NAACHGAANA
CCI rejects Devgn’s allegation of YRF abusing dominant position
abcd | November 6, 2012, 9:51 AM | 34 comments | 0 views


The Competition Commission of India (CCI) has rejected the plea of actor-producer Ajay Devgn against Yash Raj Films (YRF) for their alleged abuse of dominant position ahead of release of Shah Rukh Khan-starrer Jab Tak Hai Jaan (JTHJ).

Devgn alleged that YRF was abusing its dominant position and was asking exhibitors to provide more screens to their release than for his film Son of Sardaar.

Both the films will be released this Diwali, November 13, 2012.

“We considered the plea application. We have not found any merit in the case as there is no case of abuse of dominant position. This is a case of first comer. That can not be held against them (YRF). Hence there is no violation of Section 3 of the Competition Act,” an official source told the Indian Express. The orders for the same will be issued soon, the official said.

Earlier, last week, the Delhi High Court had asked the CCI to expeditiously decide the complaint by Ajay Devgn Films not getting enough single-screen theatres due to YRF abusing its position.

YRF had apparently told the exhibitors that it will give Salman Khan-starrer Ek Tha Tiger only if they agreed to give its Diwali release prominence over other films.

However, the production house, YRF, denied the allegations, arguing that a Yash Chopra-Shah Rukh Khan movie, coming after a gap of eight years, did not need any coercion for contractual screening.

Devgn Films lawyers in statement had said, “YRF has entered into a tie-in arrangement with the exhibitors in a manner that it has made it compulsory for the exhibitors to exhibit the untitled movie of YRF on Diwali day and two weeks thereafter with all four shows.” They added that such a tie-in arrangement in the present circumstances violates Section 3 of the Competition Act, 2002.

http://www.indianexpress.com/news/cci-rejects-devgn-s-allegation-of-yrf-abusing-dominant-position/1027301/

About the author:
Has 84 Articles

34 COMMENTS
  1. iitianWay

    thats the benefit of having frndship with con..s …. not only govt but all its deptts work for u

    aur karo modi ka google hangout..

  2. wall-D

    This was expected when last year SRK managed to get U certificate for a movie full of double meaning jokes, gay scenes, boob grabbing etc. This was no big deal in corrupt india.

  3. Fasel

    Haha jalte raho, yaha se dhuaan nazar ara hai haha :)

  4. Khan.1

    Haha jhuthe allegation honge to reject hi hoga na.

  5. Tango

    As I had said, let the law take it’s own course which it has.

    I accept it.

    ADF can still go to to supreme court.

    But problem is, even if the SC gives a decision against ADF, there will again be allegation that YRF ne manipulate kar liya.

    1. iitianWay

      Tango jee ..own cource nahin ..con course.

  6. rockie_EK THA TIGER

    I think if CCI has given a decision then there is no point in challenging them.

    Ajay D and others should now learn a lesson from this. If you are planning for festival releases make sure you pre-book ample number of screens exclusively atleast for 2 weeks.

    Anyways all the best to SOS.

  7. rockie_EK THA TIGER

    Earlier I used to say …. may the best one wins.

    But now I will not say that, because there is no competition now.
    Adi C finally will be able to AVENGE his father, by hook or by crook.

  8. aravind_66

    So much for that….But Ajay need not worry.If the fioplm is liked then it’ll get more screen space from 2nd week onwards….

  9. das

    Ajay lost the case…..koi baat nahin…still I support him. To support him I will watch SOS in theatre and JTHK on my PC :P

  10. iitianWay

    Now, I ..sincerely pray srk survives in movie.

  11. rockie_EK THA TIGER

    1 good thing for Ajay D is most of his recent movies have trended beautifully.
    Remember – Singham, Bol Bachchan both touched 100cr mark after 30 days of release.

    If SOS is good it has enough time to collect good. Though competition is more this time but we also have festival release and extended week advantage.

  12. javeed

    Wall-D was jumping like a kid when complaint was filed and i told him that his orgasm is short lived.

