And then you go and spoil it by saying something stupid like ” You must believe in God”

I had problem s with both the films I saw recently, Jab Tak Hai Jaan and Life of Pi, and God seem sto be the culprit in both the cases. Of course with the former it was problem hi problem with no mitigating pleasures. But thanks to a few rankling elements, Life of Pi wasn’t a completely satisfying experience either.

Right away let me state that Life Of Pi is an awesome technical as well as storytelling achievement. The use of 3-D to create mesmerizing visuals and the use of computer graphics animation to create Richard Parker , the royal Bengal tiger is an unparalleled achievement in contemporary cinema. The droll characters of Pi’s family, the charming ambience of Puducherry, the sheer narrative bombast of a zoo being transported across the seas and the sinewy story telling involving a boy and tiger adrift mid-sea is a far too a sumptuous offering not to satisfy any film lover’s appetite

And then you go and spoil it all by saying something stupid like ” You must believe in God because…”
And because?

Because it’s the better story.

Now that raises a lot of problem.

First, it is debatable. One could always find the story with the cook, the mother and the sailor. And it is grossly unfair not to show the other story , while presenting the preferred story in all its lovely detail, and ask us make the call.
Secondly, just asking someone to believe in God because it is the better story is as good as saying you need not believe God if you are looking for the truth. I mean I am a non-believer, but I find Ramakrishna Paramahansa’s story very moving because he said , ‘ Yes. I can see Goddess Kali as clearly and as surely as I see you.’

Thirdly, the case that one should believe in God because it is better story could have been made with any two contrasting stories, why this one? It would have made artistic sense only of the story somehow encapsulated the eternal question that Man faces. Then one could say bringing God into the picture answers the eternal questions so well., so elegantly, so beautifully, so satisfyingly. None of that happens here.

I mean this is no The Seventh Seal.

Fourthly, the God angle takes away from the impact of the main story which was so powerfully, so lovingly staged. There were many strands there the film could latch on to stage a climax. Richard Parker turning away without saying goodbye was one of them, especially it echoed so lyrically with Pi’s own regret at not having said a proper goodbye to Anandi. It could bea bout whether an animal could love a human , or is it just you seeing the reflection of your own love? Is it true of any love? Love of one human being for another? Love of a human being for God?

Perhaps to win a Booker, a book must appear to be very clever and all that, but does good powerful story need the crutch of an allegory and an appendage of asking some big questions explicitly? The Castaway did not need it. The Old Man and The Sea did not need I, and Hemingway won a Nobel. And it was just the story of an old man and a fish!
And then there is the business of carnivorous island? How does that fit with the tone of the rest of the film? I mean it just demolishes all the wonder we have been feeling about the extraordinary journey this young boy had on the sea with this tiger. The zoo animals being transported on a ship and being torn asunder in a thunderstorm was fantastic..but it was all framed in the coordinates of the real. I know. It’s magic realism and all that.

But isn’t realism so much more magical at times?

Old Man and the Sea anyone?

( And as to how God brought down Jab Tak Hai Jaan, that was already falling to pieces, actually there are far too many gods involved there, from Adi Chopra to SRK to Rahman Sir to Sir Jesus … so may be when I have lot more time to kill.)


  1. FS
    November 29, 2012 at 3:36 AM

    Just coz of god element u didnt like pie?

  2. iitianWay
    November 29, 2012 at 11:54 AM

    good god ..i missed that line ..while searching for my dropped popcorn somewhere ;)
    amazing movie with amazing visuals..and with carni island..which tells us one thing ..what u see or is beautiful in daylight ..may not be same in dark/night.
    planning one more watch this weekend…for visual one rather than narrated one.

