Why we admire Satyajit Ray so much


To his uninformed detractors — including the late Indian actress Nargis Dutt — filmmaker Satyajit Ray was a tireless chronicler of Indian poverty whose Pather Panchali captured the attention of serious filmgoers across the world. Much before the populist and sensational Slumdog Millionaire became an unprecedented award-winning hit, one might add.

But to Ray’s admirers, he was one of the most versatile filmmakers who tackled themes dear to the middle class, made films for young adults and children — including in the mystery genre — and questioned fundamentalism of all hues.

His admirers include movie moguls like Steven Spielberg , iconoclastic directors like Akira Kurosawa and a number of Indian filmmakers including Mrinal Sen, Mira Nair and Buddhadeb Dasgupta.

‘To have not seen the films of Ray,’ asserted Kurosawa, ‘is to have lived in the world without ever having seen the moon and the sun.’

April 15 to 30, New Yorkers and film buffs in the tristate area have a unique opportunity to study the phenomenal filmmaker.

The Film Society of Lincoln Center will be hosting First Light: Satyajit Ray From the Apu Trilogy to the Calcutta Trilogy, a retrospective of the director’s early work. The series, which has over 18 films, is also a tribute to the work of the Satyajit Ray Preservation Project at the Academy Film Archive in Los Angeles, which together with the Satyajit Ray Film and Study Center at the University of California-Santa Cruz has done so much to preserve and promote the work of this major film artist for future generations, said Richard Penya, director, The Film Society of Lincoln Center. There are plans to offer a second series that will include the rest of Ray’s films.

The Lincoln Center festival offers at least six films in new prints from the Academy Film Archive. These include Goopy Gyne Bagha Byne (The Adventures of Goopy and Bagha), Jalsaghar (The Music Room), Kapurush Mahapurush (The Coward and the Holy Man), and Nayak (The Hero).

Many films in the retrospective will surprise those who have seen just one or two of Ray’s masterpieces. Some of these films, say for example Chiriyakhana (The Zoo, a whodunit), may not be as appealing as some of Ray’s best work including the Apu trilogy, but nevertheless they are superior to most films made around that time in India.

Though he worked outside the mainstream, Ray did not see any of his films losing money. While some of his films like Pather Panchali made most of their business in Europe and America, a few of his films like Goopy Gyne Bagha Byne, which were hardly shown abroad, became resounding successes in Bengal.

‘I find I am inimical to the idea of making two similar films in succession,’ Ray had said after making over a dozen films, a tribute to him in The New York Times revealed.

Terrence Rafferty observed in the Times article: ‘Some of the films in this series like the nutty fairy-tale picaresque Goopy Gyne Bagha Byne (1968), can be a little baffling for non-Indian audiences; nothing travels worse than folk humour. And some might make you feel as if you needed to know a good deal more about the history and politics of the subcontinent — and specifically Ray’s native Bengal, where most of his stories are set — to understand the finer nuances of the characters’ behavior… Ray, however, has nuances to burn: you can miss quite a few and still feel as if you know his people intimately.’

In conjunction with the series, Columbia University will hold an April 25 conference on the filmmaker featuring professors of film and literature from universities in the United States and India, including a keynote lecture from Robert Young of New York University and talks by Samik Banerjee, vice chairman, National School of Drama, India.

The Columbia conference will also feature talks by filmmakers Mira Nair — who says Ray and Ritwik Ghatak are the reasons she became a filmmaker — Shyam Benegal — who while being an ad executive dreamt of making films thanks to Ray’s inspiration — and Ray’s son Sandip Ray.

Why is Satyajit Ray admired so much?

‘His films come as close to complete personal expression as may be possible in cinema,’ Helen Goritsas, a Sydney based film-maker and writer, wrote 15 years ago. ‘Ray’s style grows out of the material itself, and from an inner compulsion to express it clearly. The thread that ties the body of his work together is its strong humanist basis… He brought real concerns of real people to the screen… Above all, Ray’s is a cinema of thought and feeling, in which the feeling is deliberately restrained because it is so intense.’

A multifaceted genius

Satyajit Ray (1921-1992) made a movie every year from 1956 to 1981 and received an honorary Oscar for lifetime achievement in 1992. In a country where hardly a filmmaker in the mainstream has made more than 10 successful films, Ray made 36 films and half a dozen documentaries that either broke even or turned in a profit.

