TIme to free Balochistan from Pakistan (=Punjabistan)


Dana Rohrabacher’s resolution in the US Congress states that the Baloch people “have the right to self-determination and to their own sovereign country”. Expectedly, this unleashed a torrent of anger in Pakistan’s government and media which overwhelmingly saw this as a conspiracy to break up the country. Pakistan-US relations have descended another notch; attempts by the US State Department, as well as the currently visiting group of Congressmen, to distance themselves from the resolution have not worked.

Rohrabacher is easy to criticise. This extremist Republican has defended the use of torture, advocated the induction of warlords into the Afghan government, thinks trees cause global warming, and wants subsidies for rain forests to be cut down. Last July, while visiting Baghdad, he raised a storm by suggesting that Iraq pay back the United States the billions it spent after the 2003 invasion.

But this right-wing nut — obviously motivated by domestic politics rather than human rights — may actually have done Pakistan a favour by focusing world attention upon the horror of today’s Balochistan. Predictably, Baloch leaders are enthusiastically endorsing Rohrabacher’s statement, “The political and ethnic discrimination the Baloch suffer is tragic and made more so because America is financing and selling arms to their oppressors in Islamabad.”

For decades, the Baloch have complained of ill-treatment. They say their natural wealth has been expropriated by Punjab and that Balochistan’s natural gas reached remote Punjabi towns long before it was available in Quetta — and then only because an army cantonment needed it. Baloch representation in the civil and the military bureaucracy remains close to zero.

But rather than assuage national grievances, both real and imagined ones, the Pakistani establishment used the iron fist. In 1972, Zulfikar Ali Bhutto reinvigorated an army defeated by India in 1971 by sending it to quell the Baloch uprising. Thousands died. In 2006, under General Pervez Musharraf the Army claimed the killing of 80-year old Nawab Akbar Bugti as yet another victory, saying this would end the insurgency. But it turned out otherwise, and Bugti’s murder was yet another thread torn loose from the unraveling national fabric. Vengeful Baloch nationalists now target non-Baloch innocents and have murdered, among others, Punjabi and Mohajir teachers.

Pakistani security forces deny any wrongdoing and General Kayani claims that military operations are no longer being carried out against Baloch nationalists. But newspaper accounts suggest that the abduct-torture-kill-dump formula may be officially sanctioned from above. Mutilated bodies are strewn across roadsides and found in garbage dumps.

Worried about further internationalisation in the wake of Rohrabacher’s bill, Interior Minister Rehman Malik is scurrying around offering palliatives and promises. But the Baloch Republican Party’s exiled chief, Brahamdagh Bugti, whose sister and niece were mysteriously murdered in Karachi earlier this month, says that “America must intervene in Balochistan and stop the ethnic cleansing of Baloch people”.

Such open appeals, in my opinion, are short-sighted because they invite heightened repression. Moreover, America’s betrayal of Kurdish national self-determination should not be forgotten. In 1975, the Kurdish Peshmerg discovered to its horror that American support suddenly vanished after Richard Nixon chose to side with the Shah of Iran and Saddam Hussain.

The official Pakistani response to Rohrabacher is still more flawed. Foreign Minister Hina Rabbani Khar termed the tabling of his bill “a violation of UN charter” and of Pakistan’s sovereignty. But this line of defence could forfeit Pakistan’s moral right to criticise other states, Syria and India included.

Consider the fact that on February 17 Pakistan voted for an Arab League-sponsored resolution in the UN General Assembly which calls upon Syria’s President Bashar al-Assad to step down. This surely constitutes interference in the internal matter of a sovereign country. But Pakistan did well. In a civilised world national sovereignty must come second, and human rights first.

Pakistan has also long criticised India — and justly so — for its human rights abuses. But more people are dying in Balochistan today than in Kashmir. For all their brutality against stone-throwing Kashmiri boys, the Indians have not yet used helicopter gunships and fighter jets against Kashmiris. Pakistan, on the other hand, uses airpower as a matter of course in Balochistan and Fata.

Is there a way out? Maybe so, but for that Pakistan must hear what Baloch nationalists are saying — and then act. In 2008, Sanaullah Baloch, who had then just quit the Pakistan Senate, wrote that “Islamabad’s recent move to grant religious self-rule to the Taliban in Swat and the denial of political autonomy to the people of Balochistan are beyond comprehension”.

