author photo

Achilles



He has approached Hrithik to play the brooding Vijay Dinanath Chauhan, which was played by Amitabh in the original.

Karan Johar is all set to remake the blockbuster, Agneepath. While he had to pay an astronomical amount to buy the rights of the Hollywood blockbuster Stepmom, which he is remaking in Hindi, he does not need to buy the rights to remake Agneepath as it is his home production. His late father, Yash Johar had produced the 1990 Amitabh Bachchan-Mithun Chakraborty starrer, which was directed by the late Mukul Anand. Amitabh had won a National Award for his performance in Agneepath.

Karan has approached Hrithik Roshan to step in to Amitabh’s shoes.

A source said, “Karan has been planning to remake Agneepath but he was waiting for the right time. Now, he is confident that his company, Dharma Productions, can make multiple films at the same time. The film will be directed by Karan Malhotra, who Karan thinks is one of his most promising assistants. While some changes will be made in the script to give it a contemporary feel, Karan does not want to change any dialogue as he is very confident of the dialogue in the original Agneepath.”

“Surprisingly, Karan has not approached Abhishek Bachchan to play Vijay Dinanath Chauhan, which was played by the actor’s father in the original. While Hrithik is still deciding if he wants to star in the remake, Karan is sure that Hrithik is the perfect choice. However, the Dharma Productions team is yet to decide on the actors who will play Krishnan Iyer MA, played by Mithun Chakraborty, and Kancha Cheena, played by Danny Denzongpa, in the original,” added the source.

Karan Johar and Hrithik Roshan remained unavailable for comment.

Ashok Vashodia, Hrithik’s business manager, said, “Karan and Hrithik are extremely close. They keep discussing various projects. However, I am unaware of any offer as far as Agneepath is concerned.”

LINK

There Are 85 Responses So Far. »

  1. akshay shah 17 June 2009
    04:45:14 pm

    Comment Arrow

    Joke of the year!

  2. Som 17 June 2009
    08:07:57 pm

    Comment Arrow

    Seems like another hogwash from Mumbai Mirror.

  3. ACHILLES 17 June 2009
    08:16:38 pm

    Comment Arrow

    hopefully this is another bakwaas article, hrithik wud be great in a slick and stylish gangster role (farhan missed the trick in Don) … but Agneepath is too noisy and a mannerism prone film to be even worth of making a remake … that too by a debutant director.

  4. ACHILLES 17 June 2009
    08:18:14 pm

    Comment Arrow

    “Hain Hain Haaaaaaain!”

    sorry that was not bachchan’s throttling, but the audience yawning!

  5. Ravi 17 June 2009
    09:01:00 pm

    Comment Arrow

    Joke of the Century.

  6. FakeNGMember 17 June 2009
    09:04:53 pm

    Comment Arrow

    hey ravi – the other thread got closed :-( before i could stir it up a bit – yeh apna moderator log need to get a life!!

    tho kya haal hai. Somi used to be a looker! So is that the reason why you have started doing groceries often nowadays ;-)

  7. FakeNGMember 17 June 2009
    09:06:59 pm

    Comment Arrow

    on the topic of this post – agneepath was such a class movie. I think it needs a decade or 2 more before its remade. But I would love to see Karan make a gangster movie with Hrithik.

  8. ACHILLES 17 June 2009
    09:10:33 pm

    Comment Arrow

    somi used to be a looker or hooker?

  9. ACHILLES 17 June 2009
    09:11:54 pm

    Comment Arrow

    Beld – trust me karan is the last guy to make a decent gangster movie.

  10. RAJ 17 June 2009
    10:39:19 pm

    Comment Arrow

    Agnepath is one movie ,i dont believe can be recreated along with Sholay and DDLJ…I Belive this is the best Amitabh performance in his career(Evenif he hammed to glory )…Mithuns’ performance in the movie can never be recreated…It was a clasic…

  11. RAJ 17 June 2009
    10:40:21 pm

    Comment Arrow

    “”hopefully this is another bakwaas article, hrithik wud be great in a slick and stylish gangster role (farhan missed the trick in Don)”"

    Agree here..HR would make a really stylish Gangster..

