And then you go and spoil it by saying something stupid like ” You must believe in God”

I had problem s with both the films I saw recently, Jab Tak Hai Jaan and Life of Pi, and God seem sto be the culprit in both the cases. Of course with the former it was problem hi problem with no mitigating pleasures. But thanks to a few rankling elements, Life of Pi wasn’t a completely satisfying experience either.

Right away let me state that Life Of Pi is an awesome technical as well as storytelling achievement. The use of 3-D to create mesmerizing visuals and the use of computer graphics animation to create Richard Parker , the royal Bengal tiger is an unparalleled achievement in contemporary cinema. The droll characters of Pi’s family, the charming ambience of Puducherry, the sheer narrative bombast of a zoo being transported across the seas and the sinewy story telling involving a boy and tiger adrift mid-sea is a far too a sumptuous offering not to satisfy any film lover’s appetite

And then you go and spoil it all by saying something stupid like ” You must believe in God because…”
And because?

Because it’s the better story.

Now that raises a lot of problem.

First, it is debatable. One could always find the story with the cook, the mother and the sailor. And it is grossly unfair not to show the other story , while presenting the preferred story in all its lovely detail, and ask us make the call.
Secondly, just asking someone to believe in God because it is the better story is as good as saying you need not believe God if you are looking for the truth. I mean I am a non-believer, but I find Ramakrishna Paramahansa’s story very moving because he said , ‘ Yes. I can see Goddess Kali as clearly and as surely as I see you.’

Thirdly, the case that one should believe in God because it is better story could have been made with any two contrasting stories, why this one? It would have made artistic sense only of the story somehow encapsulated the eternal question that Man faces. Then one could say bringing God into the picture answers the eternal questions so well., so elegantly, so beautifully, so satisfyingly. None of that happens here.

I mean this is no The Seventh Seal.

Fourthly, the God angle takes away from the impact of the main story which was so powerfully, so lovingly staged. There were many strands there the film could latch on to stage a climax. Richard Parker turning away without saying goodbye was one of them, especially it echoed so lyrically with Pi’s own regret at not having said a proper goodbye to Anandi. It could bea bout whether an animal could love a human , or is it just you seeing the reflection of your own love? Is it true of any love? Love of one human being for another? Love of a human being for God?

Perhaps to win a Booker, a book must appear to be very clever and all that, but does good powerful story need the crutch of an allegory and an appendage of asking some big questions explicitly? The Castaway did not need it. The Old Man and The Sea did not need I, and Hemingway won a Nobel. And it was just the story of an old man and a fish!
And then there is the business of carnivorous island? How does that fit with the tone of the rest of the film? I mean it just demolishes all the wonder we have been feeling about the extraordinary journey this young boy had on the sea with this tiger. The zoo animals being transported on a ship and being torn asunder in a thunderstorm was fantastic..but it was all framed in the coordinates of the real. I know. It’s magic realism and all that.

But isn’t realism so much more magical at times?

Old Man and the Sea anyone?

( And as to how God brought down Jab Tak Hai Jaan, that was already falling to pieces, actually there are far too many gods involved there, from Adi Chopra to SRK to Rahman Sir to Sir Jesus … so may be when I have lot more time to kill.)

4 Comments

  1. FS
    FS
    November 29, 2012 at 3:36 AM

    Just coz of god element u didnt like pie?

  2. iitianWay
    iitianWay
    November 29, 2012 at 11:54 AM

    good god ..i missed that line ..while searching for my dropped popcorn somewhere ;)
    amazing movie with amazing visuals..and with carni island..which tells us one thing ..what u see or is beautiful in daylight ..may not be same in dark/night.
    planning one more watch this weekend…for visual one rather than narrated one.

