BARADWAJ RANGAN: For the love of money

Why does most of our discussion about cinema centre primarily on box-office collections, especially if a big star is involved?

As I write this, Bollywood-oriented websites are screaming that Talaash has finally entered the 100-crore club, though this figure includes revenues from overseas. (The domestic total is a little under Rs. 85 cr.) At the time of release, the story was slightly different. The website boxofficecapsule.com mourned, rather ungrammatically, “Talaash collected rather good numbers over weekend and was expected to fetch good numbers on weekdays. But film dropped with every passing day and it was apparent that this time audience at large did not like the content of Aamir Khan’s latest offering.” Then came the clincher. “Film collected further 3.50 cr nett on Thursday and film has finished week one at 67 plus cr nett. Film has to collect 30 cr plus in 2nd week in order to reach 100 cr nett mark…” And the second week’s total was a mere Rs. 15.5 crore, which means that Talaash will not join the 100-crore club when only domestic receipts are totalled.

This has been the dominant mode of discourse around the film, apart from reviews and a stray opinion piece or two expressing indignation over Aamir Khan’s apparent endorsement of superstition. On the other hand, had Talaash been a Hollywood movie, these are some of the topics that would have risen around the film’s release, in newspapers, magazines and web sites: the best supernatural-suspense films of all time; 10 best cops with moustaches; the origins of rug-pulling in the movies; how spouses in the cinema deal with loss; the literary tradition of lonesome policemen; why hookers in cinema, with the exception of Julia Roberts in Pretty Woman, just cannot catch a break; 10 reasons Talaash would have sucked had there been a male in the director’s chair; Farhan Akhtar’s evolution as a dialogue-writer; from Dil Chahta Hai to Talaash, a look at the male-centric multiplex movie; and, this being awards season, why Talaash won’t win the Oscar for Best Actor.

In short, we’d have had a range of writing around the movie, from the super-serious to the ultra-silly. And I’m not even talking about the lengthy profiles and interviews, the comment pieces and the debates that would have appeared. But here, all we seem to do is bother about the box office. That’s not wrong. You can do serious reporting using facts and figures that make up the trade aspect of a film. But when all those reports converge around a single question, whether or not Talaash will enter the 100-crore club, it’s depressing — not just because we can’t seem to think of other things to write about and around the film, but because the 100-crore mark itself is meaningless with this sort of film, with restricted appeal. That such a moody and slow-paced film made Rs. 85 crore so far is in itself a smashing success story, without speculating if Aamir is still the top Khan.

What, for instance, would Talaash have earned had Salman or Shah Rukh starred in it, both stars with a more massy appeal? Besides, a look at the Wikipedia page of Bollywood’s 100-crore grosser reveals that most of them are masala movies (or variants thereof, like the sci-fi masala Ra.One, or the masala comedy Housefull 2). Jab Tak Hai Jaan, if not quite a masala movie, is very much from a proven genre, plus it came with the star power of Shah Rukh Khan and Katrina Kaif, and the names of Yash Chopra and A.R. Rahman. The only two films that seem surprising additions to this club are 3 Idiots and Barfi!, the former a “social comedy,” pumped full with messages, and the latter a whimsical dramedy. Had Aamir made Ghajini 2 and had that film not made 100 crore, then there would be something to talk about. Why put these pressures on Talaash?

But that, I suppose, is part of the baggage of being a star — even a star director, for that matter. A lot of the number crunching around Lincoln has revolved around the fact that Steven Spielberg has, after a long time, had a $100 million hit. (His last blockbuster was the pre-sold Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull; his last non-franchise, non-blockbuster film to hit that mark was Catch Me If You Can, a whole decade ago). You cannot completely do away with these expectations. But the difference is that there have been scores of other kinds of articles written about Lincoln, ranging from The Scoop: Why Lincoln Grew a Beard to How Steven Spielberg’s Lincoln Benefited from Crony Capitalism to The Eternal Reach: How Steven Spielberg’s Evolving Ideas Continue to Ignite Cinema. And all we have about Talaash is endless handwringing about a numerical benchmark. You’re probably going to tell me that our mainstream media doesn’t have space, any longer, for serious, analytical writing about cinema, but isn’t that why blogs were invented?

