Why did you do this to Aamir, Sanjay… Mr Chopra?

Dear Mr Chopra,

Hope “Allz well” with you… Just thought of writing to you to tell you what I feel about your films ‘Munnabhai’ and ‘3 Idiots’. I have been a huge fan of all your films, for they are driven by quality content and a fine star cast. Out of all your films, the Munnabhai series and ‘3 Idiots’ are my favourites. Let me thank you for giving us these films that have less of glam quotient and talk more of morality and righteousness.

However, I do have something to complain about. I am sorry to say but I did not appreciate your statement about how keen you were to approach Shah Rukh Khan to play Munnabhai and Rancchod Das Chhancchad and even for ‘Ferrari Ki Sawari’ that now has Sharman Joshi playing the lead role. This straight-faced confession of yours in public has deeply hurt me… and I am sure fans of Munnabhai and Aamir would be equally depressed to have heard this from you.

You know what, I am glad Shah Rukh was unavailable every time you approached him for these films… for whatever reasons. No one else can portray the flamboyant and effervescent Munnabhai but Sanjay Dutt. Look how beautifully he has given life to the character that instantly struck an emotional chord with followers of the Munnabhai franchise. And Aamir in ‘3 Idiots’ was “perfect” as Rancchod Das Chhanchhad aka Phunsuk Wangdu. He looked literally like a college going kid with every action of his reminding us of how we behaved in our teens – his body language, his screen presence and the way he exhibited the character.

Every time I see Sanju Baba as Munnabhai, I feel there’s really someone called ‘Munnabhai’ around. He has done complete justice to the character and has left no stone unturned to transform himself into the lovable Munnabhai. Same is the case with Aamir in ‘3 Idiots’. As we all know he is a hardcore perfectionist and has done all possible things to look convincing as a brilliant student who is quite childlike and is a thorough prankster.

I really wonder how could you say, “Shah Rukh was offered `3 Idiots`, `Ferrari Ki Sawari`, `Munnabhai` and other films. He is our first guy – we go to him first and if he says no, then we move on.” Does that mean you would approach someone else ONLY if Shah Rukh was unavailable? Agreed producers and filmmakers have certain reservations and choices but that certainly doesn’t mean you would blatantly speak about your preferences that might end up hurting people. And that’s like undermining the worth of actors who finally worked in your films.

Yes, I do know for a fact that Aamir and Sanjay must have really liked your scripts hence they decided to team up with you…but I am sure they wouldn’t ever like to play second fiddle to someone. So what if Sharman Joshi is not as big a star as Shah Rukh, he is undoubtedly a fine actor. I am sure he has done a great job in ‘Ferrari Ki Sawari’.

Having studied films in college, I do know what goes on in the mind of a director-producer like you and I have a lot of respect for the seat you occupy. But please refrain from making such statements for you never know you might end up not finding the best actor for your films in future.

I am sorry if I am being blunt, but this is how you sounded while saying, “He (SRK) is our first guy – we go to him first and if he says no, then we move on.”

But I am glad you said, “Today, I feel Sanjay is perfect as Munna and same way Sharman fits the central role in `Ferrari Ki Sawari`.” You reportedly are also keen on casting Aamir and Vidya Balan in a film. I hope this time around Aamir was your first choice!

But what is the point in clarifying now Mr. Chopra? Stop mincing words and put it straight – you couldn’t have found a better Munnabhai in the form of Sanjay Dutt, Rancho in Aamir Khan and Rustam in Sharman.

Trust me, I have nothing personal against you or Shah Rukh Khan but I thought of venting my angst so that sincere feelings of mine and many others could reach you through this piece.

(Disclaimer: I ain’t an enemy of Shah Rukh Khan. He is a brilliant actor and someone I adore. So please, fans of Shah Rukh Khan do not slam me for not favouring him in this case, though I know I am bound to face severe criticism from all of you for writing this.)

