Abzee’s thoughts on Firaaq

SPOILER ALERT!!! Read only if you’ve seen the film 

Nandita Das’s Firaaq, whether she likes it or not, whether she intended or not…whether she knows or not- is a very political film. A deeply troubling one at that! As a filmmaker, one must be very sensitive when handling subjects that deal with actual real-life incidents, especially ones that affected a multitude. The ‘sensitivity’ one expects, in other words, is an expectation of a neutral voice, of a work that highlights the ‘incident’, ruminates on it, makes you think…and leaves you with more than something to chew on. The best of narratives in fact achieve much more than this- they almost become fables and gift you with a poignant lesson in humanity. Eg. Schindler’s List, Life Is Beautfiul, etc.  

But what does one do when one makes a film on an incident such as the Holocaust or the Godhra carnage(that forms the basis of Firaaq) which are disturbingly one-sided. How does a filmmaker attempt to ‘balance’, when the unevenness is mitigating in its ‘execution’? Well, cinema is a lovely art-form, and like all works of art, eventually results in catharsis of its audience. So, as artists, it becomes our prerogative and responsibility to help trigger the right emotions. Aristotle believed that plays were written about the peasant-folk and their angst so that their anger could have a ‘reasonable’ vent in the expression of the play and its characters. Great monarchs commissioned writers to write plays that were aimed at quelling possible common-folk rebellions. I will have to compare Firaaq to Mumbai Meri Jaan to elaborate on my argument, as the latter does everything ‘right’ what the former wrongs. 

The face of villainy- when dealing with incidents such as the Holocaust or the Godhra massacre, incidents that were lopsided, filmmakers can very easily fall prey to ‘generalization’. When making a film on the Holocaust, one has to be very careful in not presenting the present Germans as responsible for the act or all of the Germans who lived back then as complicit to it. The manner in which this is achieved is by denying the narrative a ‘villain’. In films such as The Pianist or Life Is Beautiful, the ‘situation’, the ‘times’, the ‘madness’ become the villain. These films do not have a definite ‘face’ to their villain. Also, despite the involvement of civilians, one restrains from portraying civilians, in general, in a negative light. The acts of villainy are carried out by the state and its agents. In Firaaq, Nandita Das shockingly generalizes the whole Hindu Gujarati community as remorseless evil fundamentalists who want nothing more than to wipe the Muslims off the map of Gujarat. So in a film that is about the sufferings of Muslims in a post-Godhra Gujarat, the only Hindu characters are either plain evil, ignorant or impotent.  

Nandita Das, in a dubious and poor casting decision, chooses the Hindu Gujarati Paresh Rawal to play a Hindu Gujarati- a wife-beating, Muslim-hating evil minion of the nth order. In Mumbai Meri Jaan, Nishikant Kamat very cleverly avoided the ‘easy’ casting choice of Madhavan for the south Indian. But Das is not sensitive, and she surely ain’t subtle. So the film opens to a macabre pile of Muslim bodies being loaded off a truck, topped by a body of a child nonetheless, and the Muslim gravedigger(Tamil actor Nasser) who gets enraged when he sees a Hindu woman among the pile and decides to attack her dead carcass with his shovel. The gravedigger, never seen for the rest of the film, turns up in a worrying climax to underline what has until then been the most politically problematic film in recent times. I’ll come to that later. 

I was willing to overlook that Das chose to have a Hindu Gujarati play a Hindu Gujarati as the face of villainy…willing to overlook that every Hindu character in the film from a roadside omlette-vendor to an educated upper-middle-class couple seemed to either condone the state-sponsored pogrom or have an apathetic reaction towards it. It didn’t even matter that the crisis of the Deepti Naval character, the only Hindu character that was haunted by the bloodbath, was resolved more as a feminist triumph than a socialist awakening. No, all of this I was still willing to overlook. Where the film became unpardonably troubling for me was in a scene towards the end. A Muslim youth runs away from a cop and successfully evades him. A random Hindu Gujarati looks out of his terrace and asks the cop about who is running after. The cop says, “Ek miyaan”. Later, having evaded the cop, the Muslim youth comes out of hiding and takes shelter under the very terrace that the Hindu Gujarati we earlier met lives in. The Hindu Gujarati notices him, goes inside, brings out a slab of rock and throws it on the Muslim youth’s head, killing him instantly. By having a random character of one community resort to a sudden random act of violence against the other community, Das incriminates an entire community of being in on the carnage.  

