Garam Hawa and 1947 Earth: Mirrors kept on the two sides of pain

In Garam Hawa, the train starts from Delhi and goes to Lahore. In 1947 Earth, the train starts from Lahore and goes to Delhi…

Macro. Micro. Two views of the same world. And within each view, multiple perspectives. And within each perspectives, multiple possibilities with multiple outcomes. The world we live in is utterly complex, and yet the basic human emotions and needs are as simple as they come. The need for acceptance, the need for association, but above all the need to live and breathe in a safe environment that gives them the freedom to live their life the way they want to. Human rights and legislative rights given to citizens of any country wish to fulfill the same aforesaid needs and ensure that each and every human being is in full control of his own story. Story? Yes story. For somebody’s reality is someone else’s fiction. So essentially we live in a world full of interlinked stories that cross path more often than once. And while we are too busy taking care of our own lives, there are people who are doing their indirectly meddling in our affairs. The lawmakers, the leaders, the politicians, the influencers, the media. It has been the same since the start of time. As human beings evolved from being solo food gatherers to creatures who hunted in groups, there were always certain few who emerged more powerful and more influential than others. Gradually they started moving slightly away from the rest of the pack, until they became truly absolute. Since then, the decisions are made by some and accepted by the others. On face value. Yes, there have been revolts. Every now and then the masses have ignited and tried to take the reins of their destiny in their own hands. Some of these revolts have been stifled. A tiny few have succeeded. But even the ones that succeeded have done nothing but create a new set of leaders with new order, new regime, new procedures, but more or less the same results.

Take a look at Mahabharata. Two sets of cousins- the most powerful ones in Jambudvipa (As India was called then), fought for a piece of land. But they were not the only ones who fought and won and lost. With them fought eleven other great kings of India. And with them fought their seventeen different armies. And within each army fought a thousand soldiers. All for what? For deciding who will assume the sole ownership of Hastinapur. Or, to give it a higher purpose as many do- for dharma. Whose dharma? Now when we look back and read the great epic we get lost in the story of revenge and the motivations, learnings, and actions of the Pandavas aided by the God himself- Krishna. But who talks about the innumerable faces that fought the battle? Didn’t all of them have a story of their own? Yes, they did.

Fast forward to 1947. Was it any different from Mahabharata? Yes of course there are many distinctions that can be made; but in essence it was a war declared at the top and fought by the masses. In the process causing nothing but loss. For most, the loss was beyond the tangible. It was beyond the loss of property and life of loved ones. It was nothing less than a complete loss of identity. The human in every human being was replaced by a label- the label of religion. And this label was indicated by the names they carried. So countless people had no option but to change their names. To change their entire identity. To give a new meaning to their meaningless existence. And to serve what purpose? To honor the decision made for them at the top by the leaders. But did they have the option? No. Could they have had the option? No they couldn’t have…

Law and order cannot be enforced without having a stable leadership taking charge of the society. And in the failure of the leadership in 1947, this fact emerged most glaringly. Human beings are no different from the animals of the jungle. In the Jungle there is no leadership- the larger fish eats the smaller one. It is survival of the fittest. Post the 1947 decision to divide India, the most anguished ones became the fittest. Law and order went for a toss. The world became a jungle. There were killings all around. The bestiality in some of the acts was basic, yet almost creative. A man was killed by just ripping him apart. Ripping him apart? The phrase got its literal celebration. The women were raped and molested in the most brutal ways possible. Humanity was reveling in its newfound freedom. The freedom to express, the freedom to revenge. Who ignited the flames? God knows (If there is God, that is).

Deepa Mehta’s 1947 Earth, and MS Sathyu & Kaifi Azmi’s Garam Hawa are two Hindi films that are based on incidents preceding and succeeding the horrific partition of India. Both the movies take a completely different view of the situation. In some ways, both the movies are like mirror images of one another. And both the movies have a narrative that can be viewed in two perspectives. Macro and micro. There was the larger picture that was common to all. But there were millions of people whose life got affected in a million different ways. While Garam Hawa tells the story of a rich capitalist Muslim trying not to leave India for Pakistan post the partition, 1947 Earth looks at the picture from the other side- how Sikhs and Hindus had to leave Pakistan for India post the partition abandoning their homes, their hopes, and their lives. While Garam Hawa is starts from six months after August 1947, 1947 Earth begins six months before that date. While Garam Hawa talks about a family, 1947 Earth talks about a family to be. While Garam Hawa is a story of resignation to fate, 1947 Earth is the story of taking charge of fate- even if it is in the most horrific manner possible. And while Garam Hawa ends on an optimistic note, 1947 Earth ends in the cruelest way possible.

