Masala Art: Kyun Genre Genre Karte Ho!!

Genre is not the word. Entertainment is. Connect is. The audience will reject a movie that fails to fulfill either the entertainment thing, or the connect thing-

You cannot define a movie as masala or art- all movies are piece of art- they may be good to some- bad to some- I don’t understand this fondness to put words and definitions to abstract and subjective things-

All movies are commercial ventures (except student films and some documentaries I guess). All of them are intended to make money. So, the terminology of a film being commercial and non-commercial is baseless. The movies termed as ‘non-commercial’ are usually low budget ones, intending to reach a limited audience (due to various reasons ranging from the subject of the film to the star-cast to the distribution acceptance)

“Genre is a class or category of artistic endeavor having a particular form, content, technique, or the like”

Coming to the question that made me curious. Is there a successful genre? A safe genre? One that guarantees success? I would say no…

Over the years we have seen all kinds of movies work and make tons of money. This is specially true for the west, where even the obscure movies find takers and do tons of business. These views have an underlying assumption (which I believe to be true), that audiences everywhere in the world are the same- they will like a film only when it engages them (of course different movies have different ways of engaging the audience)- it is same for the people in India (due to different sensibilities only the ways to engage the audience differs).

The most striking example to elucidate the point is of course, Taare Zameen Pe and Welcome releasing on the same day and doing great business. Two most common reactions to this statement would be-
1. Aamir is a huge star- a mark of quality, trust and belief in the audience.
2. Welcome was a safe genre- MASALA (every-time I read this word, a imagine of the writer salivating and licking his/her lips comes to my mind- weird thing- but it make me laugh so I don’t try to suppress it)

The answer to the TZP/Welcome success story is that both movies were loved because both managed to engaged and entertain the audience- of course the method both adopted were diverse- And of course the wider audience trusts the ‘Welcome’ method more readily than the ‘TZP’ method- And why is that- because the ‘TZP’ method is the tough to implement- and if not done correctly can lead the audience to depression/irritation/remorse/anger- While welcome had elements that had seen a lot of success before- so initial trust was easily gained- So am I contradicting my earlier point that there is nothing as a safe genre? No I am not-

While the so called commercial movies are deemed as safe bets at the box office (Ready and Bodyguard are according to many here the safest way to make money)- these come with very high stakes attached- Ready needed to do 95 Cr nett just to break even- In this age of connectivity, word of mouth spreads like wildfire- And it is these costs attached that make such genres unsafe- Frankly there is nothing worse than watching a movie that is doing everything to entertain- but is still unable to do it)

On the other hand the so called ‘non-commercial’ ventures have to bear with the gradual acceptance of the subject and the movie- Their costs attached are low, but they see lesser initial rush- they need to connect else they don’t manage to pull audiences in- TZP saw a dull opening as compared to Welcome; even SRK’s Chak De opened to dull houses- isn’t SRK a huge star? Isn’t YRF banner the biggest in India? The thing is that there was a lack of trust associated with the genre- when this trust was gained- there was no stopping this movie-

So the bottom-line is- TZP and Welcome, both were successful in engaging the audience- and hence were commercially successful too- And that all genres have equal chance of success (only thing is that their route to success is different)



  1. Ihab
    September 8, 2011 at 3:50 PM

    @ Suprabh

    Thats an excellent comment right there. Agreed completely.

    @ Piyush

    I do think there is a little confusion. I will share my views in sometime.

  2. danish
    September 8, 2011 at 4:37 PM

    @dwnpiyush – we are close to 2012. its been 20 years. so which film do you think ppl remember fondly frm 1992. beta the biggest hit of the year, saleem langde pe mat ro, the arthouse classic or jo jeeta wahi sikandar, the middleclass’s fave movie?
    well the answer is beta, the multiple telecast of it across the channels and ratings.

    a smaller section of middleclass ment, who were between 14-30 when jo jeeta wahi sikandar released recall it more fondly, but televsion ratings suggest it isnt the most well remembered.

    as for my fave of the three, saleem langde pe mat ro, nobody wud even recall the name. so plz try to understand. forget 20, even 100 years later different ppl will remember fondly different films. the arty types, the amita mailks and rajendra yadavs and uma vasudev, the india habitat centre/prithvi theatre type would remember saleem langde…. the corpotrate yuppy type swud remember jo jeeta but majority would dstill lap up beta when ever ist telecast on tv. scases in point aan milo sajna (frm anothet 20 years back 1972) gets better tv ratings than ankur and koshish.