If that weren’t bad enough, a young Muslim kid Mohsin, who has been witness to his mother and aunt being raped and killed by Hindu extremists, is witness to this act. The film closes with this kid returning to the shelter camp he earlier ran away from in search of his father. Only this time, the kid has lost his innocence. He refuses an invitation by other kids to play marbles. He sits stoically against a wall, and Das reveals the man sitting next to him- the gravedigger we met in the beginning. With nothing said between the two, and leaving a blank stare on the kid’s face, Das diegetically ties the future of this kid with that of the gravedigger. Who knows what this kid could grow up to become? He could grow up hating all Hindus, or worse get brainwashed into becoming a Jihadi. His future is most certainly bleak, and for Das sadly, it is also the only future possible.  

As a Muslim walking out of this film, having seen all Muslim characters suffering and not seeing one repentant Hindu character but instead have an actual Hindu Gujarati play the ‘face’ of villainy, what is my catharsis going to be? Has my anger been given a proper, responsible and reasonable channel? Or have I been incited, and dangerously so in an ignorant and naïve fashion? Let me come back to Nishikant Kamat’s Mumbai Meri Jaan and illustrate how he gets it right where Nandita Das gets it so wrong. 

In Kamat’s film, apart from the casting cleverness mentioned earlier, he also did something very admirable and responsible by having the Kay Kay Menon character. Kamat’s film was based on the 7/11 Mumbai train bombings. That too was a one-sided act of violence, innocent civilians losing their lives to an act of terror. The film could have easily been only about those who suffered in the aftermath of those attacks. It could have only been about Madhavan, Irrfan and Soha. It need not have been about Paresh Rawal’s cop and Kay Kay’s Hindu fanatic. But these two characters served as different devices. Rawal’s cop was the resigned voice of a city that had come to accept its crumbling under many variables, but Kay Kay’s character served a more important function, a function that Aristotle would’ve been proud of.  

Had Mumbai Meri Jaan been just about those who suffered those attacks, directly or indirectly, I could’ve walked out of the auditorium sad and angry…at the attacks and the terrorists. Unreasonable and gullible minds could even find their hatred against the Muslim community being vindicated. In having Kay Kay’s character, Kamat tempers your anger and disallows you from jumping to hasty conclusions. So right from the beginning, in Kay Kay, he plants a surrogate for the audience who is presented as an extremist Hindu who believes every Muslim is a terrorist. The loud, exaggerated execution of the character is meant to create the Brechtian alienation so important for us to view him from afar. We get turned off by his insinuations…and if we do find ourselves relating to him, then Kamat cleanses us by having his character go through a graph where he ashamedly realizes his own folly. We walk out of the hall, feeling both heavy and light at the same time…..but more importantly, guided in our responses and reactions by a clever and sensitive director. 

Nandita Das’s inert film does nothing of the sort. A narrative that pretty much ends where it begins(if not at a worse and bleaker place), Firaaq offers no hope and no respite. I’m not asking for a dance number, but certainly a more life-affirming end.

19 Comments

  1. Gorilla
    Gorilla
    March 23, 2009 at 11:25 PM

    excellent review. Read it in parts (beginning and end) as I have not seen the film and can relate to most of what abzee would have felt if the film indeed is one-sided.

  2. julie
    julie
    March 23, 2009 at 11:33 PM

    A bold and engaging take on the film. Excellent piece there ăbzee.

    Even though I haven’t seen the film, I can relate with your views. For her first directoral venture, Nandita Das has conveyed only one side of the picture.

  3. neelu
    neelu
    March 23, 2009 at 11:35 PM

    Thanks abzee, beautiful review. IMO most extreme liberal sentiment presents its own POV and casts its own biases on any telling of a story. Dev was extremely balanced and unique. Do people think Gulzaar’s Maachis was a balanced film, or colored by his sentiments?

  4. rudresh
    rudresh
    March 23, 2009 at 11:36 PM

    really disturbing.

  5. rudresh
    rudresh
    March 23, 2009 at 11:38 PM

    And after reading it I donot think I ever want to see the film.
    IS Nandita Das Bengali?

