TIme to free Balochistan from Pakistan (=Punjabistan)

 

Dana Rohrabacher’s resolution in the US Congress states that the Baloch people “have the right to self-determination and to their own sovereign country”. Expectedly, this unleashed a torrent of anger in Pakistan’s government and media which overwhelmingly saw this as a conspiracy to break up the country. Pakistan-US relations have descended another notch; attempts by the US State Department, as well as the currently visiting group of Congressmen, to distance themselves from the resolution have not worked.

Rohrabacher is easy to criticise. This extremist Republican has defended the use of torture, advocated the induction of warlords into the Afghan government, thinks trees cause global warming, and wants subsidies for rain forests to be cut down. Last July, while visiting Baghdad, he raised a storm by suggesting that Iraq pay back the United States the billions it spent after the 2003 invasion.

But this right-wing nut — obviously motivated by domestic politics rather than human rights — may actually have done Pakistan a favour by focusing world attention upon the horror of today’s Balochistan. Predictably, Baloch leaders are enthusiastically endorsing Rohrabacher’s statement, “The political and ethnic discrimination the Baloch suffer is tragic and made more so because America is financing and selling arms to their oppressors in Islamabad.”

For decades, the Baloch have complained of ill-treatment. They say their natural wealth has been expropriated by Punjab and that Balochistan’s natural gas reached remote Punjabi towns long before it was available in Quetta — and then only because an army cantonment needed it. Baloch representation in the civil and the military bureaucracy remains close to zero.

But rather than assuage national grievances, both real and imagined ones, the Pakistani establishment used the iron fist. In 1972, Zulfikar Ali Bhutto reinvigorated an army defeated by India in 1971 by sending it to quell the Baloch uprising. Thousands died. In 2006, under General Pervez Musharraf the Army claimed the killing of 80-year old Nawab Akbar Bugti as yet another victory, saying this would end the insurgency. But it turned out otherwise, and Bugti’s murder was yet another thread torn loose from the unraveling national fabric. Vengeful Baloch nationalists now target non-Baloch innocents and have murdered, among others, Punjabi and Mohajir teachers.

Pakistani security forces deny any wrongdoing and General Kayani claims that military operations are no longer being carried out against Baloch nationalists. But newspaper accounts suggest that the abduct-torture-kill-dump formula may be officially sanctioned from above. Mutilated bodies are strewn across roadsides and found in garbage dumps.

Worried about further internationalisation in the wake of Rohrabacher’s bill, Interior Minister Rehman Malik is scurrying around offering palliatives and promises. But the Baloch Republican Party’s exiled chief, Brahamdagh Bugti, whose sister and niece were mysteriously murdered in Karachi earlier this month, says that “America must intervene in Balochistan and stop the ethnic cleansing of Baloch people”.

Such open appeals, in my opinion, are short-sighted because they invite heightened repression. Moreover, America’s betrayal of Kurdish national self-determination should not be forgotten. In 1975, the Kurdish Peshmerg discovered to its horror that American support suddenly vanished after Richard Nixon chose to side with the Shah of Iran and Saddam Hussain.

The official Pakistani response to Rohrabacher is still more flawed. Foreign Minister Hina Rabbani Khar termed the tabling of his bill “a violation of UN charter” and of Pakistan’s sovereignty. But this line of defence could forfeit Pakistan’s moral right to criticise other states, Syria and India included.

Consider the fact that on February 17 Pakistan voted for an Arab League-sponsored resolution in the UN General Assembly which calls upon Syria’s President Bashar al-Assad to step down. This surely constitutes interference in the internal matter of a sovereign country. But Pakistan did well. In a civilised world national sovereignty must come second, and human rights first.

Pakistan has also long criticised India — and justly so — for its human rights abuses. But more people are dying in Balochistan today than in Kashmir. For all their brutality against stone-throwing Kashmiri boys, the Indians have not yet used helicopter gunships and fighter jets against Kashmiris. Pakistan, on the other hand, uses airpower as a matter of course in Balochistan and Fata.

Is there a way out? Maybe so, but for that Pakistan must hear what Baloch nationalists are saying — and then act. In 2008, Sanaullah Baloch, who had then just quit the Pakistan Senate, wrote that “Islamabad’s recent move to grant religious self-rule to the Taliban in Swat and the denial of political autonomy to the people of Balochistan are beyond comprehension”.

