Review Round Up: ‘Jab Tak Hai Jaan’ Woos Critics

Bollywood films, particularly romantic dramas, rarely open to universal acclaim. “Jab Tak Hai Jaan,” or “Until There Is Life,” the last film directed by Bollywood’s “king of romance” Yash Chopra, before he passed away in October, is one of the rare films that did.

Starring Shah Rukh Khan, Katrina Kaif and Anushka Sharma, the romantic drama traces Samar Anand’s (Mr. Khan’s) quest for undying love, from the streets of London to the valleys of Kashmir.

The film, which released alongside “Son of Sardaar” this Diwali, was hailed by many Indian critics. Here’s a roundup of what they had to say:

“There cannot be a better way to portray love on the silver screen,” opined a Zee News review by film critic Ananya Bhattacharya. “Jab Tak Hai Jaan has nailed that – at least for the immediate future.”

Ms. Bhattacharya was all praise for the film’s star cast, particularly Mr. Khan, who in her view brought to life a “newer, better, improved version” of Raj Malhotra, the love-smitten protagonist in Mr. Chopra’s 1995-produced classic “Dilwale Dulhania Le Jayenge.”

“If as Raj Malhotra he [Mr. Khan] had managed to woo half the population of the country; as Samar Anand, this man can make many more smitten by him. The slight stutter, the little hint of a tear in the eyes, the arms-outstretched pose – Khan knows how to make his ladies fall for him – be it that they are almost half his age!” Ms. Bhattacharya wrote.

The critic went on to applaud Mr. Chopra for his direction. “Only somebody like Yash Chopra could have made those mesmerising locales of Pehalgam and Ladakh come alive on celluloid… The film doesn’t really have the sarees flying slo-mo in the air, but what it has is sheer, pristine beauty,” she wrote.

Overall, Ms. Bhattacharya was highly impressed with the film, though she felt it was “a tad too long” and its background score, composed by Oscar-winning composer A.R. Rahman, had been “underused.”

Nevertheless, she concluded by giving the film four stars out of five. “Yash Chopra, you made sure that you will live on and that your last film will be remembered – jab tak hai jaan,” or until there is life, she wrote.

Jab Tak Hai Jaan “is the best romantic film made in this generation.” That’s how Bollywood critic Rachit Gupta summed up the movie in a Filmfare review.

“Like any piece of commercial cinema, it has its cinematic liberties and plot holes. But the sum of it is an old school love story that weaves its magic on the tender hearts of die-hard romantics,” Mr. Gupta opined.

The critic was all praise for the film’s star cast, its “master class” script and its “real, uncomplicated” dialogue. The film’s plot, though “a run-of-the-mill love triangle” in Mr. Gupta’s view, set itself apart from other romantic dramas, largely owing to its “philosophy, poetic love and honest emotions.”

Jab Tak Hai Jaan “is the perfect adieu to [Mr. Chopra’s] hallmark career,” the reviewer concluded, giving the film four stars out of five.

An NDTV review by Saibal Chatterjee concurred. “Jab Tak Hai Jaan, Yash Chopra’s last film, is a perfectly fitting finale to an eventful life and career.”

The film’s screenplay “is by no means flawless,” but the romantic drama “leaves a soothing afterglow,” Mr. Chatterjee opined.

The critic was also impressed with the film’s theme and character sketches. “Though the focus of Jab Tak Hai Jaan is on the male protagonist, the two women in his life aren’t mere mannequins.” Instead, they are blessed with “grace and intelligence, besides the ability to speak their minds and hold on to their beliefs,” a rare treat in Bollywood romances, he noted.

“Watch Jab Tak Hai Jaan not just for the obvious sentimental reason but for the fact that it shows, for one last time, what Bollywood will miss now that the undisputed master of romantic sagas is no more,” Mr. Chatterjee concluded, giving the film three-and-a-half stars out of five.

“In contemporary times when love stories have more or less turned into instant make out and instant breakup…. it’s heartening to see a full-blown romance saga which has good old values and yet a very modern outlook,” film critic Gaurav Malani wrote in The Times of India.

“Like most love stories, even Jab Tak Hai Jaan has sacrifice and sanctity at its footing yet at no point is it depressing or disheartening,” he added. The critic went on to praise the film’s “impeccable” screenplay, “strikingly beautiful” cinematography and “scrumptious” chemistry between Mr. Khan and Ms. Kaif.

“Jab Tak Hai Jaan is a sublime story about love and life. They don’t make them like that anymore,” Mr. Malani concluded. His verdict? “Very Good.”

Writing for the Hindustan Times, film critic Anupama Chopra was notably disappointed with the film’s plot but on the whole enjoyed the film, largely due to its “heartfelt performances.”