  3. FS
    November 30, 2012 at 2:11 AM

    Iam sorry to say but your review for talaash may be on par with Life of Pie… Just till the beginning of climax its fucking awesome. Keep u totally engaged

Page 1 of 1

Post Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

buying viagra mastercard bula viagra 50mg viagra online delivery lexapro 20 mg effects lasix 40 mg vidal buy viagra softtabs strattera generic buy buy cialis 50 mg buy xenical roche cialis 10 mg tadalafil lisinopril 30 mg information viagra generico mercadolivre prices levitra 5mg buy zovirax injection generic herbal viagra viagra generico 2011 augmentin 500mg tablets prednisone 1 mg dogs wholesale viagra online acquistare online viagra nexium 40 mg composicion clomid 150 mg success taking clomid 100mg cialis 5mg meals synthroid tab 0.05mg genuine cialis online lasix 500 mg romania india levitra generic generico cialis ultrafarma 50 mg viagra cheap cipro generic ciprofloxacin lexapro 20 mg dose generic vs valtrex 50mg of viagra buying valtrex cheap australia viagra generic synthroid 0.137mg 2 pills 10mg cialis costo cialis 20 mg strattera 60 mg uk cheap clomid 100mg cialis 2.5 mg experience viagra generico originale nexium 40mg australia online cialis us viagra cheapest canada buy viagra bulk metformin ct 500 mg doxycycline 100mg bestellen kamagra pills 500mg phenergan 75 mg purchase cialis 2.5 mg propranolol 10 mg cost tadacip tadalafil 20mg diflucan 150 mg dosis express generic viagra buy celebrex europe viagra online soho cialis 5 mg ceny zovirax 800 mg posologia viagra order generic wellbutrin 300 mg xr propranolol 120mg levitra dosage mg levitra 20 mg fiyat lexapro 10mg panic order propecia australia clomid 50mg ingredients cialis preise 10mg zovirax 800 mg filmtabletten thuoc clomid 10mg 100mg de clomid nexium 20mg aeh lisinopril 5 mg reviews levitra onlines 800mg generic viagra buy clomid uk clomid 50 mg tablet buy lasix 12.5mg valtrex 500 mg endikasyonlari generic wellbutrin 300xl want buy viagra levitra 20 mgs generic viagra weak levitra online sales asda buy viagra lexapro escitalopram generic diflucan 150mg buy propecia cost online cialis mg dose viagra 25 mg works zovirax generic canada celebrex 200 mgm cialis generic buy cialis original 5mg doxycycline 500 mg mexico cialis 5mg 36 buy levitra calgary safest generic cialis generic cialis thailand 1000 mg metformin hcl prednisone 20 mg color online viagra good 100 mg viagra reviews nexium 20 mg posologia generic prednisone 20mg buy levitra india 175 mg of zoloft buy viagra mastercard 20 mg zoloft prednisone 10 mg alcohol usa cheap viagra strattera 25mg high levitra 10 mg bugiardino synthroid 075 mg buy priligy safe australian viagra online augmentin 1 mg prezzo wellbutrin generic headaches 75 mg of wellbutrin doxycycline hyclate generico generic cialis 72 hour nexium 40 mg generic lexapro generic prices cheap cialis pharmasy levitra cheap overnight lexapro withdrawal 2.5 mg lexapro at 0.25mg cialis 20 mg farmaco 500mg valtrex daily generic supplements nolvadex thuoc viagra 100mg generic zoloft pregnancy buy cheap viagra 100 xenical generic drug buy cialis china prednisone 20mg symptoms zithromax 5oomg 100mg viagra kaufen generic viagra buy cialis 10 mg pret cheap viagra vancouver generic viagra women prednisone mg doses cialis 30 mg coupons viagra cheap price wellbutrin xl 100mg buy viagra 100 online buy viagra aurochem viagra 25 mg preciomexico super viagra 150 mg kamagra cheapest ever levitra 10 mg vademecum cheap levitra medications cialis 20mg 4 cialis 5mg boite zoloft 100 mg recreational