  12. Gorilla 18 June 2009
    05:26:21 am

    Comment Arrow

    I wonder if Karan will take SRK for Mithun’s role. Remeber his films ‘must’ have SRK (Dostana was too realistic), so if Hrithik is playing BigB, then SRK must be playing Mithun.

  13. Gorilla 18 June 2009
    05:52:09 am

    Comment Arrow

    BOI: If true, it will be unfortunate because while Agneepath’s remake will be mistimed, Hrithik will be a miscast

    There are many stories in the media that Hrithik Roshan will star in the remake of the 1990 Amitabh Bachchan and Mithun Chakraborty starrer Agneepath. According to reports Karan Johar will produce the film. The 1990 Agneepath was produced by Yash Johar under the the Dharma Productions banner.

    The trade is much more sceptical about such venture happening. A distributor in Delhi says “I would be very surprised if they are remaking Agneepath because as far as i can remember the film was flop in most of the country and we have seen the results with Umrao Jaan when an unsuccessful film was remade. If they are remaking the film i think there will be a lot of changes from the earlier film and the film will look a lot different. Also although Hrithik Roshan is a superstar he would not really suit the role palyed by Amitabh Bachchan in Agneepath. Ajay Devgan would be the more apt choice and would fit into the role perfectly.”

    It remains to be seen how much truth there is in the news but as yet nothing has been confirmed by either Karan Johar or Hrithik Roshan.

  14. ACHILLES 18 June 2009
    06:34:59 am

    Comment Arrow

    An ideal casting for an Agneepath remake will be Devgan as Bachchan and Akshay as Mithun.

    Only then the result would be same as the original – a box office flop.

  15. ACHILLES 18 June 2009
    06:36:00 am

    Comment Arrow

    And surely no fans of hrithik will be interested in him putting kajal in his eyes and doing ‘hain hain’ for 3 long hours…

  16. Rocky 18 June 2009
    07:59:28 am

    Comment Arrow

    Whether it is the Oily hairs in Shehanshah or Kajal in Agneepath ONLY Amitabh Bachchan can carry them with Elan.
    He is not called the Big B for nothing !!

  17. Rocky 18 June 2009
    08:08:08 am

    Comment Arrow

    After the kind of Flak SRK got for DON, I would be surprised if Hritik will says yes to this misadventure.

  18. Rocky 18 June 2009
    08:11:51 am

    Comment Arrow

    I hope Hritik is smart enough to not get carried away by getting best actor awards at various tamasha shows and actually starts thinking he can play- VJ Deena Nath Chauhaan – Pura Naam, Hain !!!

  19. Ravi 18 June 2009
    08:17:30 am

    Comment Arrow

    Exactly Rocky.

    HR is more suited for the stylish gangster and would have been perfect for Don instead of SRK, but being “Vijay Deena Nath Chauhan”, Fur get about it.

  20. Rocky 18 June 2009
    08:21:15 am

    Comment Arrow

    Hey Ravi, Somi Ali- still Hot- your friend must be joking ! LOL

  21. Ravi 18 June 2009
    08:23:14 am

    Comment Arrow

    No Rocky bro, he swears that she is still hot. We know where she lives , so next time when I am in Miami I might do some stalking.

  22. Ravi 18 June 2009
    08:26:02 am

    Comment Arrow

    By the way Rocky, it is definitely fun reading RGV’s blog. Defnitely a arrogant MOFO, but fun to read.

  23. Rocky 18 June 2009
    08:26:49 am

    Comment Arrow

    RE.- I might do some stalking

    Daant tootne ka dar nahee hai kya, Ghar ka Daton ka Doctor hai kya ??? LOL !!!!

  24. Rocky 18 June 2009
    08:28:21 am

    Comment Arrow

    Ya I know, I had asked you a question long back on RGV, either you did not read it or chose to ignore it-
    Did you know who Rifle was ??? LOL !!

