NAACHGAANA
Karthik reviews the music of Paa and 3 Idiots
Som | November 17, 2009, 7:01 PM | 15 comments | 1,393 views


Mudhi mudhi (and Udhi udhi) is one of the trendiest songs of the year; zingy, superbly sung by Shilpa Rao and exceptionally orchestrated!

More HERE

3 Idiots

About the author:
Has 4038 Articles

An Ardent Cinema Enthusiast!

15 COMMENTS
  1. Tango

    Well, well well. If Karthik dislikes 3 Idiots but loves the flat tunes of Paa (barring the theme and the Big B song) I am now confirmed why and based on what parameters Karthik likes a certain album.

    The person who cannot spend 2-3 dollars on buying an audio album but prefers online review …. :razz:

    The latest proof is that he does not even know “Paisa Paisa” is an RDB composition.

  2. Tango

    On 3 Idiots

    The title of the track is AAL IS WELL not ALL IS WELL dear Karthik.

    Please review from an actual album next time around.

  3. Angels and Belds

    Tango – aap tho Ajab Prem dikha rahe ho karthik pe :-)

  4. Tango

    Nahi Beld. I seriously believe that agar aap music reviewer hain to review from an actual album rather than from online and give it 3-4 heras.

    Not only does one get the credits wrong, but music ko bhi nahi samajh sakta. I mean a clarinet and a saxophone sounds the same or for that matter a mandolin and a guitar, online!!

    Iska hi ek itwofs ka dost bola that he is a publicity hound (sorry for that usage).

    Once he got bashed for Paisa Paisa being credited to Pritam he edited and credited it to RDB.

  5. rks

    I think original Punjabi Paisa was released in 2003 by Manak-E..Any UK punjabi music specialist?

  6. devesh

    “Mudhi mudhi (and Udhi udhi) is one of the trendiest songs of the year;”

    Compeltely diagree -Nothin but an average song – i cudnt even hear it completely..

  7. Anna

    “The person who cannot spend 2-3 dollars on buying an audio album but prefers online review …. :razz:

    The latest proof is that he does not even know “Paisa Paisa” is an RDB composition

    The title of the track is AAL IS WELL not ALL IS WELL dear Karthik.

    Please review from an actual album next time around.

    Iska hi ek itwofs ka dost bola that he is a publicity hound (sorry for that usage).

    Once he got bashed for Paisa Paisa being credited to Pritam he edited and credited it to RDB.”

    LOL :lol:

  8. Anna

    But I don’t think the above allegations are true.

    Karthik himself clarified that he reviews from an actual album and not online.. I like his crisp reviews

    BTW Karthik writes for Bangalore Mirror on regular basis and his music review in BM is quite popular

  9. Anna

    Pehle Bhardwaj phir Satyam uske baad Karthik… Aapko south indians pe itna gusssa kyon ? :P

  10. Tango

    Anna- “Pehle Bhardwaj phir Satyam uske baad Karthik… Aapko south indians pe itna gusssa kyon ?”

    Aap bhi to South ke ho, aur aap se mohabbat hai :-)

    I dont think he could have reviewed from an actual CD coz he would not have goofed up about credits on a regular basis.

    And his 3 Idiot review is a proof of that coz Bhushan Kumar aur T-Series waalon ko chhod kar, no one gets T-series music before Joginder, so Karthik could not have reviewed from CD, based on the time he put up the review.

    BTW- Yeh dekhiye aapke Karthik sahab Bollywood ke baare mein kya khyaal rakhte hain

    http://movies.rediff.com/report/2009/nov/17/music-review-paa.htm

    Re: Re: Gumm Summ Song
    by karthikeyan on Nov 19, 2009 05:35 PM
    no he might have thought tat d older composition itself is ok 4 these crap b’wood movies….

  11. rks

    Tango – Is it same Karthik? Anyone can post over there with rediff account? Link

  12. Arun

    Loving all three versions of ‘Mudhi Mudhi’!Superbly orchestrated and very well sung by Shilpa Rao and Shaan.

    Also love the Paa Theme Music. Haunting piece!

  13. Angels and Belds

    arun – u have disappeared since maghadheera released ;-)

    whats up? seen any good tamil/telugu flicks recently?

LEAVE YOUR COMMENT

Back to Top