And then you go and spoil it by saying something stupid like ” You must believe in God”

I had problem s with both the films I saw recently, Jab Tak Hai Jaan and Life of Pi, and God seem sto be the culprit in both the cases. Of course with the former it was problem hi problem with no mitigating pleasures. But thanks to a few rankling elements, Life of Pi wasn’t a completely satisfying experience either.

Right away let me state that Life Of Pi is an awesome technical as well as storytelling achievement. The use of 3-D to create mesmerizing visuals and the use of computer graphics animation to create Richard Parker , the royal Bengal tiger is an unparalleled achievement in contemporary cinema. The droll characters of Pi’s family, the charming ambience of Puducherry, the sheer narrative bombast of a zoo being transported across the seas and the sinewy story telling involving a boy and tiger adrift mid-sea is a far too a sumptuous offering not to satisfy any film lover’s appetite

And then you go and spoil it all by saying something stupid like ” You must believe in God because…”
And because?

Because it’s the better story.

Now that raises a lot of problem.

First, it is debatable. One could always find the story with the cook, the mother and the sailor. And it is grossly unfair not to show the other story , while presenting the preferred story in all its lovely detail, and ask us make the call.
Secondly, just asking someone to believe in God because it is the better story is as good as saying you need not believe God if you are looking for the truth. I mean I am a non-believer, but I find Ramakrishna Paramahansa’s story very moving because he said , ‘ Yes. I can see Goddess Kali as clearly and as surely as I see you.’

Thirdly, the case that one should believe in God because it is better story could have been made with any two contrasting stories, why this one? It would have made artistic sense only of the story somehow encapsulated the eternal question that Man faces. Then one could say bringing God into the picture answers the eternal questions so well., so elegantly, so beautifully, so satisfyingly. None of that happens here.

I mean this is no The Seventh Seal.

Fourthly, the God angle takes away from the impact of the main story which was so powerfully, so lovingly staged. There were many strands there the film could latch on to stage a climax. Richard Parker turning away without saying goodbye was one of them, especially it echoed so lyrically with Pi’s own regret at not having said a proper goodbye to Anandi. It could bea bout whether an animal could love a human , or is it just you seeing the reflection of your own love? Is it true of any love? Love of one human being for another? Love of a human being for God?

Perhaps to win a Booker, a book must appear to be very clever and all that, but does good powerful story need the crutch of an allegory and an appendage of asking some big questions explicitly? The Castaway did not need it. The Old Man and The Sea did not need I, and Hemingway won a Nobel. And it was just the story of an old man and a fish!
And then there is the business of carnivorous island? How does that fit with the tone of the rest of the film? I mean it just demolishes all the wonder we have been feeling about the extraordinary journey this young boy had on the sea with this tiger. The zoo animals being transported on a ship and being torn asunder in a thunderstorm was fantastic..but it was all framed in the coordinates of the real. I know. It’s magic realism and all that.

But isn’t realism so much more magical at times?

Old Man and the Sea anyone?

( And as to how God brought down Jab Tak Hai Jaan, that was already falling to pieces, actually there are far too many gods involved there, from Adi Chopra to SRK to Rahman Sir to Sir Jesus … so may be when I have lot more time to kill.)

4 Comments

  1. FS
    FS
    November 29, 2012 at 3:36 AM

    Just coz of god element u didnt like pie?

  2. iitianWay
    iitianWay
    November 29, 2012 at 11:54 AM

    good god ..i missed that line ..while searching for my dropped popcorn somewhere ;)
    amazing movie with amazing visuals..and with carni island..which tells us one thing ..what u see or is beautiful in daylight ..may not be same in dark/night.
    planning one more watch this weekend…for visual one rather than narrated one.