  25. Johny 18 June 2009
    08:30:07 am

    Comment Arrow

    Hrithik & Vijay Deenanath chauhan? LMAO

    Well they can try spoof on Agnipath with Hrithik playing Vijay Deenanath Chuha

  26. Ravi 18 June 2009
    08:33:22 am

    Comment Arrow

    Sorry Rocky bro, would never ever ignore you.

    We all knew Rifle but the thing was we did not know that she was called Rifle. This pan dabba in front of our college gates, we all used to sit there and gawk at his wife thinking if she looked like this now, how did she look during her prime time.

    Was talking about that with my friends the other day , Ramu was around 8 years senior to us so the name did not pass through to us, but she was hot with 2 kids, so could imagine what she was before that.

    Got to go, Gym time.

    Will catch you later bro.

  27. Rocky 18 June 2009
    08:36:12 am

    Comment Arrow

    see ya, I should get back to work as well !!!

  28. ACHILLES 18 June 2009
    08:37:01 am

    Comment Arrow

    Rocky – agree whole heartedly that it will b foolish for hrithik to agree to this, bachchan’s agneepath role and the adulation was the culmination of his superstardom, where mannerisms were enuf to make the role legendary. On top of it the story is not suited for contemporary time, thus no need to mess up with yester year’s masala movies.

    Whats the point in remaking a movie that was not even a hit in the first place? Despite national awards Agneepath had a shoddy run at the box office.

    As for hrithik, it will interesting to see him in a gansta role … he not only has the charisma/screen presence but also good acting skills to pull it off. His fan following can ensure box office returns.

    Bacchan fans will never accept anyone doing these cherished roles like don or agneepath by anyone – be it a de niro or pacino … except for his laadla where they will extrapolate or imagine some sort of similarity. But Bachchan’s bigger than life roles like this will be totally misfit for the non-acting or no-expressions from his son (which fans have learnt to praise as ’subtle’ acting).

  29. Johny 18 June 2009
    08:38:52 am

    Comment Arrow

    Somy was hot those days.. I still remember her hot item song in Krishnavatar with Mithunda

  30. Johny 18 June 2009
    08:47:55 am

    Comment Arrow

    What can you expect from this bufoon? here is one sample

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v.....mp;index=3

  31. ACHILLES 18 June 2009
    09:21:46 am

    Comment Arrow

    Well that was a young hrithik trying to imitate the likes of Govinda and Salman under Barjatya’s instructions … the imitation was surely as bad as the originals.

    But if Hrithik does agree to do this, a lot more surprises will be in store for a few. Hrithik is unpredictable and surprising … he was breezy as a middle class guy next door and a NRI in KNHP, a loud mentally challenged boy in KMG or innocent naive in Krrish that were both endearing to the kids by large, or extra stylish and charismatic in D2 or royally majestic in JA … all these varied range was competently acteded by the same guy to ensure big box office hits.

    After the initial dip in his career, he has always rose up to the occasion to deliver the unexpected and raising his status, esteem and fan following with each movie since KMG. If agneepath is his next surprise, so be it – but first there needs to be official confirmation to these rumors.

  32. Johny 18 June 2009
    09:28:40 am

    Comment Arrow

    SB gems

    TheSkeptic: Since KJo is steadily gayifying his father’s legacy, Agneepath with Hrithik sounds logical. Hrithik will play a salsa-dancing don with a crush on his right-hand played by John Abraham.

  33. Akshay 18 June 2009
    09:33:30 am

    Comment Arrow

    Johny

    -5

  34. Gorilla 18 June 2009
    09:48:01 am

    Comment Arrow

    ‘Whether it is the Oily hairs in Shehanshah or Kajal in Agneepath ONLY Amitabh Bachchan can carry them with Elan.
    He is not called the Big B for nothing !!’

    Well said Rocky.

    Hrithik is not even fit to play Mithun’s role. But in a gangster role he may suit but then anything not directed by Papa Roshan is a risk. He was pretty average in K3G in a guest appearance or maybe a little more.