http://zeenews.india.com/blog/70/blog751.html

9 Comments

  1. Suraj
    Suraj
    April 8, 2012 at 3:25 AM

    LOL! I think this writer mistook VVC’s statements! :D
    The way I see it, VVC is a man who gives importance ONLY to himself and not to any Khan, Kapoor or Bachchan! His comment seemed like he was trying to show SRK what he had lost by rejecting his offers! It was certainly not a genuine compliment from him to SRK, to show that he was too keen to work with him.
    Anyone who watches or reads VVC’s interviews can judge he’s pompous and makes it look as if he did some great thing by discovering Raju Hirani and as if he made Sharman or Aamir or revived Sanjay Dutt’s career!
    I remember cringing at his bits in the making of 3 Idiots book too! He sounded like Raju and Abhijat couldn’t have made the film without his crucial support and contributions!
    It’s one thing to speak about your contribution, but it’s different when you’re bragging!
    I still remember those Eklavya interviews where he said to Big B that this was his best performance ever. But when Big B said he felt he could have done better, VVC said that’s bullshit! Kept insisting only he extracted the best from Big B!
    If SRK is indeed his first choice always, then why only Aamir was considered for Raju Hirani’s next? And why did he express he wanted Aamir and Hrithik with Vidya in a film? Even for FKS he first talked to Aamir, then talked to SRK, later conducted a public poll in which Aamir & Sharman won – so he went ahead with Sharman then.
    He just wants to show off his successes, show off what others are losing or gaining by not working or working with him! He cares neither about Vidya, Aamir, Sharman or Sanjay nor SRK! And if you read any of the books on making of 3I or Munnabhai films, you’ll find him boasting about how he found and groomed Raju Hirani jaise johri ne heere ki parakh kar li! Ha!

  2. Talaash
    Talaash
    April 8, 2012 at 9:44 AM

    I don’t understand hw can a guy even get upset on such silly things :P

  3. Sanjeev
    Sanjeev
    April 8, 2012 at 1:51 PM

    Chillax mate.., this happens to about 40 percent of the movies… besides you can take it in any way you want depending on who you are:

    Srk fan: wow srk was offered these good movies.. He must be a hellaf a good actor

    Srk hater: hahaha srk must be feeling bad for not doing these movies…

    Neutral: I don’t give a shit about this

  4. Dan
    Dan
    April 8, 2012 at 2:06 PM

    This guy is megalomaniac Just like SRK. All he acre is bragging about himself. I remember when Lagaan Got nominated for oscars, he got interviewed by some news channel, and he was so aghast about the fame Aamir got at that time, and start te te about his short film got nominated for the same. He was wondering why such fame for Aamir, not me. He should be thankful to Raju , Sanju, And aamir, that this decade will remember him as most successful producer, otherwise Kareeb, Mission Kashmir, And Eklavya left no place for him to left directorial aspirations. Though he is a commendable Director, but lacks commercial streak.

  5. TanqeedNigaar
    TanqeedNigaar
    April 8, 2012 at 2:08 PM

    the main part who make these film best is hirani, he is the best director, sanjay and aamir do their part but i say it was hirani all the way,
    but why hirani works only with vvc,

  6. Suraj
    Suraj
    April 8, 2012 at 7:17 PM

    @TanqeedNigaar

    It would have been Hirani all the way, no matter which actor did those films (not just Sanju or Aamir). :D
    Still, one can’t deny their due to actors like Sanju, Arshad, Boman, Aamir, Madhavan, Sharman, Omi etc., for doing complete justice to Raju’s vision.

    Hirani only works with VVC out of sheer loyalty. VVC was the one who encouraged him to become a director and write scripts, and he gave him work. So he sticks to his banner purely out of sense of friendship and loyalty. They say he’s been offered mindboggling sum of money to step out of Vinod Chopra Films and make films for other banners, but he simply refuses them, no matter how lucrative offers he gets!
    He’s said to be a very loyal, simple and sincere man and always maintains he’s satisfied and happy working with VVC, makes a great team with him.

  7. superman
    superman
    April 8, 2012 at 7:41 PM

    to be honest i dont think munnabhai or hirani could have become what they did without sanju. Munnabhai would never have been the movie it turned out to be had sanju not played the title role. It was after the munnabhai films hirani became a force and i dont think he could have become such a force had sanjay dutt not been cast as munnabhai. 3 idiots wasn’t all that special to me nowhere near to as good as the munnabhai movies and 3idiots could have been a hit without amiar it wasnt all that a challenging role but munnabhai is hard to imagine without dutt

  8. Suraj
    Suraj
    April 8, 2012 at 8:57 PM

    @superman

    Ha! Yeah. Another guy who still has problems with 3I and its impact!
    Trash films of other stars are great or challenging while 3I could have been hit even without Aamir! Keep saying whatever you want to. A useless actor or a guy who comes with baggage of his own image and contrived mannerisms would have ruined Rancho! But Aamir breathed life to Rancho without ruining the essence of the film in trying to make it a ”star vehicle” for him.

    Anyway, here is VVC’s quote on Aamir in 3 Idiots from the book, ”I’ll Do it My Way” on Aamir Khan’s films: ”All I can say is that we were very fortunate to have him. I don’t think anybody else could do what he has done to the film.”

    He and Raju Hirani also described how Aamir led the team of actors and stood like a rock-solid support for Raju, Abhijat and VVC. Raju Hirani.

