Masala Art: Kyun Genre Genre Karte Ho!!

Genre is not the word. Entertainment is. Connect is. The audience will reject a movie that fails to fulfill either the entertainment thing, or the connect thing-

You cannot define a movie as masala or art- all movies are piece of art- they may be good to some- bad to some- I don’t understand this fondness to put words and definitions to abstract and subjective things-

All movies are commercial ventures (except student films and some documentaries I guess). All of them are intended to make money. So, the terminology of a film being commercial and non-commercial is baseless. The movies termed as ‘non-commercial’ are usually low budget ones, intending to reach a limited audience (due to various reasons ranging from the subject of the film to the star-cast to the distribution acceptance)

“Genre is a class or category of artistic endeavor having a particular form, content, technique, or the like”

Coming to the question that made me curious. Is there a successful genre? A safe genre? One that guarantees success? I would say no…

Over the years we have seen all kinds of movies work and make tons of money. This is specially true for the west, where even the obscure movies find takers and do tons of business. These views have an underlying assumption (which I believe to be true), that audiences everywhere in the world are the same- they will like a film only when it engages them (of course different movies have different ways of engaging the audience)- it is same for the people in India (due to different sensibilities only the ways to engage the audience differs).

The most striking example to elucidate the point is of course, Taare Zameen Pe and Welcome releasing on the same day and doing great business. Two most common reactions to this statement would be-
1. Aamir is a huge star- a mark of quality, trust and belief in the audience.
2. Welcome was a safe genre- MASALA (every-time I read this word, a imagine of the writer salivating and licking his/her lips comes to my mind- weird thing- but it make me laugh so I don’t try to suppress it)

The answer to the TZP/Welcome success story is that both movies were loved because both managed to engaged and entertain the audience- of course the method both adopted were diverse- And of course the wider audience trusts the ‘Welcome’ method more readily than the ‘TZP’ method- And why is that- because the ‘TZP’ method is the tough to implement- and if not done correctly can lead the audience to depression/irritation/remorse/anger- While welcome had elements that had seen a lot of success before- so initial trust was easily gained- So am I contradicting my earlier point that there is nothing as a safe genre? No I am not-

While the so called commercial movies are deemed as safe bets at the box office (Ready and Bodyguard are according to many here the safest way to make money)- these come with very high stakes attached- Ready needed to do 95 Cr nett just to break even- In this age of connectivity, word of mouth spreads like wildfire- And it is these costs attached that make such genres unsafe- Frankly there is nothing worse than watching a movie that is doing everything to entertain- but is still unable to do it)

On the other hand the so called ‘non-commercial’ ventures have to bear with the gradual acceptance of the subject and the movie- Their costs attached are low, but they see lesser initial rush- they need to connect else they don’t manage to pull audiences in- TZP saw a dull opening as compared to Welcome; even SRK’s Chak De opened to dull houses- isn’t SRK a huge star? Isn’t YRF banner the biggest in India? The thing is that there was a lack of trust associated with the genre- when this trust was gained- there was no stopping this movie-

So the bottom-line is- TZP and Welcome, both were successful in engaging the audience- and hence were commercially successful too- And that all genres have equal chance of success (only thing is that their route to success is different)

Cheers

56 Comments

  1. Ihab
    Ihab
    September 8, 2011 at 3:50 PM

    @ Suprabh

    Thats an excellent comment right there. Agreed completely.

    @ Piyush

    I do think there is a little confusion. I will share my views in sometime.

  2. danish
    danish
    September 8, 2011 at 4:37 PM

    @dwnpiyush – we are close to 2012. its been 20 years. so which film do you think ppl remember fondly frm 1992. beta the biggest hit of the year, saleem langde pe mat ro, the arthouse classic or jo jeeta wahi sikandar, the middleclass’s fave movie?
    well the answer is beta, the multiple telecast of it across the channels and ratings.

    a smaller section of middleclass ment, who were between 14-30 when jo jeeta wahi sikandar released recall it more fondly, but televsion ratings suggest it isnt the most well remembered.

    as for my fave of the three, saleem langde pe mat ro, nobody wud even recall the name. so plz try to understand. forget 20, even 100 years later different ppl will remember fondly different films. the arty types, the amita mailks and rajendra yadavs and uma vasudev, the india habitat centre/prithvi theatre type would remember saleem langde…. the corpotrate yuppy type swud remember jo jeeta but majority would dstill lap up beta when ever ist telecast on tv. scases in point aan milo sajna (frm anothet 20 years back 1972) gets better tv ratings than ankur and koshish.