  35. Rocky 18 June 2009
    09:57:35 am

    Comment Arrow

    Gorilla Thanks. thing is I like Hritik a lot, but if he now tries to play a stylish gangster- he will have to better Neil Mukesh in Johnny gaddar which seems kind of tough !!

  36. Rocky 18 June 2009
    09:59:28 am

    Comment Arrow

    btw looks like Johnny Gaddar was not a Gaddar after all !! LOL !!

  37. Gorilla 18 June 2009
    10:00:36 am

    Comment Arrow

    ‘I like Hritik a lot’

    ditto here but he disappointed me. He is one overrated actor and underrated star.

  38. Johny 18 June 2009
    10:08:57 am

    Comment Arrow

    Akshay: I didn’t get you

  39. Johny 18 June 2009
    10:09:31 am

    Comment Arrow

    TheSkeptic: Hrithik was gay and breezy in KNPH, gay and retarded in Krrish, gay and weepy in D2 and finally gay and royal in JA

    :lol:

  40. Gorilla 18 June 2009
    10:12:32 am

    Comment Arrow

    TheSkeptic comment ‘Hrithik was gay and breezy in KNPH, gay and retarded in Krrish, gay and weepy in D2 and finally gay and royal in JA’

    This really sums up Hrithik. Brilliantly said.
    To those who will read this and then get a high Blood Pressure – :lol:

  41. Rocky 18 June 2009
    10:13:19 am

    Comment Arrow

    wow- wtf hit TS, did Satyam leaving NG affect him so much ???

  42. Tango 18 June 2009
    10:18:04 am

    Comment Arrow

    The fact is SRK, Aamir, Hrithik and Akshay are the top stars of Bollywood, with slot number 5 open and the hottest contender is Ranbir. All the jokes can go on.

  43. Rocky 18 June 2009
    10:19:40 am

    Comment Arrow

    I think Hritik is a pretty decent actor- specially in KMG,KNPH ,Lakhshya and JA.

  44. Rocky 18 June 2009
    10:21:17 am

    Comment Arrow

    Agree Tango !!!

  45. Gorilla 18 June 2009
    10:23:46 am

    Comment Arrow

    ‘All the jokes can go on.’

    Thanks Tango Bhai. I hope you understand that I like comedy and action – in movies as well as on NG.

  46. Rocky 18 June 2009
    10:24:40 am

    Comment Arrow

    kabhee kabhee thoda emosun bhee lao bhai !!!

  47. Tango 18 June 2009
    10:29:27 am

    Comment Arrow

    Gorilla yeah I appreciate all types of cinema. But there are some who have read a few books on cinema and know afew technicalterms and try to show that only like GOOD cinema, hoping that it will bring respect to them on forums, but in my book they are c..s of the first order.

    Let them come and have a debate with me on cinema techniques and shot taking.

  48. Tango 18 June 2009
    10:31:16 am

    Comment Arrow

    Rocky bhai Rekha was just too good in Khiladiyon K Khiladi, both as an actress and looks wise.

  49. Rocky 18 June 2009
    10:35:30 am

    Comment Arrow

    Re.-Let them come and have a debate with me on cinema techniques and shot taking

    I was watching – Aei jaatey hue Lamhon , Zara thero from Border last sunday.
    there is a scene in that song where Sunil Shetty comes out of the house and his company men are waiting for him- suddenly his wife come running and hugs him- Now very subtly- All the men turn their backs to this – if you don’t pay attention you might miss it as I did on numerous previous occasions., But this time I noticed and realized how much pains these directors take to make the scene as realistic as possible. which sometimes we as viiewres do not even notice.

    hope the above makes sense !!

  50. Gorilla 18 June 2009
    10:42:24 am

    Comment Arrow

    ‘kabhee kabhee thoda emosun bhee lao bhai !!!’

    emosun kaun se gaon ka hai? Hansee majaak se hit to aadmi aadmi bantaa hai. Rote hue to har bachcha paida hota hai. Ismein kaun si badi baat hai?