  3. FS
    FS
    November 30, 2012 at 2:11 AM

    Iam sorry to say but your review for talaash may be on par with Life of Pie… Just till the beginning of climax its fucking awesome. Keep u totally engaged

Page 1 of 1

Post Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

viagra without prescription australia slimex online finasteride medication 5 mg stopping zoloft going to cymbalta side rizatriptan 10 mg price vigrande 100mg diphenhydramine glyprin 100mg diphenhydramine desyrel for sleep clorfenamina compuesta betapace 160 mg colchicine 0.6 mg tablet wsw cost of prednisone in mexico airol cream ciprodex in eyes brand cialis usa cheap prozac no prescription arcoxia 120 mg tablets caja con 7 metoprolol succinate vardenafil hcl cialis 5mgs minoxidil 5 solution for women beconase nasal spray otc floxin drops for canine ear infections viagra pills online canada cleocin hcl salzarex pharmacyclics femara drug interactions eldepryl manufacturers increasing sperm count and motility naturally salbutamol sulfate drug warfarin drug interactions chart hydroxyzine hcl 25 mg tablet what is it used for restonite reviews on vigrx tadalafil citrate wikipedia cialis on internet no prescription phamacy canana non prescription what is in claritin d ingredients maxalt mlt side effects chloroquine phosphate tablets accutane without a perscription isoptin sr 240 mg codeine erfahrungen mit viagra weight loss pills bactroban ointment buy viagra india no prescription paypal canadian pharmacy taking paypal isoniazid side effects dose coversyl 8mg saroten nebenwirkungen antidepressivascialisseagrasecuremedseladermseptra ampicillim online cvs cialis 20mg price astromenda search removal combo packs viagra and cialis order viagra online with echeck ic doxycycline hyclate 100mg omifin pastillas cuanto cuestan farmacias usa online ampicillin trihydrate fs cialis super force reviews viagra online echeck search http timberlinehotels index aleve dosage naproxen lasaoren search engine escitalopram oxalate 10mg percent of diarrhea side effect side effects of generic viagra viagra and premature ejaculation tricor medication fenofibrate target nexium on line order kamagra suppliers levitra professional 20 mg ed meds usa 100mg water pills retirides 0 025 in fractions form 2089 cheap paxil on line budesonide drug cost at walgreens where can i buy viagra with paypal amantadina para parkinson arimidex side effects forum fluoxetine uk buy zovirax ointment over the counter provera to start period pill how can i save money on viagra paxil for anxiety reviews generic finasteride uk cheap dutasteride glucovance 2.5 500 side effects online meds for uti levothroid recall 2015 chevy prexanil en espanol precio mebendazole dosage for adults benazepril hydrochlorothiazide 10 12.5mg viagra side effects alcohol levitra generic drugstore reditabs viagra natural substitute for lisinopril priligy rezeptfrei nolvadex side effects for women lipitor shelf life cefalexina english antibioticos sibutramine hydrochloride side effects buying levitra with paypal muscle relaxer mix with viagra motrin dosage chart synthroid side effects weight loss morphine pills 60 mg methocarbamol robaxin abuse letrozole ovulation induction ventolin inhaler side effects consumer reports generic viagra proventil inhaler medication price rxdiler store over counter prednisone arthritis foundation subutex withdrawal during pregnancy viagra in america sildegra tablet cases beconase aq nasal spray used for minocycline 100 mg for acne vardenafil orodispersible definition kamagrafast crooks n no prescription needed for levitra finasteride 1 mg prices pfizer stock symbol viagra brand without prescription pentrexyl ampicilina 500 mg para que sirve alli back in stock kosovarja gazeta shqiptare tirana chat link software buying viagra bucharest cefaclor drug study are cipla drugs safe atarax 25mg hydroxyzine synthroid side effects medications what is zenegra 100 eprex dose in dialysis patients doqi clinical practice viagra si perdoret prazosin 1mg cap onlain filmebi qartulad orlistat over the counter alli nonprescription tegretol in usa yasmine galenorn otherworld series reglan 10mg medication leponex tableta dejstvo surutke buy spironolactone sales cialis unicure remedies pvt ltd sildenafil rocket lawyer com login curacne wikipedia english metallica one lyrics buy domperidone on line epharmacy online timer does zofran help diarrhea non rx canada viagra and cialis combo pack sertraline withdrawal symptoms medication valtrex without prescription overnight z pak without prescription tegretol 200mg carbamazepine metoprolol succ er 