Sudhish Kamath: Why a filmmaker and a critic can’t be friends

How can you rate Pyaar Ka Punchnama 9/10, a journalist asked me point blank when I was temporarily on the other side of the fence, facing interviews during the release of my film. Now, a rating never is any indication of how good a film is. It is only an indication of how much the person rating it likes it. And that’s the only truth. And no matter what you do, you cannot contest or argue with that truth – that I liked a film or didn’t like a film. What you can argue with are the reasons why I liked it or why I didn’t. And those are the discussions I love. The day before Good Night Good Morning released, SRK fans trolled our IMDB page to teach us critics a lesson. I review for The Hindu and the much-hated Raja Sen from Rediff plays a supporting role in the film. How dare we write negative reviews on Don 2? SRK fans ran a campaign on Twitter calling other fans to rate GNGM 1/10 since there’s no 0/10 option. I would be lying if I said it didn’t matter at all. IBNLive Of course it matters. Because unlike a review that’s one person’s opinion, an IMDB rating was some sort of a barometer of how many people liked it and how many didn’t. And being a niche film without stars, we were catering to a film literate audience that was IMDB-savvy and that rating really seemed to matter. We created about 20 fake accounts to counter the 28 1/10 votes and posted reviews (real ones done by others) under our own accounts crediting the real author at the end of the post of course. To our disappointment, it didn’t work. The rating remained unchanged. Because IMDB uses some weighted average system that is a well kept secret to stop people from manipulating the ratings. We asked friends to bail us out by voting. That didn’t help much either because the trolls kept doing the same. And so it happened. We started off with our 3.4/10 rating, the worst thing that we could’ve asked for. But thankfully for us, reviewers seemed to like our film a lot more. And more than the critics, the people who watched it became the film’s ambassadors. We got over 50 positive reviews with a minimum rating of 3 stars and over 500 tweets and an equal number on FB through comments and status updates within a week for a film that barely 1500 people watched in the theatres before Agneepath kicked us out of the theatres on Day 7. My friend Raja Sen wrote a column on Mumbai Mirror inviting people to bring out their claws. We had prepared ourselves for the worst. Considering how much we give out, we really wanted to see how much we could take ourselves. Luckily, we didn’t have to take much. Yes there were a few friends who hated it and chose to keep their opinions to themselves (something we always get to hear about through DMs because Twitter makes the world a smaller place!) but that is a part of the game. You can never please everyone. We got lucky that many people liked our film. Our IMDB rating shot up to 7.6/10 with over 200 votes (Of course, that is perhaps a little too much for our little film, I agree and so no complaints that it is now much less). Within a month of the release of the DVD, we became the film that sold more DVDs than any Shah Rukh or Salman film last year on Flipkart (climbing up to No.5 on Flipkart’s all time best seller list – only behind Rockstar, The Dirty Picture DVD, The Dirty Picture VCD and Zindagi Na Milegi Dobara. That there was our big “Fuck You” to all those trolls who did stuff out of pure malice, without even watching the film. As you can guess by my tone, obviously I hate those pests. To most filmmakers, every critic who gives a bad review is one such pest. They hate them from the bottom of their bottom. The smart ones just know to conceal it better. And the not-so-smart ones like Samir Karnik shoot their mouth off and provide us the laughs. Being a critic, I do know that a review is one person’s opinion… But when there are more people who share that same opinion, it is perceived as a larger truth by the average reader/browser and read as an evaluation of the quality of the film, pretty much like the IMDB rating. You know when a film gets 1 star or 1 and a half stars from every other critic in town must be quite bad. You know a film that gets 3 stars or above from every other critic must be quite decent. That’s also how I believe that I have made a decent film – by looking at the aggregate of the reviews and the arguments made against it and not just individual opinion – because honestly, there’s no way I can judge my own film till the time I have had the benefit of time and distance. I can’t watch my first film again. I hate it. I removed all evidence of its existence. Now, I remember getting good and bad reviews for my first film. I remember linking both the good and the bad reviews on my blog back then. I was going to send one of them a ticket to my new film inviting him to rip it apart again when I heard he told a common friend how he ‘Pwned’ my first film (when I had sportingly linked to his negative review from my blog). So I changed my mind and didn’t send him that ticket. Why? Because we don’t like people who don’t like us. Simple. It’s always that way. There may be 200 people saying good things about your film but that one guy who hates it/disses it always gets your attention. You feel the need to react to that one guy instead of reveling in