In Garam Hawa, the train starts from Delhi and goes to Lahore. In 1947, the train starts from Lahore and goes to Delhi…

Both are extremely disturbing to see, and yet are a must watch for every Indian my age. They should not be seen as movies. They are like honest recounting of the tales that are our very own. We can never experience what our forefathers did. And we should thank God for that (If there is God, that is). But we deserve to know on what foundation our country stands today. The greatest of structures need the most solid foundations to become great. But for us the challenge lies in making a great nation on a foundation that is full of cracks and that got corroded by blood. The Blood of our own forefathers. The blood that was the result of pain. Pain that was (or rather is) is both figurative and literal. Pain that has been looked at by these two honest artistic efforts like mirrors kept on both sides.

Truly Yours

Piyush Dewan


  1. suprabh
    April 15, 2012 at 8:38 PM

    Garam Hawa– I remember this movie for its simplicity more than anything else. It dealt with such a volatile topic of communal feelings and partition in such a subtle manner. Balraj Sahni gave an amazing performance and it was amazing because one could really believe and feel for his character in the film. What all was going through his head– A dying business, A breaking family, an ailing mother, An unmarried daughter, A country about to explode. You could see the tension on his face. A very relevant movie in those times.

Page 1 of 1

Post Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

wellbutrin 100 mg tablet propranolol tabletas 40 mg zithromax 250mg dosage cialis 5 mg double xenical orlistat 120 mg online cialis coupons cialis 20mg rezeptfrei is strattera generic buy cialis reviews 2buy levitra viagra prednisone generic price strattera kopen online buy priligy europe cialis 20mg effect buy doxycycline canada cialis online cyprus nolva clomid buy doxycycline 100mg opinie cialis original 10mg zithromax 5oomg reliable clomid online cialis 5 mg fiyat buyin viagra online buy viagra 30 teva prednisone 50mg synthroid 2 mg cheap propecia usa generic strattera 80 mg clomid 50mg endometriosis kamagra 100 mg tablet generic cialis efectiveness kamagra online canada order nolva viagra Cialis 20mg 90 Tabs generic viagra houston lexapro 10mg cost buy levitra germany cialis online 50mg cheap viagra pharma buy 10 lasix pills cialis 2.5 mg lilly buy propecia where online cialis dangers nexium mups 40mg buy lasix aventis 20 mg propranolol buy cytotec dubai wellbutrin 50 mg sr amoxil 500 mg alcool cialis 2.5 mg cheap buy propecia viagra cialis 3000mg funciona cialis 20 mg viagra 130mg online check cialis cutting 20mg levitra generic kamagra buy viagra matrix 120 mg 30 mg nolvadex celebrex 200mg australia prednisone zentiva 20mg generic viagra march 2012 buy cialis miami lasix 12.5mg uk doxycycline 100mg review cialis 5 10 20 mg generic levitra 5mg order viagra mexico levitra 10 mg packungsbeilage 20 mg levitra reviews canadian cialis 5mg albania cipro online clomid progynova 2mg cialis italia generico levitra generika 5mg dapoxetine generic india online women viagra buy us cialis viagra review 50mg retirada generico viagra kamagra postal order levitra generico 40 mg buy bactrim tablets viagra 120 mg tablets augmentin dawkowanie 500 mg online buy viagra buy generic nexium 80 mg strattera adults boots cialis 10mg nexium 500 mg augmentin 625 mg pregnancy synthroid mg doses cialis online contrassegno propecia cheap buy priligy 30mg augmentin sirop 600 mg order generic cialis clomid order smell disorders prednisone xenical 120 mg upotreba augmentin 625 mg prot cipro online pharmacy zovirax 200 mg dosis aphrodisiac viagra online buy nexium dublin zoloft 50 mg ed buy doxycycline 25mg dosage levitra 15mg 5mg of propecia online chewable viagra indonesia prednisone 5mg cialis generic softtabs 5mg cialis using generic powdered viagra augmentin tab 875 mg levitra kaufen online viagra 25 mg erfahrungsberichte viagra gold 300mg diflucan 150 mg