Which are the most intelligent thrillers or suspense movies ala Inception, Matrix in Bollywood ??

Well the question has been pertinent and keeps coming once see movies like Matrix or Inception, which have a lot of things to say apart from what you see on screen.  There have been immense discussion related to these movies on the forums all around.

When we look at the Hindi Film Industry of the number of such intelligent thriller movies produced, we can hardly name any one which has been discussed on the lines of Inception or Matrix for that matter.

The question to all forum members is, What according to you have been intelligent thrillers in Bollywood which have tested your brain and had you discussing it for a long time once you first saw it.

Few names that come to my mind are;

1. Jewel Thief

2. Khamosh

3. Aitbaar – an Indian remake of Dial M

Among all these none of them is ground breaking or something that makes you think about it.  I just tossed them for the heck of it. Let me know what your thoughts are?

41 Comments

  1. pranay
    pranay
    July 27, 2010 at 6:55 AM

    Johnny gaddaar in recent times.

  2. Sachin
    Sachin
    July 27, 2010 at 7:13 AM

    Gumnaam is the best thriller of Hindi Film Industry for me.

  3. Tango
    Tango
    July 27, 2010 at 7:30 AM

    As a thriller Gumnaam and Bes Saal Baad for me and as a mystery Mera Saya & Woh Kaun Thi?

  4. rockie_c83
    rockie_c83
    July 27, 2010 at 8:08 AM

    I dnt remember watching as many thrillers in Bwood… Johnny gaddaar was good… infact it was the only one in recent times…

  5. Manish
    Manish
    July 27, 2010 at 8:30 AM

    gumnaam, jewel thief,Khiladi, Johny Gaddar and i wd also add The Stoneman murder which released last year

  6. rks
    rks
    July 27, 2010 at 8:57 AM

    Usual suspects?

  7. Ali
    Ali
    July 27, 2010 at 9:28 AM

    Agree with cticize that ‘Chocolate’ must be included in the list.
    And our Link Man, RKS Bhai is Right that it was Based on Hollywood Movie ‘The Usual Suspects’.

  8. sputnik
    sputnik
    July 27, 2010 at 10:16 AM

    I don’t think any of these movies can be compared to Matrix, Memento or Inception. There has to be some ambiguity or some philosophical or some new concept to have any kind of discussion.

    These are suspense movies and once you know the killer/ending there is nothing left to discuss.

  9. count_me
    count_me
    July 27, 2010 at 10:26 AM

    “Gumnaam” & “Jewel Thief” were both fantastic… Loved “Baazigar” & “Gupt” too!! Though my personal favorites are “Kaun!” & “A Wednesday”….. Heard a lot about “Amir” but yet to see that one…..
    But I doubt if any of them are original bollywood ideas…….
    How i wish Satyajit Ray’s pitch perfect thrillers “Sonar Kella” and “The Elephant God” were dubbed in hindi for pan Indian viewers!

    ..And no, nothing in the lines of Matrix or Inception from Bollywood yet!!

  10. Manish
    Manish
    July 27, 2010 at 10:29 AM

    forgot to add gupt to my list that was awesome as well

  11. Ali
    Ali
    July 27, 2010 at 10:37 AM

    Sputnik –
    ” There has to be some ambiguity or some philosophical or some new concept to have any kind of discussion. ”

    Absolutely Bang on Target.
    That’s Why ‘Inception’ and ‘The Matrix’ are Masterpiece.
    Coz People keep discussing the concept of these Two Movies, Even after coming out of Theater and again Rewatch to Learn Something New and Intersting .
    I personally believe that Every Time one watches these two Movies, he will go through something new philosophical kind of Experience.
    Such is the Power of these two Movies.

  12. Manish
    Manish
    July 27, 2010 at 11:17 AM

    Sorry to go off topic again

    I spoke to shirish Kunder abt his soon to be announced joker and his plans for alien so he tweeted this

    ShirishKunder @manish0805 Alien Sahib is shelved. Am only making JOKER now.

    Since Akki was saying he will be working on a big project next year Joker cd be the one .