His first Hindi-language film Shantranj Ke Khilari (not part of this festival) featuring Sanjeev Kumar, Shabana Azmi and Amjad Khan ran for about six weeks in Mumbai and a few other Indian cities. But the film, called The Chess Players for the international audience, ran for more than 10 weeks in London and New York, and over two weeks in at least 12 European, Canadian and Japanese cities, leading it into profit.

Ray — who switched to films from working in an advertising agency after meeting French filmmaker Jean Renoir and watching Vittoria De Sica’s The Bicycle Thief was — a complete filmmaker.

Ray was a prolific and successful writer too. He created a much-loved private detective, Pradosh C Mitter or Feluda — whose adventures practically every Bengali kid who can read knows by heart — wrote science fiction stories starring the ingenious scientist Professor Shonku, and a huge bunch of short stories (bizarre, macabre, funny, touching, scary, science fiction — you name it he wrote it).

‘The world knows me as a filmmaker,’ he once said in an interview, ‘but my writing brings home the bread.’

Ray, part of an illustrious family of Bengali writers and artists, would also sketch for his stories. The drawings were so much a part of the stories that the people he cast as the characters in the two Feluda films he made were mirror images of his drawings.


  1. 3 Belds
    3 Belds
    April 17, 2009 at 8:06 PM

    abhishek – huh? what case have u made that ray is a great director. just bcoz some pseudos gave him some awards. u really think slumdog is rahman’s best – that shows u how little the oscar juries know

    ritz – probably i went a lil overboard yday ;-) (all for good reason tho) but i can tell you that majority of folks empathize with ur thoughts.

  2. 3 Belds
    3 Belds
    April 17, 2009 at 8:14 PM

    adoor is another guy who doesnt make entertaining movies. I sometimes wonder why these guys make movies like they do. hardly a few watch them, yes they get critical acclaim but that you can get making commercial movies too. I think folks like ashutosh, vishal, mani, raju are far more accomplished to dish out realistic commercial fare that is entertaining. an adoor or a ray movie reminds me of those nfdc documentaries that they used to screen before the main movie starts

  3. 3 Belds
    3 Belds
    April 17, 2009 at 8:36 PM

    >>but Ray is certainly the most famous and widely considered the greatest director India has produced

    what a bunch of crock! considered by who? It is funny how a lawyer can make these outlandish comments without detailing any facts to support it. maybe its cognitive dissonance at work coz q has bought tickets for the ray festival. maybe he is the best bengali director – thats pretty much it

  4. Qalandar
    April 17, 2009 at 9:45 PM

    Neelu: His most recent one Nizhalkuttu (Shadow Kill) and a much earlier one Elippathayam (Rat Trap) are available. The former was interesting, but the latter was superb…

    On Satyamshot someone suggested that a third movie might be available on Youtube with subtitles (I haven’t seen this):


  5. Qalandar
    April 17, 2009 at 9:46 PM

    Thanks salim and neelu for some really informative posts here — on Nakhrewaali I only know (and love) the song of the same name, have not seen the film…

  6. Qalandar
    April 17, 2009 at 9:49 PM

    On Ray, he is not considered great because he won an Oscar — he got that very very late in his life, and was a lifetime achievement Oscar, not for a particular film. He makes every reputed film critic’s “all time” list, whether the critic is Indian or Western. Not to mention that his influence may be seen on a whole host of other filmmakers, including so much of the acclaimed cinema coming our of Iran over the last couple of decades. Above all else, I like Ray’s work because “accessibility” is not compromised by his pursuit of artistic skill, and IMO his films can be watched by just about anybody (not something one can say about every great director — e.g. Antonioni is far less accessible).

  7. neelu
    April 17, 2009 at 10:16 PM

    The Nakhrewali song is from the film New Delhi, and I think it is the only one!

  8. A C H I L L E S
    A C H I L L E S
    April 18, 2009 at 6:55 AM

    Beld – wud like to know which Ray movies have you watched till now?

  9. 3 Belds
    3 Belds
    April 18, 2009 at 9:28 AM

    >>He makes every reputed film critic’s “all time” list,
    what crap. when it is convenient people say that all critics are useless. then we quote the same critics to make someone what they are not. as i said – maybe he is the best bengali director. best indian director – not even close….

