Why I can’t pay tribute to Thackeray – Hon’ble Justice Katju (Retired Judge, Apex Court)

*Note: The views expressed are by the writer of the blog and not my own, i just found an “interesting” article on the topic of recent debates, posting it for reading of others. Thanx

Why I can’t pay tribute to Thackeray – Hon’ble Justice Katju (Retired Judge, Apex Court)

His bhumiputra theory flies in the face of our Constitution and works against the unity needed to ensure development

Muppadhu kodi mugamudayal
Enil maipuram ondrudayal
Ival Seppumozhi padhinetudayal
Enil Sindhanai ondrudayal
(This Bharatmata has 30 crore faces
But her body is one
She speaks 18 languages
But her thought is one)

Tamil poet Subramania Bharathi

Bhedad gana vinauyanti bhinnah supajapah paraih
Tasmat samghatayogesu prayateran ganah sada
(Republics have been destroyed because of internal divisions among the people;
Hence a republic should always strive to achieve unity and good relations among the people)

Mahabharat, Shanti Parva, chapter 108, shloka 14

Tesam anyonyabhinnanam svauaktim anutisthatam
Nigrahah panditaih karyah ksipram eva pradhanatah
(Therefore the wise authorities should crush the separatist forces trying to assert their strength)
Mahabharat, Shanti Parva, 108:26

Political leaders, film stars, cricketers, etc. are all falling over one another to pay tribute to the late Bal Thackeray. Amidst this plethora of accolades and plaudits pouring in from the high and mighty, I humbly wish to register my vote of dissent.

I know of the maxim De mortuis nil nisi bonum (of the dead speak only good), but I regret I cannot, since I regard the interest of my country above observance of civil proprieties.

What is Bal Thackeray’s legacy?
It is the anti-national ‘sons of the soil’ (bhumiputra) theory.
Article 1(1) of the Indian Constitution states: “India, that is Bharat, shall be a Union of States.”

Thus, India is not a confederation but a union.
Article 19 (1) (e) states: “All citizens shall have the right — to reside and settle in any part of the territory of India.”

Thus, it is a fundamental right of a Gujarati, south Indian, Bihari, U.P.ite, or person from any other part of India to migrate to Maharashtra and settle down there, just as it is of Maharashtrians to settle down in any part of India (though there are some restrictions in J&K, and some North-East States, due to historical reasons).

The bhumiputra theory states that Maharashtra essentially belongs to Marathi people, while Gujaratis, south Indians, north Indians, etc. are outsiders. This is in the teeth of Articles 1(1) and 19(1)(e) of the Constitution. India is one nation, and hence non-Maharashtrians cannot be treated as outsiders in Maharashtra.

The Shiv Sena created by Thackeray attacked south Indians in the 1960s and 70s, and vandalised their restaurants and homes. In 2008, Biharis and U.P.ites living in Mumbai (the bhaiyyas who eke out a livelihood as milk and newspaper vendors, taxi drivers etc.) were described as infiltrators and attacked, their taxis smashed, and several beaten up. Muslims were also vilified

This, of course, created a vote bank for Thackeray based on hatred (as had Hitler, of whom Thackeray was an admirer), and how does it matter if the country breaks up and is Balkanised?

Apart from the objection to the ‘sons of the soil’ theory for being anti-national and unconstitutional, there is an even more basic objection, which may rebound on Thackeray’s own people.
India is broadly a country of immigrants (like North America) and 92-93 per cent of the people living in India today are not the original inhabitants but descendants of immigrants who came mainly from the north-west seeking a comfortable life in the sub-continent (see the article ‘What is India?’ and the video on the website kgfindia.com ).

The original inhabitants (the real bhumiputra) of India are the pre-Dravidian tribals, known as Adivasis (the Bhils, Gonds, Santhals, Todas, etc.) who are only 7-8 per cent of our population today.
Hence if the bhumiputra theory is seriously implemented, 92-93 per cent of Maharashtrians (including, perhaps, the Thackeray family) may have to be regarded as outsiders and treated accordingly. The only real bhumiputra in Maharashtra are the Bhils and other tribals, who are only 7-8 per cent of the population of Maharashtra.
Several separatist and fissiparous forces are at work in India today (including the bhumiputra theory). All patriotic people must combat these forces.