    @shilac – that still doesnt answer why cant we call dabangg a better film than taare/chak de? especially when more ppl bought tickets of dabangg?

    @bodyguard papa- ye kya baat huio. piyush sensible hai, hum kyaa aapko sensible nahin lagte??

    @serenzy – but wat makes u so sure that taare/chak de are better films than ready???? its just ur feeling. how many ppl share it30 cr??? thats still less than 75 cr who think dabangg is better. and 3 idiots doent become the besetest movie ever money wise. you have to make inflation adjustment (based on ticket price rise) and that makes sholay the best film ever in bollywood and there is no way you can prove otherwise.

  3. Serenzy
    Serenzy
    September 8, 2011 at 7:21 PM

    @danish………

    but,how can sholay be once for all proven as the best movie ever made in bollywood only because it is the highest grossing film of all times???

    u cant equate a movies merits with the BO……..
    they can never be mixed together……

    a different list can be put up for highest grossing film of all times…..and a different list for ‘movies to watch brfore u die’ kind of list…..
    a movies BO performance cannot be the judge of the movies merits……

    surely,3I,ready,dabangg did superb business at the BO…….
    but just because of that,a ready cannot be a better movie then say a Taare Zameen Par………..
    now u will say why isnt ready better as it had more collections then TZP???

    now,that cant be explained properly…..there’s this inward feeling from the heart itself when u see a movie irrespective of its fate at the BO that -“wow,wat a movie…..!!!”

    when one likes a movie tooo much,does one see how did it perform at the BO…???

  4. rajesh
    rajesh
    September 8, 2011 at 7:55 PM

    “but just because of that,a ready cannot be a better movie then say a Taare Zameen Par………..”

    Hmmm, during my school days, in elementery mathematics, we were being taught bracket concept. The first case is say, “write in bracket the highest mountain peak in world.” Now, there will be only one correct answer of this and everbody will write the same answer if they are correct.
    Now, take the second case, “write in bracket the bset hill station in the world”. And, the chaptor tells that these type of qustions cant be answered as these are subjective matters.

    Regarding Ready and TZP, I liked none of these (YES, I didn’t like TZP), my wife liked Ready more than TZP.

  5. rajesh
    rajesh
    September 8, 2011 at 7:59 PM

    It is ‘best hill station’ not ‘bset hill station’ in my previous comment, edit is not working.

  6. danish
    danish
    September 8, 2011 at 8:53 PM

    @serenzy – because 10 cr ppl, almost 15% of the country’s population at that time voted for sholay by buyingg its ticket. thats never happened with any indian film. the second biiggest public endorsement of the quality of any indian film was hum aapke hain kaun. just a handful of ppl cant decide which is the best film.

    how do u define merit? is there a universal definition of merit?

    the liist of highest grossing film will automatically have the democratic public endorsement of their quality. the list of ‘movies to watach before you die’ would essentially be the opinion of one person (or at best a group of ppl, unless it was published after taking a comprehensive survey of the entire country, covering every individual)

    a movie’s footfall (not revenue) can be the only definitive universal judge of its quality. thats the only scientific truth.

    ready is without doubt a better film than a taare zameen par as close to 50 lakh ppl endorsed taare’s quality by buying its tickets while close to 1.20 cr ppl endorsed its quality by buying ready’s tickets.

    the “inward feeling from the heart” is different for different ppl. for me that happens when i watch tere naam. does that make it the greatest film ? no!

    when one likes a movie too much and doesnt care for its boxoffice performance.,, it becomes his/her favourite film, not the best/good film.

    exactly rajesh. but agin the best hill station, if it must be declared will have to be the one that maximum number of ppl write. same for films.