  51. Tango 18 June 2009
    10:44:15 am

    Comment Arrow

    It definately makes sense Rocky bhai.

    Do you know why Chandra Barot the director of DON disappeared after his first movie? That is because the script of Don by Salim-Javed was so complete that even a novice (with basic knowledge of photography could have directed !

    Example, ” The film opens with a subdued long shot of … and after that the camera pans on to .. in a subdued and contrast shot with hues of …

  52. Tango 18 June 2009
    10:47:28 am

    Comment Arrow

    While on Agneepath, the audience could not understand the fine nuances of his husky and whispering dialogue delivery.

    The makers later requested him (which he did) to dub the film in his normal voice but by then it was too late. Maybe today Agneepath could have been a pathbreaking film in the original style.

  53. Gorilla 18 June 2009
    10:47:51 am

    Comment Arrow

    Rocky I noticed this masterstroke and amazing cinematic experience during first dekho itself(not boasting myself here) and it made an instant impact on me in the theatre. The same song has many glorious moment which spellbounded the viewers in the theatre. The lyrics, direction was an ace.

    ‘Main kahin bhi rahoon aye sanam,
    tujko hai zindagi ki kasam
    phaasle aate jaate rahein
    pyaar lekin nahin hoga kam”

    Quite easily one of the most emotionally charged song picturised on only two persons for 6 minutes, taking everyone’s breath away. My emosun!

  54. Rocky 18 June 2009
    10:51:08 am

    Comment Arrow

    Ya Gorilla , I had liked this song better than Sandeshe aatey hain, which was a close second.

  55. Rocky 18 June 2009
    10:53:03 am

    Comment Arrow

    Tango – javed Akhtar had actually said in an interview that they should have shown a reason for his husky voice( accident or something ) otherwise people were confused and many thought that the Cinema hall’s sound sysytem was bad etc.

  56. Rocky 18 June 2009
    10:53:56 am

    Comment Arrow

    see you guys later, Lunch time khallllas !!

  57. Tango 18 June 2009
    10:55:37 am

    Comment Arrow

    Javed sb was rt as he knows the psyche of the Indian audience. Kyun kis liye..

    But as I have said todays audience would have lapped it up.

    Happy lunch Rocky.

  58. Som 18 June 2009
    11:33:05 am

    Comment Arrow

    Last time I heard Karan Johar was acquiring the official rights to remake Stepmom now remaking Agneepath(if true).Is he awfully running out of original scripts now?

  59. Rocky 18 June 2009
    11:48:37 am

    Comment Arrow

    Here is the song, the sequnce I was talking about starts at- 4.57 and ends at 5.14

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v.....re=related

    Main iss chand se maathey ko choom loon, tau chalooon, tau chalooon…….

  60. NyKavi 18 June 2009
    01:29:08 pm

    Comment Arrow

    KJO’s Agneepath would need to be renamed as Agneephat. Just a subtle shifting of letters would do it.
    Baaki, the only novelty of the original was the voice of Amitabh. Very risky move which didnt pay off for those times. Unfortunately, no one has the voice to even attempt that in this day and age. Already shrill voices will become shriller. Aur acting to koi match hi nahi kar payega.

  61. ACHILLES 18 June 2009
    02:51:32 pm

    Comment Arrow

    LOL@ TS comments … looks like abhi reduced to play gay acts in Dostana and everywhere after that has affected his fans (those few that remain) quite badly.

  62. Don 18 June 2009
    05:12:47 pm

    Comment Arrow

    From SB:

    TheSkeptic: Well, Ach, KJo made SRK act gay, he has made Abhi act, now he’s set sights on Hrithik. Enjoy the ride.

    :-)

  63. Don 18 June 2009
    05:15:11 pm

    Comment Arrow

    From SB :

    TheSkeptic: And to Rocky, nothing hit me. Except perhaps for the realization that the time is up for employing only one kind of language here. Unless you have been dozing off for the past few months you will notice that there has been a change of climate in these parts. And a facility with languages of both greater and lesser refinement are required if one is to successfully deal with this climate. When barbarians are breaking down the gates, one either swallows some poison or one becomes a barbarian. I have chosen the latter in the interests of adaptability.