    And do you think Aamir merely happened to accept a ready-made good script? :D

    No boss! Read the book on making of 3 Idiots. Aamir clearly mentioned in his interview that his first reaction to the script was of disappointment. It did not work for him and he openly told Raju that he would have to opt out of the film if the script was this way only. He felt the script had potential but was not in place yet. He discussed his issues with the script with Raju and Raju agreed to a lot of his points. Raju then came back to him two months later with the improvised script and this time Aamir agreed to do the film.

    In fact, there are several much admired scenes in 3 Idiots, which were added through inputs from not just Aamir, but also Madhavan and Kareena.

    It is very easy for a hater or commentator to say that any actor could have done the film and made it a hit. Sorry. Not all actors can gel well with their team or make improvements for the betterment of the film as a whole.

    And finally, it is reported that SRK was first choice for 3 Idiots. No. The first actor with whom this film was discussed was Saif Ali Khan. VVC and Raju discussed doing this film with him during the making of Eklavya. Later on they went to other actors as the film’s idea developed further.

    Other actors perhaps only add item numbers to make their film good, but Aamir has the expertise to work with the filmmakers on how to improvise the film. The making of 3 Idiots book clearly mentions how all actors and team of the film worked together, incorporated each other’s valid suggestions to come up with the final product.

    Detractors can say what they want to say, 3 Idiots is an epic success and Rancho has made impact on minds of audience all over the world. No one else can be imagined in role of Rancho now (except for fanatics of other stars who diss this film but secretly wish why their favorite actor wasn’t cast or didn’t do this film!).

    Aal izz well! :D

  9. Serenzy
    Serenzy
    April 9, 2012 at 1:30 AM

    @suraj

    ur last two para’s were Knock Outs.

