Garam Hawa and 1947 Earth: Mirrors kept on the two sides of pain

In Garam Hawa, the train starts from Delhi and goes to Lahore. In 1947 Earth, the train starts from Lahore and goes to Delhi…

Macro. Micro. Two views of the same world. And within each view, multiple perspectives. And within each perspectives, multiple possibilities with multiple outcomes. The world we live in is utterly complex, and yet the basic human emotions and needs are as simple as they come. The need for acceptance, the need for association, but above all the need to live and breathe in a safe environment that gives them the freedom to live their life the way they want to. Human rights and legislative rights given to citizens of any country wish to fulfill the same aforesaid needs and ensure that each and every human being is in full control of his own story. Story? Yes story. For somebody’s reality is someone else’s fiction. So essentially we live in a world full of interlinked stories that cross path more often than once. And while we are too busy taking care of our own lives, there are people who are doing their indirectly meddling in our affairs. The lawmakers, the leaders, the politicians, the influencers, the media. It has been the same since the start of time. As human beings evolved from being solo food gatherers to creatures who hunted in groups, there were always certain few who emerged more powerful and more influential than others. Gradually they started moving slightly away from the rest of the pack, until they became truly absolute. Since then, the decisions are made by some and accepted by the others. On face value. Yes, there have been revolts. Every now and then the masses have ignited and tried to take the reins of their destiny in their own hands. Some of these revolts have been stifled. A tiny few have succeeded. But even the ones that succeeded have done nothing but create a new set of leaders with new order, new regime, new procedures, but more or less the same results.

Take a look at Mahabharata. Two sets of cousins- the most powerful ones in Jambudvipa (As India was called then), fought for a piece of land. But they were not the only ones who fought and won and lost. With them fought eleven other great kings of India. And with them fought their seventeen different armies. And within each army fought a thousand soldiers. All for what? For deciding who will assume the sole ownership of Hastinapur. Or, to give it a higher purpose as many do- for dharma. Whose dharma? Now when we look back and read the great epic we get lost in the story of revenge and the motivations, learnings, and actions of the Pandavas aided by the God himself- Krishna. But who talks about the innumerable faces that fought the battle? Didn’t all of them have a story of their own? Yes, they did.

Fast forward to 1947. Was it any different from Mahabharata? Yes of course there are many distinctions that can be made; but in essence it was a war declared at the top and fought by the masses. In the process causing nothing but loss. For most, the loss was beyond the tangible. It was beyond the loss of property and life of loved ones. It was nothing less than a complete loss of identity. The human in every human being was replaced by a label- the label of religion. And this label was indicated by the names they carried. So countless people had no option but to change their names. To change their entire identity. To give a new meaning to their meaningless existence. And to serve what purpose? To honor the decision made for them at the top by the leaders. But did they have the option? No. Could they have had the option? No they couldn’t have…

Law and order cannot be enforced without having a stable leadership taking charge of the society. And in the failure of the leadership in 1947, this fact emerged most glaringly. Human beings are no different from the animals of the jungle. In the Jungle there is no leadership- the larger fish eats the smaller one. It is survival of the fittest. Post the 1947 decision to divide India, the most anguished ones became the fittest. Law and order went for a toss. The world became a jungle. There were killings all around. The bestiality in some of the acts was basic, yet almost creative. A man was killed by just ripping him apart. Ripping him apart? The phrase got its literal celebration. The women were raped and molested in the most brutal ways possible. Humanity was reveling in its newfound freedom. The freedom to express, the freedom to revenge. Who ignited the flames? God knows (If there is God, that is).

Deepa Mehta’s 1947 Earth, and MS Sathyu & Kaifi Azmi’s Garam Hawa are two Hindi films that are based on incidents preceding and succeeding the horrific partition of India. Both the movies take a completely different view of the situation. In some ways, both the movies are like mirror images of one another. And both the movies have a narrative that can be viewed in two perspectives. Macro and micro. There was the larger picture that was common to all. But there were millions of people whose life got affected in a million different ways. While Garam Hawa tells the story of a rich capitalist Muslim trying not to leave India for Pakistan post the partition, 1947 Earth looks at the picture from the other side- how Sikhs and Hindus had to leave Pakistan for India post the partition abandoning their homes, their hopes, and their lives. While Garam Hawa is starts from six months after August 1947, 1947 Earth begins six months before that date. While Garam Hawa talks about a family, 1947 Earth talks about a family to be. While Garam Hawa is a story of resignation to fate, 1947 Earth is the story of taking charge of fate- even if it is in the most horrific manner possible. And while Garam Hawa ends on an optimistic note, 1947 Earth ends in the cruelest way possible.

