Review Round Up: ‘Jab Tak Hai Jaan’ Woos Critics

Bollywood films, particularly romantic dramas, rarely open to universal acclaim. “Jab Tak Hai Jaan,” or “Until There Is Life,” the last film directed by Bollywood’s “king of romance” Yash Chopra, before he passed away in October, is one of the rare films that did.

Starring Shah Rukh Khan, Katrina Kaif and Anushka Sharma, the romantic drama traces Samar Anand’s (Mr. Khan’s) quest for undying love, from the streets of London to the valleys of Kashmir.

The film, which released alongside “Son of Sardaar” this Diwali, was hailed by many Indian critics. Here’s a roundup of what they had to say:

“There cannot be a better way to portray love on the silver screen,” opined a Zee News review by film critic Ananya Bhattacharya. “Jab Tak Hai Jaan has nailed that – at least for the immediate future.”

Ms. Bhattacharya was all praise for the film’s star cast, particularly Mr. Khan, who in her view brought to life a “newer, better, improved version” of Raj Malhotra, the love-smitten protagonist in Mr. Chopra’s 1995-produced classic “Dilwale Dulhania Le Jayenge.”

“If as Raj Malhotra he [Mr. Khan] had managed to woo half the population of the country; as Samar Anand, this man can make many more smitten by him. The slight stutter, the little hint of a tear in the eyes, the arms-outstretched pose – Khan knows how to make his ladies fall for him – be it that they are almost half his age!” Ms. Bhattacharya wrote.

The critic went on to applaud Mr. Chopra for his direction. “Only somebody like Yash Chopra could have made those mesmerising locales of Pehalgam and Ladakh come alive on celluloid… The film doesn’t really have the sarees flying slo-mo in the air, but what it has is sheer, pristine beauty,” she wrote.

Overall, Ms. Bhattacharya was highly impressed with the film, though she felt it was “a tad too long” and its background score, composed by Oscar-winning composer A.R. Rahman, had been “underused.”

Nevertheless, she concluded by giving the film four stars out of five. “Yash Chopra, you made sure that you will live on and that your last film will be remembered – jab tak hai jaan,” or until there is life, she wrote.

Jab Tak Hai Jaan “is the best romantic film made in this generation.” That’s how Bollywood critic Rachit Gupta summed up the movie in a Filmfare review.

“Like any piece of commercial cinema, it has its cinematic liberties and plot holes. But the sum of it is an old school love story that weaves its magic on the tender hearts of die-hard romantics,” Mr. Gupta opined.

The critic was all praise for the film’s star cast, its “master class” script and its “real, uncomplicated” dialogue. The film’s plot, though “a run-of-the-mill love triangle” in Mr. Gupta’s view, set itself apart from other romantic dramas, largely owing to its “philosophy, poetic love and honest emotions.”

Jab Tak Hai Jaan “is the perfect adieu to [Mr. Chopra’s] hallmark career,” the reviewer concluded, giving the film four stars out of five.

An NDTV review by Saibal Chatterjee concurred. “Jab Tak Hai Jaan, Yash Chopra’s last film, is a perfectly fitting finale to an eventful life and career.”

The film’s screenplay “is by no means flawless,” but the romantic drama “leaves a soothing afterglow,” Mr. Chatterjee opined.

The critic was also impressed with the film’s theme and character sketches. “Though the focus of Jab Tak Hai Jaan is on the male protagonist, the two women in his life aren’t mere mannequins.” Instead, they are blessed with “grace and intelligence, besides the ability to speak their minds and hold on to their beliefs,” a rare treat in Bollywood romances, he noted.

“Watch Jab Tak Hai Jaan not just for the obvious sentimental reason but for the fact that it shows, for one last time, what Bollywood will miss now that the undisputed master of romantic sagas is no more,” Mr. Chatterjee concluded, giving the film three-and-a-half stars out of five.

“In contemporary times when love stories have more or less turned into instant make out and instant breakup…. it’s heartening to see a full-blown romance saga which has good old values and yet a very modern outlook,” film critic Gaurav Malani wrote in The Times of India.

“Like most love stories, even Jab Tak Hai Jaan has sacrifice and sanctity at its footing yet at no point is it depressing or disheartening,” he added. The critic went on to praise the film’s “impeccable” screenplay, “strikingly beautiful” cinematography and “scrumptious” chemistry between Mr. Khan and Ms. Kaif.

“Jab Tak Hai Jaan is a sublime story about love and life. They don’t make them like that anymore,” Mr. Malani concluded. His verdict? “Very Good.”