    >>>(neelu)If that is the case then please remove my name from the list of NG members
    i second that

  10. 3 Belds
    3 Belds
    April 18, 2009 at 9:32 AM

    ach i have watched shatranj and some of pather… – very boring movies. i have no clue on his bengali work and as i have said he may be the best director of bengali movies – lets not make him to what he is not – at least not proven..

  11. Rocky
    April 18, 2009 at 11:34 AM

    How are you Tango ? kaun jeet raha hai U.P. mein???

Page 2 of 2 1 2

Comments are closed.

synthroid .112 mg vs .125 levitra preisvergleich 20 mg strattera 40 mg capsules diflucan buy generic cialis generic now cialis 5mg meals buy dapoxetine treatment generic strattera 100mg lexapro 10mg panic celebrex 200 mg tablets safe clomid online phenergan 50 mg tablets zoloft 100mg effects google viagra 800mg order viagra cialis 8 generic cialis softtabs 3 discount generic viagra buy cialis line taking 5 mg lexapro 20 mg zoloft green generic wellbutrin viagra generico pericoloso wellbutrin movement disorders generic cialis 50 clomid 50mg endometriosis diflucan 150 mg men generic strattera reviews bactrim generic price online viagra kauf doxycycline 100mg vomit cialis generica 40mg lasix 40 mg bijsluiter viagra 50 mg 30 tablet nexium mups 20 mgs doxycycline kegunaan 50 mg cialis 10 mg tab zoloft 50 mg ed lasix 20 mg injection 20 mg generic viagra acheter nexium 40 mg generic cialis 100 mg buy cialis reviews strattera 100 mg buy synthroid 100 mg daily prednisone 20 mg interactions cheap clomid 50mg doxycycline 110 mg wellbutrin 125 mg price 40 mg nexium prednisone 20mg symptoms buy viagra hk generic cialis efectiveness augmentin generic names buy viagra powder generic wellbutrin problems lisinopril 5 mg reviews there generic zoloft augmentin sale online cipro online pharmacy cytotec apteka online posologie prednisone 20 mg bactrim generic name buy clomid proviron viagra 100 mg reviews prednisone cost 5 mg kamagra 100mg erfahrungsberichte generic chinese cialis augmentin tab 500mg propecia 5mg result generic viagra hawaii diflucan 40 mg ml strattera 120 mg rec lisinopril 20 mg dosing cialis 20 mg yorum buy viagra mexico cialis 80 mg au costo cialis 20 mg viagra 500mg price cheap cialis toronto generic celebrex medication the cheapest viagra lisinopril 2.5 mg medicine buy cytotec pills brand cialis order viagra 100mg use aphrodisiac viagra online buy xenical reviews cialis generic effectiveness generic wellbutrin drug 50 mg clomid unsuccessful zoloft adjustment disorder viagra dosage mg nexium 40mg order clomid 50mg infertility buy propecia 1 mg clomid 50mg comprar generic celebrex cost celebrex 50 mg capsule viagra drops online cialis generico india generic levitra.de want buy viagra zithromax 500 mg nebenwirkungen celebrex 400 mg cap augmentin 500 mg tid kamagra gold 100 mgpret bactrim ds 400 mg cheapest price valtrex fish cipro 500mg mg of augmentin buy viagra suppositoria buy bactrim antibiotic metformin uk buy viagra 50 or 100 mg augmentin 625 mg prot 25 mg of clomid lexapro mg size lexapro 5 mg sale lexapro 40 mg pregnancy cipro 500 mg medication generic powdered viagra cialis 100 mg wiki prednisone 20 mgdosage prednisone dosage 20mg nolvadex generic pct viagra 25 mg kopen buy propecia proscar canada generic celebrex levitra 20mg 4 tabletten buy nolvadex prices prednisone 40 mg 3 days buying generic cialis take 2 20mg levitra viagra pills cheap cheap 40 mg cialis buy branded cialis phenergan 10mg sleep levitra 20 mg generico 40mg generic cialis clomid 25 mg pct synthroid 75 mg 150 mg lexapro cialis 10mg split real zithromax online cialis 20mg asli celebrex tab 100mg cheap viagra vancouver strattera generic dose dog prednisone 5mg viagra