How talking the walk makes “it” big.

First there used to be stories, then came plays and then came screenplays. The transformation of paper to stage or reel is indeed a highly likable one. People could read the text and watch it as a motion picture and compare. Sometimes it worked better, sometimes it invited criticism. In other words walking the talk is indeed something that everyone would look forward to – just to see what became of it.
Another important and fascinating development that took place as stage plays and motion pictures became really big (so big that screenplays became original and scripts were written only so that a movie can be made on them) was the reviews, features and analytical pieces written in appreciation/criticism or even interpreting the films. From occasional sections in newspapers, to film journal regulars to dedicated reviews the “about movies” texts have come a long way. These days we have an IMDb where people fight it out based on their tastes and views on movies. There are question answer sections where people discuss their interpretations of the film or how they could or couldn’t get the hidden abstract meaning of something in the film or how the film is much bigger than what others think of it. There are thousands of movie blogs that do the same just like this one.

Now that I have given a long enough introduction, let me come to the point of this article. Just the other day I read a review of Gangs of Wasseypur by one of my favorite bloggers- GreatBong. What fascinated me was his real long introduction about Gang movies and the smooth comparison of GOW with Goodfellas. On a personal level I hated GOW-1 and loved GOW-2, but that is not the point here. What amazed me was the by the end of the article, I had started looking at GOW as something, I never really did. I literally had to think about the core idea of this article to shrug myself and get back to my original opinion of the movie. Yes I enjoyed the desi flavor of the film (part 2) and liked the raw dialog but at the end of it all it was just an entertaining film (part2) and I enjoyed it at the same level as Oye Lucky, Lucky Oye, but the way Greatbong had articulated his article did make me ride in his thoughts for some time. Talking the Walk had made it bigger.

Another remarkable example of this syndrome was when the movie Inception came out. Everyone had their own interpretation and it turned out to be a bigger IMDb hit than its actual reception. Just the fact the people wrote thousands of article on a dream story (a story about dreams, well!!) made it into something much bigger. Abstract became mysterious and hence fascinating. The sheer inquiry of what the fuss is all these texts about made the artwork bigger than what it was.

An important aspect here to note is, at the end of the day, an article, a speech, a review about a film is just someone’s opinion of the film but the fact that articulation and supposed prestige associated with the author/speaker/reviewer. Moreover, it becomes really difficult to guess whether the text was written as part of one’s habit or one’s desire to write it. Given the capacity of human nature, it may very well have been written to drive a section of the dedicated audience away or towards the motion picture. I personally feel, that sometimes the language of certain texts seem “trying hard to make you believe in my words” kind of a deal. Sometimes, there is a sense of pride saying “I know more than you, you know” and sometimes requesting “please give this a try, trust me”. It’s all very fascinating.

My article here is not for or against talking the walk. It’s neither to prove a point nor to dismiss one. It just amazes me, how words can be so powerful and so convincing. The BIG in the article could mean small too. It’s just how one takes it.

15 Comments

  1. Gorilla
    Gorilla
    February 2, 2013 at 1:25 AM

    Can you pls paste the link of greatbong’s blog that u are referringk to…am intrigued now on what she has written?
    I think taking other’s opinion and then accepting it is usual human nature….non acceptance happens with strangers primarily because of ego or prejudice most of the time.
    For example I trust my community and established trust worthy sources on a movie more than anyone else. I rarely try to read intellectual take on a movie even when the movie is a high concept one. I believe movie needs to enjoyed and spoken about if it is really good…may be write about it on blogs like NG and then forget it and move on in life. Cannot imagine ppl writing essays on it…but then if it is paying or getting you a fan following then it is a kdifferent thing.
    I also find that most ppl in India have similar likings and have a clear understanding about what they want to see and entertain themselves. It is only those who want to watch world cinema comfuse others.