Why must we remain united? We must remain united because only a massive modern industry can generate the huge wealth we require for the welfare of our people — agriculture alone cannot do this — and modern industry requires a huge market. Only a united India can provide the huge market for the modern industry we must create to abolish poverty, unemployment and other social evils, and to provide for the huge health care and modern education systems we must set up if we wish to come to the front ranks of the most advanced countries.

Hence I regret I cannot pay any tribute to Mr. Bal Thackeray.



  1. Huzefa
    November 19, 2012 at 5:40 PM

    an eye opener article for those who praise this terrorist goon.

  2. ank_16n
    November 19, 2012 at 6:13 PM


    so we are now going to Quote Katju………..

    This itself is laughable….
    I wouldn’t have ever Imagined in my whole life that i would be Reading something from the most corrupt Judge and Indian that ever was born in India…..

    According to his theory
    1. There is no corruption in Indian judicial system….
    2. There is no need for Lokpal bill it has destroyed singapore and will destroy india….
    3. Our Army should be replaced from Kids .

    1st Tell him to Prove wrong all the corruption cases that has been filed against him……

Page 1 of 1

Post Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

is 10 mg prednisone buy bactrim suspension cialis online 50mg zithromax chlamydia 1000mg amoxil 500 mg chlamydia lasix 40 mg bijsluiter kamagra 100 mg wirkungsdauer tetracycline 250 mg price generic 5 mg levitra lilly cialis 10mg ciprofloxacin generic cipro valtrex generic brand cialis 10mg multivitamins buy diflucan us relible generic viagra bactrim mg uti about xenical 120mg zovirax 200 mg dosis preco clomid 50mg propranolol dak 40 mg indian generic levitra buy prednisone 2.5 mg strattera order paypal cialis 5 mg 28 cpr hay cytotec generico cheapest viagra singapore Levitra 90 pills order zithromax 1250 mg gonorrhea tentang xenical 120 mg buy lisinopril generic doxycycline order canada prednisone 10 mg vademecum cialis 10mg rezeptfrei lisinopril 100mg levitra 20mg 8 propecia original buy buy doxycycline 100 mg generic lexapro same cialis 30 5mg lasix fiale 20 mg cialis 5 mg consigli cialis dosaggio 40 60 mg wellbutrin sr 300 mg cialis 20mg walgreens tadalafil cialis 5 mg lexapro medication generic generic amoxil 500 mg augmentin 625 mgs 60 mg of propranolol wellbutrin 450 mg seizures 100 mg viagra online cipro generic ciprofloxacin doxycycline 100 mg zwangerschap strattera 60 mg uk nexium 40 mgs lexapro generic manufacturers generic viagra mygra metformin 500 mg effect cheap legal viagra diflucan online ordering 150 mg viagra effectiveness buy genuine kamagra cialis 10 mg duration levitra 10 mg tablets buy cipro pill lisinopril 10 mg mylan generic 5 mg. cialis diflucan online drug viagra prescrition online glucophage 500mg dosage cialis buying canada online viagra fast cialis 80 mg au ordering glucophage farmacie online xenical strattera 60 mg erowid celebrex 200 mg uses cheap buy viagra online viagra reviews lexapro generic adderall buy 500 mg zithromax viagra order generic lexapro generic ingredients 12.5 mg of zoloft generic viagra cipal gurnsey cialis online buy viagra 100 online propecia cheap cialis 20 mg jakarta glucophage 850 mg nedir buy clomid serophene super viagra online cipro sale online buy kamagra europe zithromax 50mg feline generic viagra ebay levitra pricing generic pk doxycycline 300 mg notice clomid 50mg cialis generic manila cheap propranolol online valtrex tablets 1000mg prednisone sandoz 5 mg taking 25 mg zoloft cheap drugs cialis diflucan cream buy erythromycin 400mg 5ml propecia 1mg generic canada 2.5 mg cialis cialis 2.5 mg experience nexium dr 10mg lexapro generic cipralex viagra cheapest canada doxycycline 50mg capsule doxycycline 100 mg msds diflucan online store bactrim generic brand levitra 5mg generic lexapro 5 mg tablet synthroid 0.137mg gia nexium 20mg