  6. RAJ
    RAJ
    March 23, 2009 at 11:41 PM

    Nadita Das is an Oriya..She is the Daughter of Dr.Jatin Das(Artist and Social worker)

  7. julie
    julie
    March 24, 2009 at 1:00 AM

    My main problem with themes like Firaaq is that when movie makers do not undertake proper research on the subject and make a representation of facts as skewed as this, they ignore the deeper and more sensitive issues that are involved in the subject. Genocide or pogrom is by no means something anyone will endorse, but one must be very sensitive in the way such themes are represented across the board, through the medium of cinema. Imagine the impact for instance a movie made on the genocide of 26/11 would have on the sensitivities of viewers.

    This also points out to some deeper issues. Our movie makers either seriously lack in creative talent, or have just run out of subject and good scripts to work on. Nandita Das would have possibly made a greater impact had she selected a theme on Gujarat’s poverty, slums rather than tackling a theme which has been done to death by both the media and fimmakers.

  8. Tango
    Tango
    March 24, 2009 at 3:29 AM

    Thanks Abzee.

    I like the way you bring forth the plus and minus and also the fact that even in criticism you are balanced.

    I have not seen Firaaq and your review deters me further. I dont like one sided portrayals.

  9. Kambakth Beld
    Kambakth Beld
    March 24, 2009 at 8:07 PM

    i am all for cinematic liberty but i think there should be limits to that. Based on abzee’s version of the movie (great one at that – i for one believe he can write awesome stuff as long as he stays away from srk ;-) ), I think this movie definitely qualifies for banning. Who are we kidding here – we censor movies with sex, movies with minority bashing – why cant we censor movies with majority bashing. Some convoluted logic of how we want to show that we are a free society where we allow all opinions to flourish.

    anyway – thanks abz – this is a movie i will avoid and so will I avoid nandita das going forward.

  10. rudresh
    rudresh
    March 24, 2009 at 9:07 PM

    True Beld, Had you seen a single channel pointing out this. And if some movie have had single word against minority these channels whould have come up with the special buletins, debates and blah blah….

  11. RAJ
    RAJ
    March 24, 2009 at 10:43 PM

    Nadita Das alnog with Shabana Azmee are the members of so called pseudo secular brigade for quite a long time…They are from that school where majority bashing is termed as secular..I am never been a fan of Nadita Das evenif she belongs to my Home City…

    Infact more than Narendra Modi ,these are the individuals we should be careful of…Atleast Modi does something for masses but charachters like Nadita and Shabana only toxicates the atmospere and make their bucks……

  12. RAJ
    RAJ
    March 24, 2009 at 10:51 PM

    A large chunk of the English media(most of them have communist bent of mind) still try to haunt Modi with Gujrat Riots whenever there is a election…The entire media tried to entangle Modi in last Gujrat election..What happned???Modi who was on weak grounds when the campaigning started won with a thumping majority..

    My point is when Gujrat has moved on after the incidents ,why the media is trying to widen the wound…And the timing of release of the movie “”Firaq”” proves that the same section of people is out again to incite the sentiments…

    The more media and psedu secularists will try to corner MODI the more stronger he would become…

  13. Bachchan Khan
    Bachchan Khan
    March 25, 2009 at 5:40 AM

    One should always see all sides of the pie. Nothing more to say. Good review by Abzee.

  14. Rocky
    Rocky
    March 26, 2009 at 8:31 AM

    Some great comments by Julie, Beld and Raj on a great post by Abzee, his need for disclaimer not withstanding !!

  15. rockstar
    rockstar
    March 26, 2009 at 9:27 AM

    good points on media

    media boom in india(mostly english media) is still at its nascent stage and at present its some elite’s who controls it its a fact though

    well on to N.D.T.V one remembers how some journalist who covered some operation got padam shree by government with no past accolade these things certainly raises question

    on to movie must say its the poltical hue and cry again most of the persons mentioned here are themselves poltical figures with association from certain parties though they are actors so what can you expect from them when elections are round the corner

  16. rockstar
    rockstar
    March 26, 2009 at 9:32 AM

    and as someone mentioed one has to look at all side of pie isn’t if there had been no godhra(where people have been burnt alive in a locked train which is being ignored compleately) there would have been no riots to

  17. Qalandar
    Qalandar
    March 26, 2009 at 10:38 AM

    Re: “Who are we kidding here – we censor movies with sex, movies with minority bashing – why cant we censor movies with majority bashing.”

