And then you go and spoil it by saying something stupid like ” You must believe in God”

I had problem s with both the films I saw recently, Jab Tak Hai Jaan and Life of Pi, and God seem sto be the culprit in both the cases. Of course with the former it was problem hi problem with no mitigating pleasures. But thanks to a few rankling elements, Life of Pi wasn’t a completely satisfying experience either.

Right away let me state that Life Of Pi is an awesome technical as well as storytelling achievement. The use of 3-D to create mesmerizing visuals and the use of computer graphics animation to create Richard Parker , the royal Bengal tiger is an unparalleled achievement in contemporary cinema. The droll characters of Pi’s family, the charming ambience of Puducherry, the sheer narrative bombast of a zoo being transported across the seas and the sinewy story telling involving a boy and tiger adrift mid-sea is a far too a sumptuous offering not to satisfy any film lover’s appetite

And then you go and spoil it all by saying something stupid like ” You must believe in God because…”
And because?

Because it’s the better story.

Now that raises a lot of problem.

First, it is debatable. One could always find the story with the cook, the mother and the sailor. And it is grossly unfair not to show the other story , while presenting the preferred story in all its lovely detail, and ask us make the call.
Secondly, just asking someone to believe in God because it is the better story is as good as saying you need not believe God if you are looking for the truth. I mean I am a non-believer, but I find Ramakrishna Paramahansa’s story very moving because he said , ‘ Yes. I can see Goddess Kali as clearly and as surely as I see you.’

Thirdly, the case that one should believe in God because it is better story could have been made with any two contrasting stories, why this one? It would have made artistic sense only of the story somehow encapsulated the eternal question that Man faces. Then one could say bringing God into the picture answers the eternal questions so well., so elegantly, so beautifully, so satisfyingly. None of that happens here.

I mean this is no The Seventh Seal.

Fourthly, the God angle takes away from the impact of the main story which was so powerfully, so lovingly staged. There were many strands there the film could latch on to stage a climax. Richard Parker turning away without saying goodbye was one of them, especially it echoed so lyrically with Pi’s own regret at not having said a proper goodbye to Anandi. It could bea bout whether an animal could love a human , or is it just you seeing the reflection of your own love? Is it true of any love? Love of one human being for another? Love of a human being for God?

Perhaps to win a Booker, a book must appear to be very clever and all that, but does good powerful story need the crutch of an allegory and an appendage of asking some big questions explicitly? The Castaway did not need it. The Old Man and The Sea did not need I, and Hemingway won a Nobel. And it was just the story of an old man and a fish!
And then there is the business of carnivorous island? How does that fit with the tone of the rest of the film? I mean it just demolishes all the wonder we have been feeling about the extraordinary journey this young boy had on the sea with this tiger. The zoo animals being transported on a ship and being torn asunder in a thunderstorm was fantastic..but it was all framed in the coordinates of the real. I know. It’s magic realism and all that.

But isn’t realism so much more magical at times?

Old Man and the Sea anyone?

( And as to how God brought down Jab Tak Hai Jaan, that was already falling to pieces, actually there are far too many gods involved there, from Adi Chopra to SRK to Rahman Sir to Sir Jesus … so may be when I have lot more time to kill.)


  1. FS
    November 29, 2012 at 3:36 AM

    Just coz of god element u didnt like pie?

  2. iitianWay
    November 29, 2012 at 11:54 AM

    good god ..i missed that line ..while searching for my dropped popcorn somewhere ;)
    amazing movie with amazing visuals..and with carni island..which tells us one thing ..what u see or is beautiful in daylight ..may not be same in dark/night.
    planning one more watch this weekend…for visual one rather than narrated one.