Sanaullah’s list of demands — still unmet today — were not unreasonable: a) end the military operation and halt construction of military and paramilitary cantonments; b) withdraw security forces; c) repatriate and rehabilitate displaced persons; d) cancel civil/military land allotments; e) demilitarise the area; f) ensure equal wellhead prices for Baluchistan’s gas, and h) abandon torture camps and establish a “truth and reconciliation commission” for trying those involved in killing Nawab Akbar Bugti and Balach Marri.

A similar list by Mir Mohammad Ali Talpur was published in 2008 wherein he rhetorically asked: a) Will the new airport in Gwadar be handed over to the CAA to ensure that a military base is not established there? b) Will Saindak’s unjust income-sharing formula be reversed to give Balochistan 48 per cent and the centre two per cent? c) Will they refrain from using Hingol National Park as a testing ground for the air force?

The Rohrabacher show will roll off the stage soon but Balochistan’s situation shall remain. More people will disappear, and the heap of mutilated corpses shall keep mounting. For now, the Pakistan Army and the Frontier Corps can ensure that there is no independent Balochistan. But their actions cannot lead to peace and reconciliation.

Men like Rohrabacher are no friends of the Baloch. But what can stop their meddling? The answer can only come once we dump the myth of Pakistan being one nation, one people. The Baloch cannot agree with ‘what is yours is mine, what is mine is mine’. If Pakistanis value the people of Balochistan rather than the wealth under their ground, they must make every possible compromise to draw them into the mainstream.

Published in The Express Tribune, February 27th, 2012.



  1. Rosh
    February 28, 2012 at 8:15 AM

    Cranky republicans …

  2. NyKavi
    February 28, 2012 at 12:25 PM

    Economic Integration with India is the answer to all problems of Pakistan.
    The Quaid must be turning in his grave upon watching the manipulation of his creation by the elite nexus of Generals-Jaagirdaars-Industrialists. His ghost must be mourning at the sight of Sunnis killing Shias, and seeing Ahmadiyaas getting discriminated, of minorities getting decimated. He must be sulking at having to watch Muslims in India prosper as part of a secular nation, the kind which he had envisaged Pakistan to be.
    The Two Nation Theory is a total farce. The logic of Two-Nations states that Hindus and Muslims are two distinct blocks. It totally misses the fact that these blocks are further sub-divided into so many little pieces, that none of them can be joined together to form those Two Blocks. Neither of these two blocks ever existed as a functioning whole, their existence is just a figment of imagination.
    If the entire 1.6 Billion Population of the sub-continent is broken down based on religio-political lines, it will reveal the following groups:
    450 million Upper Caste Hindus
    250 million Lower Caste Hindus, who are totally unaligned with the Upper Castes
    450 million Sunni Muslims
    200 million Shia Muslims, who are largely unaligned with the Sunnis.
    200 million Dalits, who are totally atheist, and unaligned with any of the above.
    The rest are Sikh, Christian, Buddhist, etc.
    And furthermore all these groups listed above are sliced and diced into more linguistic and distinct geographic sub-groups.
    In India, every 2% of the population is different from the other 98%. But all those different 2% pieces added together have created the largest secular democratic republic of the world.
    A truly secular democratic nation of the above composition could never have been an anathema to any single group. The power of democracy would have ensured that no single group ever becomes dominant. It would have accorded equal rights and statuses to every individual, as has been largely achieved in a secular India. It also would have created the largest economic block in the world, far more superior, powerful and prosperous than any other country.
    Unfortunately, historical hindsight is always going to be 20/20. What has been done cannot be undone. If the people of the subcontinent want to prosper, they must cease all differences and create a tightly knit economic block which will ensure that the true potential of this region is brought to fruition.

  3. Tashan
    February 28, 2012 at 1:45 PM

    Hahaha aa jao bhai jis mein dum hai dekhte hain kya hota hai…bangalis were mistreated i agree tho even in that one country was helping them behind the doorsbut this is bullshit…sach kuch aur and who the hell is USA? pehle iraq aur afg mein tau apna pichwada bachao, dusron ke mulk ki fiqar choro

  4. NyKavi
    February 28, 2012 at 11:12 PM

    Tashan bhai.
    Take a look at these videos, and connect the dots.