    Which films have been censored on the grounds of minority bashing?

  18. rockstar
    rockstar
    March 27, 2009 at 11:31 AM

    “Nadita Das alnog with Shabana Azmee are the members of so called pseudo secular brigade for quite a long time…They are from that school where majority bashing is termed as secular..I am never been a fan of Nadita Das evenif she belongs to my Home City…

    forget that most of their antics are unique right from the time they showed their lesbian love on screen in fire

    the most hillarious comment from shabana which i heard was about gadar and how that is an anti minority movie

Page 1 of 1

Post Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

pret augmentin 1000 mg prednisone 10 mg pill cialis 5 mg review viagra generico comprar clomid 100mg twins cialis 5 mg online kamagra 100 mg etkisi buy cheap valtrex buy clomid philippines tab zovirax 800 mg tetracycline 250 mg capsules viagra 100 mg dosis cialis 20mg kohlpharma cialis 10mg bih augmentin dosage 1000mg synthroid dosage 0.05mg safest generic viagra propecia 1 mg online thuoc diflucan 150 mg 20 mg cialis daily clomid 150 mg bfp viagra cheap now cialis super cheap 20mg cialis cheap metformin actavis 850 mg generic viagra ingrediants generic equal lexapro viagra women buy generic cialis sweden synthroid order online buy cipro online clomid success buy 80 mg strattera cost clomid 100mg bula efeito viagra generico taking 100mg viagra cialis 5mg bula kamagra tablet 50 mg 20mg cialis take 2 buy cialis 2.5 pills metformin mylan 1000 mg where buy nolvadex buying viagra pharmacy levitra generico foros buy doxycycline georgia doxycycline 100 mg medication price propecia online 40 mg levitra review zuzahlung nexium 20mg generic cialis nosebleed diflucan generico prezzo generic viagra classifieds 80 mg of lasix diflucan 150 mg cps generic for lisinopril viagra india cheap cialis generico thuoc prednisone 5mg buy nexium discount metformin online order generic wellbutrin teva cialis 1omg viagra cheapest generic 30 mg de lexapro 200 mg of strattera cialis 5 mg nedir aventis phenergan 25 mg discounted cialis 20 mg strattera buy philippines clomid steroid online dog prednisone 20mg buy viagra condoms lisinopril 20 mg uses cheapest uk cialis cialis cena 5mg propranolol 10 mg pregnancy nexium 20 mg directions cialis 5 mg cpr 28 lisinopril cheap zithromax generic name viagra sordera 10mg levitra levitra 20 mg doses buy doxycycline onlinemalaysia comprare propecia online celebrex 200mg nhs buy fake clomid cheap amoxil buy clomid otc generic cipro online viagra 50 mg nebenwirkungen viagra generic uk erythromycin capsules 250 mg dosis cialis 10 mg nexium 20 mg buying kamagra jel cheap ranbaxy viagra 50 mg viagra de 50 mgs clomid dosage150 mg 100mg clomid uk wholesale kamagra 100mg order strattera canada cipro 500mg directions cialis da 10 mg generic vs levitra cheap price nexium 10 mg viagra pfizer viagra 150 mg kamagra 100mg sildenafil drug doxycycline 100mg cialis bayer 20mg philippine generic cialis generic 100 mg viagra zovirax generico viagra kobra 100mg lasix tablets 20 mg achat viagra 25 mg 180 mg strattera valtrex 500mg gsk order cipro uk prescription viagra generic lexapro generic brands dapoxetine viagra online buy generic glucophage cheapest valtrex prices buy kamagra california viagra 50 mg kullananlar buy lexapro 20mg buy doxycycline 20mg phenergan 25mg supp lisinopril abz 5 mg viagra de 100 mgs nome generico xenical clomid malaysia online metformin dosage 1500 mg lisinopril generic form cialis pricing 20mg generic synthroid price cialis 20 mg venda lexapro anxiety 20 mg buy viagra toilets bactrim backorder medikament celebrex 200mg buy bactrim iv cipro registrations online cialis 5 mg wirkungsdauer dapoxetine for cheap