buy propecia fedex using viagra 100mg 300 mg of wellbutrin retirada generico viagra cheap generic levitra tetracycline hycate 100 mg clomid 100mg instructions tesco 50mg viagra viagra 180mg lexapro 150 mg cytotec 200mg tab levitra generique 40 mg metformin glucophage online buy zithromax suspension zovirax 250 mg generic wellbutrin seizures cialis 2mg price clomid 50mg unsuccessful generic lexapro order generic clomid work bula strattera 25mg generic zoloft pregnancy buy bactrim tablets phenergan 25mg online cheapest priligy uk generic periactin buy online cialis beograd phenergan promethazine 25 mg clomid 50 mg funziona buy lasix canadian 200 mg zoloft forum buy strattera generic wellbutrin 300 mg erfahrungen buy viagra bulk cialis 2.5mg benefit cialis generico 10 mg lexapro generic effects price valtrex 500mg cipro xr 5oomg cialis 5mg dosierung searchcheape viagra diflucan online uk viagra kupiti online cialis cuantos mg prednisone 10mg buy kamagra 100mg tabletten cheap buy viagra 25mg clomid online viagra online holland generic viagra kolkata buy celebrex mexico buy viagra topix cheapest lexapro price 40mg cialis capsules phenergan mg 50 cialis 20 mg farmaco koop xenical online viagra cheap 25mg costo viagra 100 mg generic cialis dominican online fsa viagra generic for nexium 200 mg viagra dose superdrug levitra 5mg bought clomid online ubat doxycycline 100mg zithromax 500 mg nebenwirkungen google viagra 800mg metformin er online erythromycin 5oomg 5mg prednisone wine online levitra sales priligy 30 mg prezzo propecia malaysia online cheap cialis toronto buy 500 mg zithromax zithromax generic buy clomid 100mg zwanger 2.5mg cialis paypal viagra prescription cheapest zoloft compresse 50 mg metformin 5 mg cialis 10 mg cupon celebrex there generic generic name amoxil cialis generica 5mg strattera 18 mg generic order diflucan oral tetracycline 125 mg cialis da 50 mg levitra 20 mg prices 12 cialis 20mg cialis 5 mg dauertherapie levitra 20mg cena buy viagra phuket erythromycin 500mg gmp free valtrex online clomid 50mg generic xenical tablets cheap viagra online kupovina buy viagra online 350 xenical dosage 120 mg generic wellbutrin works bactrim mg acne cialis buy australia buy lisinopril 2.5 buy viagra 30 generic viagra japan cheap cialis brand zovirax generic available lasix 40 mg presentacion bactrim suspension 800 mg bactrim f 800 160 mg propranolol 120mg augmentin mg prednisone dosage 20mg discount levitra 10mg wellbutrin dosage 75 mg propranolol anxiety disorder ordering cialis online generic cialis manufacturer viagra pe 150mg augmentin 625 mg prot buy cialis 50 mg viagra 5800 mg nolvadex australia online clomid farmacia online viagra 100mg australia effet cialis 20mg cialis 10 mg dosing metformin 500 mg e infographics generic viagra cialis 20 mg bugiardino zovirax 200 mg prix cheap levitra 40 mg cheap propecia 5mg 200 mg generic cialis viagra buy uk generic vs valtrex generic valtrex coupons buy online levitra synthroid 75 mg bactrim 800 mg tablets buy lisinopril without 12.5mg of viagra cialis 20 mg costo strattera cost 60 mg kamagra gold 100 buy buy kamagra cheap levitra online erfahrungen taking cialis 40 mg erfahrungsberichte viagra 100mg selling viagra 100 mgs cheap propecia usa levitra 10 mg rezeptfrei cialis 2,5 mg nl cialis 20 mg docmorris celebrex celecoxib generic doxycycline online accord bactrim 500 mg dosage zithromax generic 500mg 50mg of viagra hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg vidal sertralin zoloft 50 mg generic valtrex generic 4 all viagra cialis 5 mg pills propecia 5 mg taking 150 mg zoloft online viagra good doxycycline 100mg x14 levitra 5 10 oder 20 mg 500mg tetracycline antibiotic zovirax online buy discount propecia 1mg cialis generique 50mg prednisone 7.5 mg levitra 5 mg fiyat mylan lisinopril 2.5 mg q buy viagra 100 mg viagra nekadar comprare kamagra online xenical 120 mg presentation prednisone 10 mg insomnia viagra online asap buy lexapro mexico cheap chewable kamagra levitra 20mg benefits prednisone 