guess whether the text was written as part of one’s habit or one’s desire to write it. Given the capacity of human nature, it may very well have been written to drive a section of the dedicated audience away or towards the motion picture. I personally feel, that sometimes the language of certain texts seem “trying hard to make you believe in my words” kind of a deal. Sometimes, there is a sense of pride saying “I know more than you, you know” and sometimes requesting “please give this a try, trust me”. It’s all very fascinating.

My article here is not for or against talking the walk. It’s neither to prove a point nor to dismiss one. It just amazes me, how words can be so powerful and so convincing. The BIG in the article could mean small too. It’s just how one takes it.

15 Comments

  1. Gorilla
    Gorilla
    February 2, 2013 at 1:25 AM

    Can you pls paste the link of greatbong’s blog that u are referringk to…am intrigued now on what she has written?
    I think taking other’s opinion and then accepting it is usual human nature….non acceptance happens with strangers primarily because of ego or prejudice most of the time.
    For example I trust my community and established trust worthy sources on a movie more than anyone else. I rarely try to read intellectual take on a movie even when the movie is a high concept one. I believe movie needs to enjoyed and spoken about if it is really good…may be write about it on blogs like NG and then forget it and move on in life. Cannot imagine ppl writing essays on it…but then if it is paying or getting you a fan following then it is a kdifferent thing.
    I also find that most ppl in India have similar likings and have a clear understanding about what they want to see and entertain themselves. It is only those who want to watch world cinema comfuse others.

  2. Nirjhar
    Nirjhar
    February 2, 2013 at 3:10 AM

    Yes, the opposite is true too, you see people giving bad feedback abt a movie, you have a conception that it is a bad movie without seeing it, example: Shanghai

    And just like the article of greatbong, its opposite pole can make you forget the good things of a movie, only remembering its negativity, example: Barfi

    Also, when people lap up a movie and makes it a 100 crore one, if that is of your fav stars movie then “masses are the king” … and when Golmaal 3, Bol Bachchan make a 100 crore or a Son of Sardar makes a 90 crore they start questioning the taste of people for liking these craps :D

    1. FS
      FS
      February 2, 2013 at 5:33 PM

      Perfectly summed up

  3. rockie_Dabangg2
    rockie_Dabangg2
    February 2, 2013 at 3:28 AM

    Herd Mentality….

    1 Pseudo likes it and praises it … and then there are 100’s of Pseudo’s liking it just because the other Pseudo has praised it.

    Happens all the time ….. :)

    1. Nirjhar
      Nirjhar
      February 2, 2013 at 3:51 AM

      Agree to both of you :)

  4. Gorilla
    Gorilla
    February 2, 2013 at 8:41 AM

    I clicked the link provided by Suprabh and found the following:
    1. Greatbong is a he. However I referred to it as she because I feel it is always gentlemanly to give fair sex a benefit if doubt.
    2. This guy seems to have seen lot of Hollywood films and, like some of my friends and many on tv, have found one classic Hollywood film in every genre. They compare every Hindi film with those Hollywood film to deconstruct that Indian film and judge based on the classic Hollywood film.
    Here greatbong’s like a bhadrolok bong takes godfather and goodfella, one classic and the other an extremely good movie as a parameter to judge GOW.
    Not a bad idea, but after reading two para I read the last para and got what he was trying to make. Sorry Suprabh but I am not one of those viewers who while watching a Hindi movie start remembering all the past movies I have seen. I just enjoy it and become myself when watching it.
    I also find most of us do the same.
    So I hardly became a fan of great bong and do not agree to his review and hence your fascination with his write up as depicted in this thread.

  5. Gorilla
    Gorilla
    February 2, 2013 at 10:05 AM

    Sup, after your last comment, I ready your write up again. I realised that I totally misunderstood your point. You have written beautifully and intelligently.
    I also feel that you contribute more to your article which u wrote on your take on movies in 2012. I think you need to keep it alive for some more time.

  6. Serenzy
    Serenzy
    February 2, 2013 at 1:08 PM

    Nirjhar,

    “you see people giving bad
    feedback abt a movie, you
    have a conception that it is a
    bad movie without seeing it,
    example: Shanghai”

    Well Said and I was also Guilty of this Crime.

    Agree on Barfi! too.

    1. Nirjhar
      Nirjhar
      February 3, 2013 at 3:55 AM

      Well, I would say it is a mistake, not crime :)

      You liked it? … I guess you did!

  7. danish
    danish
    February 2, 2013 at 4:34 PM

    very intelligent! i cudnt even understand wat the post says, so it must be intelligent.