Page 2 of 2 1 2

Post Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

how effective is albenza for pinworms nexium otc vs prescription keflex dosage for uti treatment buy viagra without a script viagra gold usa natural doxycycline hyclate replacement cialis canada price wholesale viagra mexican pharmacies in tojuana morphine sulfate side effects medication sublingual drugs sumycin syrup norman generic viagra without a prescription online pharmacy sleep medication lamisil over the counter canada pravachol and grapefruit interaction buy paroxetine mexico fluoxetine prozac dosage prevacid vs prilosec vs zegerid purchase clomid using paypal flomaxtra australia weather arthrotec side effects nsaids asthmahaler mist buy viagra canada 50 mg pharmacy canadian pharmacy quick shipping bupropion hcl xl 150 mg viagra loan online sildenafil 50 mg prices lotrel side effects reviews vermox 100mg how much is flovent without insurance cholesterol lowering diet foods tramadol overnight mastercard metallica nothing else matters lyrics and chords sinequanone clothing fashion website yasmine petty is a man med cab reviews side effects of levofloxacin 750 mg side effects lamisil side effects liver damage lozol medication side effects buy prescription drugs without doctor diovan generic available when amoxicillin dosage chart for cats rhinathiol expectorant cough suppressant colchicine online no prescription citalopram where can i buy it xalatan coupon phamacy canana non prescription haldol decanoate injection package insert florinef 0.1 mg medication alphagan ophthalmic solution cost paroxetine side effects drugs pure raspberry ketones naproxen 500 mg side effects ranitidine 300 mg canada orlistat otc macrobid 100mg capsule dosage provera and clomid success rates generic sublingual viagra 50mg levothroid medication generic xeloda capecitabine 500 mg order teva generic cefadroxil side effects doctor mercury drug price list of medicines albuterol sulfate inhalation solution 0.083 side effects 39 vigara sinequanone dresses orange ramipril 2.5mg side effects doxylamine succinate vs diphenhydramine ibuprofen dosage for dogs naprosyn medication walgreens pharmacy drugs que son paratextos clomid with script fast shipping buy liquid tamoxifen citrate doxylamine succinate 25 mg overdoses amoxicillin for cats for sale buy cialis from a reputable co ciproxin 500 mg aldactone / spironolactone for hair loss xlpharmacy canada revenue where can i buy cyotec in the us cholesterol medications with the least side effects jasmine pilchard gosnell pregnant yasmin deliz feet levofloxacin 500 mg usage flexeril 10 mg side effects 24 hour medstore what is cost of levitra at walgreens quinine sulfate 325 mg capsules anxiety definition apa next day delivery pharmacy rimonabant acomplia india luvox dosage for anxiety apetamin p pills cialis 5 mg costo valtrex for sale in the uk discount cialis 5mg increasing sperm count and motility naturally free world pharmacy nifedipine dosage preterm labor elavil for sleep apnea oracea side effects doxycycline acne block diagram motohome mercury drug price list of medicine xanax withdrawal symptoms treatment can you buy cialis over the counter citrate toxicity and crrt online pharmacxy roaccuntane buy is it illegal to buy propecia online cheap lexapro 20mg order clonidine online overnight azithromycin 500 mg viagra online for men canadian pharmacy reviews 2012 benazepril 10 mg images thalidomide history in europe celebrex medication interactions yasmine akram imdb levitra vs cialis vs viagra cost 143 cialis for slae cheap too much cialis cholesterol lowering foods and supplements salzarex thyroxine chloromycetin kaufen ebay levitra online drugstore viagra flovent hfa 220 mcg inhaler clenbuterol side effects athletes foot order antibiotics online uk nootropil 800 mg piracetam nasonex side effects hallucinations alendronate sodium fosamax dosage avelox side effects medications reviews of generic viagra cialis 800mg what is difference in sotalol and sotalol af lumigan generic drops mometasone furoate cream 0.1 used for cialis with dapoxetine 80mg prednisone canadian pharmnacy verapamil er 180 mg tablet accutane at a discounted rate mestinon medication for myasthenia gravis cuckold creek hollywood md real estate remove vosteran search engine lisinopril combinations mentat himalaya herbals shipping viagra in 3 8 days price for viagra why was etodolac discontinued diamox sequels vs diamox amaryl medication generic combivent respimat coupon belgium viagra macrobid and breastfeeding prinivil side effects medication minomycin 50 mg viagra adapalene differin side effects canadian pharmacy cialis professional nymphomax in india synthroid dosage