propranolol 40 mg preis lasix retard 30 mg 10mg cialis time generic viagra internet generic nexium name buy hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg clomid 150mg follistim identify lisinopril 10 mg viagra 25mg sildenfil lisinopril 10mg used amoxil buy paypal lasix 20 mg pills lexapro generic list 20 mg levitra online lexapro 10 mg 10 weeks cialis 20 mg tablet lisinopril 40 mg tablet order levitra india comprar levitra generico cheapest clomid online xenical stronger prednisone mylan 5mg phenergan 25 mg iv 20mg lilly cialis levitra 10 mg kullananlar buy cialis in doxycycline hyclate 400 mg levitra online usa nolvadex 20 mg generic metformin 500 mg walmart zoloft 200 mg dosage 10mg daily cialis order cialis men cheap buspar buy lexapro uk cialis generico tadacip cialis 10 mg effective generic shop kamagra medicamento amoxil 500 mg diflucan capsule 100 mg online viagra erfahrung buy diflucan pill wellbutrin sr 100mg buy viagra prescription synthroid .15 mg 200 mg brand cialis cialis generic timetable cialis china cheap online zovirax buy buy prednisone dogs cialis © original 20mg generic metformin manufacturer cipro online uk diflucan 150 mg pret condom viagra buy order viagra eu usa cialis online metformin 500 mg kinderwunsch viagra generics safe viagra doctor online discount generic cialis generic 5mg levitra propranolol retard 40 mg cialis 5mg enough lasix generic tablet augmentin price 500mg viagra generico retirado viagra online wo diflucan 100 mg 5 doses tetracycline cap 250 mg xenical 120mg usa viagra canada generic woman generic viagra opiniones xenical 120 mg lexapro movement disorder buy lasix tabs wat kamagra 100mg viagra 100mg 50mg 20 mg citalopram buy propecia coupon zoloft generic brand generic viagra 25 mg cialis preisvergleich 20 mg cheap levitra importers generic bactrim price zithromax 1000mg cialis generico pericoloso levitra 10 mg paypal buy zoloft 100mg viagra online 150 mg levitra purchase online generic lexapro usa cialis 40 mg aust cialis 40 mg. cheapest viagra pfizer online propecia us doxycycline dosage 300 mg cialis 5mg. daily viagra generico eurofarma generics viagra paypal bactrim forte 480 mg hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg tqua cialis pills 10 mg 5 mg. cialis discounts viagra cheap line generic wellbutrin odor generic lexapro anxiety lexapro 10 mg scored prednisone 20 mg 5 days viagra generico torino bayer 20 mg levitra generic tadalafil cialis cialis 20 mg. cheasp cipro 400mg online viagra prescriptions frequency metformin 500mg generic lexapro oral cialis ricetta online levitra 20 mg dosis bactrim 80 mg tablet acquisto viagra 25 mg generic sub bactrim buy clomid malaysia buy levitra 100mg nexium cheaper alternative levitra 20 mg break levitra 10 mg 4 st much viagra online generico cialis venezuela generic viagra 20 mg valtrex 1000 mg canada dosage phenergan 25mg cialis price 2.5 mg cipro mgs buy lasix generic weaning prednisone 10mg celebrex generics zithromax powder order cialis buy chea cheap cialis safe costo diflucan 100 mg online viagra risks synthroid non generic cialis 20mg malaysia 2013 levitra 10 mg wikipedia lisinopril 2.5 mg headaches lisinopril 5 mg qualitest synthroid thyroid disorders xenical 120 mg doxycycline 20 mg vet viagra 25 mg. enough cialis online confidential preis kamagra 100mg best buy viagra taking cialis 30 mg celebrex pfizer 100mg lasix 40 mg beipackzettel original nolvadex 20 mg tra 150 mg viagra two 20mg cialis metformin sr 850 mg generic viagra cz cialis 20 mg tabletas 5 mg prednisone taper metformin mylan 500mg wellbutrin buy bactrim 240mg cialis 1800 mg synthroid generics names online viagra ratings zithromax 250 mg packungsbeilage generic alcohol cialis buy levitra now viagra 25 mg order cialis 2.5 mg generic 10mg