A dummies’ guide to the Devgn-YRF legal battle

(contains interviews of other distributor and producer)

Choosing what movie to watch where is usually not a very complicated choice, usually made while flipping through the cinema listings page and seeing which theatre or multiplex is screening which movie. But what those lists will say this Diwali is not as easy a choice, at least not for the people who decide what their theatres will run, caught as they are in a somewhat unprecedented situation.

The logic of which movie is screened where is fundamentally not very dissimilar from the logic of which movie you watch. You have options, a first impression, word of mouth, the star cast, etc, and choose to put your money to go and watch one movie ahead of another when you have multiple options in hand. The theatre/multiplex owner’s logic is not very different. He assesses your interest level in turning out to watch a film and opts to run it in his theatre ahead of another, hoping for good business.

In principle, therefore, neither can you be made to choose one movie, nor can a movie exhibitor be made to screen one. And just as word of mouth can change our calls even after we have first made up our mind, initial turnout can make theatres change their schedules after the first week or even earlier, shuffling shows to bring them in sync with what the audience is consuming. A point to note – a multi-screen venue, what we call a multiplex, has the option to screen several movies parallel, and so the call is not really a make-or-break one, it’s more about the ratio. But a single-screen – a theatre – doesn’t have that luxury. It has only one screen. So when it says Yes to a movie, it, by default, is saying No to all others for that point of time.

Now, when Sholay was released, all this wasn’t such a problem. Movies had time to grow and expand by word of mouth, there were silver and golden jubilees, and the timespan for a movie to recover cost was infinitely greater. Today, when the great bulk of a movie’s money is made in the opening weekend, not even the opening week, any movie that doesn’t hit an adequate number of screens is kaput. You can keep praising the DVD later, as happens with so many award-winning movies that released in a handful of halls, but essentially, it’s sunk. But then, it happens all the time that some movies release in a hundred screens in a city and some in just ten, right? The guys who take the call on what to run – the exhibitors – can choose what they want to, it’s a free market, so what’s the big deal?

The big deal in this case is that a very large number of single-screen exhibitors are not really in a position to choose – since when they asked for prints of Ek Tha Tiger, the makers of the movie, YRF, made them sign an agreement that they could get Tiger only if they screened the next YRF movie coming on Diwali. Correction – only if they only screened the next YRF movie. So even if a theatre had, say, 5 shows in a day, it couldn’t show the YRF movie – Jab Tak Hain Jaan, which was untitled then – in 3 shows and something else in 2. It had to show only that in all 5 shows. Given the buzz around Tiger, and the economic muscle of YRF, the country’s biggest production house, and the not-so-strong economic muscle of the average single-screen theatre, most signed on the dotted line.

Which, of course, means that any other movie that began looking for halls for a Diwali release – and hall owners which began looking for it – didn’t have much of a choice. The number of halls left unfettered to choose if they would screen any competitor to JTHJ would go down sharply. The competitor, of course, is Son Of Sardaar. And how much has the number of halls potentially available to it gone down by? Devgn’s last starrer, Bol Bachchan, opened in 1200 halls. SOS is at the moment struggling to find 400. That means barely 30-35% of Bol Bachchan’s screens.

The implication: A potential loss of 70% of the money that the movie would have made from single-screen theatres. The consequence: Devgn moving the Competition Commission for legal redressal, and moving the High Court for timely redressal from the Commission.

When contacted, YRF representatives said that they had nothing further to add to their previous statement issued on this subject.

No. of single screens for JTHJ and SOS
Cities JTHJ SOS
Delhi 20 3
Bangalore 10 2
Saurashtra 18 3
Hyderabad 18 2
Dadar/ Mahim/ Matunga 6 1

YRF got my movie removed from all multiplexes: filmmaker
I am a Marathi movie maker and therefore, have less muscle power. But my first movie produced, Deool won a National Award, and so, everyone in the Marathi belt was waiting for Bharatiya, the second movie produced by me. Our film released on August 10, and we had ensured, after sharing production schedules with other Marathi filmmakers, that our movie did not clash with other movies. We were aware that Ek Tha Tiger was releasing on August 15. Nobody had, on 8th or 9th, told us there is going to be any problem, and a Marathi movie is no comparison with a YRF movie, so we did not foresee any clash. Suddenly, we were told that on 14th, our movie will be removed from all the multiplexes. We were told that ETT was looking at setting an unprecedented record, and so, Yash Raj had placed the condition that either they take all the shows, or they will get none.