generic zovirax tab 125mg of viagra priligy dapoxetina 30 mg buy viagra nsw levitra 20 mg canada lisinopril al 5 mg cialis generic means clomid de 50 mg clomid generic uk generic levitra 517 bactrim f 500mg aust generic viagra comprar nexium 20mg nexium 40 mg colombia comprar priligy generico metformin 850 mg preisvergleich kamagra de 50 mg generic viagra does cvs generic viagra buy viagra register viagra pills cheap viagra 30 lu 100mg prednisone dosage 60 mg xenical 120mg tablet buy cialis 5 mgs. cialis online perscription gurnsey cialis online xenical orlistat 120 mg doxycycline hydrochloride 115 mg viagra 150 mg dosage generic synthroid pills cheap viagra 100 mg cheap propranolol online anwendung viagra 50 mg xenical 120mg nhs farmacie online xenical cheap cialis prices generic viagra 24h prednisone 20 mg ingredients prednisone 20mg arrow xenical nz online canadian mailorder viagra buy dapoxetine thailand levitra venta online 150 mg zoloft dose cialis 20mg everyday kosten strattera 10 mg lexapro generic cialis online sales 10 to 15 mgs lexapro cialis kac mg viagra chicago buy cipro xr 1000 generico prednisone 30 mg dosage taking 2 20 mg cialis pink viagra online online viagra mumbai nexium 40mg esomeprazole 100mg sr wellbutrin cialis original 10mg walgreens lisinopril generic teva generic wellbutrin augmentin 100mg cialis 5 mg generique iv phenergan online lexapro generic dosage posologie prednisone 20 mg cialis 10mg preise 10 mg prozac wellbutrin 200 mg diflucan augmentin xr 1000 generic amoxil 500 mg espanol tetracycline 250 mg price effectiveness lexapro 20mg efek xenical 125 mg genericdrugs levitra order propecia men levitra online belgie fast cheap viagra cialis de 100 mg buy zoloft pfizer viagra dose 50mg lasix 40 mg infusion nexium 40 mg cpr metformin 500 mg nausea levitra 20mg 30 cialis daily 10 mg buying viagra cheap real viagra 100mg propecia 0.5 mg buy cialis miami metformin ratiopharm 850mg taking 25 mg zoloft 20mg prednisone dog cheapest generic celebrex buy viagra use lexapro 20mg tab prednisone 5mg pregnancy generico do viagra wellbutrin 125 mg zoloft online order clomid 30mg 200 mg clomid viagra online singapore generic wellbutrin appearance nexium 40mg sac nexium dr 40mg viagra generic drug buspar order online levitra 5 mg posologia lexapro 20 mg identification cialis 20 mg 10 tablet cvs generic levitra 10mg prednisone croup viagra gold 300mg original levitra 20mg viagra soft 50mg metformin er 1500 mg erythromycin 200 mg 5 ml zithromax pfizer 500 mg adoxa doxycycline 150 mg cialis generic effectiveness xenical shopping online bactrim 40 mg viagra cheap legal buy levitra onli cialis 5 mg or 20 metformin cheap cialis 200mg results generic cipro 1000 generic diflucan tablet prednisone 40 mg 3 days generic canadian levitra cialis generic manila beli viagra online soft generic viagra cheap propecia 5mg doxycycline 100mg animals lexapro generic overdose dapoxetine 30mg buy cialis america buy lisinopril 5mg zithromax 1250 mg gonorrhea generic periactin cyproheptadi generic viagra ert 100 change generic wellbutrin order glucophage online levitra bayer 10 mg amoxil 500 mg coupen metformin online kaufen levitra 10mg filmtabletten cialis pills 2.5 mg prendre 2 cialis 5mg nexium generic medication cipro 500mg r xenical 120mg colombia priligy kaufen 30mg vipps viagra online lexapro 150 mg lexapro overmax 20 mg 500 mg valtrex 1000 mg generic valtrex zoloft 100 mg insomnia taking 150 mg zoloft acheter cialis 10 mg sandoz lisinopril 10 mg cialis apotheek online 20 mg di levitra buying zithromax phenergan 25 mg dose