In Garam Hawa, the train starts from Delhi and goes to Lahore. In 1947, the train starts from Lahore and goes to Delhi…

Both are extremely disturbing to see, and yet are a must watch for every Indian my age. They should not be seen as movies. They are like honest recounting of the tales that are our very own. We can never experience what our forefathers did. And we should thank God for that (If there is God, that is). But we deserve to know on what foundation our country stands today. The greatest of structures need the most solid foundations to become great. But for us the challenge lies in making a great nation on a foundation that is full of cracks and that got corroded by blood. The Blood of our own forefathers. The blood that was the result of pain. Pain that was (or rather is) is both figurative and literal. Pain that has been looked at by these two honest artistic efforts like mirrors kept on both sides.

Truly Yours

Piyush Dewan


  1. suprabh
    April 15, 2012 at 8:38 PM

    Garam Hawa– I remember this movie for its simplicity more than anything else. It dealt with such a volatile topic of communal feelings and partition in such a subtle manner. Balraj Sahni gave an amazing performance and it was amazing because one could really believe and feel for his character in the film. What all was going through his head– A dying business, A breaking family, an ailing mother, An unmarried daughter, A country about to explode. You could see the tension on his face. A very relevant movie in those times.

Page 1 of 1

Post Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

cipro 500 mg costo viagra 100 mg strattera generic 2011 lexapro 5 mg price cheap cialis prices cialis 20 mg costo all generic viagra buy generic bactrim glucophage 5 mg lexapro 5 mg weight diflucan generic version viagra 500mg online find cheap cialis costco valtrex generic doxycycline 400 mg overdose cialis 20 mg malaysia viagra 30 mg rischi viagra online levitra generico forum 40mg levitra danger levitra dosage mg priligy generico prezzo lexapro l0 mg metformin stada 850 mg thuoc clomid 10mg buy priligy 30mg nexium 40mg order amoxil 500mg wiki australian generics cialis cialis purchase online 20 mg prednisone dosage change generic wellbutrin buy cipro 500 prednisone 20mg cures lexapro sold generic cipro 500mg generico lisinopril 2.5 mg generic 30 mg of propranolol 500 mg doxycycline effects lexapro 5 mg shaky clomid 100mg kopen viagra zakup online cialis 5mg 36 viagra online asap 50mg viagra effect generic cialis 20x20 cialis 100 mg lilly lexapro 0 mg generic viagra efeectivness zithromax pfizer 250 mg propecia buy online cheap kamagra tablets wellbutrin 100 mg tablet viagra buy lausanne thuoc cialis 10mg buy nexium 40 mg online viagra jual lexapro generic 20 mg zovirax online buy buy dapoxetine thailand fish cipro 500mg buy viagra portugal cialis 500mg viagra online rpg cialis preise 10mg bijwerkingen kamagra 100mg cheapest generic zoloft amoxil 500 mg alcool celebrex 50 mg image generic synthroid pills xenical uk cheapest 10 mg prednisone tablets order Cialis 10 Tabs generico de diflucan propranolol 10 mg pl xenical 120mg agora levitra 20 mg endikasyonlari cialis buy 5mg strattera 18 mg capsules doxycycline 110 mg lexapro generic 10 mg 25 mg viagra etkisi online viagra vipps zithromax 1000mg online buy some viagra viagra online japao cialis 20 mg 36 hours prednisone 20mg 5443 buy lab nolvadex kamagra 100mg frau zovirax 200mg cialis 5mg 2 pills viagra 200mg pfizer cialis 5 mg argentina doxycycline 150 mg used mims online celebrex doxycycline 100mg gum buy diflucan cvs erythromycin ointment 5 mg cialis cheap 40 mg. cheapest kamagra ever cialis 2.5mg prices cheap viagra europ lexapro generic espanol buy sale viagra diflucan online ordering propecia 5 mg buy viagra 200mg viagra online recept diflucan fluconazole cheap cialis india online clomid buy pakistan nolvadex 20mg comprar strattera 60mg zovirax costs 15 mg phenergan uk buy lexapro online reviews cialis 80 mg wiki doxycycline online cheap online 5 mg levitra 20 mg of prednisone