online purchases buy cipro 500 online zovirax order prednisone 10 mg insomnia metformin ratiopharm 850mg 2.5mg cialis generic netherland buy viagra propecia cost generic phenergan dm generic prednisone mylan 1 mg levitra 20 mg sample nexium 40mg safe chewable viagra online nexium dr 10mg glucophage sr 500mg lasix 500 mg furosemide prednisone 20mg cures buy 60 mg nolvadex cheap generic clomid zoloft pfizer 50 mg viagra 100 mg prix buy viagra topix cialis 10 mg duration buy kamagra 100 mg buy cheapest cialis cialis 10mg canad metformin bp 500 mg nexium 40 mg tabs taking 100mg zoloft cialis 20 mg farmaco doxycycline 100mg antimalarial prednisone sleep disorders prednisone 5mg tapering buy viagra register online viagra chennai propecia buy generic bugiardino levitra 10 mg cheap liquid viagra cialis 5 mg europe clomid comprar online doxycycline 100 mg espanol diflucan generic version 200 mg clomid success levitra venta online cialis 20 mg tabletten cytotec generico generic viagra wallgreen blue zoloft 50 mg viagra 100 mg cheap cialis 2,5 mg nl order viagra cheap lexapro medication generic buy viagra doha thailand buy viagra xenical orlistate 200mg medicamentos genericos viagra xenical generico 120 mg celebrex bleeding disorders cipro 500mg generic generica viagra forums spain kamagra online online cialis consultation 99 generic viagra xenical generic canada prednisone mylan 20mg cialis 20 mg assunzione generic viagra kolkata lisinopril hctz 10 mg viagra buyonline online kamagra sales bactrim ds buy buy strattera cheap cipro online safe buying viagra vegas order viagra canadian zoloft 50 mg nebenwirkungen buy amoxil medication buy kamagra sukhumvit lexapro generic cialis 10 mg coupons erythromycin 250mg goi achat kamagra 100mg buy kamagra cheap generic valtrex brands levitra order cialis cipro 30 mg soft cialis 40 mg generic strattera .80 mg cialis 2.5 mg cheap 60 mg of propranolol lasix 20 mg tablet cheap online levitra generic propecia fertility cheap viagra alternatives reliable cheap cialis buy amoxil 500g buy diflucan cvs levitra 40 mg online augmentin prospect 125 mg buy cytotec 200mg zovirax 800 mg cialis 20 mg strength lasix tabs 40mg kamagracheaper kamagra jelly prednisone 10mg eczema buy cheap lasix xenical 120 mg leaflet cialis online packstation zovirax 400 mg hinta prednisone tablets 40 mg 90 day cialis 20mg buy doxycycline internet buy viagra 30 viagra generic overnight buspar order online generic clomid walmart buy cialis mastercard beli cialis 20 mg generic augmentin es prednisone 20mg 477 buspar 20 mg day buy cialis canadian zithromax 50mg feline cialis 100 mg sahte tetracycline 200mg bought generic cialis cialis mg tabs bijwerkingen celebrex 200 mg cialis super 20mg metformin hcl buyers buy professional viagra celebrex 200 mg recreational lexapro 200 mg viagra 100 mg fiyat generic40mg cialis metformin 850 mg axcount buying strattera online ranbaxy generic cialis levitra 10mgs levitra generico bula 40 mg lisinopril online cialis online sales lisinopril dosage 40 mg metformin bluefish 850mg clomid buy pakistan online viagra kaufen erythromycin 250 mg pregnancy xenical 120mg hartkapseln cutting 20mg levitra lisinopril 15 mg zovirax 200 mg dosis cialis 5 mg bijwerkingen cialis 100 mg ankara diflucan 150 mg prospecto amoxil 500 mg dogs diflucan cream buy purchasing nolvadex online buy viagra.ca 5 mg cialis canada zithromax order online prix cialis 20 mg all generic viagra generic viagra 100 lexapro 20 mg sale 875mg augmentin dosage buy amoxil online cialis tab 20 mg prednisone 20mg 5443 generic prednisone order order cialis holland xenical 120 mg paraguai lisinopril 10 mg capsule hydrochlorothiazide cost 25mg 50mg viagra fiyati strattera 60 mg erowid folcres generic