BARADWAJ RANGAN: For the love of money

Why does most of our discussion about cinema centre primarily on box-office collections, especially if a big star is involved?

As I write this, Bollywood-oriented websites are screaming that Talaash has finally entered the 100-crore club, though this figure includes revenues from overseas. (The domestic total is a little under Rs. 85 cr.) At the time of release, the story was slightly different. The website boxofficecapsule.com mourned, rather ungrammatically, “Talaash collected rather good numbers over weekend and was expected to fetch good numbers on weekdays. But film dropped with every passing day and it was apparent that this time audience at large did not like the content of Aamir Khan’s latest offering.” Then came the clincher. “Film collected further 3.50 cr nett on Thursday and film has finished week one at 67 plus cr nett. Film has to collect 30 cr plus in 2nd week in order to reach 100 cr nett mark…” And the second week’s total was a mere Rs. 15.5 crore, which means that Talaash will not join the 100-crore club when only domestic receipts are totalled.

This has been the dominant mode of discourse around the film, apart from reviews and a stray opinion piece or two expressing indignation over Aamir Khan’s apparent endorsement of superstition. On the other hand, had Talaash been a Hollywood movie, these are some of the topics that would have risen around the film’s release, in newspapers, magazines and web sites: the best supernatural-suspense films of all time; 10 best cops with moustaches; the origins of rug-pulling in the movies; how spouses in the cinema deal with loss; the literary tradition of lonesome policemen; why hookers in cinema, with the exception of Julia Roberts in Pretty Woman, just cannot catch a break; 10 reasons Talaash would have sucked had there been a male in the director’s chair; Farhan Akhtar’s evolution as a dialogue-writer; from Dil Chahta Hai to Talaash, a look at the male-centric multiplex movie; and, this being awards season, why Talaash won’t win the Oscar for Best Actor.

In short, we’d have had a range of writing around the movie, from the super-serious to the ultra-silly. And I’m not even talking about the lengthy profiles and interviews, the comment pieces and the debates that would have appeared. But here, all we seem to do is bother about the box office. That’s not wrong. You can do serious reporting using facts and figures that make up the trade aspect of a film. But when all those reports converge around a single question, whether or not Talaash will enter the 100-crore club, it’s depressing — not just because we can’t seem to think of other things to write about and around the film, but because the 100-crore mark itself is meaningless with this sort of film, with restricted appeal. That such a moody and slow-paced film made Rs. 85 crore so far is in itself a smashing success story, without speculating if Aamir is still the top Khan.

What, for instance, would Talaash have earned had Salman or Shah Rukh starred in it, both stars with a more massy appeal? Besides, a look at the Wikipedia page of Bollywood’s 100-crore grosser reveals that most of them are masala movies (or variants thereof, like the sci-fi masala Ra.One, or the masala comedy Housefull 2). Jab Tak Hai Jaan, if not quite a masala movie, is very much from a proven genre, plus it came with the star power of Shah Rukh Khan and Katrina Kaif, and the names of Yash Chopra and A.R. Rahman. The only two films that seem surprising additions to this club are 3 Idiots and Barfi!, the former a “social comedy,” pumped full with messages, and the latter a whimsical dramedy. Had Aamir made Ghajini 2 and had that film not made 100 crore, then there would be something to talk about. Why put these pressures on Talaash?

But that, I suppose, is part of the baggage of being a star — even a star director, for that matter. A lot of the number crunching around Lincoln has revolved around the fact that Steven Spielberg has, after a long time, had a $100 million hit. (His last blockbuster was the pre-sold Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull; his last non-franchise, non-blockbuster film to hit that mark was Catch Me If You Can, a whole decade ago). You cannot completely do away with these expectations. But the difference is that there have been scores of other kinds of articles written about Lincoln, ranging from The Scoop: Why Lincoln Grew a Beard to How Steven Spielberg’s Lincoln Benefited from Crony Capitalism to The Eternal Reach: How Steven Spielberg’s Evolving Ideas Continue to Ignite Cinema. And all we have about Talaash is endless handwringing about a numerical benchmark. You’re probably going to tell me that our mainstream media doesn’t have space, any longer, for serious, analytical writing about cinema, but isn’t that why blogs were invented?