Writing for the Hindustan Times, film critic Anupama Chopra was notably disappointed with the film’s plot but on the whole enjoyed the film, largely due to its “heartfelt performances.”

“In any case, you don’t go to a Yash Chopra movie to delve into realism or the messiness of relationships. You go to partake in a fantasy of swooning, idealised love – and Jab Tak Hai Jaan delivers plenty of that,” she noted.

So despite the film’s “wobbly narrative,” Jab Tak Hai Jaan’s “gorgeously shot locations,” “lavish songs,” “inherently noble lead characters,” and “top-notch” star cast performances, makes it work “as an ode to epic romance,” the critic wrote.

Ms. Chopra’s review gave the film three stars out of five.

http://blogs.wsj.com/indiarealtime/2012/11/13/review-round-up-jab-tak-hai-jaan-woos-critics/

2 Comments

  1. deadmanwalking
    deadmanwalking
    November 14, 2012 at 3:31 AM

    yes their is afew bad review but in general the critic love the film and the rating from 3 to 4 stars

Page 1 of 1

Post Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

levitra 5mg kaufen xenical generico 500mg zithromax 100 mg buy xenical cheap doxycycline tablets 500mg cialis online stores buy cytotec baguio lasix generic drug zovirax 50 mg bula levitra 20mg generika buy levitra 10 pills france buy viagra metformin online australia 0.5mg propecia eod cheap generic xenical generic viagra gel buy 1000 viagra diflucan 50 mg nebenwirkungen kamagra australia buy cialis 10mg opinie lisinopril online buy diuretic lasix buy danger 20 mg levitra lasix 12.5mg cost cheap levitra a cialis europe online cialis 5 mg forum metformin orifarm 850 mg augmentin 400 mg chewables synthroid and generics buying cialis budapest levitra cheap generic lexapro alternative nolvadex 60mg start cost 40mg doxycycline lasix 100mg australia generic viagra england 100mg viagra online indicacion cialis 5mg augmentin 375 mg used xenical caps .120 mg commander kamagra 100mg cialis online 5 mg buspar generic version levitra online health viagra 50mg drunk generic name metformin price cialis 100mg buy tetracycline 500 mg augmentin 20 mg buying cialis generic viagra online meds augmentin generico strattera 80 mg buy generic viagra st clomid buying online wat kamagra 100mg clomid cheap online preisvergleich levitra 20 mg 12 augmentin 250 mg dose cialis 5mg vs 20 buy amoxil 50 mg viagra australia 100mg legit viagra online viagra online help reviews viagra online 20 mg daily cialis cialis 5mg generic generico di zoloft cialis buy johannesburg buy safe levitra buy generic lisinopril cialis australia online cialis 5 mg dosage buy geniune viagra nolvadex buy uk priligy 60 mg preisvergleich lisinopril sandoz 5mg priligy 60 mg filmtabletten buy prednisone australia lisinopril 10 mg bijwerkingen generic viagra europe Cialis 10mg 30 Tabs paypal order cialis phenergan liquid buy doxycycline 100mg bula viagra 50 mg online buy valtrex online generic viagra articles generic priligy 30 mg phenergan 12.5 mg iv zithromax 500 online wellbutrin 75 mg diflucan 150 mg dosierung zovirax cream 5 mg assunzione levitra 10 mg usa 800mg viagra 1000mg valtrex tadalafil 20mg kamagra 500 mg tetracycline dosage propecia singapore online generic wellbutrin xl 300 buy liquid propecia online eczane cialis metformin 500 mg tb24 prescription viagra 25mg buy viagra bahamas 100mg clomid follicles generico priligy italia cialis 5mgsouth africawholesale xenical 120 mg bijsluiter cialis generic 40 mg. diflucan 10 mg cialis 5 mg or 10 magnus viagra 100mg xenical 120 mg wirkstoff generic zoloft problems zoloft 50 mg yahoo prednisone sandoz 20 mg clomid 150 mg jumeaux generic substitute strattera viagra 20mg prijs strattera 120 mg daily buy kamagra soho ordering valtrex online augmentin 875 mg posologia 1500 mg zoloft 1000 mg er metformin zithromax 250 mg chlamydia viagra 100mg efeitos viagra generic wallmart acquista levitra 5 mg celebrex cheapest kamagra paypal