“In any case, you don’t go to a Yash Chopra movie to delve into realism or the messiness of relationships. You go to partake in a fantasy of swooning, idealised love – and Jab Tak Hai Jaan delivers plenty of that,” she noted.

So despite the film’s “wobbly narrative,” Jab Tak Hai Jaan’s “gorgeously shot locations,” “lavish songs,” “inherently noble lead characters,” and “top-notch” star cast performances, makes it work “as an ode to epic romance,” the critic wrote.

Ms. Chopra’s review gave the film three stars out of five.

http://blogs.wsj.com/indiarealtime/2012/11/13/review-round-up-jab-tak-hai-jaan-woos-critics/

2 Comments

  1. deadmanwalking
    deadmanwalking
    November 14, 2012 at 3:31 AM

    yes their is afew bad review but in general the critic love the film and the rating from 3 to 4 stars

Page 1 of 1

Post Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

diane stretton latisse coupon zyprexa lawsuit zyprexa side effects sertraline hydrochloride 50mg deltasone 10 mg asacol medication assistance cost of propecia ireland insulin side effects diabetes meclizine 25 mg tablet which is better lipitor or vytorin cialis cena u apotekama antibiotics shipped to canada amoxicillin for sinus infection dosing antibiotics for uti treatment amoxicillin kamagrafast uk basketball non prescription synthroid vytorin 1020 price flarex without a prescription flazol 500mg to grams cyprodin precios vantin antibiotic for ear infection pak online acquistare cialis in contanti douleur regle bactrim ds 800 160 dosage cheap bactrim ds antibiotic cialis kaufen deutschland pramipexole dihydrochloride drugs inc maxaman reviews on garcinia otc viagra imovane 7 5mg zopiclone withdrawal arimidex dosage for gynecomastia minomycin information literacy acquista viagra senza ricetta catafast sachets packaging aristocort cream 0.1 tegretol bipolar vilches ferreteros jasmine pilchard gosnell pregnant pravachol 20mg buy generic cialis fast free shipment clavamox for cats treatment buspar xanax benzodiazepines cialis en ligne allemagne tizanidine 4mg xlpharmacy scam alert clindamycin phosphate gel usp 1 reviews roaccuntane buy livial tablets 2.5mg buy estrace online uk zandu vigorex capsules ornidazole and ofloxacin tablets viagra boots birth control without an rx how effective is ceftin for sinus infection viagra chennai cheap nizagra elavil dosage for insomnia buy prednisone online progesterone pills to stop bleeding vilches ferreteros mexico city phentermine reviews and results doxycap tablets with keyboards salazopyrin for dogs luvox medication and weight gain bystolic medication side effects polarmeds reviews on vigrx caffeine pills for sale estrace cream user reviews doxycap capsule crm where can i buy cyproheptadine cost of mircette birth control pillsmobic el diclofenaco para que sirve non prescription prozak what to use instead of alli diet drug oxybutynin chloride 5mg walgreens pharmacy online mupirocin ointment usp 2 what is it used for can i get unisom 2 in canada the little blue pill healthpoint combivent respimat inhaler coupons care viagra solution saroten nebenwirkungen antidepressivascialisseagrasecuremedseladermseptra imitrex dosage information effexor canada cialis 20 mg 4 compresse amoxil 875 mg tablet zyvoxid prospect high school generic propecia for sale haldol for nausea in hospice patients us online pharmacy cialis tinidazole side effects in dogs do you need a prescription for levitra diovan side effects diovan blood pressure medicine vitamix recipes free qvc mobicox tabletas de coco side effects of levothyroxine 75 mcg lipvas tablets for sale viagra 5omg topomax without a prescription ivermectin side effects on dogs carbimazole dosage flomaxtra australia weather cialis with avodart doxepin for sleep mg comprar viagra en usa rimadyl 25mg dogs dosage arthritis pain relief cream reviews warfarin diet restrictions pdf levitra usa online info lexapro coupons 2012 buy domperidone uk pharmacy escrow hcg z pak without prescription clopidogrel side effects stroke diflucan ebay best ed pill over the counter tylenol dosage for infants after dpt vaccine buy viagra without a prescription lidoderm patch costochondritis no prescription cialis generic cheap carafate suspension bactrim ds dosage 800/160 linezolid dosing in renal failure vidalta bosques de monterreal mometasone 0.1 cream alendronate sodium 70mg side effects buy toradol injection online www canadian hesalth what is parafortan 500mg viagra extreme tadalafil over nighted classification blopress paroxetine side effects drugs doxycycline monohydrate 100mg for acne kosovarja chattanooga obat gabapentin cialis cheap from india buy bupropion seroquel dosage for insomnia cockapoo dogs for sale in il viagra 100 mg price bonadoxina medicamento prednisone canadian pharmnacy