It was a weekend, and I did not have time to go to courts, etc. Finally, I went to Thackeray saab, and played the Marathi angle. So, isn’t this an unfair monopolistic approach to put such conditions that affect others’ businesses because you want to make records? We also spoke to someone at the CCI at that time, but our voice was very feeble, and for me, the damage was done. The multiplexes, fearing unpleasant incidents, ran my movie for a couple of more days, but removed it after that. At least we could pressurise them, the single screens toh just refused to show the movie. And barring Marathi strongholds like Pune and Sholapur, our movies were off screens – reduced overnight, from 400 shows to some 80 shows.

So, my film suffered very badly. I also realised that the distributors are party to this along with the exhibitors. In fact, after I went to Balasaheb, I got calls from some exhibitor organisation saying I have not done the right thing, and that my forthcoming movies will face problems – almost a threat. This experience has left me feeling, to use a bad word, that this is goondagardi. Such one-sided practice is not a good thing in the industry. I come from the US – I have been there for 12 years, and had this happened there, the law would have taken action. But here, I now have to go back to those very exhibitors for the next film.
- Abhijeet Gholap, producer, Deool and Bharatiya

The aim of this practice is to corner any film releasing around Diwali: distributor

A condition was imposed on us, on each theatre, at the time of the release of Ek Tha Tiger, that they will only supply that film if we also screened Jab Tak Hai Jaan exclusively at Diwali. There was a single agreement for both films. We said that there will be other films also releasing at that time, but they said it had to be exclusively this film if we wanted Ek Tha Tiger. In Hyderabad, big films get about 20-25 single screens and about 10 multiplexes. Now, JTHJ has 15-18 single screens out of these. I have only two single screens left because at the time of ETT, YRF didn’t want them, even though I’d offered them; they didn’t release ETT there. Those are the only two single screens where I can run SOS.

The same pattern has been followed in Aurangabad, which is also in the Nizam territory. Out of five single screens there, YRF has taken four. Of these, two are mine, two they negotiated directly, and the one they left is only because it is one of two theatres in the same compound! In Bidar, Karnataka, out of three single screens, I gave them one, they got the second also, and the third only screens Kannada movies – so Son Of Sardaar will see no release there! This is definitely unfair practice. It completely kills the business of the distributors of Son Of Sardaar, and fortunately or unfortunately, I’m both a distributor of SOS and an exhibitor. The aim of this practice by YRF was to corner any film releasing around this time – agar doosri film ko screens milenge hi nahin, toh woh release kaise hogi?
Dilip Tandon of Hyderabad,distributor of SOS in the Nizam and Andhra territory, which includes Marathwada

TOI

76 Comments

  1. Alfa.one
    Alfa.one
    November 6, 2012 at 6:28 PM

    @drnick – I was not sarcastic dear !!!

  2. danish
    danish
    November 6, 2012 at 6:39 PM

    @alfa.one – mid-day and mumbai mirror cook up stories to sell their (toilet) paper. why wud salman go out of the way to sabotage srk’s CE next diwali to avenge ajay’s loss. he is not that petty and vindictive. and why wud sajid nadiadwala risk his business? salman has done wat had to be done to help ajay – in the form of pon pon song and thats more than enuff. aaj ke zamaane mein kaun itna bhi karta hai kisi ke liye.

    as for rajshree salman film, off course it can be a beautiful experience watching it on diwali – given its not like hum saath saath hain. i didnt like that one much.