propecia zithromax monodose 250 mg lasix 40 mg ampullen 600 mg cialis lexapro 10 mg lisinopril 10mg headache xenical 120mg tablet Online Generic Levitra generic name bactrim obat valtrex 500mg prednisone axapharm 50 mg metformin 500 mg tb strattera 80 mg adderall priligy 60 mg forum 200 mg erythromycin phosphate strattera buyers cheap diflucan levitra orodispersibile 5 mg cheap viagra 100 uk buy prednisone us 10mg cialis review cheap xenical tablets lexapro 5 mg shaky valtrex generic wikipedia cialis online 50mg augmentin 625 mg tabletta is generic cialis cialis generico aurochem lexapro generic manufacturers 500 mg generic cialis propranolol 10 mg cost cialis generic chinatown generico di augmentin viagra perth buy order cialis 5mg nexium tablets 50mg lisinopril al 5 mg everyday cialis online valtrex 500 mg prescriptions tadalafil tadacip 20 mg 115, 40 mg doxycycline dominican generic viagra cialis 20 mg coupon zoloft generic alternative generic mexican viagra lexapro 5mg online glucophage generics levitra dosage 10 mg cheap kamagra tablets india cialis generic augmentin 312 mg viagra generic aclepsa comprar levitra online buy 500 mg zithromax diflucan 200 mg costo 30 day 5mg cialis canadian cialis 200 mg. viagra online slovenija utilisation kamagra 100mg cialis online bih generic viagra zoll viagra generic medication cipro 500 mg dose clomid 50mg homme clomid vs generic doxycycline buy discount buy cytotec kuwait celecoxib 200 mg celebrex clomid 25mg pregnant cialis 2.5 buy online cheap levitra.com cialis 20mg online cialis 20 mg 4 tabletas phenergan mg 50 generic zovirax tab cialis 10 mg avis zovirax 400 mg precio viagra 100 mg annostus prednisone mg doses synthroid to generic buy genuine kamagra propecia malaysia online wellbutrin xl 600 mg augmentin cpr 500 mg strattera study 60mg bactrim 200 40 mg strattera generic buy buy clomid supplement levitra 10 mg. sublinguale cialis 10 mg b4 metformin 500 mg price generic viagra doxycycline viagra online 60 cents 250mg zoloft paypal propecia cheap 300 mg clomid cipla 5mg cialis viagra andorra online generic levitra there buy kamagra london prednisone cristers 20mg nolvadex australia online augmentin es 600 generic viagra alternative buy generic propecia sweden buy bactrim tablets lisinopril 10 mg tab 1 mg prednisone dogs prednisone 300mg buy priligy safe lisinopril 20 mg nausea discount online propecia viagra cheap 100mg levitra 20mg canadian cheapest indian viagra cheap valtrex uk lisinopril 5mg vidal prednisone dosage 60mg cialis online cipla generic levitra 20 canada lasix 200 mg iv viagra generic definition zoloft 200mg reviews cheap viagra nottingham synthroid 0.137mg apteka online clomid v 5092 20 mg prednisone generic strattera 25 mg buy paypal viagra medicaments cialis 20 mg 200 mg celebrex xenical de 120 mg nolvadex 20 mg pct zithromax 500mg 4 dose diflucan 150mg generico apa nexium 20mg cheap buy viagra valtrex 3000 mg 50 mg strattera cialis 10 mg tadalafil 20 mg lexapro alcohol buy clomid 100g lisinopril tab 2.5.mg 800mg generic viagra cialis 100 mg varmi diflucan 50 mg capsules augmentin 625mg used 200 mg of wellbutrin buy viagra amsterdam generic cialis 72 hour cialis 30 5mg propecia generic manufacturer celebrex 220 mg tetracycline 250 mg chlamydia lexapro generic 30 mg augmentin 875 mg duration buy 25 mg viagra cheap cialis pharmasy order prednisone overnight 12 mg viagra valtrex generic cheap generic cialis isosorb red cialis 200 mg buy doxycycline onlinemalaysia 20 mg di levitra buying propecia singapore buy orlistat alli 20 mg propranolol generic viagra singapore prednisone cats 5mg metformin stada 500 mg viagra sklep online clomid 50mg unsuccessful augmentin 500mg goi taking 2 20 mg cialis zoloft 50 mg sospensione