  13. Khan.1

    Ye NG pe itna pseudoism kyn hai yarr…
    The people who say salman is ‘innocent untill proved guilty ‘ are crying foul on YRF even if they are proved innocent.
    Ghor Kalyug!!
    May God bless these consentious peoples.

  14. Fasel

    Rockie saab you forgot to mentioned Tezz, Rascals, and Dil Toh Bacha Hai Ji.

    1. rockie_EK THA TIGER

      Yes offcourse I forgot it intentionally, but I assumed people might understand ….. when I have specifically mentioned “MOST” and not “ALL”.

      Anyways .. .congrats to you and Happy Diwali to you as this CCI decision is no less than Diwali celebs for you … BTW are you bursting crackers already ??… :D

  15. Tango

    iitianWay

    “Tango jee ..own cource nahin ..con course.”

    Iske aagey ab kisi course ki baat mat karna…..

    (Just in case it can be recourse … so on .. and so forth…i… course)

  16. Tango

    I obviously mean intravenous course

  17. Fasel

    I didnt know 2 out of 5 was considered most.

    1. rockie_EK THA TIGER

      Okay dude you are right .. I am wrng … khush?? :P

      Happy Diwali ….. have you started your celebrations of diwali by bursting crackers?? Uska to jawabb do?? :P

  18. alizain2844

    Guys Komal Nahata just said..
    YRF never even appeared before CCI in Ajay Devgan case coz they weren’t summoned.Why? Coz the case was dismissed outright,not even admitted

    Haha

    Where are all those which were degrading YRF whole day yesterday..
    Court even didnt admitted the case.. Now times of india which was going all out against YRF is not posting verdict..

    SOS team did cheap thing by degrading YRF.. Their case was nt even accepted and they started saying against YRF.. Really bad

  19. Dr.Nisheet

    this is shameful move and its effects will be seen in coming years…….bollywood will be a warwood soon……

    1. Asif Anwar

      So you do not trust CCI or do not believe in law?

  20. dr.nick

    chalo now that the verdict is passed,no point harping over it.we have to accept it.congrats in advance to srk for a thumping victory on diwali.

  21. iitianWay

    but keep ur best luck to SOS only…
    darshak ki duyaaen hi kaafi hain picture ko chalane ke liye.

  22. dr.nick

    duvayein leke darshak jaye to kahan jayen.aas paas ke theatres mein show hi nahi honge to duvayein kya ghanta ukhad lengi.sos has absolutely no chance of being even a hit.though my best wishes are with them as it looks a fantastic masala entertainer fit for festive season like diwali practically speaking they wont help much

  23. sanket porwal

    As I said it before, if SOS is a good film, the makers shouldn’t worry, it will surely do well. Yes of-course, the opening will not be strong, but if the film has good WOM, than it helps in longevity.

  24. sanket porwal

    In-fact its possible for SOS to collect as much as JTHJ opr even more if their film is much better than JTHJ.

    May the best win.

  25. RedDevil

    Well its out and clear now. Hope Ajay learns from this release saga and takes care of his future releases without any fretful approach. Also there is no point in complaining now when its too late instead they could have waste this time on film’s publicity and promotion instead of roaming around CCI or courts. Also to be fair if Ajay’s product is good then it would succeed irrespective of its release or screen count. Meanwhile, just watched Heer’s promo from JTHJ and it does bring some positive vibe about the film. Hope the best film succeeds & Wishing both the team JTHJ and SOS all the best.

  26. Engineer

    kabhi kabhi kuch paane k liye kuch khona padta h aur haar kar jeetne wale ko baazigar kehte hai…king khan rocks…
    Jab tak hai jaan

  27. Fasel

    I dont celebrate Diwali so why would I burst crackers? I am a Muslim.

  28. danish

    @fasel – diwali to sab manaate hain. sharukh khan is also a muslim but he spent a 150 cr on a single cracker last year, which went phussssssssss! dont u remember?

LEAVE YOUR COMMENT

Back to Top