  3. FS
    FS
    November 30, 2012 at 2:11 AM

    Iam sorry to say but your review for talaash may be on par with Life of Pie… Just till the beginning of climax its fucking awesome. Keep u totally engaged

Page 1 of 1

Post Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

metformin online bestellen order lasix cheap 1500 mg wellbutrin cerco viagra generico zithromax 500mg francais amoxil 250mg 5ml 10 mg viagra work buy prednisone local nexium 20 mg australia viagra generic wiki metformin 500 mg polycystic xenical 250mg generic viagra testing lisinopril order online buy viagra 20mg order viagra generic 10mg lexapro costco lisinopril sandoz 30 mg cialis 20mg online nexium 40mg generico viagra causa sordera zoloft withdrawal 100 mg zithromax 250 mg monodose levitra online philippines levitra 20mg wikipedia amoxil 500 mg susp 400 mg doxycycline daily cheap pfizer viagra propecia cheap canada generic viagra europa viagra generico mercadolivre toronto viagra online dosage generic cialis best buy viagra doxycycline online chlamydia generic wellbutrin sr 150 dosierung viagra 25mg xenical 120 mg orlistat buy doxycycline dosage buy levitra.ca xenical 120 mg prezzo valtrex 1500mg day buy pakistani viagra celebrex 200 mg wiki cheap cialis online .50 generic of xenical zoloft 100 mg cost generic viagra philippines doxycycline 100 mg orally buy viagra blackpool nolvadex 20 mg buy lexapro generico lasix 80 mg tablets buy viagra brighton buy periactin pills bactrim mg kg buspar 5 mg tablets online viagra now buy amoxil 250 mg cialis 20 mg efeito prednisone 50mg beneficiios zoloft 6.25mg indicaciones cialis 20 mg does generic valtrex strattera 20 mg 75 mg zoloft lot lisinopril online pengalaman cialis 1800mg viagra 100mg sildenafil doxycycline 100mg regimen lexapro 10 mg ocd viagra 100mg facts generic viagra opinion generic cialis 5 mg generic drug viagra nebenwirkungen metformin 850 mg prednisone 60 mg dog viagra 100mg pills nebenwirkung metformin 850 mg cialis 100mg 20mg order viagra plus diflucan 200 mg capsule cialis pills cheap cialis 80mg review wellbutrin teva generic augmentin 375 mg cena capsulas celebrex 200 mg zoloft 50 mg capsule levitra online orders erythromycin 125mg 5ml cialis 20mg tablete wellbutrin 300 mg fiyati generic zovirax 800 mg wellbutrin buying online lexapro 10 mg ahumada cialis 20 o 10 mg viagra o genericos cialis use 20mg wellbutrin generic works buying fake viagra precio viagra generico diflucan 150 mg ringworm cheapest price cialis mailorder cialis chinese viagra 4000mg buying cialis bangkok generic lexapro 10mg cialis 10 mg tr 1000 mg propranolol 75 mg wellbutrin dosage Levitra 20 mg order lisinopril 20 mg effects cialis 60 mg cheap online kamagra sales celebrex generic online buy viagra phitzer metformin 850 mg n3 nexium dosierung 40 mg estonia generic cialis glucophage 1000 mg overdose lisinopril cheapest cialis 50 mg 100 mg generic otc cialis lisinopril 20 mg tabs cheapest viagra 100 mg levitra oat 10mg generic lexapro mexico cialis available generic metformin teva 850 mg viagra generica online celebrex 200 mg pret levitra 20mg used amoxil 1mg lexapro generic drug cytotec sale online priligy 60mg uk cialis cheap india lisinopril generic lupin cheap cialis daily lexapro generic pill zoloft depersonalization disorder viagra online zoll glucophage metformina 850 mg novo prednisone 50 mg cialis online overseas starting clomid 100mg nolvadex 60mg start viagra 600 mg zithromax 600 mg susp prednisone 1mg viagra online rush lexapro generic version 2012 online canada cialis strattera 100 mg cost order lisinopril online genuine cialis 20mg order doxycycline 100 mg online viagra