minocycline side effects depression condyline solutie prospect singulair allergy medicine generic betacin eye drop antibiotics for tooth infection over the counter latisse for eyebrows side effects colospan tablet deals viagra for sale in the usa order tretinoin cream verapamil side effects drugs walgreens employee website employee benefits clomid aventis pharma is 4000 mg of atenelol fatal symptoms of digoxin toxicity levels clindamicina dosis en perros where to buy unisom 2 unisom and pregnancy 3rd trimester sildenafil prezzo aquisto online extenze side effects ingredients lidocaine hydrochloride jelly usp 2 famvir for shingles treatment lumigan side effects bimatoprost lasuna planting where to buy cephalosporins spiriva coupons 2011 hyzaar side effects lupus cholesterol lowering diet foods losartan side effects medication kako radi tadalafil colchicine side effects apo ti 4 is tizanidine 4mg zanaflex a muscle relaxer kamagra uk paypal medoflucon fluconazole side ed drugs supplies flovent hfa 220 mcg inhaler suprax 400mg iraplax orlistat 120mg xenical rythmol dosage apo sildenafil 50 mg motilium online uk oracea coupon 2014 fungsi metronidazole cose clomid redustat capsulas 60 mgregenon aspirin overdose death on line pharmacy hong kong albuterol side effects epanutin drug mart zithromax antibiotic price does amoxicillin cure std buy ciali soft on line reglan dosage for adults citalopram 20 mg dose viagra pills had a bottom line cost of zoloft without insurance maxman capsules uk buy cialis with echeck terbinafine cream for dogs generic plavix at walmart prescription drugs 24 fast delivery septra suspension dosage for children cheap percent without prescription silagra australia provera and clomid after miscarriage female viagra sildenafil capoten contraindications to breastfeeding canadian ed pharmacy imitrex injection side effects viagra in indian market lipitor recalls online abortion pills for sale cipla suhagra from india tadalfil 20mg cialis canada vendita famciclovir for shingles treatment nitroglycerin ointment buy at store amoxicillin and clavulanate potassium dosage looking for brand viagra no perscription canadian pharmacies comparateur prix cialis tenormin atenolol 25 mg lidocaine ointment usp 5 for hemorrhoids florinef doses buy cialis 20mg fda approved pharmacy where to buy viagra in kuching 273 levlen 28 generic brand xanax alprazolam dosage amounts nizagara order online is 25mg viagra enough precio de omifin pastillas pregnant celebrities pictures viagra mexico pharmacy dysfonction erectile viagra kenacomb ointment philippines cheapest viagra soft 100 mg ropinirole hydrochloride tablets navidoxine meclizine hydrochloride side folcres finasteride tablets levoxyl recall synthroid dalacin c 300mg manufacturer jelly thailand finasteride side effects long term use 24 hour cvs near me lisinopril 20mg online pharmacy hytrin online without prescription elomet pregnancy domperidone side effects gastroparesis gupisone 20 dose description of jesus lipothin no rx viagra prices in vancouver ritalin side effects in children betneval lotion colchicine dosage for gout attack triamterene 75mg hctz 50mg tablets cephalexin 250mg capsules side effects sotalex tablettask clonidine no presciption deltasone 5 mg dose pack picture xenical mail order india my cialis online jasmine mickael jordan bikini comprar cialis en washington haldol side effects review comment prendre cytotec milnacipran drug information sertraline mexico no script needed canadian pharmacy bactroban precio warfarin diet foods sibutramine user reviews viagra in melbourne propecia side effects forum cefaclor drug study best place to buy online finasteride elimite permethrin side effects alli tablets bactrim antibiotic and alcohol order salbutamol express shipping pyrocaps 20mg cialis usmedicbay paxil amoxicillin europe ranitidine side effects aurochem india buy cialsis overnight pharmacy 4 u kamagra prozac for anxiety reviews lergigan fortes erythromycin dosage for tonsillitis torsemide medication dose buy antibiotics online securely glucophage xr 750 side effects securecheckoutz pharmacy azithromycin 250 mg for mrsa benicar hct 40 12.5 prices propecia finasteride online celexa side effects celexa weight gain norvasc 10mg medication imiquimod 5 cream packet imitrex dosage and administration mail order drugs from canada side effects of generic viagra pulmicort side effects in children sildenafil powder in bulk doxycycline 500mg comprar viagra na europa online prednisone online new zealand non prescription cialis canada ramipril medication motilium alcohol cheap atorvastatin usa pharmacy buy glipizide without prescription tijuana pharmacy adderall manly 100mg tv ads viagria does viagra make you horny viagra mexican pharmacy utilisatrice de cialis femme cialis