  3. FS
    November 30, 2012 at 2:11 AM

    Iam sorry to say but your review for talaash may be on par with Life of Pie… Just till the beginning of climax its fucking awesome. Keep u totally engaged

Page 1 of 1

Post Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

pharmacy rx one order status buy colchicine finpecia tablets pramipexole 0.25 mg rls puppies for sale in ohio aps novaldex real acticin over the counter viagra ohne rezept bestellen buying tinidazole non prescription pharmacies mexico tadacip cipla review probenecid for gout prilosec coupons ezetimibe 10mg simvastatin 80mg tablet cialis or generic credit card piroxicam 20 mg and oxycodone viagra perdorimi effexor xr side effects sweating ranitidine zantac for babies sifrol 0.18 mg amitriptyline ohne rezept bestellen clavaseptin for cats generique du viagra sans ordonnance onlain igri na shax where to buy online viagra sertralina nombre comercial careprost online cheap canadian pharmacy largo fl alldaychemist drugs cialis softgel colchicine treatment claravis accutane discount programs cheap antibiotics canada cozaar medication information buy ventolin no prescription khawaja naveed ki adalat june 2011 paroxetine hcl 40mg doxycap doxycycline how to buy cialis 5 mg average price of 100 mg viagra dove acquistare cialis in sicurezza lasuna planters ordering clozaril online arthrotec 50/0.2 non prescription calais generic zyprexa available redustat 120 mg fincar finasteride online canada buy canadian drugs without prescription vardenafil hcl 10mg generic promethazine hydrochloride 25 mg grathazon 0 5 mg reglan 10mg medication med cab online pharmacy reviews imovane 7 5mg information now how to get off paxil safely levitra manufacturer clobex spray coupon/online ospamox 1000 mg prospect capital corporation atacand hct 16 12.5 catafast 50mg trazodone antibiotics for bronchitis in children orslim orlistat side effects coumadin blood thinner readings viamedic coupon code cialis 5mg online without prescriptions salzarex tramadol capsules vs tablets terramicina oxitetraciclina 500 mg benicar hct 40 12.5 prices meclizine 25mg medication motion sickness euthyrox 50 asthma symptoms in infants levamisole hydrochloride wormer flexeril generic for bactroban cream mupirocin calcium cream 2 mestinon medication myasthenia que es omifin pastillas online pharmacy review logain estradiol side effects in dogs januvia side effects fish cycline tennessee ginseng prices 2012 anxiety disorder nos mirtazapine dosage cats para que sirve el meloxicam 7 5 mg picareta em ingles performance can cialis make you bigger where can buy viagra in singapore advantage multi for dogs side effects does target have a generic for nexium tylenol 4 codeine vs tylenol 3 propecia hair loss treatment side effects buy albuterol with no perscription levoxyl recall synthroid furosemide bodybuilding to buy ovral birth control patch voveran injection linezolid dosing ventolin pills accutane acne treatment reviews diamox altitude sickness side effects tiotropium bromide inhalation powder generic drugs how to order levitra on line nolvadex clomid pct dosage roaccuntane buy discount health and beauty products flexeril information prometrium 200 mg dose prometrium capsules tiotropium bromide spiriva classification buspirone hcl 15mg what is it for buy finasteride canada diazepam for dogs with seizures viagra preisvergleich rezeptfrei no prescription online lisinopril hctz free samples of viagra forum ordering clomid online uk duphaston tablet for pregnancy erexin spray foam actavis cough syrup uk clomid success stories on first round pravastatin sodium tablets usp 20 mg side effects viagra discount web sites buy lantus solostar tesco viagra over the counter how to uninstall vosteran search engine cheap zanaflex no prescription rythmol manufacturer desogen user reviewsdesyrel mincorp mining leveling cialis generic best price epharmacy online stopwatch arthrotec 75 mg price canadian pharcharmy online hydrocodone prescription progynova 2mg side effects tylenol 4 codeine vs hydrocodone amoxil 875 mg tablet solu medrol dosepak side effects avapro 300 mg coupons tylenol dosage chart for infants cozaar blood pressure pill captopril 12.5mg female viagra sildenafil bentyl for ibs side effects no rx synthroid 112 amiloride furosemide yasminelle tablets on sale piadas do tiririca generic ed meds international pharmacy for men viagra super active plus review motrin 800 ibuprofen cost dapoxetine free trial dicyclomine 20mg bentyl side effects budesonide nebulizer side effects eprex liturgia de las horas 2015 lipitor side effects muscle pain degeneration cymbalta philippines what is in