Salman VS SRK – Will 2012 Be Final Or Semi Final

to begin with i must narrow down the debate. there are no more than 2 contenders for the position of  the biggest star of bollywood in the last 25 years. there is no aamir or akshay or even hrithik in the race, the competition is only between salman khan and sharukh khan.

2ndly perception and awards be damned, the real king will be decided on the basis  NUMBERS.

in 2012 if both salman films are big hits and srk’s yrf film is a flop or average, the final will be over

if one salman film is a big hit and one srk and one salman film flop or average, still the final will be over.

however if all three of these films flop, it will be status quo and the finals will be in 2013.

if both salman films are flop and srk film is a hit, this becomes the semi final year (as opposed to status quo) and again the finals will happen in 2013.

 

and if both slman films are like dabangg, hahk, maine pyaar kiya or bodyguard even amitabh fans will have to admit he is much ahead of big b. in a way it will be the finals for not the last two decades but the 100 years history of bollywood.

204 Comments

  1. javeed
    javeed
    February 24, 2012 at 12:52 PM

    Tanveerafridi,
    The post is about Salman and Srk and anything regarding both can be posted here.Now lets come to the topic,first tell me why do you count hits only,you should take into the consideration flops of both actors also and you will come to know that Salman will lead all there.My dear,just get your facts right from an authentic source and then compare Srk with salman.

  2. Alfa.one
    Alfa.one
    February 24, 2012 at 1:40 PM

    Suprabh have just posted 2 review clips of BG under the thread REAL SALMAN FANS. Have a look this guy tanveer afreedi must be one among them (sallu fans coming out of theater after watching the movie).

  3. rockie_c83
    rockie_c83
    February 24, 2012 at 11:09 PM

    @JTW: “This afridi is another addition to the pile of street shit accumulating in NG nowadays.”

    Who are you to call other’s as “Pile of Street Shit”?
    Cmon man have some respect for others.

    This tells a lot about your background and upbringing, the way you RESPECT other human’s.

  4. Jasp the Wasp
    Jasp the Wasp
    February 25, 2012 at 12:25 AM

    @rockie

    The way you foul-mouth particular stars certainly exposes your sort of upbringing as well, so don’t use the angelic innocence card please.

    @danish

    Yes yes whatever you said is true, Salman is great, Salman is all-powerful, salman is so great that the heavenly Gods are tripping over each other to touch Salman’s feet. Yes yes, everybody agrees.

  5. Prashant
    Prashant
    February 25, 2012 at 1:13 AM

    @Danish: Audience award ki baat na he karo woh IMPOTENT KHAN ko bahut mile hai jaise J-e-m,LD,VEER,GTGH,YHJ,SKPY etc etc.. Samjh gaye

  6. Yakuza
    Yakuza
    February 25, 2012 at 1:22 AM

    @Danish .. “ya i count boi data till age 46 for amitabh.”

    Ha Ha Ha ….

  7. Yakuza
    Yakuza
    February 25, 2012 at 1:43 AM

    @Danish .. Chal ek kaam kar .. tu 46 Age tak hi le (i.e. upto 1988) .. and give me anything less than 48-50 counts .. and that too from BOI(world famous anti-bachhcans)

    And if you are taking Age in to factor .. how come you saying this statement again and again that Record of maximum hits will also be broken soon ?? You mean you are going to include all upcoming movies of Salman and against only 40 movies of Amitabh .. :)

  8. Yakuza
    Yakuza
    February 25, 2012 at 1:49 AM

    BTW #BollywoodKaBaapAmitabh is trending on top today.

  9. Phantom
    Phantom
    February 25, 2012 at 1:52 AM

    why is #BollywoodKaBaapAmitabh trending?? has Aish’s baby been named Bollywood?

  10. Yakuza
    Yakuza
    February 25, 2012 at 2:12 AM

    @Danish .. and if you go by actual verdicts of existing source then .. i.e. Trade Guide .. Upto Age 42 .. i.e. 1984 He had 52 Successfull movies (with 30 Clean Hits) …. full brakup is ..

    8 Exceptional Hits(Crossed 1 Crore per territory), 10 Superhits, 12 Hits, 22 Average, 18 Flops (Total 70 movies)

    http://bollybusiness.wordpress.com/2011/12/03/amitabh-movies-verdict-1969-1984-by-trade-guideprakash-pange/

    Let Salman break his records which he achieved @Age 42 .. then talk about 46 and later.

  11. rockie_c83
    rockie_c83
    February 25, 2012 at 2:45 AM

    Bakri Khan .. ye naam bohot pasand aaya … :D

    background mei Bakri mi awaz bhi chahiye …

  12. rockie_c83
    rockie_c83
    February 25, 2012 at 2:46 AM

    Yakuza:
    Are kitne din Big B ki pooorani filmei lekar baithe rahoge??
    Jitna Big B ne kamaya usse kahi jyada uske Nikamme bete ne gawaya hai.