  2. Nirjhar
    Nirjhar
    February 2, 2013 at 3:10 AM

    Yes, the opposite is true too, you see people giving bad feedback abt a movie, you have a conception that it is a bad movie without seeing it, example: Shanghai

    And just like the article of greatbong, its opposite pole can make you forget the good things of a movie, only remembering its negativity, example: Barfi

    Also, when people lap up a movie and makes it a 100 crore one, if that is of your fav stars movie then “masses are the king” … and when Golmaal 3, Bol Bachchan make a 100 crore or a Son of Sardar makes a 90 crore they start questioning the taste of people for liking these craps :D

    1. FS
      FS
      February 2, 2013 at 5:33 PM

      Perfectly summed up

  3. rockie_Dabangg2
    rockie_Dabangg2
    February 2, 2013 at 3:28 AM

    Herd Mentality….

    1 Pseudo likes it and praises it … and then there are 100’s of Pseudo’s liking it just because the other Pseudo has praised it.

    Happens all the time ….. :)

    1. Nirjhar
      Nirjhar
      February 2, 2013 at 3:51 AM

      Agree to both of you :)

  4. Gorilla
    Gorilla
    February 2, 2013 at 8:41 AM

    I clicked the link provided by Suprabh and found the following:
    1. Greatbong is a he. However I referred to it as she because I feel it is always gentlemanly to give fair sex a benefit if doubt.
    2. This guy seems to have seen lot of Hollywood films and, like some of my friends and many on tv, have found one classic Hollywood film in every genre. They compare every Hindi film with those Hollywood film to deconstruct that Indian film and judge based on the classic Hollywood film.
    Here greatbong’s like a bhadrolok bong takes godfather and goodfella, one classic and the other an extremely good movie as a parameter to judge GOW.
    Not a bad idea, but after reading two para I read the last para and got what he was trying to make. Sorry Suprabh but I am not one of those viewers who while watching a Hindi movie start remembering all the past movies I have seen. I just enjoy it and become myself when watching it.
    I also find most of us do the same.
    So I hardly became a fan of great bong and do not agree to his review and hence your fascination with his write up as depicted in this thread.

  5. Gorilla
    Gorilla
    February 2, 2013 at 10:05 AM

    Sup, after your last comment, I ready your write up again. I realised that I totally misunderstood your point. You have written beautifully and intelligently.
    I also feel that you contribute more to your article which u wrote on your take on movies in 2012. I think you need to keep it alive for some more time.

  6. Serenzy
    Serenzy
    February 2, 2013 at 1:08 PM

    Nirjhar,

    “you see people giving bad
    feedback abt a movie, you
    have a conception that it is a
    bad movie without seeing it,
    example: Shanghai”

    Well Said and I was also Guilty of this Crime.

    Agree on Barfi! too.

    1. Nirjhar
      Nirjhar
      February 3, 2013 at 3:55 AM

      Well, I would say it is a mistake, not crime :)

      You liked it? … I guess you did!

  7. danish
    danish
    February 2, 2013 at 4:34 PM

    very intelligent! i cudnt even understand wat the post says, so it must be intelligent.

    1. ank_16n
      ank_16n
      February 2, 2013 at 4:59 PM

      that’s a miracle……

      and the NOBEL AWARD goes to suprabh….
      u saved all of us..!! :)

  8. ank_16n
    ank_16n
    February 2, 2013 at 4:56 PM

    According to me no two person can have same opinion about every movie….yes there can be 2,3,4 or may be 5 movies that u can agree upon….

    But even those two will have different aspect/Liking about that particular movie…

    Review of a reviewer/Critic dependes whether he liked idea/have liking about any particular genre……and there are critics like Rajeev Masand who like Hollywood types movies (if he didn’t find a particular flavor of Hollywood movies in Bollywood movies he will write bad things about it even if he likes that movie)
    then there are certain Critics like Raja sen—there funda is say this movie is confusing general public will not be able to judge the theme or aim behind the movie so i can give it a 4star )…

    so its mainly depend on the particular liking/habits or things in movie that he can relate to or sometime a water tight screen play along with Acting of Lead actors that can make or break a movie for that Critic..!!

    I totally agree with ur view on Inception thing..!!

    every human mind works in a particular way and react differently in different situations……so one might don’t like ones Acting (saying it was OTT) but other might relate to it..!!

    So never to Trust or make perceptions about a movie from What a Particular critic or 100’s of people are saying……apni khud ki akal ladao…
    if u find a movie Interesting watch it if don’t then move on…..and don’t be afraid to express ur views…

    Atleast that’s what i was able to make ..!!