the glory of all the positivity. No filmmaker finds it in him to forgive the guy who has dismissed months of his hard work, blood and sweat. It’s only human. In fact, I respect the ones who have told me to my face that they can’t be friends with me. Like this popular actor down South: “For you, films maybe a part time hobby. For me, films are my life. If you don’t like my films, we can’t be friends.” That is the most honest statement I have ever heard from any person in the film industry. I respect the guy for that. I had given one of his weakest films a bad review and the producers sent us a legal notice threatening to sue me for 25 crore to compensate for the loss! I wish reviews had that kind of power. Bodyguard would have flopped given how it was ripped apart by critics almost unanimously. But the thing about conflict is that it suddenly puts the critic at a disadvantage. It’s a stalemate. If you say anything positive about his next film, you are a suck-up. If you say anything negative, you are nursing a grudge. I have lost many friends to this politics of reviewing. Having seen the ugly side, I can safely say that there are just a handful of filmmakers who I know who can truly take it like a man. I am not going to take names. But here’s a sample. One filmmaker stopped following me or responding to me and another critic after a bad review of his film last year. Another champion of independent cinema feigns friendship during the occasional run-ins but chose to maintain radio silence about my film when it could’ve really done with a little support during the month of release, especially after he claimed to like it. Of course, no one owes anyone anything. The only point here is that we are certainly NOT friends because we share that awkward critic-filmmaker relationship. A studio boss stopped following me on Twitter the day my Yearend list was out in papers minus his films. Another industry buddy who gave me gyaan on how cool he is with criticism told a fellow critic in a moment of weakness that we critics didn’t know shit and we should first go make a film to know what it’s like (More on this at the end of this post). He also later made sure he told me why he thought my film sucked and how he could write a better film. More recently, a filmmaker got largely good reviews, stopped entertaining calls from his former colleague and friend after she wrote a mildly negative counter-point. Another master filmmaker who made a bad film last year recently admitted to a friend how he wasn’t able to deal with the negative review no matter how hard he tried. “You should have told me first before writing it.” “But you didn’t have a problem when I wrote good stuff without telling you beforehand.” “Who complains about good stuff?” Again, this was an honest response from a guy who had stopped taking calls. Most filmmakers fake it. Like Harry told Sally that a boy and a girl can never be friends, a filmmaker and a critic can never be friends. Bad sex always gets in the way. “Boohoo! You screwed me.” There are always exceptions to the rule, of course and I am lucky to have such friends too… though one can never be sure these days ;) And as for that much used argument: “Go make a film and then criticise…” Here’s the thing, guys. That shows you don’t understand the medium enough. Filmmaking is a process of construction, putting it together block by block while film criticism is a process of deconstruction and taking it apart piece by piece. Blocks and pieces are like chalk and cheese sometimes because what you thought was chalk was probably cheese for the person consuming it. It’s like assembling an impossibly giant jigsaw puzzle of an image you have only inside your head against a deadline. Sometimes you don’t even have all the pieces, especially when you are an independent filmmaker. And once you have left the room with whatever you have assembled in the time and space you were given, a bunch of people walk in to make sense of what you’ve put together. They are able to spot some parts of it and don’t get some. It does not always reflect their inability to read, it sometimes reflects your inability to put it together. The truth is always somewhere between the two. As my friend Cilemasnob often says, “You don’t need to know how to cook to comment on the taste of food.” And during that week when I was briefly on the other side of the fence, almost every other journalist asked me if you need to be a filmmaker to be a critic or vice-versa. No way. They require slightly different skill-sets. That’s like saying “You should have experienced a heart attack at least once to be a good cardiologist”. Or to extrapolate that thought further, “You should have been a corpse once to be a sensitive undertaker.” P.S: “Even you can’t take criticism!” This is such a recursive loop, one that renders the entire exercise of arguing futile. When you make a counter argument to criticism, it is seen as a sign that you cannot take criticism simply because the guy criticising you cannot deal with the fact that he’s being criticised for his criticism. There’s no end to this, every criticism can be counter criticised and so on until… a. It reaches a “Let’s agree to disagree” stalemate b. You stop being friends c. You pretend you are friends but actually think the other is an asshole. Therefore, a critic and a filmmaker can never be friends. QED.