Page 2 of 2 1 2

Post Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

feldene gel uk where to buy obagi tretinoin online misoprostol from canada world suhagraat information in urdu video lisinopril 10 mg coumadin antidote dose buy cheap synthroid 125mcg no rx clomid and twins rate generic adderall buy canada cealis india buy viagra at walmart 318 pharmacy online usa have clomiphene flunitrazepam buy online india med cab online pharmacy reviews prednisolone 5mg for dogs motrin dosage by weight distribuidora mincorp ivermectin wormer for swine buy finasteride no perscription cheap tadalafil usa exelon patch treatment canadian medstore atorvastatin recall 2013 soviclor tabs furniture cheap amitrippline lidocaine viscous 2 uses no script canadian pharmacy orderpharma accutane before and after pictures furolin tableti differin coupon code minoxidil 2 topical treatment for women betnovate scalp application hair loss amantadine side effects weight gain ornidazole injection phexin azdrama dutasteride 0 5 mg cheap finasteride online protonix medication pantoprazole doctor cyrux misoprostol 200mg morphine duloxetine hcl dr 30 mg zofran over the counter walgreens photo coupon codes 4x6 prints vitamix recipes for weight loss hytrin prostate treatment bph cheap albuterol inhaler proviron side effects mesterolone proviron clenbuterol side effects athletes performance propranolol shortage accutane reviews before and after pictures doxycycline overnight nautisol medication identification periactin canada viagara without a script vardenafil hcl 20mg side effects tomoxetin no script amphetamine dextroamphetamine bentyl dosage for children fincar finasteride online canada allegra d side effects allergies no script trimix ed meds colospan tablets mesterolone steroid forummetformina viagra side effects long term 489 stendra ephedraxin review doxylamine succinate vs diphenhydramine steroid medrol dose pack side effects zantac coupons sildegra tabletop omeprazole vs esomeprazole side effects dicyclomine 20 mg tablets used for buy proscar in the uk pravastatin sodium tablets usp 20 mg side effects carbimazole treatment dose alphagan p canada no prescription online pharmacxy cozaar side effects weight gain neurontin 24 hour shipping to us maximum nuvigil dosage xanax and alcohol use amphetamine salts 20mg discount card alli best buy health shop doxycycline lisinopril hctz 20 12.5 side effects flexeril 10 mg cyclobenzaprine cost xenical international purchases buy onadron roxifen capsules for sale bausch & lomb lotemax side effects cialis nose bleeds clopidogrel side effects symptoms hyzaar 100 25 side effects doxylamine succinate sleep aid dosage ibuprofen dosage for dogs viagra 100mg instructions online buy of orlistat 60mg baclofen 20 mg tablets best viagra pill buy viagra from egypt where can i get some viagra immy viagra on canadian pharmacy prazosin hcl 5 mg mirtazapine for dogs dose fincar 5 mg india clomid stockist uk buying colchicine albendazol for sale viagra women effects buying cialis in montreal cheapest prozac online lipitor recall 2010 atepros drug emporium levitra 20mg uk pinamox amoxicillin kamagrafast uk basketball acheter cialis livraison rapide novolax laxative sidenovolog viagra italia singulair allergy medicine side effects dilantin toxicity side effects canada pharmacy cilias primatene mist tablets ingredients nuvigil vs provigil cost rizatriptan benzoate generic epogen information clomid pregnancy test calculator reglan side effects in infants pacific care pharmacy online caverta 50 side effects jasmine villegas hot buy elocon without prescription zyban to quit smoking directions viagra ireland online shop feldene gel side effects tegretol withdrawal symptoms cheap non prescribed flagyl medication renagel mexico comprar cialis barato mastercard online cialis noprescription paypal viagra pills had a bottom line prevacid dosage for infants phexin azithromycin speedy rx meds tryptizol side effects benazepril hcl 20mg prescription testosterone cream for men can you take 150 mg viagra cialis italia gratis flovent diskus 100 mcg side effects benadryl for infants dosage no prescription cialis generic cheap letrozole side effects blog raloxifene drug interactions viagra sans ordonnance pharmacie macrobid 100mg capsule p&g united pharmacies uk online pharmacy 365 pills scam linezolid antibiotics cost estradiol cream estrogen prednisolone acetate eye drops for dogs allopurinol side effects mayo clinic pheromones for men reviews para que sirve glimepiride 1 mg cheapest levitra in fort lauderdale prednisolone for cats doseprednisona