    @shilac – that still doesnt answer why cant we call dabangg a better film than taare/chak de? especially when more ppl bought tickets of dabangg?

    @bodyguard papa- ye kya baat huio. piyush sensible hai, hum kyaa aapko sensible nahin lagte??

    @serenzy – but wat makes u so sure that taare/chak de are better films than ready???? its just ur feeling. how many ppl share it30 cr??? thats still less than 75 cr who think dabangg is better. and 3 idiots doent become the besetest movie ever money wise. you have to make inflation adjustment (based on ticket price rise) and that makes sholay the best film ever in bollywood and there is no way you can prove otherwise.

  3. Serenzy
    September 8, 2011 at 7:21 PM


    but,how can sholay be once for all proven as the best movie ever made in bollywood only because it is the highest grossing film of all times???

    u cant equate a movies merits with the BO……..
    they can never be mixed together……

    a different list can be put up for highest grossing film of all times…..and a different list for ‘movies to watch brfore u die’ kind of list…..
    a movies BO performance cannot be the judge of the movies merits……

    surely,3I,ready,dabangg did superb business at the BO…….
    but just because of that,a ready cannot be a better movie then say a Taare Zameen Par………..
    now u will say why isnt ready better as it had more collections then TZP???

    now,that cant be explained properly…..there’s this inward feeling from the heart itself when u see a movie irrespective of its fate at the BO that -“wow,wat a movie…..!!!”

    when one likes a movie tooo much,does one see how did it perform at the BO…???

  4. rajesh
    September 8, 2011 at 7:55 PM

    “but just because of that,a ready cannot be a better movie then say a Taare Zameen Par………..”

    Hmmm, during my school days, in elementery mathematics, we were being taught bracket concept. The first case is say, “write in bracket the highest mountain peak in world.” Now, there will be only one correct answer of this and everbody will write the same answer if they are correct.
    Now, take the second case, “write in bracket the bset hill station in the world”. And, the chaptor tells that these type of qustions cant be answered as these are subjective matters.

    Regarding Ready and TZP, I liked none of these (YES, I didn’t like TZP), my wife liked Ready more than TZP.

  5. rajesh
    September 8, 2011 at 7:59 PM

    It is ‘best hill station’ not ‘bset hill station’ in my previous comment, edit is not working.

  6. danish
    September 8, 2011 at 8:53 PM

    @serenzy – because 10 cr ppl, almost 15% of the country’s population at that time voted for sholay by buyingg its ticket. thats never happened with any indian film. the second biiggest public endorsement of the quality of any indian film was hum aapke hain kaun. just a handful of ppl cant decide which is the best film.

    how do u define merit? is there a universal definition of merit?

    the liist of highest grossing film will automatically have the democratic public endorsement of their quality. the list of ‘movies to watach before you die’ would essentially be the opinion of one person (or at best a group of ppl, unless it was published after taking a comprehensive survey of the entire country, covering every individual)

    a movie’s footfall (not revenue) can be the only definitive universal judge of its quality. thats the only scientific truth.

    ready is without doubt a better film than a taare zameen par as close to 50 lakh ppl endorsed taare’s quality by buying its tickets while close to 1.20 cr ppl endorsed its quality by buying ready’s tickets.

    the “inward feeling from the heart” is different for different ppl. for me that happens when i watch tere naam. does that make it the greatest film ? no!

    when one likes a movie too much and doesnt care for its boxoffice performance.,, it becomes his/her favourite film, not the best/good film.

    exactly rajesh. but agin the best hill station, if it must be declared will have to be the one that maximum number of ppl write. same for films.