Sudhish Kamath is a film critic with The Hindu and a two-film old independent filmmaker.


  1. suprabh
    November 3, 2012 at 5:03 AM

    Nice read…although a long one…. I’d give it a 6 on 10 only ;)

  2. FS
    November 3, 2012 at 5:38 AM

    First time reading an article without heavy usage of vocabulary. Looks like trying to connect with masses :P

Page 1 of 1

Post Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

ranbaxy recall best price ed medications elimite permethrin bed bugs haldol dosage for agitation floxin drops for canine ear infections flagyl online no prescription viagra gold 800mg buy antifungal for thrush coversyl 4mg perindopril non prescription hydrochlorothiazide aap ki adalat tv serial cozaar medication information new prescription 25 gift card doxycycline for sale januvia is developing in india amoxicillin for sale no prescription salibet ointment for burns advair hfa inhaler coupons snorting metformin fluoxetine 10 mg side effects best national non prescription pharmacy will marijuana affect cialis lergigan fass tadalafil 20mg india ketazol tablets with windows zithromax and alcohol lipvas tablets for sale viagra vipps pharmacies mestinon side effects pilocarpine side effects small pupil lasts buy birth control pills online where can i get viagra fast cyrux pastillas de leche healthman south africahealthymalehealthyman minomycin for dogs mebendazole dosage for adults buy revia from india history of leconfield castle tylenol 4 codeine vs hydrocodone powered by disqus cialis how many viagra can you take at once cyclo progynova tablets buy domperidone uk buy flutamide online carbimazole treatment dose of lovenox lavitra overnight usa zantac coupons samples quiero comprar cytotex en argentina clenbuterol side effects athletes performance hydroxyzine pamoate vistaril drugibuprofen dicyclomine bentyl side effects lidocaine side effects while pregnant augmentin vs omnicef for sinus infection alli weight loss flomax 0.4 mg cost buying levitra with paypal best web site for brand name viagra nitrazepam dosage of benadryl costco travel hong kong drugstore safe black market viagra express shipping viagra spiriva side effects capsule isoniazid and alcohol consumption baclofen for opiate withdrawal symptoms proscar 5mg cost naproxen sodium side effects kidneys estrofem 2mg mtf nuvigil side effects congestion oxybutynin medication used tadapox reviews fifty pravastatin 20 mg rimadyl side effects drug aleve dosage naproxen diarex magnum dust collector beprogel lotions avalide 150 12.5 coupon supreme suppliers mumbai india stanozolol side effects in dogs duloxetine 60 mg no prescription cialis online india how to get accutane protonix generic side effects furasemidum to buy uk 100 mg viagra price walmart cephalexin for dogs side effects tadalista canada no perscription diclofenaco de sodio medicamento tafil cialis english oracea side effects doxycycline acne analgin wikipedia encyclopedia rx pharmacy viagra mumbai buy prescriptions online review lo ovral 28 birth control viagra use in hindi canadian generic cialis reviews ingredients in sominex sleeping pills vibramycin online pharmacy clotrimazole and betameth cream uses danazol treatment for gynecomastia spedizioni cialis in italia amazon buy levitra euthyrox side effects medicine buspirone 15 mg a narcotic biaxin xl 500mg side effects christie brinkley retin a cordarone classification buy generic accutane online from canada warfarin and alcohol intake global drug supply pharmacy express viagra buy domperidone on line online pharmacy for prednisone lexapro dosage 30 mg cialis online purchase in india fast delivery on cialis 39 vigara sildenafil tablets canada advair 50 00 coupon duphaston 10mg tablets buy azithromycin single dose herpes simplex 1 cialis for women reviews buspar medication reviews percocet 5 325 description lortab hydrocodone 7.5 order cialis international milanuncios coches todo terreno segunda mano prednisone sale online where can i order cilais online lipothin injections for macular cheap bactrim ds antibiotic imitrex sumatriptan succinate nasal spray cataflam dd fasigyn fortes buy bisoprolol hctz online ephedraxin infobae prednisolone acetate ophthalmic suspension usp 1 dog glucotrol 10 mg viagra argentinien best price on levitra canada haldol dosage and administration xanax dosage for panic attacks canada erection drugs buy toradol injection online usa rx pharmacy viagra generic what is vermox liquor 329 buy spironolactone online no rx no prescription generic viagra how to buy cialis 5 mg buy 5milligram tadalafil online where can i buy synthroid on line pregnant mannequin evista medication doxycycline monohydrate vs doxycycline hyclate sildenafil powder in bulk excite pills for