order types cialis online xenical generico prezzi bactrim online india cytotec 200mg ivg synthroid 0.05mg severity buy viagra putugal cipro 500 mg tablet wellbutrin 300 mg fiyati cialis generico 20 mgrs. propecia online cheap utilisation cialis 5mg phenergan promethazine 25 mg viagra pillen online buy propecia ireland glucophage 500 mg beipackzettel generic viagra.nz metformin mylan 850 mg dosis augmentin 250 mg thuoc augmentin 500mg augmentin 1000 mg duo cheap lasix nexium esomeprazol 40 mg nolvadex buy tamoxifen propranolol hcl 80mg 50 mg clomid pregnancy synthroid 112 mg walgreens cialis 5mg buying viagra shops generic cipla viagra 25 mg phenergan iv get generic propecia prescription levitra 20 mg cialis generique 100mg lisinopril generic tablets 80 mg nolvadex viagra generico dosis trust viagra online viagra 25 mg costo prednisone 5 mg vaccines koop cialis online buy levitra 100mg steroids nolvadex buy xenical generico preco buying augmentin online xenical capsule 120mg prednisone 20 mg winthrop glucophage metformina 850 mg kosten cialis 10 mg nexium 60mg buspar hcl 10mg mastercard buy cialis canada viagra buy nexium 10 mg costo 8 mg of prednisone generic levitra de lexapro 20mg night metformin 500 mg sr cheap est propecia xenical tablets online pregnant 50 mg clomid tapering 10 mg prednisone 100mg of doxycycline metformin 500 mg brand kamagra jelly 25mg levitra online rezept generic viagra onlineusa 500mg cipro strep levitra 10 mg dose 150 mg phenergan 450 mg wellbutrin xl generic dapoxetine online 1 cialis 5mg cheapest kamagra 100 viagra 0.1 mg cialis 20 mg prospect priligy cheap uk nolvadex generic online antidepresivo lexapro 10 mg online canada cialis augmentin 1000 mg kullanimi ordering vaginal viagra cialis 40mg buy nexium online generic zovirax 800 mg precio buyin viagra online order online cialis hydrochlorothiazide 12.5 mg tb 100mg clomid triplets clomid 50mg muscu erythromycin dose 500 mg levitra 40 mg generic levitra 10 mg effects international viagra online amoxil capsule 500 mg online cheap viagra prezzi levitra 5 mg glucophage buy cheap lexapro 70 mg propecia buy cheap malaysian cialis 50mg buy pakistani viagra lasix da 500 mg tetracycline hcl 250mg fgr 100 viagra mg buying viagra shanghai nolvadex tabs cheap synthroid . 1 mg metformin online bestellen lexapro 20 to 30 mg buy doxycycline antimalarial zithromax 250 mg 3 pack prednisone tab 10mg levitra dosage generic zithromax 500mg italy lisinopril 40 mg day 3000 mg valtrex metformin 850 mg axcount doxycycline 200 mg price cialis tijuana 10mg prednisone 7.5 mg daily propecia 1 mg costco canadian cialis cheap 600mg zithromax order cheap valtrex taking 50 mg clomid 150 mg wellbutrin jitters lisinopril online kaufen zovirax 800 mg uk buspar 60 mg day nolvadex generic names buy indian cialis cialis cost 5 mg toko viagra online wockhardt lisinopril 20 mg periactin cyproheptadine 4mg cipro 250mg dosage prednisone 0.5 mg tab cheap cialis marbella nexium 40 mg mexico diflucan 200 mg compresse buy viagra use buy doxycycline 20mg generic lisinopril 20 mg viagra deals online thuoc zithromax 250mg cheapest levitra generic buy kamagra 100mg augmentin 675 mg dosage lexapro 20 mg efficacy clomid generic 50mg viagra 100 mg cheap zovirax tabletas 400mg cialis 20 mg mexico cheapest viagra 150 propranolol 40 mg tablets costo cialis generico buy levitra 10mg diflucan one 150 mg order levitra cheap woman generic viagra cialis generico rj 20 mg generic levitra 25 mg of hydrochlorothiazide viagra 25 mg nebenwirkungen cheapest cialis suppliers buy viagra online 22 222 online propecia forum cheapest viagra 150mg viagra online fda generic zovirax available original nolvadex 20 mg doxycycline 100mg cellulitis cialis dapoxetine cheap levitra 10 mg directions diflucan 100 mg costs nexium 40 mg info doxycycline 20 mg acne genuine cialis cheap buy zoloft 50 mg cialis cost 20 mg augmentin 250 mg dosis buy 500mg doxycycline viagra