diflucan 20 mg online pharmacy cialis online cialis cheapest dominican generic viagra synthroid buy uk levitra 10 mg tablets cialis 5 mg colombia propecia online europa hydrochlorothiazide cost 25mg cheap authenic viagra lexapro tabletas 20 mg ordinare cialis generico cialis 05 mg tetracycline 125 mg 150 mgs clomid bula propranolol 80 mg nexium 80 mg dia buy cipla clomid purchase levitra generic cialis .05 mg buying generic clomid augmentin 250 mg 5 ml generic viagra female propecia cost 5 mg bactrim forte 800 160 mg diflucan 150 mg tratamiento cialis super 20mg viagra online goedkoop buy propecia fast clomid 50 mg nexium 5mg review diflucan 50 mg indian viagra 100mg viagra online kupovina mexico cialis generico cialis 80 mg au generic viagra bestseller cialis gel cheap online fsa viagra cialis online rating buy periactin cheap buy diflucan 150 levitra srbija online wellbutrin and generics augmentin generic brand buy celebrex discount xenical 40mg cialis buy singapore Levitra pill Buy metformin uk buy cialis 50 mg dosage take levitra 40mg novo doxycycline 100mg 2 mg propecia lexapro generic manufacturers buy cialis generico take 200 mg viagra nolvadex 25mg online pharmacy buspar teva prednisone 20mg priligy generico prezzo viagra 100mg deals cumpara viagra online cialis 10 mg precio boots online cialis buy cialis canadian buy cialis 25mg 60 mg levitra cialis generico 10 mg amoxil capsules online pill cheap viagra buy doxycycline nz costo nexium 40 mg 10mgs cialis enough metformin 1000 mg online viagra 100mg preise cialis da 50 mg generic lexapro dreaming buying generic lexapro cheap legal viagra xenical kaufen online bactrim 800 mg online augmentin dawkowanie 500 mg levitra 20mg info buy strattera 100 mg viagra online slovenija medicament celebrex 100mg wellbutrin pharmacy online is cialis generic 5mg cialis price generick viagra viagra oil buy clomid 150mg bfp generic for nexium augmentin 125 mg generic lexapro 20 mg buy diflucan overnight malaria doxycycline 150mg cialis daily generic viagra buy uk viagra generico maxifort legitimate levitra online buy cytotec pills 5mg prednisone wine purchasing nolvadex online levitra 20mg pakistan diflucan 150 mg tablets viagra 25 mg generico cialis viagra 50 mg ervaringen buying viagra paris cialis 10 mg tab wellbutrin xl 50mg 50 vs 100mg viagra viagra cialis generici buy doxycycline 100 mg 2 beli cialis 20 mg cheap viagra samples celebrex 100 mg precio xenical 120mg capsules 42 online viagra legitimate doxycycline 50 mg capsule 20mg lexapro effexor viagra canada order free valtrex online buy prednisone pills viagra cheaper alternatives lexapro online cheap buy cytotec dubai zithromax 500 mg nebenwirkungen strattera 80 mg nausea metformin glucophage online cialis 3800mgx 10 pills cialis daffodils 20mg synthroid mg doses synthroid 150mg propecia acquisto online cheap viagra 50 mg strattera 18 mg nebenwirkungen prednisone 20mg biogaran vente cialis online effets cialis 10mg generic lexapro test 2 mg of prednisone taking 300 mg wellbutrin buy viagra canadian valtrex generic shingles generic zoloft lawsuit buy cialis sydney cheap cialis 40 cheap viagra 20 mg cialis generico aurochem buspar generic 5 mg viagra 100mg women levitra generic 10 zithromax 750 mg enough cheapest generic valtrex buy cheap lasix celebrex 50 mg cialis pro 40 mg clomid generic name metformin 3000 mg day diflucan online uk lisinopril 40 mg identification clomid 50 mg bijwerkingen cialis prescription buy order cialis 40mg prednisone 20 mg cost lilly cialis 10mg buy augmentin 625mg generic celebrex cost 60 mg prednisone