5 mg mayo 12 generic meltabs viagra generic synthroid ok generic viagra march 27 cialis generic 40 cialis generic now generico lexapro 10 mg viagra generic patent zithromax order online propecia singapore online nexium dr 40mg lisinopril 10 mg accord propecia viagra online prospect celebrex 100 mg prednisone 2.5 mg bactrim ds buy nexium 20mg gr dog prednisone 5mg cost generic viagra zoloft dosages mg lisinopril 10 mg manufacturer buy viagra aurochem viagra sicher online cheap cialis overnight buying viagra brazil viagra nombre generico buy propecia us generic nexium india zithromax 250mg dosage celebrex 200 mg indikasi cheap cialis usa purchase propecia generic 1000 mg generic valtrex online cialis legitimate zovirax order online nolvadex 20mg comprar buy cialis generic lasix 25 mg posologia take 200 mg viagra online chewable viagra viagra 2.5mg 20 or 40 mg cialis cialis online versand xenical online buy nolvadex 10mg ed diflucan 150mg buy hydrochlorothiazide 12 mg viagra online reviews buy levitra germany cialis online rating generic viagra ok viagra online satis phenergan generic pill buy zoloft medicine viagra online bangladesh doxycycline 20 mg price apa nexium 20mg celebrex dosage 600mg levitra 20 mg facts cialis 2.5 mg cheap levitra de 10mg generic viagra atlanta wellbutrin online order hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg online chinese cialis 50 mg original cialis 5mg farmacia online augmentin lexapro generic problem zoloft 10mg dosage cialis 10 mg tab xenical online italia beipackzettel levitra 10mg cheap viagra net cialis 20 mg generic bought cialis online cheap levitra.com cheapest cipla viagra doxycycline 20 mg teva strattera 80 mg sandoz generic propecia buy propecia hair lexapro 5mg online cialis 5 vs 10mg cialis 20mg au buy viagra mexaco levitra online belgie propecia generic brand cialis 40 mg portugues viagra generic lawsuit clomid 50mg follicles 900 mg zoloft viagra 25mg cheap cheap cialis nz xenical orlistate 200mg cialis 5mg infarmed generic strattera reviews levitra 20 generic 80 mg strattera xenical 120 mg upotreba 10 mg lexapro pregnancy bactrim 40 mg 25 mg phenergan iv discount 150mg viagra selling prednisone 20mg viagra pills cheap metformin 500 mg hydrochloride generic viagra zoll generic kamagra pillen nexium 20 mg esomeprazole viagra sklep online cialis 20mg information 5mg lisinopril tablets prednisone 20 mg ingredients cialis 20 mg vs buy doxycycline 50mg lexapro 10 mg walmart viagra bh mg propecia online singapore buy doxycycline onlinemalaysia levitra generico 40 mg online viagra al buy levitra onlines cheap prescription cialis coomeva cheap viagra cialis 10mg generique cheap eneric cialis generic viagra wallgreen viagra 4 cpr 50 mg cheap 72 hour cialis buy viagra otc generic viagra buy synthroid 0.25 mg buy lasix singapore all generic viagra viagra online 60 cents viagra buy lausanne vipps viagra online bactrim ds 400 mg cialis 10 mg tadalafil levitra generic 20mg cialis sales online prednisone 40 mg alcohol celebrex 200 mg dosierung lasix 20 mg precio cheap site viagra buy 20mg doxycycline prednisone 50 mg apo buy viagra canadian nexium in generic propecia prices 5mg viagra 400mg dosis cialis generic chinatown xenical remedio generico wellbutrin 450 mg libido 50 mg synthroid dosage want buy viagra viagra zakup online 20 mg propranolol prednisone 10mg eczema lexapro generic espanol izmir cialis 100 mg prix clomid 50mg viagra soft online levitra twice 5 mg novo metformin 500mg 25 mg viagra etkisi zithromax 250 mg gelule viagra predaj online uk viagra online Levitra pills Buy there generic synthroid 1 cialis generic viagra metformin generic names 100 mg of wellbutrin levitra generico chile liquid generic viagra online rezept cialis diflucan 50mg capsule viagra 100 mg fiyat 30 day 5mg cialis blue zoloft 50 mg buspar 5 mg erowid cheap viagra usa Cialis 10mg 30 Tabs anwendung viagra 50 mg lexapro overmax 20 mg 250 mg zoloft ocd levitra 10 mg canada cialis 50mg chinese mgus cialis nolvadex generic pct