  13. pranay
    pranay
    July 27, 2010 at 11:51 AM

    Gumnaam was based on the agatha christie’s masterpiece novel And then there were none.

    someone mentioned Kaun here.. how can i forget it? i thought it was wonderful but underrated
    also, ek hasina thi..

  14. sputnik
    sputnik
    July 27, 2010 at 12:04 PM

    I felt Kaun was somewhat similar/inspired from the songless movie Ittefaq directed by Yash Chopra (won Filmfare for Best Director) starring Rajesh Khanna and Nanda. Even the camera work seems similar (the constant movement and spinning).

    Ittefaq itself was inspired/copied from Signpost to Murder.

  15. film_maker
    film_maker
    July 27, 2010 at 12:09 PM

    “Aar Ya Paar” – by Ketan Mehta. Jackie Shroff was in it.

    Was sad to hear it was a frame by frame copy of a Western movie which in itself was based on a book…

    Regardless, a well made flick.

  16. sputnik
    sputnik
    July 27, 2010 at 12:52 PM

    rohit,

    I saw Aar Ya Paar back when it released and thought it was very good. Jackie was brilliant in a negative role. Paresh Rawal was very good and Deepa Saahi was good too. MTV VJ Kamal Siddu was horrible though.

    I read that it is a copied from James Hadley Chase’s novel The Sucker Punch.

    Its a bit surprising that they did not credit James Hadley Chase coz they did credit Madame Bovary for Maya Memsaab.

  17. Tango
    Tango
    July 27, 2010 at 7:32 PM

    Sputnik – I read that it is a copied from James Hadley Chase’s novel The Sucker Punch.

    Yup i have read the novel and alse seen Aar Ya Paar, it is totaly based on The Sucker Punch.

  18. rajesh
    rajesh
    July 27, 2010 at 8:59 PM

    One interesting suspense movie missing from the discussion is Dhundh starring Sanjay Khan, Naveen Nishchal, Jeenat Aman and Danny.
    I watched this movie long back on DD and quite liked it.
    And, titls song of this film sung by Mahendra Kapoor is one of my favourite.

  19. manoj16_391
    manoj16_391
    July 27, 2010 at 9:10 PM

    Teesra Kaun :)

  20. beckett
    beckett
    July 28, 2010 at 1:17 AM

    Gumnaan-Based upon And then there were none. If one watches it wthout reading the book, the film a’int that bad.

    Dhundh- Based upon The Murder of Roger Ackroyd. The film was beautifully shot and can be termed a ood thriller

    Bees Saal Baad- Based upon The Hound of Baskervilles. I enjoyed watching the movie. Again what sort of was a dampener was having read the book earlier before watching the movie

    Chocholate- Bad copy of Usual Suspects

    Khiladi,Gupt,Khakee were good. And so were Woh Kaun thi and Mera Saya..

  21. RAJ
    RAJ
    July 28, 2010 at 1:25 AM

    Mera saya and Woh kaun thi were very good…Dhund was very good too…Khikadi is another one…

    But I haven’t yet come across a complete suspense thriller which would excite me…I can watch Vyomkesh Vakshi any day compared to BW suspense thrillers…

  22. beckett
    beckett
    July 28, 2010 at 2:35 AM

    Vyomkesh Bakhshi was a great series though inspired from Holmes-Watson which was anyway inspired from Poe’s Dupin. Tough one can say that Vyomkesh was a lot more polite and humble than Holmes.
    Karamchand was another great series and the protagonist’s character had a few shades of Christie’s Poirot and John Dickson Carr’s Henry Merrivale and Gideon Fell
    Kiley ka Rehesya was another thriller which was one of it’s kind. Would love to watch it again..

  23. beckett
    beckett
    July 28, 2010 at 3:40 AM

    Yes,won’t it be great to see a full-fledged movie on this series? Maybe have Rajat Kapoor as Vyomkesh and Vinay Pathak as his side-kick..

  24. Gorilla
    Gorilla
    July 28, 2010 at 3:52 AM

    I think some of the back and white films of Dev anand like CID aswell as other B&W movies made on court scenes were thrilling and very intelligently made.
    I have bought full series of Byomkesh Bakshi after being its fan when i was a kid. However i felt it lack the same punch now. Ditto with Tehkikaat, my other favourite once upon a time.