    1. ank_16n
      ank_16n
      February 2, 2013 at 4:59 PM

      that’s a miracle……

      and the NOBEL AWARD goes to suprabh….
      u saved all of us..!! :)

  8. ank_16n
    ank_16n
    February 2, 2013 at 4:56 PM

    According to me no two person can have same opinion about every movie….yes there can be 2,3,4 or may be 5 movies that u can agree upon….

    But even those two will have different aspect/Liking about that particular movie…

    Review of a reviewer/Critic dependes whether he liked idea/have liking about any particular genre……and there are critics like Rajeev Masand who like Hollywood types movies (if he didn’t find a particular flavor of Hollywood movies in Bollywood movies he will write bad things about it even if he likes that movie)
    then there are certain Critics like Raja sen—there funda is say this movie is confusing general public will not be able to judge the theme or aim behind the movie so i can give it a 4star )…

    so its mainly depend on the particular liking/habits or things in movie that he can relate to or sometime a water tight screen play along with Acting of Lead actors that can make or break a movie for that Critic..!!

    I totally agree with ur view on Inception thing..!!

    every human mind works in a particular way and react differently in different situations……so one might don’t like ones Acting (saying it was OTT) but other might relate to it..!!

    So never to Trust or make perceptions about a movie from What a Particular critic or 100’s of people are saying……apni khud ki akal ladao…
    if u find a movie Interesting watch it if don’t then move on…..and don’t be afraid to express ur views…

    Atleast that’s what i was able to make ..!!