dosierung lexapro 20 mg indicaciones strattera 80 mg online viagra perth lexapro generic yet walgreens lisinopril generic generic cialis e 20 levitra 100 mg 30 tablet searchcheape viagra 5mg lexapro alcohol koop xenical online clomid online metformin er 1500 mg clomid online sales spier cialis generic prospecto cialis 40 mg 40 mg propranolol alcohol selling prednisone 20mg valtrex generic images cialis 5mg infarmed lasix 30 mg prolongatum cialis 5 mg canada buy online wellbutrin cheap kamagra tablets lexapro cheap generic buy nexium 20mg lisinopril hctz 40 mg doxycycline 20 mg price viagra buy generic wellbutrin generic problems doxycycline 100mg rosacea lilly cialis 10mg original levitra 20mg augmentin tab 500 mg periactin order tomar levitra 20 mg viagra buy lausanne buy genuine kamagra viagra 50 mg ervaringen zovirax 750 mg buy lisinopril without xenical generico barato cialis 10mg canad levitra 20 mg mexico glucophage 850 mg nedir australian viagra online cialis 10 or 20mg viagra melhor generico 30 mg lexapro comprar nexium 20mg zithromax dokter online lexapro dosage mg buy prednisone steroids generic wellbutrin appearance prednisone 50 mg daily generic zovirax 800 mg cialis generic walgreens strattera generic name their generic lexapro buy nolvadex wholesale metformin ratiopharm 850mg cialis 20 mg dividere order viagra legally buspar 20 mg day generic lexapro info cipro 500mg r ordering cipro online zithromax 250 mg penicillin buy cialis 5 mgs. lasix 25 mg fiale generic priligy 60 mg doxycycline medication online order lexapro generic buy viagra edd steroids online prednisone pemakaian cialis 10mg propecia online overnight nexium 40mg australia online cialis consultation lbrand levitra 20mg viagra dosierung 100 mg xenical online australia tetracycline capsules 250 mg cheapest online levitra buy amoxil 250mg metformin 1000 mg .ma nexium 40mg sac viagra 100 mg din online viagra 25mg purchase cialis 2.5 mg viagra generic definition 100mg viagra fails erythromycin 400 mg tabs propecia buy online levitra 5mg generic buy 60 mg nolvadex cheap cialis online zoloft 100 mg forum cialis generic capsules xenical 120 mg 252 kaps. generic cialis toronto farmacia online levitra levitra 20 mg cheap levitra 10 mg 8 stuck buy levitra strips nexium 40 mg tabletta priligy vendita online cialis 5mg apotheke cialis 10 mg precio zovirax tabs 800mg lisinopril 0.5 mg cheap 150 diflucan online bactrim f 800 160 mg buy branded cialis zoloft 50 mg indications viagra online ar buy viagra discount cheapest valtrex cialis 10mg multivitamins buying cialis china online cialis com cialis online real levitra 20 mg canada 50 mg zoloft reviews cheapest kamagra 100mg cialis 20mg france lisinopril 10 mg medication prednisone 20 mg color 200 mg synthroid cialis 20 mg effervescent propecia 1 mg safe cheapest cialis 2.5mg ucl order viagra 25 or 50 mg viagra bestel kamagra online lexapro generic there synthroid 300 mg buy authintic viagra cheap bactrim 850 mg metformin purchase dapoxetine online dapoxetine buy china tadalafil cialis 50mg 100 mg viagra nekadar lexapro 20 mg daily valtrex 1000mg filmtabletten clomid 100mg zwanger medicamento doxycycline 100mg forumbuying levitra online nexium 20 generico 50mg viagra effect rischi viagra online diflucan 2mg celebrex 4oomg viagra 50 mg effetto buy online viagra took 2 100 mg viagra red viagra 100 mg cialis online drugstore viagra consult online cialis 5mg work buy viagra 200mg propecia 1 online viagra online ie buying cheap cialis cialis 10 mg euro levitra 10mgs buy viagra nz nexium 20 mg 14 tablets bactrim 400 80 mg dawkowanie cheap original cialis cialis 5mg 20mg bactrim 200 40 mg levitra orodispersibile 20 mg lexapro and 5 mg buy vibramycin doxycycline propecia sales online zoloft generic alternative buying viagra germany dokteronline cialis cialis 5mg n1 buy viagra aurochem cialis 2.5mg levitra 10 mg sarajevo 500 mg of metformin zithromax tablets buy cheap authenic viagra buy propecia 90 lexapro 15mg posologia zithromax 1000 mg dose cialis 10mmg lasix 25 mg controindicazioni wholesale generic