Sanaullah’s list of demands — still unmet today — were not unreasonable: a) end the military operation and halt construction of military and paramilitary cantonments; b) withdraw security forces; c) repatriate and rehabilitate displaced persons; d) cancel civil/military land allotments; e) demilitarise the area; f) ensure equal wellhead prices for Baluchistan’s gas, and h) abandon torture camps and establish a “truth and reconciliation commission” for trying those involved in killing Nawab Akbar Bugti and Balach Marri.

A similar list by Mir Mohammad Ali Talpur was published in 2008 wherein he rhetorically asked: a) Will the new airport in Gwadar be handed over to the CAA to ensure that a military base is not established there? b) Will Saindak’s unjust income-sharing formula be reversed to give Balochistan 48 per cent and the centre two per cent? c) Will they refrain from using Hingol National Park as a testing ground for the air force?

The Rohrabacher show will roll off the stage soon but Balochistan’s situation shall remain. More people will disappear, and the heap of mutilated corpses shall keep mounting. For now, the Pakistan Army and the Frontier Corps can ensure that there is no independent Balochistan. But their actions cannot lead to peace and reconciliation.

Men like Rohrabacher are no friends of the Baloch. But what can stop their meddling? The answer can only come once we dump the myth of Pakistan being one nation, one people. The Baloch cannot agree with ‘what is yours is mine, what is mine is mine’. If Pakistanis value the people of Balochistan rather than the wealth under their ground, they must make every possible compromise to draw them into the mainstream.

Published in The Express Tribune, February 27th, 2012.

http://tribune.com.pk/story/342053/is-rohrabacher-wrong-on-balochistan/

6 Comments

  1. Rosh
    Rosh
    February 28, 2012 at 8:15 AM

    Cranky republicans …

  2. NyKavi
    NyKavi
    February 28, 2012 at 12:25 PM

    Economic Integration with India is the answer to all problems of Pakistan.
    The Quaid must be turning in his grave upon watching the manipulation of his creation by the elite nexus of Generals-Jaagirdaars-Industrialists. His ghost must be mourning at the sight of Sunnis killing Shias, and seeing Ahmadiyaas getting discriminated, of minorities getting decimated. He must be sulking at having to watch Muslims in India prosper as part of a secular nation, the kind which he had envisaged Pakistan to be.
    The Two Nation Theory is a total farce. The logic of Two-Nations states that Hindus and Muslims are two distinct blocks. It totally misses the fact that these blocks are further sub-divided into so many little pieces, that none of them can be joined together to form those Two Blocks. Neither of these two blocks ever existed as a functioning whole, their existence is just a figment of imagination.
    If the entire 1.6 Billion Population of the sub-continent is broken down based on religio-political lines, it will reveal the following groups:
    450 million Upper Caste Hindus
    250 million Lower Caste Hindus, who are totally unaligned with the Upper Castes
    450 million Sunni Muslims
    200 million Shia Muslims, who are largely unaligned with the Sunnis.
    200 million Dalits, who are totally atheist, and unaligned with any of the above.
    The rest are Sikh, Christian, Buddhist, etc.
    And furthermore all these groups listed above are sliced and diced into more linguistic and distinct geographic sub-groups.
    In India, every 2% of the population is different from the other 98%. But all those different 2% pieces added together have created the largest secular democratic republic of the world.
    A truly secular democratic nation of the above composition could never have been an anathema to any single group. The power of democracy would have ensured that no single group ever becomes dominant. It would have accorded equal rights and statuses to every individual, as has been largely achieved in a secular India. It also would have created the largest economic block in the world, far more superior, powerful and prosperous than any other country.
    Unfortunately, historical hindsight is always going to be 20/20. What has been done cannot be undone. If the people of the subcontinent want to prosper, they must cease all differences and create a tightly knit economic block which will ensure that the true potential of this region is brought to fruition.

  3. Tashan
    Tashan
    February 28, 2012 at 1:45 PM

    Hahaha aa jao bhai jis mein dum hai dekhte hain kya hota hai…bangalis were mistreated i agree tho even in that one country was helping them behind the doorsbut this is bullshit…sach kuch aur and who the hell is USA? pehle iraq aur afg mein tau apna pichwada bachao, dusron ke mulk ki fiqar choro

  4. NyKavi
    NyKavi
    February 28, 2012 at 11:12 PM

    Tashan bhai.
    Take a look at these videos, and connect the dots.