    IMO, the best TV series on suspense and thrill was Shekhar Suman’s Reporter. That was an awesome series of arounf 35-40 episodes till Shekhar Suman become editor.
    In movies of recent times, i think Khiladi leads over most others followed by 100 days and Gupt. I am eagerly waiting for Saif’s Agent Vinod.

  25. beckett
    beckett
    July 28, 2010 at 4:05 AM

    I think there was one movie Kanoon where the denouement at the end was shocking. Not sure if the name of the movie is Kanoon. It had Rajender Kumar and Ashok Kumar in lead roles

  26. ritz
    ritz
    July 28, 2010 at 8:55 AM

    Beckett, I loved Kanoon. Yes it had Ahok Kumar and Rajender – it is 1960 movie.

  27. count_me
    count_me
    July 28, 2010 at 10:09 AM

    Today one of my friend was highly recommending “Manorama six feet under”…. hv any of u seen it? How good is it?

  28. ritz
    ritz
    July 28, 2010 at 10:15 AM

    Manorama was okish. Good execution…

  29. suprabh
    suprabh
    July 28, 2010 at 10:59 AM

    first of all, I don’t think…any hindi movie has ever come close to the shock value or the suspense part as compared to memento, inception, matrix or fight club etc..

    some of the good hindi movies that I can think of as good suspense films would be

    -Khamosh (vidhu vinod chopra)

    – Khoj (starred rishi kapoor, kimi katekar and naseeruddin shah)

    – Kaun (manoj bajpai, urmila)

    -manorama six feet under (abhay deol)

    also there was this movie called “Yakeen” starring arjun rampal and priyanka chopra…I liked it a lot..is possile that it might e a copy of some hollywood flick.

  30. sputnik
    sputnik
    July 28, 2010 at 11:19 AM

    suprabh,

    “also there was this movie called “Yakeen” starring arjun rampal and priyanka chopra…I liked it a lot..is possile that it might e a copy of some hollywood flick.”

    With Vikram Bhatt involved you dont even have to doubt. You can be sure that it is a copy of some other movie.

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shattered_%281991_film%29
    http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0102900/

  31. S T R E E T
    S T R E E T
    July 28, 2010 at 12:04 PM

    watched Inception last nite.. nothing extra-ordinary. if anything, the movie kinda dragged on for too long.. and became more and more predictable.. specially the climax. Would take Don’s twist in the end over it anyday.

  32. beckett
    beckett
    July 28, 2010 at 1:52 PM

    @ Ritz- Thanks for clearing the doubt about the movie name. Was not sure as had watched it a long time back

    I enjoyed watching “The Others”. The twist at the end gave me a real jolt.Never saw it coming.There was a Hindi film based on the same story with Amitabh.It was a disaster at the BO.

    There was one Hindi whodunit set in a forest.It was the story of a film crew. Amidst the shooting,the murder happens.Don’t remember the name.I believe Shabana Azmi stared in it.It was a very Agatha Christie like setting.Would love to watch it again on DVD if somehow get to know the name

  33. ritz
    ritz
    July 28, 2010 at 2:17 PM

    I think you are referring to VVC film Khamosh?

  34. beckett
    beckett
    July 28, 2010 at 2:55 PM

    Thanks again. You are right on the button.It is Khamosh.Googled n confirmed just now.Will try to watch it this WE

  35. lalsub
    lalsub
    July 28, 2010 at 11:24 PM

    Loved VVC’s Khamosh when I watched it on tv a few years back. Good suspense.

    Among Hollywood thrillers I love Phone Booth. Watched it a couple of months back on Star Movies. Didn’t leave my couch even for a few seconds–absolutely rivetting. Must watch it again if it is shown and I catch it. Wonder how a Hindi version of this film would pan out.

  36. beckett
    beckett
    July 29, 2010 at 3:10 AM

    I enjoyed Identity too, starring John Cusack. There was a rip off of it in BW Khamosh- Khauff ki raat.It starred Shilpa Shetty n Juhi Chawla

  37. ritz
    ritz
    July 29, 2010 at 7:25 AM

    I liked Identity very much. BW remake was pathetic ..cud not watch it for more than 30 mins.