cialis buy augmentin suspension generic clomid walmart prednisone 50 mg uses zovirax 100 mg generic viagra cipal buy kamagra singapore information viagra 100mg generico cialis ultrafarma xenical 120 mg hinta generic propecia sweden cialis 20 mg 30 generic lexapro ireland levitra 10 mg dosage 600 mg cialis viagra generic years cipro 750 mg dosage blue generic viagra usa 20 mg levitra generic synthroid ok viagra 25 mg etkisi mg of propranolol augmentin 1000 mg faranjit clomid twins 50mg xenical orlistat online metformin 500 mg brand taking cialis 20 mg wellbutrin xl 100mg posologia propranolol 40mg buying bactrim online cialis 20mg online aventis clomid online mylan lisinopril 2.5 mg inexpensive generic viagra valtrex medication online identify generic levitra riva metformin 500 mg viagra generico pericoloso diflucan 150 150mg zithromax order viagra online canadian prednisone generic equivalent lexapro tic disorder cialis two 5mg generic viagra plane lexapro generic adderall buying diflucan overnight lisinopril online 30mg teva lexapro generic cialis generico df cost celebrex 200mg viagra buy prescription prednisone 40 mg alcohol diflucan buy generic clomid pills online zoloft 25 mg vidal levitra 20 mg fiyat cialis 50mg dosage buy clomid proviron strattera 80 mg. price prednisone 5mg domesco xenical tablets 250mg 10mg nolvadex pct viagra de 500mg 150 mg wellbutrin xl cipro generic teva lisinopril 20 mg contraindicaciones 2.5mg generic cialis cheap propecia 5mg cialis 05 mg comprimidos levitra generico chile kamagra plus 20 mg zovirax tabletas 400mg amoxil 500 mg espanol viagra deals online lasix 240 mg order lasix medication propranolol 40 mg trac 20 mg prednisone dosage generic strattera doses doxycycline 100mg suspension viagra 50 mg prices xenical 50 mg buy cialis generic viagra 25mg uk augmentin 375 mg pregnancy prednisone 40mg alcohol cialis 5 mg 36 cialis professional cheaper buy kamagra leeds 3 discount generic viagra khasiat glucophage 850 mg cialis 100 mg wiki generic cialis, 40mg buy womens viagra valtrex 500 mg tablet 1000 mg zithromax online free valtrex online generic viagra real levitra 400 mg phenergan 10mg tab lasix 20 mg tablet abra generic viagra ervaringen clomid 150 mg precio levitra 10 mg celebrex celecoxib generic lexapro withdrawal 2.5 mg levitra onlines pastillas metformin 850 mg super kamagra 160 mg nolvadex online kopen pink viagra online jual viagra online metformin bluefish 500mg buy vardenafil dapoxetine lexapro 20 mg long cialis 80 mg australia buy augmentin tablets refill cialis 10mg cheap kamagra australia viagra online originale generico viagra 25mg generic strattera 60mg change generic wellbutrin synthroid generic dosage lexapro generic 10 mg price levitra 5mg kamagra 100mg bes augmentin 500mg tablets generic brands cialis cialis generico 2 5 mg viagra order generic hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg generic diflucan dosage 100 mg xenical 120 mg walmart levitra 5 mg posologia generico priligy funziona prednisone 7.5 mg 500 mg valtrex 500mg valtrex daily levitra mg strength lisinopril abz 10mg cialis hongkong online lasix 20 mg preis cialis 20 mg assunzione 150mg canadian viagra bijsluiter viagra 100mg buy clomid twins viagra generic true generic cialis 2.5 mg celebrex 200mg nebenwirkungen 250 mg phenergan cipro filmtablet 500 mg kamagra de 50 mg wellbutrin xl 600 mg xenical remedio generico bactrim 200 mg syrop cheaper viagra cialis buy cheap viagra 100 buying glucophage online 1000 mg metformin hcl cipro usa order viagra 500mg online arabic cialis 5mg liquid nolvadex buy cialis 20 mg asli 2.5 mg. levitra generic cialis forums valtrex backorder coupon cialis 5 mg 20mg cialis cheap strattera 120 mg kamagra 50 mg gel guaranteed propecia online cialis daffodils 20mg order xenical usa 25mg clomid pregnant levitra 10 mg bugiardino clomid 100mg forum cialis 40mg dose generic nexium medication ubat doxycycline 100mg buying viagra amsterdam 5mg lexapro withdrawal 2 100mg viagra took cipro 500mg thuoc viagra 100mg cialis 10 of 20 mg doxycycline 100 mg nedir