http://www.thehindu.com/arts/cinema/for-the-love-of-money/article4225920.ece

Post Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

1000 mg zithromax online prednisone 40 mg 3 day cipro dosage mg propecia cheap xenical 120 mg leaflet nexium mups 20 mgs 200 mg viagra dose viagra dose 50mg order 50mg cialis lexapro 5 mg price zovirax tabs 800mg 1000 mg zithromax chlamydia viagra 100 mg. upotreba cialis generico italia prednisone 20mg 477 generic viagra bulk safe clomid online generico di augmentin 50mg viagra effect 120mg of lasix propecia uk cheapest cheap 72 hour cialis cialis online consigli buy viagra topix 2.5mg of cialis generic strattera reviews generic mexican viagra nolvadex pct 20 mg kamagra 100mg frau zestril lisinopril 10 mg order doxycycline paypal amoxil bd generico online levitra order buy viagra online erythromycin 500mg medicine diflucan tablet 150 mg nexium 20 mg pakkausseloste kamagra 100 mg upustvo lisinopril 25 mg tablet 100mg de clomid viagra online goedkoop phenergan 25mg tablets 50 cheap cialis .ca viagra mexico online discount online propecia viagra kamagra 100mg cialis 2 x 5mg lexapro tabletas 20 mg online rezept cialis mg of propranolol xenical cheapest price 3000 mg viagra skusenosti buy clomid therapy nexium packets 10mg 5mg lexapro alcohol lexapro 10mg tablets levitra 20mg 4 st viagra online dhl order 150 mg viagra levitra 20 mg india viagra cheapest pharmacy viagra 25mg uk generico do viagra kamagra 100 mg upotreba erythromycin 400mg 5ml cialis cuantos mg cialis 20mg dauer sertralin zoloft 50 mg condom viagra online augmentin tab 500 mg viagra cialis generici prednisone 30 mg dosage buy doxycycline dosage prednisone 20 mg ingredients buy doxycycline caps generic clomid walmart viagra buy local lisinopril 0.5 mg real viagra 100mg levitra 10 mg posologie lasix 20 mg preis cialis generic 40 mg buy cheap viagra 100 viagra online satis order Cialis 10 Tabs levitra 20 mg facts change generic wellbutrin cialis cheap brand Levitra pill Buy generic viagra euro Online Generic Levitra order xenical philippines generic wellbutrin seizures generic to nexium buy glucophage xr doxycycline 50 mg daily viagra 100mg sideeffect kamagra 100 mg wirkungsdauer buy nexium 40 mg novo metformin 500mg cialis 5mg tratamento metformin 500 mg e cialis online vanzare online brand propecia online cialis ordering cialis 100mg tablet tesco online viagra buy propecia fast generic viagra bodybuilding levitra generico 20 mg 50 mg viagra cheap buy doxycycline onlinemalaysia cialis 5 mg 36 generic viagra japan esiste cialis 200 mg prednisone kidney disorders zoloft mg strengths buying cheap cialis prednisone 15 mg taper cialis genuine buy cialis 10 mg bestellen azithromycin generic zithromax cipro xr 1000 generico valtrex generic pill augmentin xr 1000 generic cipro 1000 mg xl clomid online twins generico de lasix cialis online 5mil priligy online forum levitra 20mg 4st viagra online flashback viagra 100mg kosten generico del bactrim 2o mg levitra cialis australia cheap buying celebrex mexico celebrex uk 200mg propecia generic prices zithromax 200 mg 5 bactrim 400 800 mg erythromycin 200 mg 5 ml buy cialis beijing bugiardino levitra 10 mg comprar priligy generico lisinopril dehydration 2.5mg cialis 2 5mg bula lisinopril dosage 80 mg viagra chennai online doxycycline 25mg tablet legit cheap viagra 500mg valtrex uses 100 cialis 5mg buy amoxil bencard levitra work 10mg viagra generico opinioni 500 mg zithromax prednisone zentiva 20mg buy valtrex generic celebrex 100mg caps generic propranolol manufacturers propranolol sa 160 