viagra from italy macrobid for uti treatment strattera non prescription canadian beconase nasal spray side effects vega 100 tablets side effects tindamax tinidazole side effects maxaman caye caulker belize lodging duetact 30mg oxycontin tadalafil over nighted prices for donepezil medication non prescription cialis canada colchicine tablets pictures female cialis recomended dose propranolol hydrochloride adverse effects viagra germany neurontin and weight gain allpills complaints against doctors contrave diet pill coupon viagra online cheap buy estrace tablets cialis 5 mg generika triamterene hctzno prescription kamagra strong indinavir crixivan 400mg online meds for uti benicar medication doses tadalafil with dapoxetine online online purchase viagra dicyclomine hydrochloride 20mg livial menopause orderpharma accutane baby pharmacy rx one reviews pastillas para abortar microgram avodart 0 5 mg buy hydrocodone refills online famvir dosage cold sore kips publishing world website oxytrol india ranitidine zantac eq bystolic side effects patient reviews xenical side effects palpitations cialis generic best price lidocaine ointment usp 5 for hemorrhoids cialis to buy uk metallica one guitar tabs does viagra make you harder buy plavix on line no prescription colchicine without rx haloperidol drug information generic cialis au suhagraat ka tariqa salbutamol pay pal metronidazole flagyl antibiotic side effects amitriptyline 100mg buy on line does cialis come in generic form valium information pictures laxifen tabletas anticonceptivas bisoprolol 5mg side effects cialis supr active for sale what is casodex bicalutamidecatafast colchicine treatment for gout prednisolone acetate ophthalmic suspension usp 1 dog therapy dog certification texas prednisone 10mg dose pack xanax addiction symptoms benzodiazepine amerimedrx coupon codes tienda la esquina famosa puerto rico doxycap capsule wardrobe can you use diflucan during pregnancy lopressor generic cheap bactrim no prescription prandin medication side effects gabapentin on the counter terazosin pharmacy online uk cipralex causes weight gaincipro venta de cialis clomiphene citrate 50 mg price elomet cream for baby levitra generika kaufen precose dosage calculations metronidazole overnight prescription drugs without rx fluconazole 150 fun dosage forzest tadalafil canada cialis generika deutschland bestellen minoxidil shampoo and conditioner nitrofurantoin buy online ciprotab 2500 retirides otc drugs anafranil drug reviews diclofenaco sodico inyectable purchase synthroid mexico mesterolone steroid cream cuvarlix taken after or before meal prayer generic cialis 200mg microcidal meaning of flowers seroquel for sleep aid carbimazole 5mg side effect atenolol side effects mayo clinic no doctor viagra colospan hovid horgesic tablet canadian viagra online low cost antibiotics medical in urdu buy ampicillin tr 500 mg carbimazole side effects prenisolone order minimum age for taking viagra price of viagra in sri lanka online pharmacy lisinopril restonite ambien dosage minocycline hydrochloride capsules alendronate sodium 70mg side effects glucotrol xl 2.5 pharmacy rx aciclovir dosis medicamento captopril 12.5mg viagra jelly for sale uk im hydrating sustiva side effects efavirenz side cardizem drip medication drug crestor side effects rhabdomyolysis lawsuit retail price for crestor strattera tablets online vosteran search browser zyprexa relprevv temovate cream 0 05 uses for vinegar forced to orgasm atarax canafa no prescription visa parlodel medication celexa withdrawal side effects how long tamsulosin flomax dosage accutane without a perscription flomaxtra xl 400 homelite order zoloft without script venlafaxine 75mg er side effects tofranil pm 125mg over the counter viagra walmart can i take keflex for sinus infection stanozolol side effects in dogs can you buy viagra in mexico pfizer stocks verapamil for migraines mayo clinic pills that make an erection flomax medication side effects therapy dogs international california pharmacy technician training paypal propecia ketazol shampoo for dry scalp nitroglycerin ointment for sale canada birth control without an rx omeprazol igual que cytotec lamictal for depression only viagra kopen propecia sale viagra for sell online citalopram withdrawal symptoms nebivolol hydrochloride prices generic cialis ireland flagyl dosage for children walmart levitra prices lynoral ethinyl estradiol side pergotime 50mg prednisone ezetimibe 10mg side effects order online propranolol 40mg dr barak accutane side effects years later flagyl syrup levlen 28 information viagra soft online using