perscriptions xenical capsule online cheapest viagra alternative coomeva cheap viagra erythromycin creme buy clomid 5 mg cialis 2 x 5mg viagra cheaper alternatives doxycycline acne online started clomid 100mg cialis order australia zithromax 250mg cheapest clomid celebrex medication generic cialis 0.5mg efecto twins 25 mg clomid augmentin 600 mg dawkowanie propecia generic us cheap levitra sales lexapro generic 40 mg lisinopril 10 mg eon wellbutrin 600 mg day propecia generic uk women viagra 500mg erythromycin 250 mg tablets generique levitra 20mg zovirax 500 mg nexium 10 mg kaina generic lisinopril cheap nolvadex 20 mg forum order cialis today buy zovirax us buy triamterene hydrochlorothiazide doxycycline 100 mg dreams buy cialis safely tablet lasix 50 mg zithromax trockensaft 1200 mg viagra order pills cipro 500mg tab buy viagra york thyroid synthroid generic viagra plus buy viagra gels cheap cialis 40mg dosis viagra 150 mg cena prednisone mental disorder cialis 10 mg dosing cialis danger 75 mg propecia dosage 0.25mg comprare levitra online viagra canada generic buy xenical vs strattera 18 mg kapsul buy viagra pill buy propecia without buy zovirax 200 mg augmentin 250 mg suspensie lexapro 10mg or 20 200mg viagra india zithromax sold online viagra generic herbal existe viagra generico viagra price buy viagra uk 800mg metformin 500 mg kosten 25 vs 50 mg zoloft zovirax labiale generico taking generic synthroid buy viagra safely 2 50 mg viagra cialis de 05 mg lexapro 10 mg embarazo apo metformin 850 mg viagra 50mg dosage prednisone 20 mg 12 days cheap cialis auckland purchase viagra 50 mg viagra generic us generic 40 mg levitra clomid 50mg buy cipro 750 mg generic cheap cialis pharmasy buy lasix 500mg cialis 20 mg 8 tablets hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg dose viagra buy oonline lexapro 30 mg withdrawal generic viagra .99 ed cheap viagra celebrex 100 mg price cialis generic pharmacy synthroid 0.125mg buy viagra au cialis 20 mg works buying viagra 100mg legit generic viagra cialis 10 or 5 mg priligy 30 mg preis augmentin es 600 generic cialis 5mg instead viagra generico 50 buying strattera canada zoloft for borderline cialis 20 mg medicamento cialis online walgreens 20 mg lexapro cipro 30 mg viagra buy sarasota 5mg everyday cialis cipro generic prescription clomid generic 50mg valtrex 1000 mg 21 tablets buy bayers levitra augmentin 500 mg dawkowanie generic name bactrim prednisone mg tablets levitra online receptfritt buy viagra disqus lisinopril 10 mg pink buying azithromycin zithromax glucophage 100 mg celebrex sleep disorder propecia generic patent buy levitra discount amoxil 500mg capsule cheap periactin online levitra online gambling nexium 40 mg effects strattera generic 2011 xenical generico preco viagra 50 mg administrare pfizer viagra order buy lasix overnight glucophage 1000 mg kullanimi metformin 1000 mg sandoz levitra 20 mg australia 60 mg prednisone injection order Cialis Jelly 90 buy cialis sydney lexapro 20mg symptoms bactrim prescription online order celebrex online levitra sale online buy zoloft without zithromax buy australia propranolol 15mg buy us viagra buy everyday cialis propecia online cheap augmentin 312 mg dosage 0.25 mg propecia valtrex going generic lisinopril 5 mg reviews bactrim forte 800 mg prednisone 50mg 5 days zithromax 250 mg vidal 20 mg levitra reviews cialis generic benefits buy bactrim overnight generic strattera uk levitra ftbl 10mg viagra online canda cheap kamagra jelly buy kamagra fuerteventura viagra discount buy viagra 100mg effectiveness zoloft 100 mg overdose buy dapoxetine clomid 50 mg vs 100 zovirax generic cost billig cialis online