Page 1 of 1

Post Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

buying levitra canada cialis generic american viagra online prednisone order online generic propecia online cheap 100 mg viagra price viagra generic cialis 10 mg kaufen nolvadex 10mg used clomid generic online clomid nome generico cialis 80 mg bali buy clomid privately 12.5 mg lasix dogs costco generic viagra iv lasix 40 mg buying viagra cialis pfizer zithromax buy generic cialis vs levitra 10mg australia generic lexapro mylan viagra de 50 mgs doxycycline tablets cheap propecia 1mg paypal is hydrochlorothiazide generic viagra 100mg effects viagra generic online 3generic sildenafil viagra zovirax tablet 800 mg cialis 20 mg tab hydrochlorothiazide 12.5 mg dosage buying cipro online viagra alternative generic nexium tablets generic lexapro 20 mg results nexium online purchase starting zoloft 50mg generic viagra approval canadian levitra 20mg pil clomid 50mg pro cialis 20 mg daily cialis 2.5mg zoloft 100mg tablet wellbutrin generic 75 mg cheap levitra importers generico viagra panvel instructions 20 mg cialis prednisone taper 7.5 mg online zovirax buy cialis cena 5mg doxycycline 100 mg india zoloft generic date kamagra 100 gold cheap doxycycline 20mg online lasix 80 mg online walmart clomid generic lisinopril generic review lisinopril 10 mg e101 propecia finasteride 5 mg metformin 500 mg alcohol cialis reviews 5 mg lisinopril splitting 2.5mg buy Cialis 90 pills ratio metformin 500mg cialis 5 mg kosten buy cheap valtrex zithromax tablets 500mg diabetes metformin 500 mg generic viagra fraud erythromycin 250mg zastosowanie lisinopril 30 mg w953 generic strattera paypal xenical generico emagrece apo prednisone 5 mg levitra sublinguale generico cialis 5 mg online buy viagra colombia buy cialis 2.5 levitra 20 mg bayer amoxil 150mg cheap viagra missouri cialis 2.5 mg opinioni augmentin 80mg nexium 20 mg generico lexapro 10mg generico xenical buy india viagra generic real zithromax buy overnight buy viagra leeds cialis sverige generic buying cialis singapore cheapist cialis cheapest valtrex generic cheap levitra line harga lasix 40 mg woman generic viagra levitra 10 mg orodispersible kamagra 100mg fake kamagra buyers propecia order sales valsartan 80 mg hydrochlorothiazide augmentin 500 mg generic generic substitution cialis phenergan 25 mg sleep cialis mexico buy viagra 100 mg teva buy cialis 200mg cialis lilly 20 mg taking 2 50mg zoloft glucophage 1000 mg farmaco levitra 20 mg walmart zithromax generic substitute reviews cialis 20 mg lisinopril tablets buy cialis 20 mg. cheasp cheap generic viagra buy cialis emedsrx zoloft 200 mg dosage valtrex 200mg order zoloft 100mg generic cialis, 5 mg viagra 50 mg generika buy viagra chennai viagra online generic viagra 25 mg precio zoloft od 100mg buy real nolvadex cialis 10 mg cipla lexapro escitalopram 10 mg doxycycline 100mg pills metformin generic otc nexium online drug propecia 2mg jour t.cytotec 0 2 mg propecia to buy order doxycycline cat xenical 120 mg bijwerkingen doxycycline 100mg dosage buy prednisone 20mg lasix drip order buy zithromax 1 gram metformin hcl 1000mg levitra 10 mg 4 st lexapro 20 online erythromycin 400 mg tablets 100mg generic viagra cialis 5 mg pret zithromax online ordering dosages levitra order celebrex 200 mg wirkstoff cheapest 800mg cialis cost viagra 25 mg metformin 850 mg tablets augmentin 875 mg compresse discount augmentin online propecia tablets 1mg dapoxetine 30mg price generico viagra valor taking 2 10mg lexapro generic doxycycline 100mg valtrex 500 mg directions buy effervescent cialis doxycycline 500mg cylmidia lisinopril dosage 7.5 mg