100 mg viagra for sale in alaska cialis wanking acai berry living xs tadalafil europe enalapril maleate 10 mg lidoderm patch costochondritis viagra dosage women artane side effects trihexyphenidyl 2mg ramicomp genericon 2014 ramipril 2.5mg capsules lipitor withpout presp buy lisinopril 30 no prescription clindamycin hcl quinine side effects doctor viagra pas cher livraison rapide diane von furstenberg luggage toprol medication dosages cialis best price fast delivery motilium online uk neurontin medication side effects cardizem drip propecia finasteride neurontin 24 hour shipping to us cheap trazodone 100mg no prescription cheap meds online betacin tablets percocet 10/325 pictures augmentin vs omnicef for sinus infection faridexon dexamethasone altace medication levitra 10 mg kaufen rezeptfrei cytotec venta online usa farmacia online svizzera ciales puerto rico pictures of ponce antibiotics and birth control effectiveness perisonse wiothout a script canada periactin weight gain baytril for dogs dose naproxen 500mg uses side effects methotraxete canada no prescription harga ketoconazole decadron side effects injection ropinirole hcl 0.5mg tab zyvoxid pfizer animal health tantalum capacitors polarity tinazol cream puffs nifedipine er 30mg what is it used for ephedraxin ingredients in cigarettes indinavir crixivan contraindication impugan lasix furix canadian viagra online medicament cialis prix benadryl for dogs itching how to use praziquantel for fishpredisoneprednazoneprednisolone levothroid medication generic amerimedrx scampi pharmacy tech certification book ed tablets free del amoxicillin rash picture children gabapentin buy online albenza treatment for roundworms provera period started early estrace cream user reviews pharmacys in usa that sell cialis buy cialis brand canada neurontin for pain control extenze male enhancement side effects kamagra usa no prescription canadian pharmacy atosil drops of jupiter buying clomid online uk novolog insulin pump cost of propecia ireland disgracil pills elimite 5 permethrin cream viagra purcgase mastercard im hydrating canadian drugstores ebay viagra pills baytril dogs antibiotic side effects canesoral duodenitis lisinopril buy online medicine like prednisone cipralex 10 mg tabletta 200 mg cialis overnight shipping rapidtabs viagra commercial actress cefadroxil monohydrate medrol dose pack instructions picture best price online cialis 10mg priligy forum alli back stock clopidogrel side effects breathing problems chlamydia discharge elimite over the counter lialda savings card for 2014 buy olanzapine online india canadian 24hr pharmacy cyrux misoprostol 200mg morphine tadalafil tablets 20mg how to use cytotec for abortion eldepryl medication buy plavix in usa requip drug interactions cheaper alternative to levitra onlain igri tabla seroquel and weight gain side effect pfizer stock price today blue force viagra biorezonanta magnetica forum adipex p 37.5mg reviews walgreens employee website employee benefits topamax and alcohol dependence aciphex 20 mg side effects nymphomax review viramune 200mg morphine retin a cream 0.1 tretinoin online generic viagra buy orlistat without prescription baclofen 20 mg price generic viagra cialis levitra cheap best legal on line site to buy cialis naproxen medication side effects tapiales hoy safe to buy viagra online where to buy salbutamol nebules detrol la 4mg capsule side effects gupisone 20 dose description of jesus sumycin 500 mg naproxen how does viagra feel anafranil side effects in children where can i purchase bupropion online spiriva inhaler capsule ativan side effects weight gain himcolin cream puffs best over the counter viagra quinine sulfate 324 mg capsules budesonide nebulizer price average wholesale price drugs 2012 vicodin overdose amount all pill shop online pharm tech degree prilosec side effects omeprazole side effects tegretol toxicity seizures rumafen gel nail 36 hour cialis online peritol weight gain pill sumycin capsules empty purinethol price in singapore betneval lotion making ornidazole dispersible tablets cafergot from mexico tylenol recall levitra overnight without prescription asthma drugs no prescription tadalafil buy online benazepril hcl 20mg zithromax online in us citolapram no rx cheapest lidocaine hydrochloride jelly usp 2 used for alfuzosin hcl 10mg obestat 10 mg benazepril 10 mg tablets femara fertility drug benicar hct 40 12.5 prices tramol online u k lotemax 0.5 eye drops coupons procalisx reviews 50 can i buy viagra in cvs pharmacy buy levlen online no perscription ciprofloxacin sales depakote side effects drug amikacin injection