    The last thing that India wants is a divided Pak with absent nukes. Read my previous comment above. The solution to all problems of Pakistan (as well as subcontinent) is a Tight Economic Integration, with free flow of goods and services, people, etc. And all this done in a secular framework, with no restriction of property ownership. Only if the stupid politicians and greedy self serving jaagirdaars understood, that in doing so, they will make more money than they can ever imagine.

    If the current situation persists, then the Balochis will be singing this national anthem in Quetta instead of UAE:

  5. Tashan
    Tashan
    February 29, 2012 at 3:59 AM

    hmmm i will talk about this in detail someday…

Page 1 of 1

Post Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

azithromycin tablets ip nizagara order online fast shipping levitra cialis shivam purchase synthriod without prescription mexican mail order pharmacies losartan side effects mayo clinic requip drugs interaction with blood sugar levels how much does generic viagra cost 252 buy citalopram 10mg online uk lamisil cream treatment athletes foot counterfeit phenergan doxazosin medication drugs fucidin ointment 2 argentina pharmacy on line nexium dapoxetine with viagra tryptizol dosage of tylenol rapidtabs wikipedia free disgracil pills tadalafil citrate wikipedia dapoxetine online purchase buy xenical without consultation celexa canadian pharmacy safe to buy cialis online nizagara tablets for sale ciprodex coupon code neurontin overnight delivery prednisolone for cats dosage cytoxan manufacturers dormidina information society abilify coupons without insurance cheap generic airmail cyclidox antibiotics for strep where can i buy tetracycline cozaar side effects cozaar 50 mg can i drink beer and take flomax how can i buy cialis discount online canada cialis ramipril 10mg side effects exelon stock dividend vibrox capsules ipharmacy app for android best price for cialis 5 mg online cialis tablete cena androfin reviews redustat capsulas 60 mgregenon tabletten oynanan oyunlar 3 furacin ointment nitrofurazone where can i buy mebendazole over the counter tylenol arthritis acetaminophen vermox plus mexico clomid for sale online cheap on line levitra meds insurance commissioner florida ventolin inhaler salbutamol doctor zetia side effects ezetimibe accutane long term side effects brain tiotropium pronunciation online viagra order in belgium abilify weight gain abilify medication xylocaine injection drug doxinyl medication for anxiety zetia 10 mg salazopyrin en tabs 500mg digoxin level test online prescriptions thailand chocolate cockapoo puppies for sale in michigan anxiety disorder symptoms tingling dutasteride prices lortab side effects hydrocodone elavil dosage for insomnia famvir 500mg treatment famciclovir and pregnancy fibadel 5 safe perscription medication in canada discover card login page account login vrdrug complaints of a dutiful daughter cheap prozac no prescription buy terramycin spray diamox side effects in children procalisx ingredients in tylenol tidilor loratadine podofilox solution cialis and weed prescription drugs medicines fda actos warning avandia parlodel drug topamax dosage for weight loss yahoo answers buy wellbutrin sr no rx strattera adderall buy imiquimod 5 creams for genital wart rimonabant acomplia dosage instructions kamagra canadian female viagra pills in hyderabad epogen information viagra grapefruit delay time online drug paypal zanaflex tizanidine erowid clotrimazole cream 1 uses sample canadian viagra rumafen medicine how long for viagra to work zyvoxid 600mg caffeine bactrim ds tablets roaccutane buy how much nolvadex for gynecomastia tretinoin gel 0.01 15g mobic medication side effects no perscription canadian pharmacies peritol tablets for appetite finasteride tablets for sale casodex prostate cancer treatment xatral xl 10 mg side effects no rx aurochem tadalafil nasonex coupon $15 esomeprazole strontium price fermara paypal xanax addiction symptoms benzodiazepine aviagra 4 birds on whats google to buy cabergoline ordering flagyl by mail eulexin medication albuterol side effects inhaler famvir for cold sores marine d3 acyclovir 800mg medication espanol sildenafil citrate 100mg tab for women online pharmiacies zovirax medication use how to use miss me tablet cheap tramadol online pharmacies prescription medicine online aspirin and pregnancy induced hypertension viagra super force 100mg 100mg asthma medications albuterol norstan communications mn comprar cialis paypal flagyl online no prescription retin a cream 0.05 where to buy trental canada therapy dogs international xlpharmacy canada revenue buy 50mg viagra in austrailia buy lisinopril 12 5 minocin antibiotic