http://www.thehindu.com/arts/cinema/for-the-love-of-money/article4225920.ece

Post Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

amazon bactroban buy glipizide without prescription tretinoin gel 1 for sale microcidal 500mg to g cefaclor side effects doctor rocket power wikirogainrogaine neurontin overnight delivery prednisone 50 mg for 5 days viagra gel uk online dapoxetine canada generic viagra on line order pilexil capsulas de aceite fincar 5 mg india wellbutrin weight loss stories does amoxicillin work for staph atenolol side effects weight gain propecia online prescription healthman south africahealthymalehealthyman hoodia weight loss drink costco raloxifene hcl tablets online pharmacies without prescription mobicool power cooler avelox 400 mg cost buy levlen birth control cpg generik daivonex calcipotriol effexor and weight gain taking acticin cream permethrin basket sevre et maine plavix patient assistance forms euroclinix netspend comprar viagra en argentina viagra extreme aciphex side effects treatment buy viagra pfizer online potenz mittel propecia finasteride lidocaine hydrochloride jelly usp 2 used for vistaril 25mg side effects lidocaine injections for pain valafexina in uk antibiotics and birth control how long coversyl 4mg bar la esquina cabo san lucas clonidine 0.1mg patch side effectsclopidogrel viagra and cialias black buy qsymia in canada dilantin levels too high effexor reviews for social anxiety elomet pregnancy yasmine bleeth now is discount press legitimate buy zovirax ointment medicationzyban oxazepam drug screen no prescription online pharmacy india temovate emollient cream ciprobay antibiotic cialas 800 mg otc inhaler generic viagra forum tamsulosin flomax classification mail order amoxicillin inhouse drugstore uk suhagra pills zantac 150 dosage directions buy retin a online no prescription bactroban nasal ointment generic cardizem side effects with cats anti anxiety drugs canada digoxin and potassium chloride tamsulosin flomax and erectile dysfunction cheap gabapentin online no rx ampicillin overnight shipping hoodia gordonii plus gnc tetracycline 500mg no prescription advair online no prescription gnc ed pills medsindia comcast login buying cialis cheap levofloxacin 500 mg tablet side effects to purchase cialis in australia isoptin sr 240 mg verapamil pfizer careers cialis online us antibiotics for bronchitis in children 40 viagra pills for 99 dollars south african online pharmacy meclizine medication mirapex dosage and administrationmircette imitrex dosage and administration buy prozac online uk 351 powpill 100 verapamil er 240 mg leconfield kennels von hytrin prostate drug crestor vs lipitor 2012 acticin 5 cream blue force viagra amerimedrx complaints definition actos lawsuit news ciprobay 500mg information hydrodiuril hydrochlorothiazide clozaril registry mylan prednisona 20 mg duetact 30mg codeine spiriva inhaler pravachol side effects cough medoflucon fluconazole for dogs salzarex pharmaceuticals duramycin for gonorrhea super calcium carbonate ca 8000 buy medicine from cannada orlistat amiloride hctz 5 50 cialis at discount breast cancer tamoxifen alternatives viagra buy houston best price online pharmacy revista kosovarja cefixime generic cheap sertralina nombre comercial content marketing definition buy alesse without prescription bupron sr priligy thailand lantus insulin price get a priscription for viagra online requip medication side effects buy lybrel uk cialis generic best price ordering 40 mg acquten canada metformin no prescription sibutramine hydrochloride side effects is cialis covered by medicare viagra preisvergleich rezeptfrei generic viagra online india anafranil medication tamsulosin side effects teeth resources for cialis carprofen 100 mg tablets furacin spray for horses anxiety disorder symptoms tingling order antibiotics online uk ativan medication for alcohol withdrawal no prescription online pharmacy indocin 50mg side effects actos side effects water retention remedies lipvas cipla india serophene and multiple births record flonase otc fda paxil generic side effects orlistat no prescription usa mircette reviews 2012 mentat himalaya herbals myambutol ethambutol dosage generic accuatne online buy zithromax z pack for sale mastercard vicodin withdrawal symptoms high blood pressure isoniazid pronunciation of english words sublingual drugs keflex antibiotic information cephalexin amoxicillin dosage for cats detrol la generic nizoral cream hair loss study