    TheSkeptic: To clarify the ambiguity in the last statement, this is not to say that I have joined hands with the barbarians, merely that I do battle with them with the same implements that they wield.

  64. ACHILLES 18 June 2009
    05:16:22 pm

    Comment Arrow

    TS – I am flattered to have caught your attention. Lets not forget we are discussing no more than a rumour. Let hrithik confirm this, then i may think of rejoicing or worrying.

  65. ACHILLES 18 June 2009
    05:24:06 pm

    Comment Arrow

    And thanks johny and don, the epitome of barbaric invasion is NG threads getting hijacked by SB comments.

  66. ACHILLES 18 June 2009
    06:37:57 pm

    Comment Arrow

    Since we are discussing gangster roles, here is my two cents.

    Someone mentioned Neil Mukesh in Gohny Gaddar as gangster role? thats a joke for sure, that guyz role was more of a petty thief. Yes the movie was a slick one, well made. But Neil was weakest part of it, mainly due to weak dialogue delivery and no screen presence. Had Raghavan casted a more charismatic actor in the lead, the movie had the potential of attracting the youth and become at least a hit at box office.

    When i say stylized gangster, its more like Farhan’s Don … SRK imo did very well, he has unique mannerisms in such anti-hero roles that makes him a mean avataar, that comes out well. But the problem with casting SRK in Amitabh’s Don was not mannerisms, acting or even body language. It was due to the difference in the physicality of the two actors. SRK was two too many inches shorter to remake a amitabh role.

    Being more exposed to post-bachchan hayday era of bollywood, the original Don did not exite me any more than Farhan’s version. But I can understand the impact of the original in its time. The only gangster character that made impression on my mind is Devgan in Company – the sharpness of body language, dialogues, intensity of eyes, etc made it apt and memorable … his act gave an impression that malik could quash the overacting oberoi with just a mere glance.

    The next one wud be Dutt in Vaastav, sadly i didnt see such intensity in any other works of both Devgan or Dutt. I am not sure how hrithik will fare in such roles (though i am 100% confident Hrithik wud have ben the best mordern day Don) … the main reason is I dont think hrithik will ever chose to do such a dark movie, which has minimal box office prospects. He is more interested in making a career full of blockbusters.

    Akshay despite his physicality will be a miscast as he lacks a serious personality and the masses accept him only as a comedian much like Govinda. His latest serious attempt in Tasveer is a failure in all accounts.

    If Aamir had the height, he wud surely have made a good gangster. But then he is even smaller, oops i mean shorter than SRK!

  67. Ravi 18 June 2009
    07:02:24 pm

    Comment Arrow

    Nicely said Ach bhai, though for me the original Don was a classic.

  68. Som 18 June 2009
    07:04:30 pm

    Comment Arrow

    Well.. lets not put every SB comment on NG thread.If members start putting SB comments suiting to them and their arguments,I am afraid the thread will merely remain full of SB comments.

  69. ACHILLES 18 June 2009
    07:21:42 pm

    Comment Arrow

    thanks ravi bhai

  70. Kunal 18 June 2009
    10:07:25 pm

    Comment Arrow

    I don’t know whats the fascination of people with remakes, that too remakes of movies like Don, Agneepath. NO matter what the BO record of Agneepath was, it is a genuinely admired movie of BW, and that too rightly so.

    Which was the last successful remake in BW?? and by successful I mean both critical and BO wise.

    Try doing sequels, remakes mein sirf gaali milti hai. And if Karan is so hell bent on remaking Agneepath, take Abhishek, atleast there would be one site which will give good numbers that Amitabh can post on his blog.