    Pataa nahi kya paap kiya tha Big B ne jo aisi Nikammi aulad paida ho gayi ghar pe?

  13. Yakuza
    Yakuza
    February 25, 2012 at 10:58 AM

    @rockie_c83 .. kab tak Amitabh se muh modne ke liye topic ke beech mein Abhishek ko laate rahoge ?

    Vaise to logo ne Danish ke faltu ke bogus bakchodi wale threads pe comments karna band kar diya hai .. muzhe bhi koi interest nahi hai bhains ke aage been bajane mein .. lekin jab koi apni aukaat se aage badta ja raha ho .. usko kabhi kabhi aaina dikhana bhi zaroori hai ..

    The most ridiculous thing while showing the mirror to any Salman fan(i guess only Danish, rest are not bad) is that putting yourself in a situation where argument are against two of your favorite stars. There is some fondness and affection to Salman within me .. and fans like Danish are doing great job stobage his fan base.

  14. Jasp the Wasp
    Jasp the Wasp
    February 25, 2012 at 1:44 PM

    @danish

    Whose irritation, yours? I can understand that. I back up Yakuza’s statement:- nobody is really bothered about your bogus figures and analysis. Amitabh>>Salman any day.

  15. Jasp the Wasp
    Jasp the Wasp
    February 25, 2012 at 2:07 PM

    @danish

    If I comment on your thread it doesn’t mean I’m bothered with your figures; I came here to talk about something entirely different. Obviously you won’t understand that and are too lazy to browse through the comments, but jumping and shouting without thinking will ultimately put you as the idiot, not me.

  16. Jasp the Wasp
    Jasp the Wasp
    February 25, 2012 at 2:16 PM

    A big problem is that I can’t find the proper smiley site when I want to use it. Damn, I must favourite it :(

    I really want to use 10 laugh-roll smileys for this crap comment and excuse danish is giving to cover up his embarrassed a**; unfortunate I can’t find the site now.

  17. Yakuza
    Yakuza
    February 25, 2012 at 2:34 PM

    @Danish … so your count now comes to 44 .. Ha Ha .. Yaar counting to theek se kar le ..

    Chal Main tuzhe batata hun count kaise karte hain ..

    The movies which are listed in bogus site BOI but you skip counting :

    1. Kabhi Kabhi
    2. Adaalat
    3. Ganga Ki Saugandh
    4. Shahenshah
    5, Barsaat Ki Ek Raat

    And movies which are not listed in BOI, but are success as per Trade Guide :

    6. Mahaan
    7. Pukaar
    8. Inqulaab
    9. Mili
    10. Bemisaal
    11. Silsila
    12. Manzil
    13. Ganga Ki Saugandh
    14. Jurmaana

    So now adding these 14 movies to your list of 44 … will give you total 58 ….. and that too till age of 46 as desired by you .. :)

    (Kya yaar .. Gireftaar likh ke ehsaan jata raha hai .. aur jo 14 movies skip kar di uska kya ??? Kam se kam research and counting to sahi rakh).

  18. Yakuza
    Yakuza
    February 25, 2012 at 3:46 PM

    And no .. With these 57 movies, nothing like Saat hindustaani or Do aur do paanch are included. All data is from BOI(ur fav site) and only movies(8 films) which are absent in BOI are taken from Trade Guide.

    Diff between BOI and Trade Guide is that BOI scaled down the verdicts of Many Amitabh movies (Instead they should have elevated the verdicts given their theatrical collection only system ..)

  19. Yakuza
    Yakuza
    February 25, 2012 at 6:09 PM

    @Danish .. tu aadami hai ya ghanchakkar ?? You mean if BOI not listed 9 movies .. this means they were never released ??

    1. Mahaan
    2. Pukaar
    3. Inqulaab
    4. Mili
    5. Bemisaal
    6. Silsila
    7. Manzil
    8. Jurmaana
    9. Gireftaar

    And if you believe these movies were never released then why you taken Gireftaar in your first list ?????

    Kuch bhi ???

    And above all .. Whats point taken Data from BOI if they don’t have complete list ????

  20. Ank
    Ank
    February 29, 2012 at 10:59 AM

    @yakuza
    ya srk is still ahead due to boi is fake verdicts.

    1. Yakuza
      Yakuza
      February 29, 2012 at 12:17 PM

      Yeah, but Danish accepts only BOI for Salman .. otherwise i happy to take filminformation numbers and verdicts .. ;)

  21. Jasp the Wasp
    Jasp the Wasp
    February 29, 2012 at 1:47 PM

    @danish

    Bolti band ho gayi? Your deperate attempts to convince that salman was “biggest superstar of bollywood for 23 years” has fallen through the floor and landed with a resounding thud. Face it, SRK and Aamir are LEAGUES ahead.

