Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image

NG | June 20, 2013

Scroll to top

Top



6 Comments

Akshay’s Poor Script Sense: A Specious Perception


THIS TAKES INSPIRATION FROM MANISH’S POST “Akshay Kumar in love with Marathi plays”

http://www.naachgaana.com/2012/09/14/akshay-kumar-in-love-with-marathi-plays/

While reading about Akki’s interest and investment in novel ideas and scripts, I thought of writing this for those who bash akki for having no-script sense.

I personally believe that Akki chooses his movies quite smartly, but unfortunately the executers make him fail every now and then. Here is my take on the novelty and entertainment factors in some of his movies that eventually failed at box-office.

CC2C:

With the same script, a slightly undertone first half (minus deepika’s irritating scenes) and a bit more intense second half,, would have made this movie a lot more entertaining and appealing revenge story set with backdrop of Chinese martial arts, that was never experienced before in Indian cinema.

8×10 Tasveer:

A Nagesh Kukunoor’s thriller which revolves around akki’s ability to see the past and he uses it to investigate a murder that was made to look like accident, at the risk of his own life. Quite interesting in the concept with an unimaginable climax. But, if CC2C was criticized for being extremely OTT, this probably didn’t work because of excessively subtle treatment by Nagesh, which made the movie look like a family drama than a intense thriller. IMO, the only flaw at script level was climax where the motive of crime was not convincingly explained.

Action Replay:

Inspired from a super successful play, this talks about a son traveling to the past to change his father’s lifestyle and attitude. This was meant to be light hearted comedy, and didn’t have any logic as in case of any escapist cinema. Writing may have been flawed in some portions, but overall on-paper script will look defiantly engaging and interesting to anyone.  I like this movie especially in the second half which brims with ample laughter and wackiness in the sequences featuring translation of Akki’s character.  I still don’t understand why it failed so badly at BO, may be the fan’s found Akki’s look in the movie reppealing.

Blue:

Here I totally admit that it had a poor script to start with. But, this kind of adventure based movies mostly work for their level of thrills coming across the journey as we have seen in numerous hollywood movies. Although the cinematography was praiseworthy, the much touted underwater action scenes in Blue were limited to just couple of small sequences without any convincing thrills. In fact, a bike chase scene from the movie has higher recall value than it’s underwater sequences.

Joker:

Akki signed this when this was supposed to be a light-hearted science fiction made in real 3d (First time in India). However, what happened is known to everyone. Even before the release of Jokar, it was apparent that Akki was not happy with this movie.  He was promised something else and felt unhappy with the way Shirish handled Joker. So,, no more arguments for this case..

 

Comments

  1. ank_16n

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 1 Thumb down 1

    Superb article……..

    wud still maintain……Tasveer was a good movie……

    Enjoyed CC2C…….it wud have been a success at boxoffice……
    if Some action scenes wud have been there in First half as the movie was perceived as an Action Comedy before its Release…….

    and BTW his ….osm….Script sense includes the likes of—–

    Bhool-Bulaiya

    Singh is King —who thought of making a movie on Singh being a king….

    Namestey London

    Hera Pheri—a classic comedy when comedies were seen as poor cinema

    Ankhein ——Blind people looting a bank in daylight

    AitraaaZ——never seen plot and Story in Bollywood

  2. Like or Dislike: Thumb up 2 Thumb down 0

    Thanks Ank,

    I also enjoyed Tasveer, Action Replay and even majority of CC2C.
    IMO, De Dana Dan was one of the best comedy of recent times.

  3. Like or Dislike: Thumb up 3 Thumb down 0

    @mkt .. when the script is played around during the making u get CC2C …

    CC2C was intense axn movie with slight dose of humour here and there but the script was played around during the making ..

    ……………………………………………………………………………………………

    8X10 tasveer had an alternate climax or second half … akshay asked to use that .. the second half of movie was escapiset – typical bollywoowd thing however .. the cliimax which was shot and which akshay wanted to use was different ..

    same happened for HF .. he wasnt happy with the climax..

    IAM HAPPY HE DIDNT EVEN SPOKE ABT JOKER IN MEDIA..
    THE PROBLEM IS HE DOESNT THRWO HIS WEIGHT LIKE OTHER SUPERSTARS .. HE SUGGEST BUT DOESNT PUT HIS FOOT DOWN .. I HOPE HE START PUTTING HIS FOOT DOWN UNTILL HE GETS AGOOD PRODUCT

    ………………………………………………………………………………………….

    Axn replayy has subtle comedy i havents een any subtle comedy working big time .. they gross small and liked by a sectioon tjough i wd say Axb replayy wasnt a great script ..

    Blue disastrous script .. Anthony Dsouza was fool with 2-3 good twists he wd have got a great start to career but he cared only abt how movie looks not how the story is told and what is being told

    …………………………………………………………………………………………

    DDD was nt at all required why do such movies where u part of ensemble cast and remain away from the movies for 30 minutes all of sudden …

  4. iitianWay

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 1 Thumb down 0

    by remaining silent on joker he has sent his message very loud and clear ..no more chutiyapa…(from anyone) …anymore.

  5. kumar786

    Like or Dislike: Thumb up 1 Thumb down 1

    no doubt on akshay’s acting.he is perfect actor.
    cc2c,8/10,action reply,tmk, were flop bcz of bad direction

  6. Like or Dislike: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0

    Agree on Aankhen being a great script. It was a fabulous movie and deserved to be a much bigger hit! Even Aitraaz was a very good script, although liberally borrowed from Disclosure. Same case with Ajnabee (Consenting Adults). Khakee was another one with a fantastic script, executed brilliantly, which deserved a lot more success. Amongst recent movies, Rowdy Rathore, in spite of being a masala movie, had a very engaging script – constantly moving storyline and full of entertainment. However, I have to disagree with some examples mentioned here – Action Replayy was a great concept on paper, but had a very very dull script, which led to a boring movie. Its one thing being subtle, and another mouthing inanity with a straight face hoping someone in the audience will crack up. Blue – the less said, the better. Both Housefulls hardly had any script as such – they were a series of gags, which worked with a majority of the audience. Same case with Garam Masala and De Dana Dann and all similar films. Heyy Babyy had a better script which faltered in the second half. I would hardly call Singh Is Kingg, Welcome, Desi Boyz, Tashan as good scripts. Akki has a lot of strengths – comedy, raw action, dance and at times great dialogue delivery. Impeccable script sense is hardly one of them though. Unfortunate, because that one missing piece is what differentiates him from someone like Ajay Devgan. Devgan himself has been consciously moving away from good scripts lately though. No more Gangajals and Apaharans from him, looks like :(

Submit a Comment

Read previous post:
Barfi! Has Strong Start At Multiplexes: BoxofficeIndia

Barfi! Has Strong Start At Multiplexes  Friday 14th September 2012 11.30 IST Boxofficeindia.Com Trade Network   Barfi had a strong start at...Read More

Close

Coach Outlet

rippln

stream website

UK Payday Loans

sitebildz

gay social networking