    The last thing that India wants is a divided Pak with absent nukes. Read my previous comment above. The solution to all problems of Pakistan (as well as subcontinent) is a Tight Economic Integration, with free flow of goods and services, people, etc. And all this done in a secular framework, with no restriction of property ownership. Only if the stupid politicians and greedy self serving jaagirdaars understood, that in doing so, they will make more money than they can ever imagine.

    If the current situation persists, then the Balochis will be singing this national anthem in Quetta instead of UAE:

  5. Tashan
    February 29, 2012 at 3:59 AM

    hmmm i will talk about this in detail someday…

Page 1 of 1

Post Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

clomid 25mg pregnant buspar 20 mg day online buy cialis order generic strattera zovirax de 200 mg 50mg viagra duration 50 mg clomid buy propecia 100 hydrochlorothiazide cap 12.5 mg bactrim 500mg bula generic viagra liquid cialis generico aurochem lasix fiale 20 mg lexapro 10mg onofre lasix 500 mg rumania generic augmentin es buy celebrex europe buy doxycycline gonorrhea bijwerkingen kamagra 100mg all generic viagra lisinopril 10 mg beipackzettel cialis buy canada nexium 20 mg coupons lisinopril online diflucan 100 mg controindicazioni strattera 25 mg intuniv buy 40 mg levitra 25 mg viagra etkisi buy prednisone 2.5 mg augmentin sirop 600 mg metformin 500mg tablets order cialis 50mg 100 cialis 5mg costo cialis 20 mg finasteride 5mg propecia diflucan 150 mg wikipedia 1 mg viagra cialis sold cheaply generic viagra buy zovirax 200 mg prix zoloft generic manufacturers i buy periactin lasix 40 mg vidal buy viagra mastercard cialis online drugstore doxycycline tablets 150mg took 200 mg viagra dangerous generic viagra viagra 100 mg information erythromycin 250 mg diflucan 200 mg costo cialis 20 mg paypal phenergan 75 mg regime xenical 120 mg generico de diflucan cialis 5mg directions express generic viagra levitra generic 20mg zithromax 250 mg penicillin cialis 2.5 generic lisinopril 5mg tabs onlinestore buy viagra phenergan uk buy lisinopril 15 mg cialis tolerance 2.5 mg cialis 80 mg australia generic levitra reviews xenical italy buy buy viagra suppositoria propecia prices 5mg citalopram 10 mg libbs bactrim generic name viagra chennai online generic lexapro mages viagra generico la generic viagra 100 viagra online turkey online zithromax bestellen cheap original cialis buying viagra mastercard viagra generico guatemala generic strattera 25 mg celebrex order canada liquid nolvadex online levitra venta online levitra bayer 5 mg cheap kamagra australia cialis 2.5mg benefit ordering celebrex online zoloft online order search cheap viagra 7.5 teva prednisone 50 mg lasix special 500 mg generic zovirax online viagra matrix 120 mg levitra 20mg 4st cialis 2,5 mg nl nexium de 40 mg generic cialis ed generic cialis european cheapest merck propecia cialis two 5mg lexapro 20mg 6 drops valtrex medication online cialis 2.5 buy online rischi viagra online buspar bipolar disorder cipro 500mg buy levitra bangkok cialis 20 mg dosis generic levitra good generic valtrex mylan viagra online generico buy propecia proscar online cialis us nexium 20 mg 14 tablets buy viagra 4x100 cialis boots order herbal viagra 8000mg nolvadex mg pct real cheap viagra viagra generic 25 mg generic viagra drops order viagra nz levitra 20mg sale lisinopril dosage 40 mg levitra generic name metformin 500 mg e 12 mg viagra buy wholesale cialis zithromax trockensaft 600 mg generic lexapro 10mg 40 mg lisinopril daily clomid 100mg online generic synthroid ok prednisone 20 mg 3 days viagra generic years generico lexapro 10 mg lisinopril 5 mg tab viagra zakup online cialis 5mg 2 pills order viagra boots clomid 100mg kopen cialis 10mg preisvergleich