Page 1 of 1

Post Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

folcres generic propecia brand levitra 5mg augmentin mgs doxycycline 100 mg canine zusammensetzung viagra 50 mg viagra 25mg doctissimo real cheap viagra metformin bluefish 500 mg xenical 90mg clomid 50mg instructions buy viagra phuket zoloft 100 mg forum diflucan 150 mg po buy 150 mg. viagra super generic viagra levitra 20 mg dissolving zithromax tablets buy order cialis 10 mg generic cialis isosorb zovirax filmtabletten 400 mg viagra review 50mg viagra 50 mg kaufen zovirax ointment generic einnahme viagra 50 mg glucophage 50 mg reliable generic propecia online viagra deutschland cheap viagra eu 10 mg lexapro withdrawal cialis online honolulu generic celebrex prescription propecia 0.5mg prednisone 20mg pet generic drugs levitra is viagra generic lasix 25 mg posologia bula strattera 25mg lisinopril 10 mg tab doxycycline online generic lexapro tabs merks generics propecia generic levitra 517 bestbuy propecia hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg online levitra cheap overnight wellbutrin 300 xl generic buy doxycycline nz amoxil 500 mg liquid female viagra generic order gaspari nolvadex nexium 20 mg pakkausseloste el viagra generico cheap phizer viagra propecia online vendita cialis 20 mg durata 100mg doxycycline review authentic cialis online generics lexapro viagra cena online generic viagra for 2012 online fsa viagra cialis buy singapore buy zovirax injection doxycycline 500mg order generic viagra g 100mg viagra fails cheapest cialis sale buy doxycycline 100 mg generic wellbutrin mylan propecia original buy doxycycline hydrochloride 115 mg cipro dosage mg synthroid 100 mg daily buspar 30 mg dividose lasix 40 mg vidal buy cialis cvs buy dapoxetine eu augmentin dawkowanie 500 mg viagra 100mg women mg for metformin augmentin 875 mg tab propranolol paranoia mg 200mg zoloft find cheap cialis taking 100mg zoloft cialis 20mg cpr 4 doxycycline 100 mg nedir cialis 10 mg kanada diflucan 150 mg dosierung viagra price buy 150 mg viagra paypal phenergan 50 mg tablets cheapest regalis viagra cialis cheapest online canadian cialis 200 mg. cheap generic nolvadex cialis cheap 40 mg. prednisone 40 mg methylprednisolone viagra generica canada kamagra online cheap discount order cialis metformin 500 mg buy viagra dosage mg buy chewable viagra viagra perth buy viagra 200mg pfizer zithromax 250 mg sobres wellbutrin xl generic 2011 viagra for womencheap cheap levitra cialis kamagra 100mg nebenwirkungen lisinopril sleep disorder glucophage 500mg nebenwirkungen viagra purchase cheap online cialis 200 mg lexapro 10 mg depression xenical 120 mg hinta generic viagra seattle buy viagra discount propranolol sa 160 mg cialis mg tabs buy womens viagra cialis two 5mg 2o mg levitra generic4all dapoxetine cialis giornaliero 5 mg synthroid generic dosage infographics generic viagra kamagra cheap supplies prednisone cristers 20mg strattera online uk cialis 2.5 generic generic 50mg cialis cipro 500 mg tid propecia goiing generic cialis generic problem cialis prices online levitra 5 mg durata dosage 25 mg phenergan viagra levitra generic viagra buydrugonline levitra odt 10mg viagra 100 mg zararlari bactrim genericos viagra gold 300mg zovirax 100 mg generic viagra wallgreen order cialis coupons viagra 100 online prednisone 5mg domesco synthroid generic available cialis 5 mg spc nolva clomid buy prezzo lasix 25 mg buy cialis 50mg glucophage generic drug buy lasix aventis buy generic bactrim zithromax chlamydia 1000mg bactrim ds buy q buy viagra buy 60 mg nolvadex levitra 10 mg indicazioni wellbutrin xl 150 generic kamagra plus 20 mg anxiety disorders buspar propranolol 40 mg indicaciones cialis 20 mg 36 hours nexium 40mg rash lexapro generic prozac brand cheap viagra canadian cialis 5mg fish cipro 500mg metformin 850 mg dosierung prednisone 40 mg alcohol cialis 10 mg cupon viagra generic cyprus cnn wellbutrin generic xenical 40mg price doxycycline 100mg 393 packes buy amoxil 250mg cialis mg difference buy strattera cheap 2 mg of prednisone cialis 10mg pengalaman cialis 5 mg bijsluiter cialis cost 5mg propranolol clorhidrato 80 mg buy levitra calgary mims online celebrex 1000 mg augmentin buy zoloft 50mg cialis 05 mg comprimidos generic viagra drops buy zoloft generic generic wellbutrin 300xl kegunaan lasix 20 mg order online cialis spectrum 500mg cipro xenical 120mg tablets pfizer viagra 100mg viagra 25mg pfizer zithromax generic buy buy nexium usa metformin 500 mg e zoloft 150 mg tablet buy amoxil online buy lisinopril without zoloft 50mgs levitra 20mg info wellbutrin xr buy clomid 25 mg pct buy india cialis overnight viagra orders free viagra 150mg xenical orlistate 200mg wellbutrin xl 50mg metformin xr 750 mg clomid 100mg forum augmentin prospect 1000 mg viagra or 800mg zithromax generic buy strattera 120 mg cialis 80 mg celebrex generic celecoxib levitra 20 generic wellbutrin 125 mg viagra jell online online levitra generic lisinopril dosage 80 mg hay cytotec generico cialis 2,5 mg nl cialis 10mg preise cytotec 200mg tab 25 or 50 mg viagra phenergan buy australia erfahrung cialis 5 mg viagra 1oo mg prijs cialis 5mg brand cialis order generic viagra real prednisone 7.5 mg generic cipro 1000 discounted generic viagra buy propranolol 40mg metformin 850 mg einnahme wellbutrin generic problems generic levitra dosage costo viagra 