Page 1 of 1

Post Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

lisinopril 10 mg ratiopharm generic propecia fda viagra usa buy clomid online order cheap cialis sale viagra canada generic 28 doxycycline 100mg hydrochlorothiazide 12.5 mg qualitest synthroid generic pill nolvadex 10mg tamoxifen viagra 25 mg precio cialis 20 mg 8 comprimidos buying metformin online lexapro 30 mg pregnancy wellbutrin generic pill 141 cialis 20 mg generic valtrex generic date to buy doxycycline cialis 20 mg venda propecia generic 5mg levitra 20 mg dosage cialis 5mg enough priligy 30 mg tablets generic zovirax buy synthroid dosage 0.05mg generic valtrex ineffective cheap clomid 50 mg xenical buy ireland buy 10 mg lexapro cialis 80 mg bali buy brand zoloft zithromax 500 mg indicaciones augmentin 12h generico xenical generic eu edmonton cheap viagra zithromax online discount prednisone 20 mg qualitest nexium 40 mg alkohol propranolol er 80 mg buy lexapro cipralex prednisone 5mg dosage prednisone 60 mg surgery efectos levitra 10 mg costco generic diflucan cheap doxycycline tablets valtrex cheap doxycycline 100 mg uti nexium online kopen buying nolvadex uk buy levitra australia cialis professional online kamagra 8000mg lisinopril 10 mg info metformin xr 1500mg buy chinese clomid augmentin tablets 375mg doxycycline dosage 150 mg prednisone 10 mg 6 day clomid 25mg nederlands cialis online kopen xenical 120 mg metformin 500mg her buy strattera 18 mg propranolol 40 mg prospect generic viagra ciplachennai cialis headaches 20mg nolvadex research buy online viagra subscription lasix drip order viagra generico brevetto strattera 60 mg cost cialis medistar 20 mg buy levitra 100mg cialis 5mg 28 tabletten viagra canada 25mg indigestion lexapro generic viagra 200mg online synthroid 0.025mg co montreal viagra 100mg generic propecia january 2013 tabletki xenical 120 mg hypothyroidism generic synthroid propecia ie buy online cialis brand wellbutrin xl 300 generic price generic viagra 1000 mg metformin hydrochloride composicion cialis 20 mg propecia tablets 1mg cialis generic benefits celebrex 100mg cipro cheap online manfaat metformin 500 mg instructions 20 mg cialis cheap lexapro 20 mg generic celebrex price generic lexapro mylan lexapro 10mg 15mg generic propecia difference buy liquid propecia generic levitra dapoxetine buy viagra paysafe diflucan buy australia buy mens viagra lexapro generic march thread cheap viagra zithromax generic form 4 days 10 mg prednisone doxycycline tc 100 mg lady generic cialis cialis 20 mg doses viagra generic philippines doxycycline 300 mg dogs buying cytotec viagra cheap sale cialis 20mg kokemuksia order cialis 50 mg erythromycin 250mg zastosowanie cialis sicuro online dosage augmentin 500mg bula lexapro 10mg doxycycline 100mg ingredients kamagra 100mg erfahrungsbericht cialis 40 mgcena buy 5 viagra buy clomid online priligy 60 mg tablets cipro xl buy ordering viagra online prezzi cialis 20 mg 1.25 mg synthroid doxycycline dosage 300 mg cialis 20 mg prijs glucophage price 500 mg buy doxycycline 20mg 40 mg of strattera viagra 800 mg opis generic medicine nexium prospecto diflucan 150 mg doxycycline 50mg eye cialis 200mg tab cialis 20mg cheap durata cialis 10 mg propecia 1 mg online prednisone 5 mg chews viagra online wien xenical buy pills bactrim online bijsluiter viagra 50mg nolvadex liquid buy buyin nolvadex ireland levitra 10 mg paypal cialis 10mg erfahrungsberichte cialis thailand online cheap 5mg cialis online eczane levitra viagra 100,3000 mg buy Cialis 90 pills cipro 1000 mg 5 day synthroid buy it cialis gold 20 mg buy kamagra fuerteventura 50 or 100 mg