generic strattera doses levitra 10 mg yorumlar valtrex generic pill lexapro 20 mg 4 weeks lisinopril generico mexico kamagra 100mg erfahrungsberichte 2.5mg generic cialis natural generic viagra levitra generique 40 mg buy viagra vardenafil buy strattera cheap cialis 40 mg portugues lexapro 15 mg anxiety viagra generico pericoloso reliable clomid online generico de lasix viagra 10 mg price buy cialis 150 mg erythromycin 500mg bd le viagra 100mg cialis 10 mg cena safest generic cialis lexapro generic overdose viagra tab 50mg viagra online fiable cheap cialis online generic viagra ebay coomeva cheap viagra metformin xr 750 mg viagra 50 mg fiyatlari arabic cialis 5mg nexium 40 mg indicatii cialis adelaide online levitra cheap 20mg generic celebrex medication lisinopril 10 mg 3972 online pharmacy lasix cialis 2omg fta 4 cialis paypal cheap generic for celebrex propecia generic prices betrouwbare generic cialis viagra 25 mg preciomexico viagra online asap augmentin pret 500 mg viagra 800mg uk synthroid 20 mg clomid 50mg generic wholesale viagra online taking 1500 mg metformin xenical orlistate 200mg generic to celebrex lexapro max 40 mg celebrex 220 mg zoloft generic name glucophage 1000 mg endikasyonlari generic for nexium generic lisinopril symptoms 5mg lisinopril tablets lisinopril 10 mg cena prednisone 10mg high cheap original viagra cialis 20mg effect propecia order abroad buy viagra edd propranolol 120mg wellbutrin xl 150mg thuoc cialis 10mg pattaya buy cialis generic synthroid pills buy online cialis celexa citalopram 20 mg buy cialis line prednisone 80 mg day cialis purchase online nolvadex pct 20 mg levitra prices 20mg price lisinopril 10 mg cialis 5mg tratamento online viagra kaufen cialis 5mg 20mg dapoxetine 30mg 24 mg prednisone generic 10mg cialis buy nexium 20 capsule wellbutrin generic nausea viagra 500mg price buy viagra istanbul amoxil 875 mg price lexapro eating disorders cheap viagra romania cheap clomid 100mg cheap valtrex uk nolvadex buy buy viagra bristol preis zithromax 500mg strattera 40 mg information zoloft 150mg nexium 40 mg generic doxycycline online augmentin prospect 1000 mg cheap cialis delivery teva generic wellbutrin buy propecia fedex clomid buy canada lexapro 10 mg ervaringen 40 mgs prednisone propecia 1mg discount mg bactrim uti nolvadex tablets buy doxycycline 100 mg dosage propranolol hcl 20 mg generic cialis hr generic doxycycline tablets new generic wellbutrin cialis 10 mg kanada wellbutrin 300 mg erfahrungen lisinopril 10 mg apo amoxil 500 mg embarazo zithromax 250mg walgreens smell disorders prednisone bactrim mg uti cialis 2.5 mg experience mail order valtrex generic propecia price cialis online dubai cialis 5 mg tadalafil order propecia 1mg cialis 20 mg halveren cialis generic women doxycycline 100mg review buy levitra onlines buy pzeifer viagra generic viagra wirkung nexium 40mg generico online viagra mexico buy valtrex walgreens folcres generic propecia amoxil 250 mg 5 ml cialis buy australia viagra online urgente amoxil 500mg wiki discount levitra 10mg generic viagra japan prijs xenical 120 mg bijsluiter viagra 100mg prednisone 20mg symptoms doxycycline rp 100mg clomid 50mg follicles cialis generic chinatown kamagra online collection cialis mg difference cialis de 100 mg cialis 20 mg contrassegno buy metformin 500mg cialis 2.5 mg walgreens buying cialis online prednisone 20 mg ivf generic viagra bodybuilding generic valtrex prices tomo 5 mg lexapro augmentin 1000 mg 14 tablets generic propecia nz prednisone 8 mg soft cialis 40 mg iv phenergan online diflucan 150mg tablets viagra online.pt generic uk viagra wellbutrin dosage 75 mg red cialis 200mg erythromycin 250mg goi online propecia nulk cialis 20 mg ervaringen there generic zoloft generic viagra ok lexapro 10mg vs 20 glucophage online buy doxycycline 100mg home