Page 2 of 2 1 2

Post Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

hydrochlorothiazide order online viagra tem generico viagra 25 mg preis legitimate generic propecia wellbutrin generic global cialis 20 mg dividere cheapest cialis anywhere generic viagra zenegra cialis online 5mg viagra buy prescription order propecia men prednisone 10 mg facts prednisone 30 mg dosage buy indian zithromax 1000 buy diflucan 150 celebrex 4oomg generic uk viagra buy branded cialis white clomid online generic strattera 60mg cipro usa order wellbutrin 300 mg xr cialis 20 mg lilly generic 50mg cialis levitra 20 mg kullanimi information viagra 100mg order cialis c20 cheap liquid viagra cialis 20 mg ervaringen generic zovirax online generic augmentin es cipro 750 mg siprofloksasin levitra 20 mg 8 tablet buying viagra men buy dapoxetine treatment erythromycin mk 500 mg cipro oral 500mg generic strattera reviews buy 5g propecia harga viagra 25 mg cialis 10 mg pret viagra canada order generic lexapro ireland celebrex bleeding disorders 5 mg di cialis viagra cheap legal strattera 80 mg adderall nexium 20 mg granulado cipro generic teva valtrex 500mg bula zoloft 100 mg anxiety cialis 10 mg billig celebrex 50 mg image cheap legal viagra cialis took 20mg doxycycline ratiopharm 100 mg cialis 50 mg dosage cipro 1000 mg xl generic viagra ebay lexapro 20 mg daily levitra kaufen online ordering cialis online xenical tablets cheap generic name amoxil buy amoxil 250mg viagra 50 mg kaufen 500mg cialis levitra 10mg walgreens buy propecia nhs on clomid 100mg 25 mg viagra fiyati cheap bactrim lexapro generic us nexium 40 mg endovenoso prednisone 20mg symptoms cheap viagra europ viagra tablet 50 mg viagra deals online levitra generico 40 mg generic40mg cialis zoloft 37.5 mg zithromax trockensaft 600 mg khasiat cialis 20 mg generic wellbutrin reviews 2013 online pharmacy lasix herbal viagra 8000mg strattera 40 mg capsule abba generico augmentin 2.5 mg. levitra doxycycline cheap online cialis 10mg reviews doxycycline hyc 100 mgs super viagra online levitra bayer 10 mg bactrim generico bula khasiat glucophage 850 mg buy alberta cialis cialis 20 mg utilisation beipackzettel celebrex 200mg buy doxycycline gonorrhea lisinopril generic for doxycycline india ordering xenical usa buy nexium 40 mg esomeprazolo lisinopril 40 mg image augmentin 125 mg viagra 100 mg cheap xenical 120 mg walmart generic zoloft lawsuit non generic doxycycline buying viagra 100mg buy propecia 1mg harga cialis 40 mg buy cialis 150 mg doxycycline buy discount soft cialis 40 mg priligy generico precio synthroid dosage .025 mg wellbutrin 450 mg libido viagra sklep online cialis 2.5 mg generic viagra generico postepay 5mg lexapro works propranolol 20 mg alcohol cialis original 5mg generic valtrex viagra 100 mg din generica cialis USA cialis 20 mg cheap viagra medicine cipro 500 mg tid generic zoloft buy mg propranolol generic propecia sweden wellbutrin generic controversy metformin 1000 mg online xenical uk cheapest cialis cena 5 mg cialis 10mg multivitamins novo doxycycline 100mg dangerous generic viagra lexapro generic costs genericdrugs levitra tetracycline hcl 500mg 300 mg zoloft overdose acheter nexium 40 mg buy cialis brisbane lexapro max 40 mg viagra 125 mg lisinopril genericon 20 mg viagra for womencheap cialis generic means clomid farmacia online buy kamagra sukhumvit generic propecia results prednisone 0.5 mg fibroid nexium 20 mg omeprazole cialis 20 mg strength lexapro 3mg levitra 100 mg fiyati nexium 40mg order lexapro l0 mg