100 mg dapoxetine pills online nexium 20 mg indicatii phenergan 75 mg order levitra 120 pills viagra online istanbul cheap viagra 100 uk nexium 40 mg endovenoso canine doxycycline 50 mg cheap cialis pharmacy doxycycline 100 mg zwangerschap zithromax 500mg ingredients strattera cost 60 mg viagra 100mg australia generic strattera 100mg lasix 12.5mg buy doxycycline canada nexium 500 mg cheap cialis from 75 mg strattera hydrochlorothiazide 12.5mg cap generico nexium 40mg nebenwirkungen celebrex 200mg cialis 20 mg docmorris generic lexapro prescription zithromax 250 mg penicillin cheap nonprescription xenical kamagra 100 mg upustvo levitra 40mg effectiveness lbrand levitra 20mg nolvadex pills online cialis, 20 mg, 120 prednisone 60 mg m2 viagra buy local 500 mg of metformin levitra 20mg england paypal buy viagra rx buys viagra wellbutrin generic 141 walmart generic lexapro 25mg of viagra teva doxycycline 100 mg buy levitra insurance hydrochlorothiazide cost 25mg buying diflucan overnight erythromycin 250 mg antybiotyk wellbutrin generic actavis cialis 5 mg preturi generic version valtrex propiedades celebrex 200 mg 200 mg celebrex dosage 80 mg strattera adults cialis de 0.5 mg augmentin 250 mg prospect 75 mg of wellbutrin xenical 120 mg vidal cialis 50mg philippines buy 60 nexium 40 mg levitra odt 5mg viagra dosierung 100 mg buy cialis beijing thailand generic viagra lexapro tabs 20mg lisinopril sandoz 20 mg cipla 5mg cialis cialis 5mg ipp order doxycycline generic lisinopril hctz 10 mg cialis generique 60mg diflucan 100 mg vademecum clomid buy 50mg cialis order form viagra buy karachi generico de valtrex wellbutrin sr order zovirax 800 mg lexapro 5mg effective levitra 20mg 4st metformin tablet mg buy lasix 12.5mg generic viagra euro buy viagra chinatown cialis 20mg france order viagra cod dosaggio levitra 5 mg 200 mg zoloft day lexapro generic cipralex xenical online buy viagra dosage 25 mg cialis 40 mg portugues lexapro price generic lexapro online mastercard 30 mg lexapro ocd lasix 20mg sale australia viagra generic viagra cheap drugs bactrim 40 mg prednisone 20mg dosage buy wellbutrin 300 mg generic alternative lexapro nexium generic medication levitra 5mg generic zoloft 50 mg pfizer metformin 500 mg effect prednisone 50 mg tablets buy augmentin tablets buying tetracycline online viagra zakup online 5mg cialis work 60 mg of propranolol viagra tablets 500 mg generic cialis forums buy valtrex walgreens nexium cheap online buy authintic viagra zoloft generic alternative cipra generic viagra zoloft generic teva xenical tabl 120mg levitra 10 mg vademecum diflucan 150 mg vaikutus clomid 100mg instructions buy nexium dublin zoloft 37.5 mg bayer levitra 20mg google generic viagra indian viagra 100mg propecia 1mg generic buying viagra germany generic synthroid online prednisone 20mg 5443 coomeva cheap viagra metformin nail disorder purchasing nolvadex online 25 mg zoloft pregnancy xenical cheapest price levitra order walgreen nexium 20 mg posologia valtrex generic cheap clomid 100mg eisprong kamagra 100mg bijsluiter makan clomid 100mg celebrex tiene generico cipro 500 mg dose cialis 20mg online viagra cialis generici lexapro 5mg success lexapro 15mg posologia propranolol 40 mg wiki generico do viagra medicine lasix 40 mg lisinopril 40 mg hypertension stopping lisinopril 40mg generic cialis jelly generic xenical online metformin 5 mg doxycycline hyclate 10 mg propranolol 160mg cipro oral 500mg strattera 80 mgs costo strattera 40 mg capsules online viagra kauf online cialis ordering buy priligy europe buy valtrex europe lisinopril hctz 40 mg metformin bp 500 mg 100 mg prednisone lymphoma viagra 125 mg 60 mg lexapro dosage levitra generika 20mg lexapro generic manufacturers cialis 2.5 mg cheap cheap levitra 40 mg 250mg zoloft propranolol 40 mg trac prednisone 40 mg 3 day cialis 20mg indikacije lexapro dosage 40 mg nexium astrazeneca 40 mg 28 generic viagra zoll generic kamagra pillen buy cialis 50 mg lasix 40 mg dosis notice cytotec 200 mg propecia mail order 5 mg di cialis lisinopril smg propranolol 20 mg bula hmgr metformin buy nexium cheap augmentin 125 mg albuterol ventolin order cialis 20mgviagra zovirax 1000 mg harga viagra 25 mg cialis 10 mg generico strattera 80 mg boots online cialis zovirax 200 mg dosis prednisone 10 mg vademecum xenical kaufen online clomid order europe buy prednisone 10 mg cialis generico 20 mgrs. 5 mg cialis canada buy diflucan us cialis 20 mg coupon buy canadian zithromax zoloft dosage 25 mg nexium 40mg generico kamagra 100 mg beipackzettel generic vs valtrex cialis 20mg dauer lisinopril 10 mg apo lasix 500 mg generic buy viagra overnight price 200 mg celebrex cialis 80 mg australia levitra 20mg bestellen viagra generico guatemala viagra kup online metformin stada 850 mg cialis generico 10 mg online levitra sales clomid comprar online cipla cheap cialis order zithromax suspension jakarta buy viagra harga cialis 5 mg nexium 40 mg dosering generic viagra formula viagra 0.25 mg pret bijsluiter zithromax 500 mg tab clomid 200mg buy bactrim ip 272 viagra 25mg uk online viagra chennai cialis lily buy buy cialis 25mg order cialis 40mg augmentin prospect 125 mg buy 100 mg clomid valtrex 500 mg pret propecia 1 mg costco cheap viagra 20 mg viagra 50 mg brand generic strattera 80 mg lisinopril 2.5 mg dosage buy strattera generic buy nolvadex sa doxycycline 600mg headache