  71. Gorilla 18 June 2009
    10:34:45 pm

    Comment Arrow

    agree with Kunal (i hope he is serious) that Abhishek will fit into Agneepath or Don kind of roles better than Hrithik or SRK. (Hate clubs please ignore this statement.)
    Ofcourse here I am assuming his Yuva or Bluffmaster kind of personality, not the Guru one.

  72. Bash 18 June 2009
    10:37:55 pm

    Comment Arrow

    This news can’t be true. Impossible! Karan Johar and Agneepath??? NO WAY!

    “After the kind of Flak SRK got for DON, I would be surprised if Hritik will says yes to this misadventure.”

    I guess the passionate disapprovals that new Don got from staunch Bachchan fans was mainly because it did well. :) Had it flopped as much as they had hoped, it wouldn’t have been discussed.

    Not many understand that Farhan and SRK’s assertions that the new Don character was INTENTIONALLY made Travoltaish and cartoonish.

    I had always thought Hrithik would have been stylish in the real sense rather than the flauntingly on your face kind of style that was attempted. But Hrithik’s body language in Luck By Chance has been a suprise. May be, he would have suited more than SRK.

  73. RAJ 18 June 2009
    10:46:50 pm

    Comment Arrow

    “”"Being more exposed to post-bachchan hayday era of bollywood, the original Don did not exite me any more than Farhan’s version. But I can understand the impact of the original in its time. The only gangster character that made impression on my mind is Devgan in Company – the sharpness of body language, dialogues, intensity of eyes, etc made it apt and memorable … his act gave an impression that malik could quash the overacting oberoi with just a mere glance.”"

    Agree to this 100 Pct…Ajay spoke a lot through his eyes in “”Company”"..His body laguage projected a intelligent but ruthless Gangster..

  74. RAJ 18 June 2009
    11:03:43 pm

    Comment Arrow

    Well..Agneepath was a BO dud when it released and even DON was a not a BIG hit either…The only thing with DON was the script was quite contemprory in nature…Hence it could be remade..Its SRK s charsihma which pulled the movie through..I sincerely belive new Don was a bit better thyan Old one..

    Coming back to Agneepath,it was a stale script even at that time…But Amitabhs charishma and performance which took the movie to a different plane…(Audineces never liked the copied voice modulation of Amitabh from some HW actor,initially.. )I dont think audinces now would be interested to watch such a ghisa pitta script and moreover HR (Any current actor for that matter) would be complete miscast in the role…

    Some were talking about Abhishek fitting in to the role..Well i completely disagree..Abhishek would make a mess of it(As he does in allmost all his movies)…This role require a lot of hamming which i believe even Ajay Devgan is incapable of..

  75. Kunal 18 June 2009
    11:07:40 pm

    Comment Arrow

    Bash, I do agree that mannerisms of SRK were ver Face-off-ish, but the whole attire was actually gayish. If he had been in simpler clothes, and those kind of mannerisms, he would have been as deadly as Travolta in face-off, but at the same time I must tell you that catching up on Travolta is not an easy feat.

    They wanted to show SRK evil personified, as in someone who gets saddistic pleasure in pain, and is kinda mentally imbalanced, but it just didn’t come out that way. You watch Cage in his introduction in Facce Off, and then watch SRK making his entrance in that Ballet scene in Don, different levels altogether.

    Lets just say that their intentions were right, but execution wasn’t.

    And Gorilla, I was not serious about Abhishek being in remake of Agneepath, though you are absolutely right to say that Abhishek will fit in lot better than any of the contemporary actors, and will even get more favorable response from media in general, but then seriously, why a remake???

  76. RAJ 18 June 2009
    11:12:37 pm

    Comment Arrow

    To add to my earlier post,Agneepath was presented stylishly by the director (Mukul Anand if i am right)even at that time…Towering perfromances from Amitabh,Mithun and Danny made the movie a classic…The dialogues were fantastic and lot of credit should go the Dialogue writer too…

    I like the scene where Amitabh emerges from the sea to meet Kancha seth…That was a heck of a scene which is etched in the memory…

  77. Arun 18 June 2009
    11:41:17 pm

    Comment Arrow

    I love that scene at the dinner table with Rohini Hattangadi. Subtle but highly impactful. Amitji was absolutely brilliant in that scene. Also, the one at Vikram Gokhale’s house. The movie was a bit uneven (songs were a put-off) but there were lots of such brilliant moments involving Amitji.