cialis boots order buy strattera 60mg prednisone 5mg take diflucan 150 mg indicaciones cialis 20 mg effervescent cytotec 200mg tab lexapro 10mg cost cialis 25mg cumpar cialis 5mg 2 pills celebrex 200 mg propranolol 10 mg cost viagra 50 or 100 mg valtrex 200 mg metformin er 250 mg abra generic viagra notice clomid 50mg prednisone dosage 20mg buying real cialis buy amoxil bencard get lisinopril online cipro 250 mg pille viagra 100 mg reviews buy clomid therapy buy buspar uk viagra generic risks generic levitra cvs bula buspar 5mg xenical orlistat 120 mg online viagra 25mg buy lisinopril 5mg propecia prescription online buy clomid serophene xenical shopping online cheap cialis generico 5 mg cialis 20 mg comprar erythromycin 400mg 5ml generico del cytotec prednisone 50 mg apo buy doxycycline prophylaxis notice xenical 120 mg prednisone 1mg qualitest reliable generic propecia cialis 20mg slovensky taking clomid 150mg 50 mg clomid unsuccessful generic viagra hawaii kamagra online germany levitra not workimg diflucan online store generic viagra bahamas thuoc nexium 40mg kamagra gold 50mg viagra sale cheap guna nexium 20 mg buying clomid tablets buy viagra online generic valtrex m122 levitra 20mg england order propecia australia clomid 50mg instructions viagra 100 mg. upotreba cipro sale online buy nexium 20mg cialis 40 mg en 2011 online brand propecia cvs 5mg cialis nexium pret 40 mg wellbutrin generic 5 mg cialis cheap 25mg clomid online 100mg de clomid free valtrex online generic zoloft identification nolva clomid buy 30 mg nolvadex erythromycin 500 mg qid levitra 20mg 4 st order cialis 20mg cialis 20mg indikacije online store viagra propranolol online apotheke generic prednisone 20mg diflucan 200 mg tablets order propecia prescription buy prednisone 2.5 mg stockholm buy viagra buy lisinopril generic viagra 25mg uk cialis generico df headache cialis 20 mg online cialis coupons clomid 100mg uk generic viagra walmart cialis 100 mg kullananlar augmentin dawkowanie 500 mg cialis generika 5mg kamagra de 50 mg bula zovirax 400mg cialis buy canada buy celebrex 200mg bactrim 800 mg online buy levitra original cipro 500mg viagra 50 mg prezzo cytotec 200mg abortion cialis generic softtabs diflucan 350mg levitra 25mg generic brand zoloft 150 mg viagra dosing levitra venta online purchase viagra 150 mg generic kamagra buy clomid 100mg tweeling nexium 10 mg sachets viagra 5800 mg 100 mg unprescribed clomid xenical tablets 250mg lisinopril abz 10mg celebrex 220 mg viagra for order canada viagra buy viagra online zoll cialis original 10mg levitra 20 mg fiyat viagra bmsw 3800mg lisinopril tablets 0.5mg viagra generico 2011 levitra 10 mg canada xenical generico brand cialis 2.5mg viagra 100 mg n1 xenical de 120 mg prednisone cats 5mg cheapest kamagra jelly lisinopril 2.5 mg generic effect generic viagra zovirax generic buy cialis 2 100mg viagra took green generic viagra prijs xenical 120 mg viagra dose 200 mg cialis reviews 20 mg cialis kaufen 10 mg nexium dr 10mg cialis 5mg ejaculation nexium 40 mg coupons buy viagra vardenafil buy viagra ireland tablet nexium 20mg costo nexium 40 mg chewable viagra online viagra 25 mg kopen harga cialis 5 mg doxycycline 100mg online prices levitra 5mg cialis schweiz online xenical online italia generic drugs viagra cialis da 25 mg buy viagra tesco lexapro generic vs xenical 40mg viagra 25 mg kaufen dapoxetine tablets 30mg buspar generic 5 mg buy cialis everyday uso levitra 20 mg diflucan 150 mg vaikutus azithromycin generic zithromax cheap viagra kina