mg 80 mg nexium safe 20 mg di levitra thuoc clomid 10mg propranolol al 40 mg levitra mg strength lexapro 2mg cialis generica 40mg to buy nolvadex metformin 500 mg symptoms kamagra online schweiz buy levitra europe xenical italy buy doxycycline online doxycycline 50mg 30 tablets buy doxycycline 40 200mg 200 mg of wellbutrin cialis 5mg tschechien search cheap levitra amoxil 500 mg coupen green viagra online 100 mg nolvadex generic xenical bestellen viagra tablets online 100 mg unprescribed clomid cheap kamagra tablets kamagra kapsule 800mg cialis 20 mg discount diflucan 150 mg uomo cialis daily generica dapoxetine generic india synthroid equivalent generic doxycycline hyc 100 mg buy xenical roche buying viagra gel preis zithromax 500mg escitalopram generic lexapro buy viagra.ca celebrex 400 mg pret buy nolvadex real steroids online prednisone cialis 5 mg. storys 25 mgs of cialis buy cialis sweden nolvadex dosage 5mg tetracycline 250 mg chlamydia buy clomid generic wellbutrin dosage 75 mg xenical 120 mg tablets levitra 10 mg dosage viagra online perth zoloft 100 mg insomnia 300mg wellbutrin xl xenical generic canada zithromax 600mg notice viagra trial generic buy kamagra jakarta cialis generica net clomid cheap online propecia buy online generic viagra march 2012 lexapro 10 mg ervaringen order cialis canada lexapro cheap generic viagra 100mg swiss xenical 120 mg resultados kamagra 100 mg sachet generic lexapro nausea cialis online international 2 10 mg levitra pills china buy cialis get lisinopril online viagra 100mg nebenwirkungen cipro 500mg testicle orjinal cialis 20 mg nolvadex 100 mg viagra online purchases cialis online bih wellbutrin 100 mg tablet doxycycline 20 mg capsules cheap viagra jellys generic zoloft hives buy viagra pill xenical acquisto online lisinopril 2.5mg tab viagra romania buy price valtrex 500mg cialis india online v 5092 20 mg prednisone kamagra online canada cialis boots order zithromax monodose 250 mg lisinopril 100mg buy kamagra sukhumvit generic viagra 20 mg glucophage 500mg nebenwirkungen cheap liquid viagra cheap viagra samples 25mg of viagra lasix 20 mg injection generic cialis exists generic brands cialis cialis 5mg meals buy viagra istanbul erfahrung cialis 5 mg nexium 40 mg directions taking 10 mg cialis levitra 10mgs lexapro 40 mg fibromyalgia buy propecia ny cialis 5 mg preturi 20 or 40 mg cialis 20 mg nolvadex eod generic viagra paypal synthroid 25mg doxycycline injectable buy generic wellbutrin images buy xenical reviews bactrim f 800 160 mg lexapro generic ingredients viagra pe 150mg nexium mups 40mg cheap cialis usa levitra generika 20mg cialis pro 40 mg presentacion cialis 10 mg cialis malaysia 200mg lisinopril 10 mg nebenwirkungen strattera 40 mg ndc zithromax order 50mg viagra duration brand levitra 10mg foro levitra generico viagra generic medication online viagra legitimate cialis 5 mg cheap buspar bipolar disorder generic cialis .nu buying augmentin online cheapest brand cialis wellbutrin 125 mg purchase levitra generic celebrex 200mg australia buy 10 lasix pills buy cialis brisbane dosage 25 mg phenergan viagra generico contrassegno cialis online venezuela prednisone 10mg high buy 5g propecia buy zovirax injection generic viagra bbb priligy generico italia viagra 100mg comprar amoxil 250 mg capsules generic name amoxil buy levitra onli kesan clomid 150mg order propecia men buy cipro 500 tesco viagra buy ervaringen clomid 50mg viagra 1oo mg viagra tesco online dosage xenical 120 mg 10 mg cialis daily generic viagra onlineusa strattera 60 mg generic cialis mg difference generic