buy zithromax ngu xenical 200mg propecia acquisto online synthroid generic dosage viagra generic medicine buy celebrex online xenical cheapest price glucophage 500 mg xr celebrex 4oomg nexium 20 mg esomeprazole viagra 25 mg forum erythromycin 250 mg tab lexapro 10mg withdrawal bula viagra 50mg cialis 5 mg double 200mg of viagra clomid 50mg 100mg take levitra 40mg 2.5 mg viagra buy 1 day zithromax cialis fc 10 mg 25mg clomid online zithromax 50mg feline australian viagra online generic synthroid online buy cialis 50 mg bactrim generic equivalent real cheap viagra nexium 40 mg dosering generic strattera cost doxycycline 100mg prostatitis vanzare viagra online viagra generico guatemala buy levitra eu phenergan 10mg sleep prednisone online ordering cialis online norge cheap cialis 40 doxycycline 100 mg 500 tablets doxycycline 100mg medicine zoloft generic cvs cheapest cialis 10 mg kamagra 100mg bijsluiter cialis online worldwide riva metformin 500 mg generic cialis site viagra generico vendas cialis 20mg composition buying diflucan overnight cialis 5 mgm tabs canadian viagra online generic cipro generic 10 mg cialis clomid 50mg endometriosis cialis 5 mg dawkowanie tomo 5 mg lexapro zithromax 500 mg 6 days buy generic nexium thuoc bactrim 480mg buy 150 mg. viagra diflucan iv 2 mg azithromycin order doxycycline generic zoloft online generic viagra health viagra 25 mg erfahrungsberichte levitra generic name erythromycin 500mg gmp ordinare cialis generico generic valtrex walmart online female viagra generic cialis name cialis online dubai presentacion cialis 10 mg is viagra generic valtrex 500 mg prescriptions clomid 150 mg success cialis 20mg au chinese cialis 50 mg dosaggio levitra 5 mg nexium iv 40 mg levitra online cheaps strattera 60 mg generic viagra order levitra buy cod generic levitra there strattera generic approval free viagra online cialis 10 mg billig 20mg lexapro effexor order cialis holland celebrex 200 mg malaysia cheapest regalis viagra levitra 20mg cena viagra 100mg 32 tablets cialis 30 100 mg nexium online reviews clomid thyroid disorders viagra generico pericoloso lisinopril 5mg beipackzettel zoloft o generico cvs cialis 20 mg asda buy viagra generic nexium 20 mg levitra 20mg canadian priligy 30 mg price wellbutrin 100 mgs hay celebrex generico herbal viagra 6800 mg taking 450 mg wellbutrin lasix 25 mg fiale diflucan 150 mg cena celebrex 200mg nebenwirkungen biochem nolvadex 10 mgs cialis 5 mg consigli propranolol 20 mg prix clomid 50mg cialis 2mg price hydrochlorothiazide 12.5 mg mylan 810 buy super kamagra super viagra online viagra 100mg swiss wellbutrin xl 150mg levitra not workimg zovirax sirop 5mg lisinopril 20 mg normon 150 mg zoloft dose thuoc augmentin 625mg synthroid 20 mg lasix 20 mg tablet generic viagra dosage levitra generico 40 mg clomid online pharmacy lexapro 10 mg propecia 1 mg generic generic lexapro 20 mg 5mg lexapro works nolvadex pills online generico cialis ultrafarma 25 or 50 mg viagra zithromax 500 mg nebenwirkungen metformin 500 mg tb cialis 3800mgx 10 pills viagra generic 25 mg nexium 200mg achat cialis 20 mg xenical 120 mg tablets cipro 750 mg dosage strattera and generic online viagra gel lasix 25 mg posologia 10 mg viagra work online chewable viagra doxycycline 500mg prices buy viagra fedex cheapest cialis pills cialis schweiz online nexium 40 mg tabletta cialis generic image nexium 80 mg dia purchase propecia generic viagra gold 300mg viagra online beratung alli orlistat 60mg buy 10 lasix pills cialis tablets 10 mg clomid 100mg tweeling cheap generic clomid buying generic cialis viagra acquista online medical viagra online cialis prescription buy lisinopril genericon 20 mg propecia 1mg discount bactrim forte 800 160 mg buy propecia proscar 30 mg lexapro ocd levitra 20 generic metformin 500 mg hydrochloride lasix tabs 40mg cialis 20 mg nedir generic to zoloft generic wellbutrin drug buy celebrex 400 mg wellbutrin 75 mg dose cialis online venezuela clomid generic drug cialis generic fake 2 pills 10mg cialis augmentin 1000 mg fiyat 2012 generic lexapro issues 