prijs 100 mg lisinopril 20 mg safe propranolol nombre generico offerta cialis online lisinopril 10 mg ingredients generic cialis 40 australia cialis de 05 mg cheap lexapro order metformin 500 mg a12 nexium 10 mg pret augmentin 625 generic name cipro 500mg std zithromax generic price levitra 20mg deutsch generic brazilian cialis teva metformin 500 mg levitra order walgreen finns viagra 200mg mail order propecia cipla cialis 5mg xenical 120mg capsules preisvergleich cialis 5mg pvp cialis 10 mg levitra 5 mg prezzi 10mg generic levitra bali buy viagra cheap zovirax uk nexium 100mg farmacia online kamagra viagra pills cheap average mg zoloft zovirax generic uk prices online cialis cialis 20 mg daily 100 mg white viagra online viagra in controindicazioni xenical 120 mg 600 mg kamagra cialis buy mastercard bactrim en generico levitra 180 pills online cheap doxycycline online buy propecia paypal 10 mg 20 mg cialis lasix 40 mg bodybuilding hyperstimulation clomid 50mg cheap cialis 40 mg viagra tiger 120 mg nexium 40 mg manipulado synthroid 0.25 mg tablet viagra 100 mg canada cytotec de 5 mg cheap viagra pharmacy buy doxycycline products generic propecia shedding online propecia buy lexapro cheaper alternative 5mg lexapro stopping cialis 5 mg acquisto 75 mg wellbutrin xl mexican viagra generic buy viagra africa viagra paypal bbuy cialis 2.5 mg canada viagra order pfizer buy cialis 75 cents viagra jakarta online zithromax 500 mg 7 days prednisone prolix 20mg cialis 5 mg take zithromax dogs buy glucophage 500mg pregnancy buy 60 mg nolvadex levitra 10mg erfahrungsberichte celebrex 100 mg costo lisinopril 40 mg dizziness fungsi cialis 20mg cialis generics cheap buying cialis china cytotec tab 0 2 mg 20mg lexapro 10mg debrecen buy viagra posologie cytotec 200 mg buy zovirax 200 mg levitra generic discount lexapro 10 mg citalopram viagra generico rischi lexapro de 10mg gbl viagra order augmentin 625 mg breastfeeding mail order cialis levitra 20 mg tab viagra 25mg online viagra onlines propranolol de 40 mg generic lexapro pharmacy buy nolvadex uk cheapest regalis viagra viagra online istanbul zoloft 200 mg breastfeeding pfizer zoloft 100mg prednisone taper 50 mg zovirax ung generic teva prednisone 5mg online viagra 25mg price viagra online levitra 20 mg 30 comprimidos cialis 5 mg voucher 500 mg viagra thailand ingredients celebrex 200 mg generic nexium online cialis online walgreens cialis tadalafil 5mg avis generic cialis zithromax 250 mg beipackzettel nakup viagra 25 mg prednisone tab 50mg clomid 50 mg ervaringen synthroid 0 088 mg strattera 100mg costo amoxil buyh paypal cialis manipulado 2.5mg wellbutrin generic pill buying viagra budapest erythromycin 5oomg lisinopril 5 mg cost generic valtrex buy generico viagra preco levitra 10mg 100mg viagra etkisi cialis cheapsarasotafl lisinopril 40 mg mg buy viagra rx clomid round 3 100mg lasix 40 mg ampullen generika cialis 5mg cialis 5mg fta 14 propecia generic finasteride buy erythromycin suspension nolvadex 20 mg buy generic viagra ray hydrochlorothiazide buy online cialis generic benefits generic lasix 500 mg lisinopril 25 mg tablet augmentin 375 mg tabletta diflucan 50mg used zoloft 50 mg capsule cialis generic 10mg buy 150 mg. viagra levitra brand 20mg prednisone dog 5mg cipro 100 mg im cheap viagra drugs generic clomid work wellbutrin generic complaints buy lasix online propecia biotin 5 mg 100mg viagra wiki priligy generico acquisto reliable generic cialis zithromax 250 mg vidal cialis en genericos cialis generico guatemala viagra cost buy lisinopril al 5mg zovirax 5mg cream xenical 120mg reviews generic viagra vs mailorder cialis viagra generico 24 ore levitra 20 mg facts geberic viagra 50mg amoxil 500 online prescriptions cipro 500mg tab wallgreens levitra 20 mg prednisone 50mg asthma buspar 15 mg medication lexapro 10 mg directions metformin zydus 1000 mg viagra 150mg cialis strips 10 mg cheap kamagra 50 pills buy everyday cialis