clomid lexapro anxiety disorders dapoxetine 60 mg canada levitra 20 mg break no generic lexapro buy bradn viagra cialis 20 mg tabletas viagra medication online cytotec de 400 mg pfizer viagra 50 mg viagra japan buy lisinopril 10 mg effects online propecia forum order synthroid canada phone order cialis viagra generic 20 effects 200 mg viagra comanda online levitra 150mg diflucan order generic lexapro india viagra 50mg strength nolvadex 20 mg generic purchase cialis cheap cialis online org lasix 40 mg online wellbutrin sr 100mg viagra online bestellen zovirax tabl 800 mg zithromax 500 mg 3 hoeveel mg nolvadex buy doxycycline gel 5mg lexapro reviews 10 mg prednisone ivf buy viagra penang kamagra tablets cheap generico viagra panvel generics viagra paypal buy cialis 2.5 viagra buy camden is cialis 100mg priligy online pharmacy online viagra ireland celebrex 200mg anwendung indikasi metformin 500 mg identify lisinopril 10 mg xenical buy nz kamagra tablet 50 mg 37.5 mg of zoloft diflucan capsule 100 mg buy doxycycline nairobi erfahrung kamagra 100mg strattera 60 mg reviews celebrex 200 mg cena wirkung levitra 5mg strongest generic cialis viagra 150 mg kaufen buy prednisone uk zithromax online chlamydia clomid 25 mg jour prednisone withdrawal 5 mg medicamento xenical 120 mg preis cialis 5mg phenergan 12.5mg iv lisinopril tablets 40 mg 20 mg clomid pills prednisone 50mg pregnancy zoloft 25 mg tablet cheap kamagra london propecia online purchase zoloft sertraline 25mg buy zithromax 500mg buy clomid 500mg online cialis satis propecia generic coupons diflucan dosage 150mg canadian nexium 40 mg doxycycline 200 mg syphilis blueberry 100 viagra buy cipro online uk augmentin 90 mg kg buy viagra cheap cialis 40 mg einnehmen augmentin farmaco generico 100 mg di zoloft viagra x generico levitra 20 mg. orosolubile rx cialis online 250 mg cipro erythromycin order online viagra order mastercard 600 mg wellbutrin overdose comprar cialis 20 generico propecia online 5mg cipro 750 mg muadili viagra fiyatlari 50 mg erythromycin capsules 250 mg generic sub bactrim augmentin 400mg buying hydrochlorothiazide pill nolvadex online viagra 150mg safe buy clomid bodybuilding viagra online 150 kamagra 100mg fake nolvadex generic names order levitra generic xenical comanda online online viagra prescriptions clomid 50mg musculation starting zoloft 25mg lisinopril accord 10mg diflucan to buy wellbutrin authorized generic buspar buy buy levitra pen medicamento levitra 20 mg 5mg lexapro review nexium 40mg tiem lisinopril 20 mg preco lexapro 20 online xenical buy london zithromax 500mg fta 40 mg strattera cialis illegal online cialis black 500mg cialis film 20mg viagra online britain kamagra 100 mg gold hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg po viagra generic dose cytotec 200 mg directions levitra dosage 40 mg synthroid . 5mg cheap generic viagra glucophage 1000 mg poudre lisinopril splitting 2.5mg cialis mexico buy lilly cialis 100 mg nexium 40 mg prospect doxycycline 500mg capsules buy xenical sydney 500 mg generic viagra cheapest valtrex prices cialis buy review cialis kaufen 5 mg cialis generico fiable generic levitra store priligy 60 mg prezzo augmentin 1000 mg tablets generic levitra facts cheap cialis online .50 buy zithromax walmart nexium 40 mg 30 tablet strattera overdose mg viagra online vgr buy Cialis 60 pills viagra online bangalore erythromycin 1000mg clomid buy paypal doxycycline 100mg shqip levitra 10 ou 20 mg lexapro 20 mg buy cheap generic priligy synthroid 05 mg lexapro canada buy 10mg lexapro alcohol viagra sildenafil 50 mg cipro antibiotic online doxycycline 