  78. Arun 18 June 2009
    11:54:53 pm

    Comment Arrow

    Vriksh ho bhale khade, ho ghane ho bade,
    Ek patra chhav bhi maang mat, maang mat, maang mat
    Agneepath Agneepath Agneepath.

    Tu na thakega kabhi, tu na thamega kabhi, tu na mudega kabhi,
    Kar shapath, kar shapath, kar shapath,
    Agneepath, Agneepath, Agneepath.

    Ye mahaan drishya hai, chal raha manushya hai, Ashru swed raqt se lathpath, lathpath, lathpath,
    Agneepath, Agneepath, Agneepath.

    Inspiring poem by Harivanshji!

  79. Gorilla 19 June 2009
    12:07:01 am

    Comment Arrow

    [aside]

    एक अमीर लड़की को School में गरीब परिवार pe Essay लिखने को कहा गया|

    ESSAY :

    एक गरीब परिवार था, पिता गरीब,माँ गरीब, बच्चे गरीब.
    परिवार में 4 नौकर थे, वोह भी गरीब.
    Car भी टूटती हुई SCORPIO थी.
    उनका गरीब ड्राईवर बच्चों को उसी टूटती Car में School छोड़ के आता था.
    बच्चों के पास पुराने N95 Mobile थे.
    बच्चे हफ्ते में सिर्फ 3 बार ही HOTEL में खाते थे.
    घर में केवल 4 2nd Hand A.C. थे.
    सारा परिवार बड़ी मुश्किल से ऐश कर रहा था.!!

  80. Bash 19 June 2009
    01:20:20 am

    Comment Arrow

    “. But Bachchan’s bigger than life roles like this will be totally misfit for the non-acting or no-expressions from his son (which fans have learnt to praise as ’subtle’ acting).”

    Totally agree. Abhishek had messed up a few meaty roles with non-acting, whereas his father would try to take every normal role to a lofty level. Pity both have the similar physical attributes – height and intense looks.

  81. Rocky 19 June 2009
    06:48:01 am

    Comment Arrow

    Re.-whereas his father would try to take every normal role to a lofty level

    all I have to say is-

    Tu kitni achhi hai, tu kitni bholi hai
    Pyaari pyaari hai, amaa amaa
    Kitni BHOLI hai, kitni sheetal hai
    Nyaari nyaari hai, amaa amaa
    Pyaari pyaari hai, amaa amaa

  82. Rocky 19 June 2009
    06:55:03 am

    Comment Arrow

    Agreee Arun- the way he says- Kaat ke Phek dega is simply superb.
    Even the scene at the cofee shop where he creates scene is superb.

  83. Rocky 19 June 2009
    06:57:50 am

    Comment Arrow

    Abhishek Bachchan would be a terrible terrible choice for reamaking Agneepath.

  84. Rocky 19 June 2009
    07:07:52 am

    Comment Arrow

    thanks for the long clarification TS, totally makes sense.

  85. ACHILLES 19 June 2009
    03:17:09 pm

    Comment Arrow

    Does anyone expect the Nicholas Cage of Face Off in SRK? if that was the case then SRK wud not be considered the King of Luv.

    None of the Khans can even come close to a Travolta or a Cage in action movies, even if they chose to spend their entire fortune on platform shoes.

    But agree that its foolish to make a remake of a flop film, or even expect a blockbuster by taking Farhan’s version of Don forward. YRF is on the right track of not trying to make a dhoom 3, as ramping up dhoom 2 in style or action would be very difficult given the premise of the franchise. Even a third munnabhai is a difficult proposition as expectations will be sky high and even decent efforts with crumble in front of gigantic expectations. Hirani is better off doing a 3 Idiots instead of Munna chale america.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.