generic cialis order strattera mastercard cialis buy mastercard cialis 2.5mg review docmorris levitra 10mg lexapro escitalopram 10 mg strattera cheap online clomid online order viagra orders diflucan 150mg generico cialis 20mg cc lasix 20 mg cheap buy priligy dapoxetine cialis 20mg half generic lasix 100 mg strattera 18mg, zyprexa buying clomid privately wellbutrin purchase online actavis wellbutrin generic prednisone 10mg 12 day viagra nz buy cialis 20mg berichte buspar 10 mg vidal lisinopril generic review levitra viagra online kamagra soft generico buy doxycycline australia 10mg cialis tablets cialis 20 mg confezioni levitra 100mg kaufen cialis generic best buy ciprofloxacin cipro generic viagra urdu glucophage 1000 mg overdose buying viagra nyc kamagra generic cialis order viagra london viagra c200 online xenical buy ireland buy viagra chennai cheap cialis 40 mg prednisone 20 mg uses doxycycline buy usa buy strattera discount rx cialis online cheap cialis online .50 buying cialis legal metformin 100 mg reviews zovirax brand generic 10mg nolvadex daily blue 800 mg viagra cialis internet order nolvadex 20 mg dosage erythromycin 50 mg furosemida lasix 20 mg generic valtrex canada prednisone 5mg dosage bactrim f 400mg cialis 20 mg eu lasix generic oxycontin levitra 10mg polska cheapest reputable viagra lisinopril 7.5mg phenergan 12.5mg iv kamagra online romania kabdungan celebrex 300 mg valtrex 1000 mg fiyati cialis 20mg achat phenergan buy online 500mg cipro uti xenical buy winnipeg doxycycline order zovirax 200mg tablet nexium 40 mg mexico nexium 20mg 28 50mg kamagra jellies viagra chemist online buy lisinopril viagra generico cinfa herb viagra 6800 mg strattera generic 25 mg cytotec de 5 mg viagra online dealers generic cialis 1.89 generic viagra warnng lloyds viagra online 800mg of viagra viagra 100 mg prezzi viagra buy montreal viagra 25 mg funziona pill nolvadex online generic cialis nz cialis 10 mg cipla erythromycin order online types cialis online cialis 1mg propecia brand cheap buy real nolvadex clomid 50mg tablets generic propecia target cialis cheap 5mg wholesale cialis 20mg zovirax generic cream cialis 40 mg australia valtrex online bestellen viagra japan buy safest online viagra coupon cialis 5mg cialis 5mg costs cialis 200 mg india misoprostol cytotec buy existe generico viagra generic order viagra 40 mg of strattera myla lisinopril 2.5 mg cipro xr 500mg viagra generico compro augmentin 457 mg suspension 30 generic cialis softtabs augmentin amoxicilina 500mg valtrex online canada generic cialis authentic cialis generico forum lexapro generic image metformin 500 mg pdr cialis generic pakistan nexium 40 mg review cialis lilly 40mg viagra online doma lisinopril online prescription diflucan 2 pill 150 mg xenical 120mg emagrece celebrex 200 mg review traitement clomid 50mg cialis thailand online doxycycline hyclate online 50 mg phenergan safe augmentin 625 mg doses metformin generic otc propranolol hydrochloride 40 mg buy clomid vancouver cialis 10 mg effectiveness cipro 500 mg alkol buy 1 gramm zithromax nexium 40mg order prednisone withdrawal 5 mg buy prednisone 2.5mg erfahrungen viagra online dapoxetine 60mg usa cheap lisinopril 10mg zithromax 400 mg strattera 100mg germany order zovirax uk viagra 100mg posologie metformin 500 mg stada cialis 10 mg directions dapoxetine online australia viagra generic tesco doxycycline 200 mg lyme wellbutrin 150 mg online bulk buy viagra levitra online discount viagra 100mg english viagra 25mg online cialis 35mg buy viagra maryland order strattera atomoxetine metformin tab 500 mg buy 20 mg cialis xenical generico bogota viagra blue 800mg generic 25 mg viagra kamagra uk online buy viagra nexium 20 mg tab lexapro panic disorders buy viagra internet generic valtrex 1000mg