doxycycline 50 mg bid 1500 mg metformin clomid vidal viagra 100mg doxycycline 100mg disease lasix generic name walmart 50mg viagra wellbutrin 120 mg viagra 100 mg doses medicamento xenical 120 mg zithromax online canada levitra online 20mg zovirax 800 mg candidiase cialis 5 mg philippines viagra online bestellen online cialis costco buy viagra alternative viagra buy china kamagra gel online generic viagra 200 mg nexium generic wiki lexapro online purchase generic levitra brand cheap 2.5 mg cialis buy viagra men buy prednisone india cheap lisinopril 10mg augmentin 400 mg prospect achat viagra 25 mg tablets cialis 20mg buying cialis online clomid 50mg testosterone 400 mg of doxycycline buy bactrim sulfamethoxazole clomid 250 mg prednisone burst 200 mg take 2 100 mg viagra generic cialis ebay generic strattera adhd taking 70 mg lisinopril buy 40mg cialis nolvadex online paypal will nexium generic cheap lexapro 10 mg viagra sildenafil 50 mg lexapro 30mg tabs viagra 100mg online cialis 20 mg wirkungsdauer medicijn nexium 40mg buy zithromax pills mail order levitra cialis 5 mg information 1oomg cialis wholesale posologia levitra 10 mg lexapro reviews 10mg order lasix online cialis 10 mg posologia buy dapoxetine australia propranolol 40 mg galenika augmentin 625 mg ulotka buy clomid 200mg generic alcohol cialis doxycycline 500mg capsules 20mg lisinopril high lisinopril dosage 30 mg zoloft 100 mg pregnancy metformin 500 mg n3 augmentin 875 mg sobres lily cialis 100mg generic propecia meinung diflucan 150mg dosage viagra buy phuket levitra 60 pills online viagra no generica valtrex order online zoloft 25 mg tabs viagra integration online clomid 100mg grossesse japan buy viagra xenical orlistat 60 mg cialis ricetta online buy lasix tabs concor viagra 50 mg buy levitra pills valtrex 500 mg generico lisinopril 20 mg wockhardt cipro antibiotic 500 mg lasix 40 mg beipackzettel australian generic cialis wirkung levitra 5mg sandoz lisinopril 40 mg cheapest legitimate viagra cheapest cialis price 100mg doxycycline antibiotic augmentin price 500mg cialis women generic celebrex 90 mg generic 40 mg cialis zovirax cream 5 buy order cipro metformin 500 mg actavis generic zoloft 100 mg viagra generico comprar generic viagra proffessional cheap cheap viagra propecia generic fda generic lisinopril oral buy levitra pen 10mg cialis time levitra schmelztablette 10 mg lisinopril 10mg effects diflucan buy canada nexium 40mg programa doxycycline 100mg eyes generic cialis canadian buy viagra 2.5mg cheapest nexium online online viagra women propranolol hci 40 mg viagra generic date clomid cheap uk buy celebrex online lasix ret. 60 mg viagra 2oomg xenical generico opinioni forum generic levitra cipro xr generic 12.5mg clomid levitra 20mg fta4 propranolol 40 mg information generic propecia viagra cialis 5mg opinie cialis 25mg image cheap viagra substitute propranolol 20 mg tablets buy cialis ghana 120 mg viagra online viagra online br dividere cialis 10 mg generic wellbutrin safe prednisone tablets 5 mg indo metformin 500 mg generic cialis offers coupons cialis 20 mg viagra buy turkey viagra 100,3000 mg import generic viagra buy clomid 100mg order viagra overnight doxycycline dosage 40 mg buy viagra england strattera 60 mg precio generico do valtrex dosis augmentin 600 mg prednisone mg tablets 15 count 50mg viagra buy medicaments cialis levitra 5 mg pret augmentin suspension 875 mg buy 30 mg prednisone cialis 800mg reviews kamagra 100 mg etkisi vibramycin 100mg doxycycline generic viagra urdu buy doxycycline nairobi diflucan 100 mg their generic celebrex buy zovirax zovirax purchase generic lexapro celebrex 200mg