dose drugs for depression and anxiety buy kamagra online sildenafil pfizer lergigan biverkningar av morfin suhagra 50 bluemountain pharmacy cymbalta medication for fibromyalgia buspar dosage range lipitor online no prescription sertraline hcl 25 mg doxycap doxycycline phexin bd tablets at walmart sildenafil citrate from india lipitor side effects muscle pain legs buy viagra without a prescription using domperidone for gastroparesis glucotrol xl 5mg 10mg vagiral ovulos de sabilavagravaiagravaigaravaigravairgavalium furolin medicine diazepam for dogs over the counter metformin best alternative to viagra doxycycline overnight pfizer blue pill vgr 100 albuterol inhaler dosage children cialis 5mg generic sale can a man use hydroxycut max for women octreotide injection rest el bohio ciales ciales amantadine hcl cream olmesartan om line sotalol side effects betapace af avalide side effects weight gain catafast sachets packaging albuterol inhaler dosage for adults leponex tableta dejstvo surutke estrace estradiol aspirin overdose death triderm cream generic pfizer viagra coupon z pak without prescription cheap propecia no rx seroxat antidepressant doctors levofloxacin side effects after levitra prescription coupon let me watch this discount health and beauty products pak online diovan hct side effects forum dublin pharmacy to sale kamagra pheromones for men reviews aristocort cream 0.1 accutane no prescription geriforte ingredients in benadryl tri levlen generic where to get cialis online where can i buy nitroglycerin ointment celecoxib mechanism of action ppt buying lipitor without a script benefits of clomid for men what is phenamax reviewsphexin recommended viagia sites uroxatral vs flomax medication canadian medicine estrogen pills uk crestor price gufulvin without a prescription zofran medication dosage gupisone prednisolone 5 mg usage statistics famvir dosage cold sore paroxetine 10 mg and weed promethazine vc syrup drug cialis information 10mg price of doxycycline at walgreens cialis kantucky safe propecia how to treat bacterial vaginosis buy citalopram online uk viagra like over the counter lortab 7.5mg citalopram 20 mg side effects weight loss where to buy lantus insulin zentel albendazole 0.2g alli back in stock colchicine no prescription torsemide 20 mg and lupus buy stimulant no scripts fast delievery altace medication dosage rx one online review zyprexa medication what is it used for hyzaar side effects with alcohol anxiety definition regenon 25mg sertraline actos warnings risk baytril for rats for sale estrotab 2mg dilaudid cadex 2 mg warning caution arimidex bodybuilding aromatase inhibitor propranolol hydrochloride adverse effects raloxifene breast cancer treatment fast delivery viagra z pack antibiotic prices buy atorvastatin 20mg chloroquine phosphate injection tiotropium pronunciation antibiotics and alcohol side effects buy cialis in singapore 166 extenze male enhancement drink generic viagra costa rica doxycycline hyclate uses treat cymbalta medication dosage buy clomid online uk chemist flomax for kidney stones how long does it take overnight medications viagra black fake birth control pills for sale doxycycline 100mg canada clonidine 0.2mg tablets cheap cialis generic online viagra price list caffeine pills walgreens propecia price australia canadian drug fail mall casodex 50 mg bicalutamide side effects digoxin side effects digoxin toxicity irbesartan 300 mg tablet side effects cephalexin 500 mg capsule dosage keftab cephalexin dosage tofranil drug information mexican steroids pharmacy viagra without prescription in usa xenical side effects forum walmart minoxidil 5 for women sunsuria group of companies maxifort zimax 100 mg viagra buy houston femara infertility success nexium esomeprazole 20mg in uk ferility drugs for sale in canada omnicef 300 mg capsule entocort and ulcerative colitis thalidomide multiple myeloma side effects pulmicort flexhaler 180 mcg price captopril 12.5mg betafusin cream of tartar bactrim no prescription canada olanzapine 10 mg side effects cycline family of antibiotics best viagra online pharmacy viagra coupons walmart femara letrozole fertility protocol zenerx reviews in medical journals zetia 10 mg walmart micardis medication side effects benicar hct 40 12.5 discount card cialis 5mg from canadian pharmacy donepezil hcl 10mg tab pyridium medication is used for what etodolac side effects kidney no prescription warfarin how to use penegra 50 sildenafil citrate 100mg tablets lotrisone cream medication over the counter escitalopram online india prazosin side effects weight gain brahmi herbal medicine 1477 finasteride lisinopril dosage 2.5 mg ventolin inhaler side effects order nitroglycerin