viagra ohne rezept bestellen colcrys 0.6mg how to take zithromax side effects azithromycin does topiramate change your metabolism que es omifin pastillas douleur regle aggrenox medication and plavix extra super cialis comune santa luce xatral od side effects doxycap 100mg morphine be pharmacy order brand viagra online how to take levitra 20 mg novox carprofen for humans amoxicillan without a prescription supradol ketorolaco 30mg serophene and multiple births repronex risperdal risperidone children bactrim ds 800 160 tab nitrazepam dosage for melatonin fgr 100 generic viagra tronto drug store neurontin medication side effects prednisone mail order amikacin peak and trough timing cytotec lima colchicine treatment for gout clomid ovulation pills for sale alberta tinidazole over the counter drug avalide side effects patient comments zyvox lawsuits oxazepam 15mg side effects fungsi metronidazole lanoxin drug side effects canadian pharmacies that accept amex overnight for usa order viagra online rythmol dosage requip drug canadian pharmacy 24h com vn viagra black citrate synthase deficiency octreotide infusion protocol vigamox prednisolone eye drops side effects zantac side effects acnelyse ingredients in tylenol terramycin ointment for cats wellbutrin withdrawal symptoms side effects quiero comprar cytotex en argentina olanzapine for sale from canada cabaser dosage pct terminal oxazepam 15mg capsule forced cum letrozole gynecomastia before and after where to buy acticin 5 viagra from canadian pharmacies buy viagra out of us buy femora cialis australia catafast dosage of tylenol northwest pharmacy canada review can you buy vermox over the counter norvasc 5 mg picture quickest delivery of viagra to sydney kamagra oral jelly paypal buy prednisone for poison ivy 5 mg predisome canada highest strength cialis prednisolone without prescription proventil inhaler medication drug ranigast max cena biaxin xl antibiotic online meds for uti cardura medication reviews valtrex and shingles treatment minoxidil 10 erection pictures nitrazepam vs diazepam dosage toy cockapoo puppies for sale in michigan mometasone 0.1 ear drops buspar medication side effects viagra prescription on line buspirone side effects weight gain risnia tablets at walmart accutane lawsuit settlements canada procalisx scampi female viagra sildenafil viagra tablet ranbaxy pharmaceuticals news nasonex side effects when will generic viagras be available toprol xl 25 mg serax oxazepam medication cialis giornaliero acquisto cialis buy sweden restonite ambien addiction provera 10mg medroxyprogesterone acetate vagiral ovulos femeninos sito sicuro comprare cialis lopid medications viagra going generic 100mg viagra price what is amantadina clorfenamina paracetamol stromectol buy amazon vytorin generic alternative usmedicbay paxil amiloride hcl used effexor xr best non prescription pharmacies cabaser reviews on fifty clomid success stories on first round claravis accutane best no prescription online pharmacy nhs omeprazole side effects cialis da 5 mg generic finasteride health shop colcrys 0 6 mg tablet hydrea or hydroxyurea tretinoin cream usp 0.025 for wrinkles healthpoint blue pill buy doxycycline hyclate online depomedrol no rx required uso terpeutico del chalis e viagra order xenical online pharmacy prinivil side effects medication terramycin for dogs dosage ciprodex sterile otic suspension in eye nebivolol side effects patients hyzaar american express online viagra next day delivery what is casodex bicalutamidecatafast prandin side effects repaglinide drug desogen birth control pills buy painkillers online decadron dosage for croup viagra canadian check coumadin side effects coumadin vitamin k foods ritalin vs adderall vs dexedrine antibiotics for ear infections and sinusitis mtabs reviews for fifty phentermine 37.5 reviews depakote and weight gain or loss buy meloxicam uk health and beauty discounts elomet cream ointment ovral no prescription lipothin injections for arthritis clindamycin 150mg capsules side effects alfuzosin er 10mg tab glipizide er 10mg tablet viapro ingredients for lasagnaviargaviasek buy valacyclovir buy ammocillin online paypal cod pharmacies for pain medications biaxin side effects in women increasing sperm count diet elimite 5 where to buy metallica onesie flomax for kidney stones dosage duvadilan drug isoxsuprine percocet dosage for severe pain levofloxacin 500 mg interaction with nexium ketorolac 10mg street value champix tablets side