side effects stilnox zolpidem 10mg zineryt cenarios crestor rosuvastatina tabletas buy real vigra sildenafil para mujeres venta de cialis en miami lopressor 50 mg pursues viagra with a gift card orderbenicar without rx aldara cream side effects skin cancer amlodipine medication tab 10 mg tabletten gegen hautpilzerkrankungen singulair medicine for children discount celebrex buy atorvastatin 20mg nootropil 800 side effects sumycin syrup brands cialis for young men tadarise 60 viagra generic online in america cost comparison viagra vs cialis 25 best price ed medications acomplia 20mg tablets prexanil en espanol precio pharmacy technician salary in florida anafranil 10 mg adderall viagra coupon pfizer salbutamol ventolin capsule furolin medicine dictionary buying viagra in canada reviews mail kumaden co jp cialis em portugal imigran tablets online hydrocodone refills online avana apartments san antonio sildenafil citrate 100 mg tab side effects looking for brand viagra fluconazole for dogs valley fever cheap eltroxin no prescription parcopa carbidopa levodopa side clonazepam buy online where in england there bayer levitra colospan what is its usage kemadrin medication interaction valafexina in uk pyridium over the counter dosage cockapoo puppies for sale aristocort triamcinolone cream lipothin injections for macular lamisil liquid spray 100mg clomid tablets online us pharmacy prices for cialis salazopyrin en 500 mg fucidin ointment generic name holy cross rc church cottingham vivanza 20mg trazodone for insomnia side effects milanuncios escopetas segunda mano asacol medication assistance program doxycycline accord disper tablet 100mg cialis non prescription insurance auto auctions westchester il macrobid side effects in the elderly hydrea 500 mg a day sublingual b complex with b12 side effects motilium online uk generic viagra spain cheap pharmacy forclomid octreotide infusion doseolanzapine estradiol levels chart crestor 10 mg cabaser 1mg is how many mcg zovic 800 elocon lotion scalp nonprescription zofran duphalac dosage betacin medication side erexin maximum male strength pills tegretol bipolar medication penegra tablets at gnc differin cream adapalene prescription water pills online how to use vigora no perscription azithromocin tablets accutane lawsuit class action update atacand candesartan cilexetil 8mg 50 mg pfizer viagra for sale lasuna planting motrin and robitussin dont mix colcrys 0.6mg how to take viagra overnight delivery purchase cialis online cialis free trial coupon buy cialis in israel flomax side effects cheap viagra usa viagra cheap euro hydroxyzine pamoate vistaril drugibuprofen insulin syringes and needles buy esomeprazole buy accutane online search http kwrt index nootropil 800 mg piracetam rocket raccoon gun diane lane measurements oracea 40 mg coupons levofloxacin 750 mg tablet buy brand viagra online overnight albendazole dosage for dogs where to purchase chat lagyl zantac coupons samples 1st rx orders for clomid flazol medicine cabinets usa online pharmacy 2077 buy periactin weight gain pills mesterolone steroid use vicodin withdrawal symptoms cost of cialis for daily use secure buy cialis online europ benadryl for dogs dose naprosyn side effects ingredients is discount press legitimate altace ramipril capsules 5mg levofloxacin 500 mg usage wellbutrin for anxiety disorders metallica one youtube compra decialis clomid for men success stories night sweats increased urine output extenze pills side effects lanoxin 0.25 mg tablet furosemide medication for hypercalcemia hydrochlorathazide without prescription furolin tablets with windows epratenz dox leponex drug study 365pills complaints about doctors zyvox 600 mg foods to avoid order viagra online with echeck actavis promethazine codeine for sale clopidogrel bisulfate plavix risk levamisole wormer for sheep exelon corp opportunities people culture digoxina in english translation fluconozole dogs eutirox 50 efectos secundarios cialis to my door without perscription allegra d 12 hour viagra online sales ramipril 2.5mg capsules mincorp mining gazette insulin side effects for dogs donde puedo comprar cytotec viagra 50mg canada buy plavix in usa metallica songs youtube doctors in ri who prescribe propecia redustat pastillas estradiol levels ivf mirapex lawsuit mirapex restless leg syndrome douleur regle lortab 7.5mg avalide side effects irbesartan by safety and chep aricept binozyt 500 mg lipitor side effects muscle pain legs med cab reviews domperidone side effects gastroparesis amantedine no prescription canada usa albuterol inhaler usa overnight zyprexa 0 dollars 63 cent mupirocin uses bactroban online mexican pharmacy paroxetine hcl 40 mg side effects generic estrace pills elomet cream ointment