Page 1 of 1

Post Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

zovirax buy usa celebrex 50 mg capsule buy celebrex discount zoloft de 50 mg propecia viagra online levitra onlines clomid 50mg chances buy clomid uk order doxycycline generic contraindicaciones levitra 20 mg nolvadex 20 mg fiyati taking 2mg propecia indian viagra 100mg propecia x generico strattera 25 mg intuniv propranolol clorhidrato 10 mg clomid 50mg ingredients generic propranolol er synthroid 100mg strattera online bestellen generic nexium india generic chinese cialis order propecia men viagra 125 mg synthroid dosage mg buy propecia proscar metformin axcount 1000 mg lexapro available generic generic synthroid effective doxycycline 500mg prices buy strattera eu generic wellbutrin 100mg celebrex 100mg research cialis 50mg dosage generic xenical online buy nexium 20mg zoloft 100mg cost price cialis 25 mg generic viagra wirkung zovirax pastiglie 400 mg zoloft generic walmart condom viagra online viagra drops online celebrex 200 mg werking online glucophage generic chinese viagra prednisone 20 mg interactions cialis prescription buy cialis 20 mg lilly synthroid tab 0.05mg xenical buy xenical buy professional viagra xenical reviews 120mg levitra 20 mg prices buy doxycycline nz cialis 10 mg euro thuoc lisinopril 10mg nexium generic buy generic priligy 60 mg buy viagra vardenafil viagra order china cialis paypal cheap viagra fake online levitra generic cost buy levitra 10mg zovirax 800 mg price buying viagra brazil cialis 10 mg b4 propecia prices 5mg cialis uk order order lexapro generic cialis generica 40mg generic wellbutrin problems cheap genuine propecia buying authentic cialis glipizide metformin 5 500 mg buying clomid tablets ervaringen clomid 50mg phenergan 50 mg iv generic viagra bulk prednisone 50 mg daily metformin 500 mg hexal generic viagra real 60 mg prednisone cialis 20mg espanol metformin stada 850 mg diflucan 150 mg uomo bactrim mg uti chinese viagra 4000mg augmentin 1000 mg fiyat 2012 generic viagra questions buy nexium 40 mg generic valtrex tablets propranolol 40 mg wiki cialis online venezuela viagra online recept synthroid generic available paypal propecia cheap cheapest zovirax pump priligy en generico 50 mg zoloft reviews viagra zakup online cheap levitra prescriptions cialis 20mg slovensky nolvadex 25mg buy zoloft generic levitra 10 mg rezeptfrei cialis 20 mg yorum glucophage 1000 mg muadili mg propranolol xenical 120 mg leaflet cialis online mexico generic viagra jel online cialis diagnosis zovirax ointment mg 200 mg viagra dose order generic strattera cialis 2 5mg bula buy prednisone us amoxil 500 mg pregnant prednisone 50 mg uses propecia compare buy viagra buy aberdeen generic lisinopril 40 mg strattera generic dose cialis 20 mg generic is strattera generic cialis 20mg uzivanie erythromycin 200 mg 5 ml viagra online tn you buy viagra buspar 5 mg erowid viagra online canadian cheap cialis 80 mg potenzmittel levitra 10 mg 250 mg zoloft ocd cipro 500 mg walgreens viagra order europe levitra 20mg 30 diflucan suspension generic lasix 20 mg reviews buy strattera generic bfp clomid 100mg levitra online uk viagra oil buy 50mg viagra effect cialis deals online cialis online contrassegno generic strattera usa issues generic lexapro 25 mg phenergan iv farmaco wellbutrin 150 mg cipro 250 mg pille generic propecia sweden cheapest valtrex mg of augmentin Online Generic Levitra viagra feminino online cheap nonprescription xenical 120 mg lisinopril overdosr doxycycline 100mg abortion doxycycline vibramycin 100mg buy dapoxetine eu doxycycline online pet 50 mg prednisone burst buy lexapro 20 mg erythromycin 125 mg 5 ml zoloft overdose mg lasix 80 mg dosage viagra 25 mg dose online pharmacy lasix viagra 100 mg reviews diflucan 150mg buy nolvadex generic pct cialis generic chinatown doxycycline 110 mg tablets cialis generic supplements safe clomid online lexapro generic us bula viagra 50mg cialis generico.pt controindicazioni cialis 20 mg capsulas celebrex 200 mg generic augmentin antibiotic kamagra cheap supplies xenical orlistat online nexium ec 20mg viagra buy price lexapro tabs 20mg 2 mg of prednisone 10mg lexapro zoloft thailand buy viagra xenical 120 mg capsule augmentin duo 625mg buying cialis calgary generic diflucan tablet 5 mg di cialis viagra online barato kamagra syndinalon 500mg nexium mups 40 mg 90 online cialis singapore amoxil amoxicillin 500 mg buying viagra bulk buy zovirax 5 ointment buy viagra edd bactrim 800 mg online levitra cheap overnight biochem nolvadex 10 mgs 30 mg of lisinopril cialis 5 mg 36 liquid generic viagra buying bactrim online 150 mg lexapro cheapest branded levitra cialis giornaliero generico wellbutrin 450 mg seizures doxycycline 100mg horses viagra cheapest canada taking cialis 40 mg celebrex tiene generico levitra 10mg walgreens usa viagra 3000 mg synthroid de 100mg metformin 500 mg e doxycycline 100 mg msds generic nolvadex pct augmentin 625 mg composition zovirax sirop 5mg cheapest authentic cialis lexapro 20 mg identification generic augmentin costs metformin 500 mg biverkningar lisinopril generic for levitra dosage 30 mg viagra online sweden buy 5 cialis pills generic viagra results order viagra softtabs generic viagra 24h nexium when generic nolvadex forum order cheap cialis from generic to zoloft prednisone 40 mg alcohol prospecto cialis 10 mg adoxa doxycycline 150 mg zestril