effects vigrx reviews amazon no prescription discount pharmacy acyclovir side effects symptoms keflex for uti in pregnancy biaxin antibiotic for sinus infection singulair allergy medicine side effects alfuzosin hydrochloride 10 mg viagra 110 mg viagra riyadh non prescription calais elocon lotion scalp finax cereal garlic bread recipe food network pravachol 40mg price where can i order aygestin online betacin eye drop where to buy clalis drugs himcolin benefits of honey obat licodexon does lasix help pass a drug test benicar medication side effects rapidtabs viagra cabergoline drug coupon viagra pill for sale kamagra chewable buy isotretinoin online kuwait vitamix recipes weight loss buy finasteride online lowest price where to buy tadalafil beconase nasal spray generic viagra site that excepts mastercard kamatra gel manicure cialis softabs 20mg metallica enter sandman video oxazepam drug testing new prescription 25 gift card edrugstore reviewselifemeds diclofenaco de sodio dosis clavaseptin 50 mg zoloft vitamix recipes free qvc cialis prix clotrimazole lozenges 10mg vasotec iv half life tijuana pharmacy prices lozol medication cialis rezeptfrei paypal acquistare cialis generico con ebay best ed pill over the counter xenical precio colombia salzarex tramadol capsules 50mg orlistat 60 mg capsules canada buy lantus in canada for us myrx olanzapine levoxyl side effects abilify maintena cost of propecia ireland maxifort zimax 100 mg best generic cialis website cialis for sale glendale ca strattera usa overnight kamatra gelish gel escitalopram 10mg espanol dosage of famvir for shingles rohypnols dubai canesoral in usa levaquin lawsuit settlements new jersey discount brandedcialis online octreotide infusion doseolanzapine generic nexium without prescription lasuna food for less tylenol recall viagra pills online canada macrobid for uti treatment ivermectin side effects on dogs can you get high off indomethacin pharmacy technician training cialis prescription online lisinopril medication generic name nizoral cream 2 treatment where to buy naproxen ospamox 1000mg pret rxlist pill identification tool viagra with dapoxetine online levofloxacin 750 mg uses tadalafil mastercard over night viagra metazole cream puff rapidtabs reviews on fifty advantage one federal credit union morrison clomid fast delivery albuterolnoprescription reviews apo sildenafil 50 mg cardinal bank mclean va colchicine side effects liver probenecid drug info catafast 50 mg viagra walgreens otc asthma medicine shop for generic cialis aap ki adalat tv serial rhinathiol syrup indication what is aristocort ointment cialis dosage vs viagra coumadin for sale recommended viagia sites esomeprazole 40mg price maxalt 10 mg mlt cialis5mg sold on line furasemidum to buy uk adderall withdrawal amphetamines danazol drug interactions dapoxetine actual work lopid gemfibrozil retail price for cialis thalidomide multiple myeloma dexamethasone sotalol medication for dogs lialda side effects weight gain zofran medication dosage pregnant man has baby viagra hungary diclofenaco de sodio medicamento pirifur tamoxifen buy online uk viagra or similar products grathazon 0 5 mg zopiclone 7.5 mg tablets cymbalta on line flomist cipla field nolvadex pct guide cyctotec non generic brand proventil hfa inhaler coupons costco travel nolvadex side effects for women ic ciprofloxacin online drugstore usa cefalexina english antibioticos singulair side effects in toddlers generic viagra does it work cipralex information medication cialis 5mg online without prescriptions cefabiot 500mg amoxicillin indian viagras myambutol adverse reactions to morphine doxazosin medication doctor inderal and weight gain alfredo volpi biografia caffeine and breastfeeding orlistat capsules 120mg can you buy viagra in mexico walgreens 4 00 generic list clorfenamina compuesta lasix mexico zometa calculator ampicillin sulbactam side effects risnia syrup dispenser rualis 20 ambien addiction ambien withdrawal symptoms online pharmacy buy accutane amoxicillin cap500mg clindamycin phosphate lotion torsemide side effects demadex androgel testosterone cost gumigem usair diamox side effects acetazolamide mechanism buy finpecia cheap puretone hearing test diazepam for dogs uk drugs plendil medications hytrin medication doctor puretone hearing aids mesa az donepezil hcl 10mg tab ceftin for sinus infection dosage metformin er 500mg tab feldene flash drug literature allopurinol side effects mayo clinic viagra cijena ljekarna