paypal neurontin for pain gabapentin qsymia price melovax 15mg morphine where can i get nolvadex novolog sliding scale insulin dosage chart indapamide side effects medication finpecia tablets usp cialis achat acheter alli contact customer ed clomid ovulation pills for sale alberta meglio viagra o cialis polarmeds in canada the executive branch effexor reviews for social anxiety buy prozac online uk betnesol side effects xenical precio colombia glucophage weight loss pcos cholesterol tests at walgreens free cialis trial pack cheap viagra online in canada generic cialis professional naproxen vs ibuprofen for inflammation generic finasteride uk trental 400 para que sirve rualis cialis triderm ointment creamtrimox prozac and alcohol interactions tretinoin cream usp 0.025 for wrinkles cheap ed trial packs isoniazid and vitamin b6 dyazide 37 5 25 capital partners vilches radioactive alli india buy zoloft onlne no pre best viagra tablets name clomid online buy overnight viamedic coupon code viagra without a doctor 357 toronto drug store pharmacy yasmine hamdan youtube what is clorfenamina compuesta free lasaoren removal alendronate sodium tablets 70 mg side effects indomethacin gout treatment dosing canada pharmacy viagra pacak flazol 500mg to grams metoprolol side effects mayo clinic buy methotrexate 2 5 mg no rx overnight quanto costa il cialis proviron impotence estrogen compound finpecia vs propecia moduretic drugstore binozyt antibiotic cefuroximeblupillblycolin ivermectin dosage for dogs with heartworms accutane online pharmacy phenergan dm syrup dose walgreens take care clinic jobs where to buy bactrim antibiotic linezolid package insert sublingual viagra bevispas side effects does aetna pay for cialis eprex 40000 ketazol tablets with windows maxalt migraine ingredients clindamycin dosage testosterone cream for men pharmacy technician salary in new york indinavir crystals for healing actos plus metformin patients buy doxycycline no rx viagra usa without a prescription allpills complaints against dentists diamox side effects acetazolamide mechanism medrol online no prescription cipro 500mg tab price where to buy priligy online uk parafortan tabs for bass anavar proviron cycle new simvastatin warning atacand side effects medications viamedic com vfw store supplies viagra for sale in hong kong cialis super active 20mg levofloxacin 500 mg tablets fast delivery viagra prostata inflamada cancer bactrim chew trazodone sleep aid side effects asthma symptoms in children age 5 online generic pharmacy zentel suspension nitrazepam prospective definition whear can i buy paxil mexican pharmacies in tojuana viagra kaufen mit mastercard medyka przemyska plentyoffish login voltaren for sale synthroid vs levothyroxine side effects cialis daily 5 mg loss of a dog what to say trazodone 100mg buy doxycycline online confidential vermox dosage suspension canadian pharmacy in dubai flomist cipla eas obetrol medication interaction digoxin and potassium acnelyse retinol side sildenafil 50 mg prices yasmine galenorn otherworld series list bevispas tablets with keyboards does amoxicillin cure std doxitab 100mg benadryl virectin side effects brand viagra online canadian pharmacy dyazide side effects doctor finasteride generic visa benoquin before and after photos internet drugstore increasing and decreasing functions and the first derivative test prescrizione viagra svizzera diabecon ingredients for lasagna xylocaine injection drug estradiol levels ivf ampicillin sulbactam side effects ortho 777 online without a prescription prevacid vs nexium prilosec sildenafil schweiz kaufen rxdiler store orlistat weight loss pills zyvox side effects in pregnancy rx relief card snopes cipla fieldcall fda approved viagra oxybutynin 10 mg estradiol valerate estrogens where to buy vibramycin syrup can i get soma with out the rx torsemide no prescription australia estradiol valerate injectable lidocaine ointment usp 5 uses neurontin medication side effects allegra versace anorexia recoveredallercet reglan lawsuit free viagra trial pack naprosyn medication hyzaar side effects lupus renagel vs renvela effexor xr side effects weight clopidogrel side effects breathing problems buy apo prednisone 50 mg lamictal side effects bipolar disorder duloxetine hcl dr 60 mg cap raloxifene breast cancer treatment revatio 20 mg cheap ibuprofen and alcohol and liver damage stilnox zolpidem 10mg xenical 120mg no prescription seroquel side effects divya pharmacy arthritis medication for dogs orabet bloger hr hydrea or hydroxyurea how can i buy cialis discount online jasmine rice in rice cooker