shelf life lopid gemfibrozil 600 mg help for stomp cramps caused from norfloxacin medication prescription drugs without rx pfizer viagra 100mg coupon viagra hk risnia tablets with keyboards health benefits of cialis orderpharma accutane and alcohol careprost for lashes viagra going generic yasmine petty bio domperidone dosage gastroparesis lipitor recall 2010 restonite ambien dosage premarin tablets 0.625 buy viagra levitra doxycap tablets under $100 where to buy citolopram in canada vagiral ovulos de sabilavagravaiagravaigaravaigravairgavalium lamictal bipolar levothroid medication dosage what is betacin capsules used for sifrol parkinson side effect rythmol medications temazepam buy in line seroflo inhaler entocort medication price pharmacy technician letter login elimite 5 percent no perscription azithromocin tablets fanegada wiki answers buy paxil nuvigil side effects morphine withdrawal symptoms dose can you get high on indomethacin mobicox 7 5mg percocet letrozole infertility nizoral ad shampoo reviews lipvas cipla pharmaceuticals vermox 500 janssenvgr100 viagra liquid amikacin injection for infants all day chemist retin a ativan lorazepam drugs side effects european phamarcy flagyl online overnight modern depression dermizol gel electrophoresis canadian pet meds pharmacy rythmol manufacturer levitra producer india average price of cialis pharmaceutical products viagra ibuprofen 800mg dosage viagra for sale without a prescription luvox ocd medication buy tetracycline ophthalmic ointment benemid medication side asthmahaler mist buy clotrimazole lozenges 10mg ciprotab dosage of aspirin buy qsymia in canada onlain filmebi qartulad terbutaline side effects clonidine 0.1mg patch side effectsclopidogrel does aarp pay for viagra retirides 0 025 sofilex wiki answerssoftware order fertility pills online advair online no prescription ephedraxin infowars periactin for sale myambutol medication identification lipitor lawsuit best place to buy medical drugs online lotemax side effects medication tabletten oynanan oyunlar 3 how to use cytotec for abortion azithromycin 600 for sale where to get nizagara pain meds online kamagra made in india keppra medication and alcohol lipitor side effects capoten food interaction aricept drug card atenolol and weight gain cheap tadalis coumadin blood thinner testing machine dicyclomine bentyl side effects eprex dose in dialysis patients doqit lantus insulin price propecia dosage fanegada en metrostudy mountainwest apothecary how long for viagra to work avodart 0 5 mg buy wee northwestpharmacy where to purchase chat lagyl levitra 80 mg anastrozole bodybuilding dosages propecia for womens hair loss trichologist venta on line la viagra mas barata order viagra online fast shipping canada medicines prescription drugs dapoxetine online purchase viagra without subscription buy cheap cialis on line sildenafil 100mg dapoxetine 60mg overnite shipping on vigar clomiphene for women in store what is super active cialis buy diflucan canada cybalta overnight can you buy zithromax over the counter claritin d coupons zyrtec fish medications for humans buy accutane in large quanity levitra yan etkileri illegal diet pills tsx exelon patch 5 bonadoxina pfizer dosis pastillas para quemar aldara side effects look like herpes cialis 40mg professional for sale doxazosin mesylate 4 mg tab cephalexin 500 mg capsule dosage malaseb dog medicated shampoo doxycycline purchase to buy roaccutane cialis generic with paypal lamictal rash obat zovirax cialis sale online canada cleveland clinic baclofen pump spasticity alfuzosin hcl er 10 mg tablet side effects best price 20 mg cialis how much should carbogoline cost cheap cialis from india ivermectin dosage for dogs with heartworms reputable online pharmacy cialis nexium generic equivalent bactrim ds side effects alcohol melovax 15mg morphine phentermine canada pharmacy mexican steroids pharmacy altace blood pressure medicine axet ear drop starcef capsule size flomaxtra xl uk zithromax over the counter apertium wikimapia gabapentin over counter viagra online echeck hydrochlorothiazide thru canada xylocaine injection drug cost of crestor at walmart best on line pharmacy buy albuterol sulfate inhaler online penicillin online arthritis foundation of america buy sildenafil citrate on line relafen nabumetone medications cialis asia ventolin 100 mg aldactone side effects weight loss and gain lantus solostar pen herpes simplex 1 entocort for collagenous colitis viagra pill for sale ciprofloxacin 500 mg buy strattera adderall buy increasing lung capacity for swimmingindapamide astra zeneca pulmicort flexhaler coupons viagra 100mg vs 50 mg rhinathiol infant syrup dosage micardis 40 mg cost tadalafil generico cephalexin for dogs side effects percocet side effects percocet addiction