lisinopril 10 mg viagra 50 mg effetto awp 2.5mg cialis nexium 40mg sac prednisone overdose mg indonesia prednisone 5mg relible generic viagra cialis jelly online buy prednisone philippines viagra 100mg 4st buying tetracycline online viagra comparison online doxycycline online accord generic cialis 60 mg prednisone dosage 60 mg buy priligy lebanon cipro usa order clomid 50 mg bijwerkingen order cialis daily cheap cialis manila levitra srbija online lasix 5 mg online online women viagra buy periactin cheap strattera 200 mg buy diflucan 150 cheap valtrex generic strattera mood disorder strattera study 60mg cheap 150mg viagra clomid fertomid 50 mg cialis 0 5mg viagra tem generico q buy cialis propranolol 10 mg reviews compra buy doxycycline nexium 20 mg 14 tablets medicament xenical 60mg dapoxetine generic priligy brand cialis order buy levitra eu cipro generic fda generic cialis 20x20 prednisone 5mg withdrawal australian generics cialis 20 mg levitra reviews generic levitra good lisinopril smg clomid de 50 mg cialis 20 mg zararlimi tomar levitra 20 mg bactrim 500mg bula clomid 50mg 100mg viagra herbal online zoloft 200mg reviews cipro 500mg generic cialis 20mg asli xenical 120 mg test online propecia nulk esiste cialis 200 mg dapoxetine tablets 30mg generico lexapro 10 mg buy viagra otc notice clomid 50mg cialis 5 mg bijsluiter cheapest viagra 150 propecia 1mg rogaine cialis halbe 20mg cialis 5 mg preis erfahrungsberichte xenical 120 mg nolvadex kup online augmentin 500mg prospect xenical shipping online levitra cheap prices lisinopril 2.5mg tab synthroid 250 mg 100mg sr wellbutrin buy cialis philip propranolol dak 40 mg doxycycline 100 mg injectable cialis generico italia levitra order walgreen viagra online edmonton viagra buy uk zoloft 50mg dejstvo nexium 40mg order 2 pills 10mg cialis prednisone 10 mg facts buspar bipolar disorder purchase generic cialis nolvadex 80 mg viagra 50 mg coupons metformin sale online viagra 30 lu 100mg lexapro 20 mg daily buy kamagra jakarta generic lexapro prescription zoloft 50 mg diarrhea cheap overseas viagra cipro 1mg buy tetracycline antibiotics augmentin prospect 125 mg buy clomid supplement cialis 20 mg 2 li australia cheap cialis mylan lisinopril 2.5 mg 20 mg of prednisone generic cialis 50 levitra 10 mg preis viagra de 500mg 20 mg propranolol cialis 2.5mg prices 6generic propecia xenical 120 mg upotreba buying propecia singapore viagra 100mg good metformin 1000 mg pcos valtrex generic wikipedia cytotec online forum ed viagra online buy cheap cialis lasix 20 mg tablet kegunaan lasix 20 mg synthroid and generic prednisone 50 mg apo nexium sachet 5 mg nolvadex 20 mg forum buy glucophage online diflucan 150 mg cpr cialis online international diflucan 150 mg tratamiento augmentin 875 mg uti cheapest viagra worldwide generic to nexium order viagra cialis online cialis consultation 100 mg nolvadex Levitra 90 pills order generic viagra ert 100 800mg generic viagra augmentin 375 mg pregnancy cialis malaysia 200mg buying valtrex cheap kamagra 100 mg upustvo took 100mg levitra lisinopril 30 mg tab erythromycin 250 mg suspension cheap propranolol online cialis 5mg singapore doxycycline online buy nexium cheap cialis super 20mg tetracycline 125 mg buy doxycycline 25mg lexapro 20 mg info cheap viagra alternatives celebrex 200mg erfahrungen cialis online versand online levitra sales viagra online purchases buy viagra 200mg bayer levitra 20mg generic viagra march 2012 acheter nexium 40 mg glucophage for cheap metformin 1000 mg pill cipro 500mg high lexapro breathing disorders generic nexium medication 10 to 15 mgs lexapro cipralex 20 mg citalopram lexapro generic effects 10mg lexapro price nolvadex online prescription levitra odt 10 mg buy 100 mg clomid viagra 25mg uk celebrex celecoxib generic buy metformin 1000 mg doxycycline 150 mg identification prednisone 20 mg ivf buy periactin cyproheptadine erythromycin 250mg tabs nolvadex dosage 5mg kamagra 100 mg tablets celebrex 200 mg indikasi buy cialis originale clomid 50mg homme cialis 5 vs 10mg farmacie online priligy cialis 100 mg kullananlar xenical 120mg agora clomid 50mg endometriosis propranolol 160mg levitra 100 mg cheapest 2.5 mg cialis propecia buy italy effetti viagra 100mg metformin 500mg 93 48 viagra genericos medicine lasix 40 mg dapoxetine 30mg cialis rx 20 mg lexapro 12.5 mg 15mgs of cialis infographics generic viagra celebrex 100mg caps buy bactrim antibiotic viagra online goedkoop viagra 50 mg halbieren lisinopril genericon 20 mg zithromax 250 mg cpr6 augmentin 625mg pret buy celebrex usa generic to celebrex discount online propecia precio levitra 10 mg buy paypal viagra phenergan 50 mg tablets 10mg lexapro prescription buy nolvadex generic generic viagra dominican viagra 50mg buy wellbutrin xl 150mg synthroid generics cialis 5mg 28 lisinopril 15 mg buy cytotec uae buy bactrim forte viagra 25 mg wirkungsdauer levitra 10 mg tablets generic levitra.de viagra generico brasileiro doxycycline 100 mg dosage buy viagra shanghai propecia online europa nexium 40 mg coupons xenical orlistate 200mg results 0,25mg propecia tijuana generic cialis generico nexium 40mg cialis 5 mgm tabs tusgenericos viagra cialis 20 mg 4 tb 500mg valtrex daily viagra 100mg deals thuoc clomid 10mg lisinopril 20 12.5 mg diabetes viagra buy kiev propranolol buy online levitra not workimg erythromycin 5oomg cyproheptadine periactin 4mg online viagra fast