levitra generic substitute forum propranolol 40 mg cipro mgs prednisone 5mg dosage cost valtrex 1000mg cialis soft cheap nexium 40 mg high kamagra 100mg sildenafil generic cialis name prijs lexapro 15 mg lexapro 30 mg dosage cialis 2 5 mg costo cialis 20mg schweiz viagra 4cpr 100mg posologie doxycycline 100mg lisinopril 40 mg lupi 20 mg daily cialis generic cialis 40 australia generic viagra comparison doxycycline generic names cialis pills order comprare cialis online xenical 120 mg posologie online cheap viagra cialis 2.5 mg buy apo lisinopril 10 mg 60 mgs of prednisone nexium 20 mg omeprazole generic tetracycline names viagra buy philippinen lisinopril hctz 20 25mg levitra 10mg dosage buy online nolvadex 604 comprimido generico viagra 2013 5 mg dose lexapro buying cialis dubai online levitra reviews cheap price nexium review generic viagra buy viagra trusted buy diflucan 200 mg generic viagra 50 buy viagra glasgow toronto buy viagra buy viagra manchester cialis 30 mg generic cialis 20 mg buying cialis 5mg prednisone withdrawal 40 mg buy cialis delhi strattera 18 mg buy indian cialis generic viagra use levitra 20 mg yorumlar levitra tablets online order viagra 50mg hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg daily viagra generic canada cialis 5 mg opiniones buy viagra onlines buy nolvadex europe buy 50mg kamagra viagra usa order buy clomid pregnancy xenical 15 mg 500 mg doxycycline valtrex cheapest erythromycin 250 mg reviews buy lexapro india viagra generic au tried generic viagra order lasix levitra 10 ou 20 mg buy generic zovirax viagra generic 150 mg generic levitra safe valtrex order online generic 24 cialis cialis 20 mg confezioni prednisone ten mg cialis 2.5 mg appearance buy levitra london cialis 10mg preisvergleich zoloft lek 100 mg lisinopril 10 mg effects synthroid cytomel online online viagra in buy cialis philippines spain kamagra online prednisone 20 mg synthroid buy cheap viagra singles buy levitra generic celebrex 50 mg capsule lisinopril al 5 mg prednisone 5 mg ingredients cipro xr generic clomid online ireland cat 50 mg doxycycline buying cialis budapest generic viagra forums 2011 genericos cialis buy lisinopril 40 mg cialis 200 mg canada metformin mg dosage viagra generico europa prednisone 5 mg identification buy zovirax 200mg buy amoxil 250mg propecia cena 1mg 60 mg of lexapro zithromax 1000mg dosis viagra 100 mg 10 cialis usp 25 mg preisvergleich levitra 20 mg 6generic propecia effective lisinopril 20 mg qd metformin 500 mg preis propecia brand 5mg cheap quick viagra 5mg cialis daily cialis 5 mg take buying celebrex generic levitra reliability diflucan 150mg price buy wockhardt lisinopril cialis 20 or 40mg diflucan nombre generico kamagra online safe lexapro 50 mg ulotka tetracycline 500 mg used propecia cheapest online 150 mg phenergan canada viagra order viagra buy 24 cialis 10 ou 20 mg lexapro 2.5 mg withdrawal zithromax 500 mg 6 days buying augmentin online cipro generic brand augmentin 250 mg dose prednisone 10 mg alcohol prednisone 20mg nebenwirkungen levitra 10 mg halbieren nexium 40 mg manufacturer viagra uk buy diflucan pill buy cialis wieviel mg glucophage online prescription lisinopril hctz 10 mg generic levitra italy diflucan fluconazole 150mg generic propranolol er gebruiksaanwijzing cialis 20mg generic cialis risks precio lisinopril 20 mg kamagra gel 100 mg 10 mg tablets lexapro lasix 80mg diflucan 150 mgs buy viagra winnipeg order zenegra viagra augmentin 875 generic name acquisto levitra generico celebrex 400mg buying viagra china pastile cialis 20mg buy real priligy clomid round 3 100mg bactrim de 500 mg cialis 20mg cpr 4 cialis tonafil 20mg