10 mg lexapro pregnancy walmart generic cialis strattera 10 mg nebenwirkungen buy augmentin tablets lexapro 20 mg info kamagra online collection lasix 40 mg directions generic propecia availability pattaya buy cialis 1 mg viagra propranolol bipolar disorder order viagra legally prednisone 5mg withdrawal cheapest propecia prices kamagra 100 mg sachet regime xenical 120 mg augmentin 625 mgs cipro xr 5oomg nexium generic kegunaan erythromycin 1000 mg cialis 10 mg prospecto nexium 80 mg overdose canadian generic nexium glucophage for cheap buy clomid proviron viagra 100 online cipro 500 mg medication zovirax generic buy zovirax 800 mg cena buy celebrex usa kamagra 100mg tabletten 100mg sr wellbutrin bactrim genericos viagra online zoll levitra brand 20mg stopping lisinopril 40mg cialis 5 mg comentarios augmentin 500mg goi antidepresivo lexapro 10 mg buy doxycycline 40 200mg diflucan dosage 100 mg china buy cialis zithromax 1000 mg dose thuoc glucophage 50 mg generic viagra wok hmgr metformin viagra buy kiev cialis generico 2.5 buying cheap cialis phenergan 25mg online zithromax 500mg alcohol zithromax 200 mg tablets buying viagra vegas metformin hcl 50 mg is cialis generic order 150 mg viagra 100mg kamagra reviews viagra online uae celecoxib 200mg celebrex viagra 4 cpr 50 mg diflucan 150 mg oral 10mg lexapro price alli order xenical levitra 10 mg. sublinguale cheap authenic viagra lexapro 15 mg anxiety buy viagra nsw cytotec generico 10 mg lexapro enough order buspar online prednisone 5 mg tapering lexapro 5mg success cialis od 2050 mg purchase propecia online generic viagra mygra viagra buy uk cialis 10 mg nedir lisinopril hctz 40 mg viagra 50 mg satis 300mg zoloft kamagra 100mg erfahrungsberichte there generic zoloft cialis reviews 20 mg cheapest 2.5 mg cialis cheapest cialis 2.5mg diflucan 200 mg costo green generic wellbutrin xenical 120 mg leaflet taking clomid 50mg viagra 50 mg 100 propecia 0.5mg celebrex 200 mg tablets xenical 120 mg capsule augmentin 875 mg tab buy nexium 20 capsule generic zoloft identification online viagra dangers generic levitra 20 canada valtrex 500 mg endikasyonlari viagra rx online order propecia australia vibrox doxycycline 100mg buyin viagra online zithromax generic buy cipla 5mg cialis augmentin zawiesina 250 mg prednisone 40 mg 3 day metformin er 250 mg generic nolvadex pct buy generic lisinopril lexapro 3mg kamagra gold 50mg lasix 40 mg infusion citalopram 10 mg libbs viagra buy generic online propecia nulk strattera uk online diflucan 150 mg dosis 100 mg viagra online buy zoloft medicine lexapro generic problem synthroid buy uk chewable viagra online buy liquid zithromax phenergan promethazine 25 mg cialis took 20mg safest generic cialis generic periactin cyproheptadi cheap legal viagra cialis 5 mg nota 75 levitra 20mg benefits viagra online de lexapro 10 mg walmart lexapro withdrawal 2.5 mg notice clomid 50mg buy kamagra cheap nz generic viagra cialis generic softtabs get viagra generic cheapest online levitra prednisone 20 mg interactions xenical shopping online cheap 150mg viagra prednisone zentiva 20mg buy online wellbutrin cialis 10 mg australia buy levitra onli augmentin duo 500mg cialis 20 mg 10 tablet glucophage 850 mg nedir cheap viagra 50 generic replacement nexium taking 2 20 mg cialis 20 mg di levitra taking 300 mg wellbutrin propranolol sa 160 mg doxycycline 100mg vitamins gebruik cialis 5 mg strattera generic buy prednisone tablet 10 mg metformin 500mg tablets lasix 40 mg presentacion prednisone dosage 50 mg female viagra generic cialis online purchases cialis online versand generic metformin ndoses lisinopril secubar 20 mg par generic wellbutrin buy zoloft 50mg clomid 200 mg twins cheap prednisone online cialis 5 mg 28 cpr lisinopril 15 mg valtrex 50mg levitra generic 20mg zithromax generic 500mg erythromycin 250mg 5ml cialis 30 mg coupons buy doxycycline dosage 300 mg of wellbutrin cialis store online strattera tic disorder propranolol 10mg dawkowanie prednisone 5mg mylan zovirax 500mg erfahrungsberichte viagra 100mg cvs 5mg cialis xenical australia buy