100mg drinking nexium backorder prednisone 2.5 mg qualitest lexapro when generic propecia generic uk online viagra ratings cialis prostate disorders amoxil 250 mg used lasix ret. 60 mg cialis 5mg double vendita viagra generico generic zoloft appearance viagra 20mg price cost 20 mg lexapro cialis economico online xenical 120 mg acheter comanda cialis 10 mg generic viagra laws diflucan one 50mg 100 mg zoloft cheap levitra online celebrex generic 100mg synthroid 0.1 mg celebrex 100 mg hartkapseln zovirax tabletki 200 mg doxycycline teva 100 mg buy 50mg kamagra metformin 1000 mg day zoloft 100 mg pregnancy cytotec 200 mg vidal metformin 500 mg pdr online rx valtrex lisinopril buy reviews couper cialis 20 mg amoxil 250 mg suspension cialis lilly 20 mg buying viagra lisinopril 20 mg online kamagra jelly buy cialis uk 5mg cialis 100mg 20mg cialis de 5mg cialis 5mg cena clomid online purchase viagra 25 mg effet buy strattera discount buy viagra phitzer generic doxycycline online nolvadex mg ml buy doxycycline 50 capsules viagra 50 mg wirkungsdauer comprare xenical online nolvadex 20 mg precio celebrex 200mg information buy propecia brazil generisk cialis 10 mg viagra 2 20 mg lisinopril qualitest 30 mg cialis 20mg order valtrex generic wiki 10 mg daily cialis viagra buy nottingham generic viagra 40 tabs clomid online france levitra 20 mg walmart xenical tablets 120mg viagra 100mg blue buy levitra qatar buy tetracycline 250 mg nexium buy online buy viagra 100g cialis 20 mg 90 tablet gold viagra 3 000 mg cheapest viagra pfizer cheap generic xenical zoloft 12.5 mg dose cialis 100mg portugues cialis buy chea tetracycline 250 mg capsules cialis pills 10 mg viagra generico eurofarma synthroid dosage 150 mg lisinopril 10 mg results levitra orodispersible 5mg cialis 5mg ndc order levitra 180 pills acheter cialis 2.5mg buy cheap clomid viagra cheap cod import generic viagra generic cialis 10 yellow get celebrex online bactrim 160 mg posologia xenical 120 mg preisvergleich glucophage retard 1000mg nexium 20 mg precio bactrim 1 mg order viagra america generic propecia online viagra buy oonline levitra 10 mg fta 4 propranolol 40mg tablet generic propecia 1 mg cialis everyday 20mg propecia buy mexico order viagra 25mg order cialis site cialis 5mg peaks buying cialis generic levitra 60 pills online cialis 20mg tadalafil buying viagra free costco generic lexapro viagra sublingual 150mg zovirax generico viagra bali buy reviews lisinopril 20 mg levitra cost 10 mg dapoxetine 60mg online viagra online australia cheap viagra canadian xenical online discount clomid 100mg ed erfahrungsberichte cialis 5mg lisinopril 5 mg medication lisinopril 20 mg india nolvadex 10 mgs cytotec online pharmacy order diflucan roerig 150 diflucan 200 mg used propranolol 20 mg tab buy nexium generic buy lexapro mastercard doxycycline 100mg dose generic viagra experiences metformin 500 mg beipackzettel clomid malaysia online clomid 50mg forum 20mg lexapro lot cipro 500mg ingredients doxycycline 100mg forum lasix 40 mg comprimidos xenical 120 mg bijwerkingen buspar 20mg kamagra 50 mg tablets ordering propranolol online generic viagra legal cialis 3800 mg fake generic zoloft liquid cialis generic brands viagra kobra 100mg buying zovirax ointment 7 mg prednisone taper healthymen buy viagra reichen 5 mg cialis cialis buy france lexapro 5 mg conversion generic cialis zoll buy augmentin 625mg zoloft overdose 300mg nexium 40 mg pharmacy lisinopril 40 mg appearance viagra online richmond 50mg cialis equivalent cialis generico prospecto cialis generico germania buy kamagra california cialis bayer 20mg buy generic glucophage