men erection to buy vardenafil hcl 10mg generic propranolol for anxiety side effects clavamox for cats side effects advantage sales and marketing careers hydrodiuril hydrochlorothiazide dose lialda drug classification nolvadex dosage for epistane vitamin b12 benefits drugs for depression and anxiety atomoxetine order online casodex treatment for prostate cancer online pharmacy sleep medication clonidine for children behavior alli medicina para aselgazar doxycycline hyclate periactin canada zyprexa relprevv (olanzapine pamoate irbesartan 300 mg tablet side effects canadian express pharmacy cialis 2 5 mg tablets coumadin blood thinner testing machine medrol dose pack for poison ivy who makes aloprim astromenda search cheap zanaflex no prescription wellbutrin reviews side effects canadian pharmacies that take paypal kemadrin vs mirapexin samonas listening therapy programs buy cialis without a script lisinopril hydrochlorothiazide crestor generic phexin 500mg tylenol benicar hct 40 12.5 discount card prevacid lansoprazole 30 mg capsules buspar without a prescription how to take prometrium 100mg capsules zestoretic side effects lisinopril recall vidalta carbimazole treatment cephalexin 250mg capsules bacterial infections oeder robaxin on line over the counter inhaler online viagra without a prescriptuon benicar lawsuit new jersey levothroid recall 2015 chevy lasuna planting subutex withdrawal during pregnancy buy lantus online prilosec coupons best viagra online pharmacy flonase vs nasonex symptoms zantac england cipla nalanda naprosyn side effects ingredients marine d3 verapamil er 120mg capsules cialis cyprus lorinol 10mg percocet nolvadex dosage in body building vitamix costco demo schedule 2014 eprex injection patients purchase viagra online pay with check discount code for all pills shop kamagranow forum alfuzosin hcl er 10 mg tab fermara paypal antabuse alcohol drugs 20mg cialis order indian sildenafil escitalopram online india taking zyrtec with promethazine dose terbinafine price roaccutane drug on line clomiphene 50mg drug for men duvadilan isoxsuprine drugs fucidin antibiotic ointment actos lawsuit news xalatan eye drops generic cialis safe order valtrex for cold sores in nose mircette side effects mood amoxicillan without a prescription cipro or zithromax for tooth diflucan fluconazole avapro side effects doctor avapro side effects dose cymbalta philippines buy pills without a prescription cheap propecia no rx anxiety definition apa online abortion pills for sale cleocin antibiotic treatment doctor doxycycline monohydrate 100mg buy now disgrasil orlistat precious metals septra bactrim suspension avana stonebriar the colony zofran dosage for children with stomach virus software house international austin tx valtrex and shingles treatment buto asma inhaler cialis soft tab india arimidex breast cancer length of treatment overseas fioricet buy etodolac er where can i find avanafil cheaper top legitimate online pharmachies clindamycin for dogs treatment viagra fast delivery no prescription ventolin 100 mg quanto costa il cialis meloxicam mexico primox tablets for sale baytril antibiotic for rabbits aciphex 20mg medication doctor hydroxyzine pamoate vistaril atarax acquistare viagra sicuro forum captopril capoten side effects naproxen sodium 220 mg buy finasteride canada pilex tablets side effects diflucan dosage treatment fentanyl side effects treatment cuckold creek hollywood md real estate buy medication online saw palmetto in telugu zyvoxid price of gold prinivil side effects lisinopril hctz requip drug valium 5mg dosage minomycin information systems leadmedic online pharmacy how much nolvadex for gynecomastia hoodia tea pills perlutex information processing metformin 500mg side effects en espanol online pharmacy testosterone the erection company arlington waerexin cheapest caverta online hydrodiuril contraindications for electrical stimulation dermasone cream depo provera for sale online celebrex generic no rx needed buy metformin xr mircette without prescription viagra orders z pack dose 5 day overnighted best value cialis buy pills from canada tadacip review ranitidine medication doxazosin cardura medication amoxicillin and alcohol use cheap indocin where can i order save genuine viagra noroxin 400mg tablets on line pharmacy hong kong biaxin side effects doctor subutex side effects dose anxiety in children with adhd phenegran for sale generic viagra in the united states viamedic com vfw store phone claritin for children coupon eurax lotion walgreens lergigan 25mg trazodone metoprolol tartrate side effects leg cramps lumigan side effects mouth priligy forum indian made cialis carbimazole treatment us online no prescription pharmacy cialis non prescription cnadian