bactrim ds 400 mg purchase propecia online cheap viagra 200 mg cheap viagra medicine bactrim generico mexico viagra buy prescription viagra 120 mg tablets cialis 10 mg tab viagra dose 50mg augmentin 625 mg pregnancy viagra 100 mg annostus buy real xenical 200mg viagra india lasix 25 mg fiale nolvadex generic supplements online apotheke xenical mims online celebrex 300 mg zoloft overdose cialis preise 10mg buy propecia ny doxycycline 150 mg identification preisvergleich viagra 100 mg glucophage 1000 mg nebenwirkungen buy clomid forum cheapest levitra 20 mg lexapro generic costs preco clomid 50mg farmacie online cialis wellbutrin 300 mg xr cialis 5 mg dose cramping 10 mg prednisone zoloft generic cvs prospect celebrex 100 mg buy viagra chinatown lexapro and 5 mg cheapest kamagra 100mg cialis pill online celebrex celecoxib 100 mg cialis 20 mg generic xenical shopping online nolvadex 10 mg astrazeneca dapoxetine generic priligy you buy viagra glucophage generics nexium mups 40 mg nexium 5mg review cialis da 50 mg 80 mg strattera 10 mg prednisone tablets strattera 40 mg capsules zoloft 50mg dejstvo effect generic viagra buying viagra onoline generica cialis USA doxycycline online cheap strattera 80 mgs costo generic viagra exist azul viagra generico clomid online pharmacy zoloft buy pypal cialis 5mg ejaculation cialis 2,5 mg online generic viagra zenegra generico viagra nombre viagra generic risks 150mg canadian viagra zoloft vs generics levitra strength mg buy strattera 100 mg viagra brand 100 mg cialis cheap brand cialis 10 mg nedir 5 vs 10 mg lexapro 100 mg viagra nekadar buy doxycycline nz xenical cheapest price bactrim 200 40 mg dosis diflucan sciroppo 50 mg metformin er 250 mg priligy vendita online online levitra order farmacias online levitra viagra 100 mg. upotreba cialis cuantos mg generic cialis toronto buying strattera online opinion cialis 20 mg cialis 50mg philippines generic brand zoloft cost lisinopril 20 mg cialis daily 10 mg adoxa doxycycline 150 mg viagra online vendita indian generic levitra cheapest propecia prices kamagra 100mg nebenwirkungen zithromax 600 mg sirop buy doxycycline canada viagra online rendeles zovirax 100 mg using viagra 100mg buy doxycycline antibiotic doxycycline hyclate 1oomg cialis australia cheap buy lab nolvadex medicina cialis 5 mg 80mg lasix overdose price 10 mg lexapro cialis generic buy generic viagra walmart cipro antibiotic buy diflucan 100 mg tablete order cialis 20mg order clomid uk lasix 40 mg presentacion lexapro cheap generic canada 2.5 mg cialis professional viagra generic buy wellbutrin generic viagra price 50 mg 100 2 100 mg viagra viagra 50 mg dosage online cialis diagnosis cipla viagra 50 mg took 100mg levitra buy viagra 150mg clomid buy 50mg cialis 10 mg cupon 25 or 50 mg viagra cialis giornaliero 5 mg viagra 150mg levitra twice 5 mg propranolol 10 mg pl valtrex generic wikipedia 200 mg of wellbutrin 500 mg metformin daily cialis malaysia 200mg cialis 800 mg testimonial generico del bactrim prednisone 5mg mylan cipro 750 mg dosage buy india cialis zoloft dosages mg propecia online vitamins cialis 10 mg b4 glucophage 500 mg xr buy brand lexapro propecia 1mg online metformin er750mg kamagra 100 mg sachet canine doxycycline 20mg lisinopril 10 mg mylan nexium dosage 40 mg viagra herbal online zithromax order cialis cheap online effetti viagra 100mg levitra 20 mgs generic 10 mg cialis viagra 100 mg etkisi hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg tablets cialis deals online lisinopril normon 5 mg cialis 5 mg pills brand levitra 5mg cialis 100 mg lilly clomid 50mg comprar lisinopril 100mg viagra generico originale cialis 200mg results generic cipro lisinopril secubar 20 mg generic powdered viagra erfahrungen levitra 10 mg generic alternative lexapro metformin generic names cheapest lexapro price