claritin d ingredients lasix 100 mg canadian pharmacy ventolin hfa coupon 2014 overseas escitalopram lagatrim tablets for sale navidoxine information minomycin information xalatan no prescription cialis online with amex bonadoxina pfizer dosis pastillas para quemar zanaflex vs flexeril strength benoquin before and after photos alphagan p canada no prescription pill cutter for viagra brand name viagra cheapest topiramate 25mg tablets estradiol blood test for men leconfield house curzon street w1 alesse side effects celebrex celecoxib side effects online viagra with out a prescription aricept medication reviews irbesartan hydrochlorothiazide dosage lexapro vs celexa canadian pharmacy paypal bisoprolol hydrochlorothiazide 5 6.25 side effects doxycycline hyclate order erectile dysfunction medication 1st rx orders for clomid lergigan biverkningar uroxatral vs flomax discussion groups topics sustiva side effects efavirenz/emtricitab/tenofovir digoxin therapeutic level arrhythmia verapamil 240 mg er capsules amoxicillin or zithromax for sinus infection redustat capsulas 60 mgregenon buy viagra with mastercard mountainwest apothecary viagra lipothin 200 fenofibrate capsules flagyl antibiotics for men for sale avodart side effects dutasteride generic viagra best supplier cialis et endometre fin lamisil side effects where to buy naproxen how to get azithromycin prednisolone 5mg for dogs sildenafilo normon 50 mg precio aciclovir 800 mg no script amantadine medication side effects lasix furosemide side effects buy albuterol sulfate inhaler online ventolin evohaler buy metronidazole flagyl and alcohol side effects sildenafil preis cialis daily use vs viagra ed pills online cymbalta on line cialis indonesia milanuncios valencia contactos what does cialis cost at walgreens caffeine pills walgreens super active canadian pharmacy 24h com vn vigrx reviews amazon singulair side effects children citrato de sildenafil furosemide medication side effects xenical shopping reductil diet pills in philippines pfizer stock symbol buy disulfiram online pharmacy erection problems natural remedies rogaine men over 50 best price on levitra 20 mg phentermine adipex medications diamox sequels 500 mg cap sdmd rx one pharmacy canada non generic generic cialis 20mg zanaflex medication side effects buy albuterol buy citalopram hydrobromide tiotropium pronunciation order tamoxifen trusted laxifen dosis apiretal como conprar cialis how to buy zopiclone online famciclovir drug medication best price ed medications jasmine guy lupus buy brand cialis no prescription what is relafen 750 nabumetone for combivent side effects medication revapol pastillas ephedraxin reviews of fifty citolapram no rx cheapest venlafaxine 75mg er side effects discount viagra pills viagra online prescription free generic male enhancement pills antibiotics for sale 24 hour delivery estradiol patch 0.1 mg proventil hfa online indomethacin dosage gout dilantin side effects pregnancy risnia 3 estrotab 2mg valium doxepin for sleep reviews ciprobay antibiotic side effects ampicillin in canada nexium 40 mg capsules purchse astromenda removal tool propecia finasteride tablets venlafaxine hcl 37.5mg weight loss antibiotics for urinary tract infections price comparison viagra cialis levitra cialis last longer prevacid dosage for infants erectalis 20mg oxycodone cipla nalanda retirides otc drugs medrol side effects metronidazole flagyl antibiotic side effects rapharmacy reviews of fifty aspirin dosage for dogs per pound rocket launch from virginia what is betafusin duloxetine hydrochloride generic price no doctor viagra plendil er side effects cheap tadalafil usa rx canada 365 antibiotics for pneumonia treatment toradol medication information revatio 20 mg cialis 5mg prix diflucan 150 mg en espanol xeloda patient assistance in chile buspar xanax together capoten side effects orlistat uk order pills for chymedia cheap paracetamol toxicity graph viagra grapefruit delay time content marketing agency original cialis 20mg price rimonabant fda no prescription required drugstore venlafaxine for dogs rizatriptan 10 mg reviews levitra without prescriptions promethazine dm syrup information best price on generic viagra stilnox zolpidem 10mg fosamax and jaw problems drugs cialis online india generic cialis online united states indian made cialis what happens if i take two cialis berodual prezzo stilnox drug side effects xanax pharmacy in india lasix side effects in elderly tadarise 60 misoprostol in south africa bactroban cream for acne bevispas tablets with keyboards clobex shampoo cost reputable online pharmacies uk cialis 20 mg best price jasmine villegas hot digoxina in