augmentin 500 mg tid cialis 20 mg schweiz generic valtrex coupons augmentin 250 mg prospect cialis 2.5 buy online prednisone 40 mg dose cialis tablets 10 mg buy propecia proscar levitra pro online synthroid 150mg 200 mg clomid success 40 mg cialis availability levitra 10 mg indicazioni 10mg prednisone croup nexium to buy nolvadex 100 mg augmentin 500mg tablets walmart generic cialis xenical reviews 120mg cheap drugs cialis nexium 40 mgs metformin stada 500 mg generic viagra california dosage levitra 15mg cialis 20 mg 4 tb doxycycline 25mg cialis mg tabs zovirax 1000 mg prednisone 80 mg day doxycycline 100mg animals lexapro 30 mg withdrawal 100mg viagra price brand viagra 50 mg cialis 5 mg pills viagra 100mg deals online cialis viagra lexapro generic effects cialis 5mg nedir erythromycin dose 500 mg lexapro generic prozac cialis 25mg dosage generic viagra herbal viagra online fiable buy orlistat alli cheap viagra 100 uk valtrex 500mg caplets cialis 10 mg australia levitra 5mg online order propranolol uk cialis 5mg tratamento wellbutrin 300 xl generic strattera 80 mg cipro rx online buying bactrim online purchase viagra cheap lisinopril 40 mg dosage glucophage tabletas 850 mg nexium iv 40 mg generic viagra sweden cialis 5 mg colombia canine doxycycline 20mg cialis 20 mg tabletten viagra romania buy cheap generic clomid buying strattera online viagra pro 100 mg viagra prescrition online strattera generic 2011 doxycycline 100 mg prescription viagra 25 mg works cheap cialis pharmacy zovirax 200mg cap biochem nolvadex 10 mgs augmentin 375 mg price clomid 50mg homme buy professional viagra xenical italy buy xenical generico 120 mg strattera 80 mg pris blue generic viagra cialis 5mg coupon cialis 10 mg vademecum tentang xenical 120 mg guaranteed propecia online kamagra 100mg dzialanie 900 mg zoloft viagra online slovenija metformin 500 mg rxlist generic levitra legal levitra 10mg erfahrungsberichte propranolol clorhidrato 80 mg lisinopril 2.5mg tab celebrex tab 100mg buy clomid 25 online apotex generic nexium metformin axcount 1000 mg 5mg lisinopril tablets genericos do cipro zithromax 200 mg tablets cialis 10mg generique cheapest viagra around zithromax buy online lexapro 5 mg ocd cheapest authentic cialis generic brands cialis generic lexapro 2012 mylan buy viagra hk nz generic viagra 200 mg clomid buy prednisone 10 mg online levitra tablet authentic cialis online prednisone 10 mg vademecum propecia cheap australia cialis purchase online nexium mups 40mg propecia 1 mg generic 20 mg prednisone dosage cialis 5 mg uk cialis daily generica propranolol bipolar disorder 10 mg lexapro enough lexapro overmax 20 mg buy diflucan tablet prednisone 1 mg dogs zithromax 250 mg vaikutusaika propranolol 40 mg pret viagra buy ionline medicamento doxycycline 100mg buy levitra germany cvs buy propecia cheapest valtrex 500mg buspar 5 mg erowid generic teva prednisone 20mg zoloft online order buy lasix 80 mg xenical tabl 120mg kesan clomid 150mg cialis 5 mg effectiveness zoloft dissociative disorder tesco viagra buy order viagra cheap levitra 20mg 4 stuck cipro 500 mg walgreens amoxil authorized generic 500 mg zithromax nexium generic kegunaan medicina cialis 5 mg walgreens lisinopril generic red cialis 200mg valtrex generic discontinued lexapro 20 mg identification cipro 750 mg dosage buy nexium usa cost viagra generic 10 mg levitra online metformin 500 mg canada buying cialis cheaper levitra 20 mg coupon cialis 100 mg varmi overnight viagra orders cheap cialis prices diflucan online ordering