viagra kopen tadapox onlin feldene flash 20mg piroxicam where is the safest plac ciprotab dosage of benadryl buy prozac mexico onlain filmebi qartulad clomid online buy overnight cialis en venta vardenafil 20 mg hydroxyzine hcl 10mg information doxycycline 100mg canada tadalafil over nighted wellbutrin withdrawal and weight gainwesthroid fasigyn tablets information literacy purchase maxalt tablets on line metformin 500 mg zyd can you buy viagra on line trusted medstore online alli where can i buy dutasteride avodart side effects glucovance side effects metformin xlpharmacy medications for ocd buy propecia online ketoconazole usa viagra mail order restonite ambien side buy lexapro with amex fucibet cream 30g cialis in pakistan price best generic viagra sites us online pharmacy cialis canada pharmacy 24 hours xlpharmacy medications diazepam 10mg tablets oxazepam us brand name walgreens take care clinic memphis tn carbimazole treatment dose livial tibolone treatment for bronchitis diamox side effects acetazolamide mechanism medications without a prescription mebendazole 100mg side effects sildalis reviews cheap tadifil pregnant man has baby takeda duetact coupon aspirin overdose death diane stretton vexatious litigant safe nonprecription sites for cilas overdose fluoxetine fafipa vestibular buy domperidone uk fastest way to get viagra viagra livraison rapide oracea doxycycline usp octreotide treatment for iih revista kosovarja zovirax ointment over the counter parcopa discontinued ralph benoquin cream before and after viagra 100mg brand buy cialis amazon canadianmeds 24hr pergotime in english mesterolone bodybuilding cialis italia gratis most trusted drug mail order sites viagra at discount ventolin dosage for children is there a generic cialis available viagra tablets online antara purchase online terbinafine cream for dogs the pharmacy express complaints thyroxine side effects in canines wee northwestpharmacy arthrotec generic names content analysis example arthrotec side effects nsaids como conprar cialis pheromones for men reviews suhagra 100 rx canada levitra after eating pheromones for women that work tramadol side effects medications for dogs beprogel lotion applicator doxycycline 100mg capsules side effects much does viagra cost walmart augmentin for sinus infection imitrex injection side effects buy alli weight loss pills increasing sperm count diet can i buy viagra in cvs pharmacy venta de viagra en worcester ma best price levitra 20 mg does doxycycline work for acne vilches radio shack pharmacy rx one review asthma inhalers shipped overnight metallica enter sandman video usa safty website to buy propecia clopidogrel 75mg what is vardenafil hcl 20mg tab isoptin 40mg side effects cytoxan chemotherapy for lupus viagra for sale in hong kong canada pharmacy cilias clomiphene for sale tijuana mexico pharmacy euroclinix uk basketball alphagan eye drops brimonidine tartrate silagra australia onlain tamashebi nadirobaze rythmol side effects medication pregnant cat litter does zofran help diarrhea valium and alcohol abuse sofilex capsuleshow clomiprimate from canada motilium tablets uses detrol la generic methotraxete canada no prescription orderpharma topix forum imitrex nasal spray buy online pay pal pharmacy sildenafil pfizer manly 100mg levitra online overnight delivery buy nolvadex and clomid cymbalta side effects in women christie brinkley retin a glaxo betnovate n cream new pregnant celebrities 2015 zithromax z pack for sale mastercard micardis side effects weight gain lotemax 0.5 triamterene hctzno prescription venlafaxine side effects 37.5 tadalafil soft gel capsule best viagra tablets in india for men amantadine sulfate retin a cream 0.05 20g eldepryl medication kamagra tablets for sale cheap 20mg nolvedex metformin tablets for sale how to buy zopiclone online canadian pharmacy valtrex buy viagra uk tesco alli best price cuvarlix review of fifty generic aripiprazole in mexico keppra side effects with alcohol cialis manufacturer coupon olmesartan drug side effects thuoc renapril 5mg cialis perlutex veterinary technician lopressor generic and trade name synthroid vs levothyroxine side effects where can i buy zovirax therapy for depression in children levitra 20 mg reviews can you take keflex for sinus infection aricept side effects alzheimers disease cheapest prozac online parcopa discontinued avon levitra prices buying viagra over the counter overnight prednisone over the counter inhaler 2013 depakote withdrawal symptoms drug cefalexina english antibioticos precio de omifin pastillas provera 10mg buy zocor warning side effects naproxen medication what for extended release depakote and weight gain canada pharmacy viagra sale generic sublingual viagra 50mg