english please buy sildenafil citrate online paypal propecia rx relief card fertility medications for sale online liposafe gnc avodart side effects avodart viagra for sale in ireland aciclovir dosis tableta silagra without prescription coumadin for sale viagra en ligne carte maestro order amoxicillin from mexico buy orlistat online buy bupropion buy viagra from mexica or canada plavix generic in usa xenical precio colombia cialis canadian pha milanuncios perros how much is a pint of promethazine dulcolax fait maigrir perioral dermatitis corn huskers lotion canadian pharmacy quick shipping viagra best prices online ofloxacin buy from canada cardizem dosage acls depakote withdrawal side effects priligy di malaysia no prescription online pharmacy india danazol 200mg no rx needed cialis donepezil 5 mg tablets side effects london drugs bc proventil coupon card can i buy cialis in bali radio commercial for viagra coumadin antidote dose viagra onlion holand bactrim para que sirve buy viagra online canada no pres licodexon dexamethasone obat apa generic wellbutrin in par side effects restonite ambien addiction cream ketrel asacol 800 hd coupons india sildenafil citrate tadalafil generic best price alphagan 0.1 patient assistance buy cheap purchase uk viagra metazole cream of mushroom penegra tablets at gnc propranolol for anxiety side effects digoxin toxicity level does viagra work when drunk zitromax ithout a prescription best national non prescription pharmacy most trusted drug mail order sites balranald shire council lexapro pills in canada no prescription viagra online aus usa kaufen pharmacy rx one reviews esidrix without perscription costco pharmacy price list 2014 stanozolol cycle dose torsemide medication dose praziquantel for fish tanks epanutin drug mart eutirox 50 mg paracetamol tablets 500mg farmacia viagra viagra online kaufen europa canadian pharmacy northwest maximum nuvigil dosage grathazon kaplet thailand pharmacy zestoretic side effects lisinopril propecia for women order pfeifer brand viagra online software engineer salary range dostinex side effects patients cipralex causes weight gaincipro buy amoxicillin online canada trusted finpecia seller purchase levitra with check online pharmacy promethazine codeine lotrisone cream 45g serophene and multiple births repronex acheter viagra ou cialis generic orlistat india ceftin for sinus infection dosage cialis preiswert kaufen buy flagyl use paypal comment prendre cytotec discount brandedcialis online aspirin dosage for dogs dose aristocort triamcinolone cream cephalexin 500mg side effects azithromycin no script endo pharmaceuticals lidoderm patch coupons clenbuterol side effects athletes wives minoxidil 5 for women reviews levothroid recall 2015 chevy antibodies without a precription fluconazole diflucan treatment dose lialda medication generic names cheap erection pills benicar hct 40 12.5 mg diamox medication for headaches erexin maximum male strength standards rapidtabs viagra viagra tablet use in hindi dalacin t topical solution side effects celexa buy kamatra sumatra straits buy levothyroxine no rx in usa buy tetracycline 500 mg for dogs haloperidol 5mg ml metformin 500mg side effects type 2 diabetes antabuse alcohol drugs how many viagra can you take cialis on internet no prescription lagatrim forte 960mg best price online pharmacy can i get cymbalta in mexico norstan communications mn cyprodin precios qsymia cost pfizer careers flomaxtra australia weather phexin dropsend carbimazole treatment dose of lovenox cialis best price biaxin xl antibiotic progesterone levels during pregnancy with twins crestor side effects rhabdomyolysis kidney damage cialis online next day delivery india drugs generic cialis 40 real brand name viagra generic cialis for less accutane for acne zyvoxid pfizer animal health lialda medication for colitis prednisolone without prescription leukeran for cats with ibd onlain filmebi qartulad safe nizagara site order deltazone where to buy baclofen cipla acivir 400 dt usa buy rx processing inc mississauga on canada micardis generic tadalafil tabs aus malaysia chloroquine resistant malaria buy valtrex tablets in australia cb1 weight gain pill reviews black cockapoo puppies for sale in ohio paracetamol contraindication pregnancy kamagra made in india kemadrin drug viagra coupon free trial ivermectin scabies where to buy ebay safe online cialis periostat uk trimetabol syrup recipe cardinal community credit union ashtabula what is terramycin ointment for humans misoprostol induction protocol albenza or vermox over the counter chlamydia pneumoniae treatment topiramate side effects depakote er side effects 500 mg