levitra 517 propranolol 20 mg bula valtrex generic form order cialis coupons propranolol 40 mg comprimido viagra online america nexium 40 mg thailand celebrex 100mg prices augmentin 250 mg 5 ml walgreens generic cialis lexapro escitalopram generic soft generic viagra viagra 200mg cheapest online cialis 200 mg 200 mg wellbutrin sr doxycycline 100mg 393 packes cipro online australia cialis paypal cheap levitra online sales results 0,25mg propecia remedio nexium 40 mg online viagra cialis online purchases prednisone 1 mg price viagra de 3000 mg cheap bactrim kamagra online lastschrift cialis 20 mg effervescent diflucan 150 mg prospecto buy cialis email viagra gold 800mg merks generics propecia cheap buy viagra guaranteed propecia online zovirax 500mg generic wellbutrin drug generic propecia nz buy zoloft 50mg kamagra 100mg bijsluiter augmentin mg cialis 2.5 mg online buy levitra edmonton cialis generica 5mg buy synthroid australia cipro 500 mg medication lisinopril 40 mg lup online cialis diagnosis doxycycline 600mg headache cialis 5 vs 10mg strattera tic disorder search cheap viagra levitra de 10mg dog prednisone 5mg diflucan 100mg candida bactrim strong buy cialis generico 2 5 mg buy zovirax online cialis buy singapore levitra dapoxetine online buy levitra tablets viagra 400mg dosis kamagra 100 online nexium 20 mg capsules lexapro 5mg success cheapest price valtrex costco valtrex generic prednisone 20 mg ivf zithromax buy chlamydia generic chinese cialis levitra odt 10mg augmentin 620mg generic priligy 60 mg doxycycline 100mg antimalarial doxycycline 110 mg tablets lasix 40 mg vo viagra 100 oder 50 mg metformin 1000 mg hexal australian cialis 100mg 600 mg wellbutrin high online zovirax order is strattera generic online medical viagra nolvadex 20 mg pct nexium 40mg laboratorio buy clomid cod viagra online vendita 500mg metformin enough viagra online belgie prednisone 5 mg sciatica wellbutrin hcl 75mg buy 25 mg viagra viagra buy prescription obat doxycycline 10mg levitra mg10 prednisone 5mg information diflucan generic version online viagra al bactrim prescription online kamagra 50 mg gel propranolol 40 mg trac augmentin prospect 1000 mg by online cialis cialis 20mg asli buspar 5 mg erowid generic viagra 24h cheap prescription cialis 50mg clomid triplets order diflucan one propecia online vitamins clomid 100mg instructions prednisone 5mg online cialis 5 y 20 mg nolvadex 25mg order viagra 25 mg viagra matrix 120 mg lisinopril 10 mg pink generic lexapro mages levitra 20 mg. tabletas propecia original buy erythromycin 250 mg uses generic viagra 130 mg metformin 500mg tablets 30 mg of propranolol teva prednisone 50mg generic viagra walmart valtrex 500 mg pret augmentin duo 500mg spectrum 500mg cipro cialis prescription buy prednisone 20mg biogaran natural generic viagra cheapest viagra ever medication viagra online amoxil 500mg wiki cipro usa order cheapest propecia prices bactrim 800mg kamagra 100 mg price viagra price buy viagra 25 mg works celebrex 81 mg aspirin buy nolvadex wholesale lisinopril al 5 mg nexium 20 mg coupons cialis 5 mg spc strattera generic prices viagra online tn augmentin sale online cialis generique 50mg generic strattera .80 mg buy viagra 100 online preco clomid 50mg lasix 100 mg generico de diflucan cheap cialis from zoloft 50 mg farmaco cheap viagra 200 mg buy cialis eli ebay generic viagra tetracycline 200mg 5mg propecia safe cialis 10 mg prospecto nolvadex 20 mg day cialis 10 mg pret free valtrex online cialis comenzi online is generic cialis cyproheptadine periactin 4mg composition celebrex 200mg