naproxen sodium 220 mg flomist cipla pharmaceuticals tamsulosin hcl 0.4 mg capsule what is it for best online canadian pharcharmy metrondiazonale for cats with ibd asthma inhalers online canada flonase nasal spray generic viagra paypal checkout kamagrafast brighton ski daily cialis is it better milnacipran for depression latisse for eyebrows before and after 265 painkillers without a prescription buy femora cialis australia best online pharmacy brand cialis espn viagara omeprazole 40 mg atrial fibrillation zenerx a scam buy arimidex cytotec lima luvox cr coupon mometasone furoate ointment usp 0.1 uses doxinyl medication for anxiety clopidogrel bisulfate 75mg cost mexitil mexiletine medrol canadian no prescription mild acne accutane before and after pictures lansoprazole 30 mg magnesium deficiency symptoms in plants mesterolone bodybuilding supplements eltroxin tablets vosteran removal tool v.1.2 glucovance generic name coumadin for sale super avana reviews best website to by viagra cuvarlix taken after or before meal grace subutex withdrawal in newborns is zifi 200mg tablets causes sleep female viagra in india oxytrol india dianabol side effects on women capoten sublingual flomist cipla field how to get plavix for free alphagan 0.1 patient assistance viagra noprescription viagra canada pharmacy rx dth 24 b kamal kunj mumbai india phentermine diet pills for sale clopidogrel side effects stroke best legal on line site to buy cialis flagyl and alcohol how long to wait atenolol side effects in cats salzarex tramadol capsules 100mg prices for cialis generic sotalex medicine dictionary alendronate sodium side effects medication vgr 100 piroxicam 20 mg capsule side effects order doxycycline 100mg 351 powpill 100 omeprazol igual que cytotec best web site for brand name viagra cyclo progynova ivf black cockapoo puppies for sale in ohio can you snort meloxicam etodolac er beprogel scalpel online viagra prescription bisoprolol fumarate 5mg ta san how much is propecia at pharmacy mexico pharmacy no prescription paroxetine hydrochloride extended release rocket power games diclofenac sodium 75mg minocycline hydrochloride for dogs side effects nizagara ingredients crestor walgreens price progesterone only birth control effectiveness buy inderal mastercard mometasone cream for eczema prednisone withdrawal symptoms doctor europe online pharmacy online viagra without a prescriptuon 40 viagra 99 dollars top legitimate online pharmachies river pharmacy canada famciclovir drug how to buy calais from canada codeine cough syrup mexican pharmacies online cheap lamotrigine 100mg picture xlpharmacy medications celexa withdrawal symptoms last 24hr pharmacy no perscription cialis daily 5 mg viagra overnight order by phone buy zyvox with mastercard primatene mist inhaler refill for sale fluoxetine 10mg cap ibuprofen for dogs veterinarianimiquimod zyprexa withdrawal symptoms medication lesofat side effects orlistat rocket stoves costco flovent temovate cream 0 05 uses for vinegar sertraline zoloft reviewssibutramine cheap flagyl no prescriptions overnight singulair side effects weight gain tryptizol dosage calculator cialis purchace walgreens careers apply online is it safe to buy generic cialis online indocin for gout dosage 689 buy liquid antibiotics online farmaci generici cialis indomethacin gout treatment dosing bactrim chew quien a comprado cytotec en usa lowest priced doxycycline anything otc like viagra or cialis valium 5mg drug generic viagra buy online online apotheke deutschland cialis vimax detox reviews magnesium side effects supplements topiramate 25mg used for flazol medicine cabinets tofranil drug uses online pharmacy promethazine codeine flomaxtra xl uk lisinopril no script metformin hydrochloride extended release 500 mg rx pharmacy viagra mumbai newport gwent viagra can you get high off indomethacin terbutaline sulfate and pregnancy lorinol 10mg percocet metazole tablets with keyboards zithromax online uk lidocaine ointment usp 5 back pain differin reviews clozapine and agranulocytosis zofran ex acyclovir for cold sores azithromycin cause constipation actos medication side effects rogaine for eyebrows side effects alli at australian pharmacies viagra pill for sale citrate synthase regulation online viagra review ventolin inhalers for sale doxycycline hyclate for sinus infection levitra scaduto nortriptyline recreational use novolax laxative diet buy cephalexin online novolog flexpen coupon amerimedrx model mayhem ativan withdrawal with zoloft zestoretic side effects lisinopril eltroxin 0 1mg folic acid buy plavix on line no prescription imitrex migraine medication dosage microcidal 500mg tylenol danazol treatment in hereditary angioedema