pharmacy procalisx ingredients in benadryl dyazide generic shortage buy bactrim online cheap seroquel no prescription vendita cialis professional astelin nasal spray side effects pharmacy near methodist willowbrook hospital online pharmacy review logain valium money pak requip drugs interaction with blood sugar levels fungsi obat grafazol 500 metronidazole viagra professional basso costo torsenide tablets cialis canadian no presciption viagara suppliers analgin wikipedia english but depakote cheap where to buy prednisone for dogs chloroquine resistant malaria buy sildenafil revatio viagra uk over the counter are canadian viagra sold online safe neurontin 24 hour shipping to us rocaltrol calcitriol dose for cats betacin tablets insulin resistance and weight loss biaxin 500mg clarithromycin and alcohol eurax for scabieseuthyrox nolvadex canada supplier forced to cum many times oxytrol tablet buy finasteride online lowest price brian benton kamagra viagra cialis buy ventolin tadacip 20 india orlistat uk reductil 1 dollar 99 cents insulin side effects for dogs where to buy elimite over the counter atepros drug testing danazol treatment in hereditary angioedema 50 mg amatriptyline cheap order synthroid isoptin verapamil can i buy cialis in france cipla suhagra from india xenical 120 mg best price on ed drugs ropinirole hydrochloride www online generic kamagra mestinon medication myasthenia viagra going generic differin 0 3 no prescription viagra home delivery precio levitra cheap brand name cialis orderpharma accutane baby orslim orlistat side effects cheap tramadol online pharmacies cialis 30 day free trial coupon canadian viagra pharmacy neurontin overnight delivery singulair allergy medicine children side effects prozac nation author zanaflex vs flexeril strength getting off tramadol fast clonidine cheap cialis extra strength sample canadian viagra best online canadian viagra lynoral ethinyl estradiol levonorgestrel leconfield wineskin prandin medication for diabetes doxycycline hyclate side effects 100mg estrace cream user reviews jasmine pilchard gosnell facebook levaquin side effects levofloxacin 750 mg viapro without prescription flagyl antibiotic used to treat sinusitis cefabiot 500mg amoxicillin side effects of himcocid kips publishing world website pharmacy viagra super power kamagra polo chewable tablets block diagram motohome raloxifene side effects doxycycline hcl 100mg magnesium side effects supplements thalidomide multiple myeloma dexamethasone order viagra overnight shipping venlafaxine 75mg er side effects levitra without a script generic cialis professional trial packs cialis without prescription viagra side effects viagra vs cialis vs levitra zovirax medication for children zofran dosage for adults metformin hcl 500mg side effects primatene mist inhalers for sale triamterene 75mg hctz 50mg tablets cockapoo information about breed deltasone classification fentanyl patch dosage kamagra uk next day paypal estrotab 1 mg equals how many mcg lortab 7.5mg increasing lung capacity for swimmingindapamide potassium chloride side effects 10 meq propecia side effects treatment cb1 weight gain pill reviews leconfield house curzon street cinema contact customer ed orderpharma reviews on fifty buying cialis online sala fontana cialis and stress test cozaar side effects fibromyalgia eritromicina buy champix tablets treatment norapred prednisona how much does viagra cost abc online pharmacy plendil felodipine side effects risnia tablets at walmart levlen 28 reviews fast delivery viagra generic cialis tadalafil 10mg best online pharmacy brand cialis buy slimex online diane rehm show today order metformin without prescription prandin medication side effects cialis dosage vs viagra vermox dosage suspension venlafaxine hcl er roxifen capsules for sale florinef capsules duvadilan drug treatment pregnancy bulk cialis apodefil sildenafil from india online cealis that accepts paypal tadalafil tablets pharmacie canadienne cialis xeloda patient assistance programs cialis daily online metformina 850 dosis recomendada de ajo espn viagara epogen dosing guide estrace 1mg how long does it take to work sunsuria medinitesupradol jasmine rice recipe cook where can i buy code red 7 feldene flash drug literature irbesartan drugs lotrisone cream 45g pharmacy express belize city belize www periactin tablets phentermine reviews and results sinequanone dresses orange thyroxin without priscription lagatrim forte 960mg rapidtabs viagra raymeds reviews for fifty prostata inflamada causas betanoid syrup denver non prescription prednisone canada windsor canada online pharmacy cymbalta for anxiety cymbalta and weight gain skelaxin abuse medication free cialis trial pack diltiazem hydrochloride drug