    @ank

    Proof hai tumhare paas? No. You just want to blabber day-in-day-out that BOI is fake. Now I declare that Dabangg’s BB status by BOI is also a big fake and a piece of paid news; like this, I can call EVERY Salman film’s BB status as fake and paid for to BOI, but I don’t. I’m not as stupid as you.

  22. Ank
    Ank
    February 29, 2012 at 4:14 PM

    In anil kapoor words ” are purani baaton par mitti dalo, abhi toh salman top pe hai na with three consecutive blockbusters,”
    @ danish
    bhai aap kyun gade murde ukhadkar inn haters ko bolne ka mauka dete hai just enjoy the success of salman khan and please only post about ett and dabangg2…aur srk ki halat iss samay kya hai woh hum sab jaante hi hai….aur rahi baat amitabh ki toh ng per sirf aap hi hai jo salman ko amitabh se compare karte hai…salman ke fan hai aap sunkar accha lagta hai lekin doosre actors se itni nafrat kyun karte hain aap.

  23. rockie_c83
    rockie_c83
    March 1, 2012 at 5:30 AM

    @Yakuza: “Yeah, but Danish accepts only BOI for Salman .. otherwise i happy to take filminformation numbers and verdicts ”

    What are the filminformation verdicts for Players, KHJJS, Raavan, Drona, Budda, Teen Patti??

    All time disaster .. :D

    njoi ..

  24. rockie_c83
    rockie_c83
    March 1, 2012 at 5:31 AM

    @Jtw: “Face it, SRK and Aamir are LEAGUES ahead.”

    Poor Srk fans have to take help of Aamir’s name, kya kare a Srk ke naam pe to kuch chalta hi nahi. :P

  25. Jasp the Wasp
    Jasp the Wasp
    March 3, 2012 at 1:31 PM

    @danish

    Comments dekh ke toh yehi dekh sakta hoon ki tu faltu mein bahut desperate ho raha hai. Its great that you have such fanatic love for Sallu, but at the cost of logic this love can be dangerous. I know you will try to give some sort of answer to this, like “yeah yeah tera SRK ka kya hua?” etc. You can never defend Sallu without bringing SRK (who is way way ahead of Sallu) and you just end up making a fool of yourself. The bigger problem? That there are other fools like rockie who are supporting you in this Sallu-God-like chanting and shouting and ranting.

  26. Dino
    Dino
    March 3, 2012 at 5:45 PM

    Yakuza numbers mein to Salman is miles and miles behind Amitabh infact he is even behind SRK and there is no doubt in that. Anyways you forgot a very important indicator of Super Stardom which is classics and great performances. Can you imagine the difference in that indicator. I don’t even want to take the pain of listing Bachchan classics as they are aplenty. For Salman, barring Madhuri dominated HAHK its a pain to even try and find a classic movie.

    1. Yakuza
      Yakuza
      March 3, 2012 at 11:53 PM

      @Dino .. Quality can be discussed only with quality conscious people, Danish is poor even in analyzing numbers, leave about actual quality of movie.

  27. Jasp the Wasp
    Jasp the Wasp
    March 3, 2012 at 8:27 PM

    @Dino

    HAHK was classic, MPK also maybe. Nothing else. For Amitabh, strangely one of my fav films of his is The Great Gambler. Yakuza, are you sure that was a flop?

    1. Yakuza
      Yakuza
      March 3, 2012 at 10:29 PM

      Yes, it was flop. In early 80’s any movie with little feel of urban setting was failing .. back then Shaan under-performed which was way too technical advance movie for audience too enjoy. Great gambler with foreign locales was going out of head for masses (And masses at that time was lower class). Same was fate of Dharmendra’s big budgeted Shalimaar and Burning Train because of urban settings.

  28. Dino
    Dino
    March 3, 2012 at 11:43 PM

    JTW agreed MPK could be a classic as well.

  29. Yakuza
    Yakuza
    March 4, 2012 at 12:01 AM

    1. Yakuza
      Yakuza
      March 4, 2012 at 1:06 AM

      A corrected list after removing some miss and blink appearances which were included before :

  30. rockie_c83
    rockie_c83
    March 4, 2012 at 1:42 AM

    Yakuza .. why are big B nbrs only till 1994??
    Add them to list as well. Then we will see how much is the success ratio?

  31. Naveed_EkThaTiger
    Naveed_EkThaTiger
    March 4, 2012 at 11:45 AM

    I don’t wish to indulge in what film broke what or who is the biggest as I have done that for the last 3 years and frankly am now bored of it

    All I know is that how on earth people have the cheek to include many Salman films as flops when he is not even in lead role and then to take the piss even further (hypothetically speaking) when they don’t credit him with the successful films. You can’t have it both ways.

    Now Salman fans – chill and relax Salman is doing extremely well and just wait for the hurricane of Ek Tha Tiger :)

    and then the massive storm of Dabangg 2 few months later……

Page 2 of 3 1 2 3

Post Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.