for infants cialis 20 mg walmart price vilches chile earthquake amiloride side effects metformin 500mg side effects en espanol prinivil medication lisinopril nizoral a d mail order cialis canada ofloxacin buy from canada cabergoline side effects dose duetact 30mg methadone ed hardy online site cialis interact where to buy viagra in nyc furacin nitrofurazone inexpensive alli canadian pharmacy ed meds viagra without subscription buy pilex max prednisolone acetate eye drops for dogs sildegra nedir ne best over the counter erection pill voltaren retard prezzo levitra 20mg information vasotec drug classification viagra brand cheap where to get cheap prescriptions potassium chloride side effects medication can i buy viagra in tijuana viagra tablets india buy prednisone 20mg florinef 0.1 mg medication vidalta 10mg oxycontin cozaar side effects cozaar 50 mg best price 5mg cialis can i buy pyridium onlinr viagra online without prescription sinequanone paris dresses levitra vs cialis vs viagra cost 143 lortab hydrocodone 5 500 reglan medication for migraines coumadin diet restrictions medication viagra use in hindi canadian pharmacy prednizone valium withdrawal durationvalrexvaltraxvaltrex how to order clomid on line in canada septra antibiotic side effects suhagra 50 adderall canadian pharcharmy online online prozac no prescroption ivermectin for humans side effects buy norvasc online singulair allergy medicine donde comprar misoprostol irbesartan side effects mayo clinic valium vs xanax medications no doctor viagra vosteran removal windows 8.1 metallica onesie buy ranitidine bismuth citrate glucophage 500mg side effects no 1 pharmacy 2077 buy periactin weight gain pills ditropan medication use viagra beograd ortho tri cyclen lo no prescription diflucan dosage for yeast infection singulair medication side effects how mich is doxycycline lipitor 40mg to buy kamagrafast comcast prednisone 20mg side effects dogs evista medication lasix diuretic buy ephedraxin infobae furolin 100mg side effects butyr fentanyl buy online pharmacies for viagra buy ceslis where to buy retin a cream thyroxine medications clavamox side effects cats generic xenical by mail morphine sulfate 30mg seroquel dosage dose new cialis rx balranald shire council walgreens employee website company employer info lipvas cipla pharmaceuticals buy sildenafil 50mg viagra boots ketorolac tromethamine injections achat de tadalafil au canada renagel vs renvela ampicillin color in india mirtazapine 30 mg tablet side effects bromocriptine buy without prescription rush delivery antibiotic purchase torsemide 20 mg and lupus long term synthroid side effects medication viagra online indonesia diclofenaco de sodio medicamento tafil tofranil anxiety reviews buy cortisone shots online advantage car rental coupon offer saroten retard albanetinfo ciprotab 250 new emojis dapoxetine and viagra cymbalta withdrawal brain zaps aspirin dosage for adults myambutol medicine shoppe omeprazole 20 mg treatment patients espanol how long do baclofen withdrawal symptoms last fasigyn tablets 500mg tiotropium pronunciation citrate magnesium prep for colonoscopy how to buy pills online viagra jellies wikipedia evista and breast cancer prevention overnite shipping on vigar prozac without a perscription can i get viagra in morocco allegra d 12 hour allergy & congestion hyzaar american express nasonex vs nasacort vs flonase levofloxacin 750 mg tablet buy esomeprazole tadarise 10 mg atarax canafa no prescription visa danazol 200mg information buy alli online usa azithromycin sold in stores arimidex breast cancer length of treatment escitalopram side effects in men sildalis reviews viagra vpxl online canada betnovate n cream in usa cheap genuine cialis amikacin injections in cats saroten 25mg viagra can you split ramipril 5mg capsules non perscription valtrex tramadol hcl 50mg treatment tramadol hydrochloride tricor 145 mg buying cialis in canada online online cealis that accepts paypal moduretic side effects propecia finasteride online does viagera help women viagra at cvs topiramate medication for pain aciphex generic date tinidazole 500mg tablets propecia pills eldepryl manufacturer coupons viagra brand online usa cialis dosage hydroxyzine hcl 25 mg tablet reviews pfizer patient assistance program phone number propecia finasteride forum i want to order cialis priligy dapoxetine fda 2014 budget zyvox medication assistance program clomid clomiphene citrate buy buy zanaflex online overnight delivery meds mexico pednisone over the counter at walmart vistaril side effects men online cialis sales celexa buy cefalexina dosis perros