pharmacia bijsluiter viagra 50mg 10mg levitra benefits amoxil 250 mg image buy levitra brand viagra generics philippines online prescriptions viagra propranolol 10 mg posologia buy nolvadex 40mg buy cytotec generic glucophage de 1000 mg cialis generico prospecto amoxil 500 mg cena clomid 200 mg pcos zoloft mg dose prinivil lisinopril 10 mg lexapro generic weight viagra order internet bijsluiter lasix 40 mg buy doxycycline usa 100mg doxycycline usage clomid 100mg pct 50 mg doxycycline blepharitis buy nolvadex arimidex synthroid 0.88 mg avis zoloft 50 mg cheap cytotec philippines viagra onlinesouth africa buy lexapro paypal cialis 35mg wellbutrin 150 mg bijsluiter viagra uk 50mg much viagra online rx cialis online levitra shop buy buy viagra orlando viagra 25 mg generic prednisone dogs 5 mg viagra 100mg preisvergleich tetracycline cap 250 mg buy msd propecia propecia tablets cheap viagra online bulgaria lexapro 50 mg dose khasiat doxycycline 100mg 10mg lisinopril manufacturers cialis generico recensioni zoloft anxiety 50 mg generico de celebrex valtrex generic ingredients levitra online bahrain synthroid generic buy usda generic viagra generic order viagra apo doxycycline 100mg existe priligy generico nexium 40 mg vaistai generic levitra montreal diflucan 200 mg dosage generic priligy manufacturer order synthroid canada nexium medicamento 10 mg online levitra kaufen cheap levitra online buying daily cialis viagra nz buy diflucan uk buy zoloft withdrawal 25 mg generic augmentin sizes diflucan prospect 150 mg cialis available generic celebrex 100mg 150 mg doxycycline hyclate buy generic amoxil xenical tablets online medicament levitra 10 mg lexapro 10 mg presentacion prednisone 500 mg zoloft 300mg lisinopril 2.5mg tablets viagra da 100mg dosage phenergan 25mg buying viagra online online viagra japan zithromax 500mg tablets generic viagra international kamagra 50mg paypal buy lasix fast wellbutrin sr 100mg cipro generic 500mg nolvadex 10 mg use cialis 5 mg beipackzettel synthroid online prescription propecia 5mg buy generico viagra precio taking 30mg cialis efectos levitra 10 mg buy levitra qatar pfizer viagra 300mg zithromax 250 mg uses levitra 10 mg wikipedia cialis 20 mg wirkungen levitra 20mg wirkung nexium o generico buy cialis 40 mg zithromax 4x 250mg kamagra generic 24 buy viagra today cialis black 500mg purchase cialis 20 mg kamagra gold cheapest buy lexapro 20mg 40 mg cialis dangerous prednisone 50 mg po refrigerate generic bactrim zithromax trockensaft 1200 mg generic celebrex celecoxib clomid 250mg 5mg cialis dose canadian celebrex online anwendung viagra 100mg viagra women buy xenical buy now erythromycin online pharmacy generic lexapro india generic doxycycline online kamagra 100mg sildenafil priligy 30 mg filmtabletten levitra generikum 20mg cialis online soft cialis filmtabletten 10 mg clomid online johannesburg buy 1 pill viagra celebrex 100 mg forum 800mg cialis reivew cheap levitra 20mg bactrim 10mg hydrochlorothiazide 12.5 mg identification australlian generic viagra non generic lisinopril obat doxycycline 100mg buy cialis 150 mg synthroid online pharmacy buy cheap synthroid buy viagra oman metformin 1000 mg day prednisone 10mg arthritis levitra 10 mg erfahrungen prednisone dosage 2.5 mg lasix 500mg diuretics xenical 120 mg kapszula 80 mg nexium cipro 500mg price buy 5 mg cialis nexium buy online viagra cheap sale bactrim 240mg zoloft 300mg daily nexium tab 40mg comprar levitra 10 mg tablet cialis 20 mg wellbutrin available generic xenical generic cost strattera 100 mg buy valtrex new generic viagra 100 mg dosis metformin 500mg sr hydrochlorothiazide dosage 50 mg