24 Comments

  1. neelu
    neelu
    December 27, 2008 at 2:24 PM

    Mani is abandoning Abhishek for a more youthful talent? ;-)

  2. rohitkarnbatra
    rohitkarnbatra
    December 27, 2008 at 2:38 PM

    I think so neelu. I think Raavana will be AB/Mani’s last collaboration.

    Incidentally, I think Raavana will be a good film – the concept sounds exciting.

  3. utkal
    utkal
    December 27, 2008 at 6:50 PM

    It is good to see mani working on films written by a young writer like Renil. I think infusion of fresh ideas will create exciting results.

  4. rohitkarnbatra
    rohitkarnbatra
    December 27, 2008 at 7:29 PM

    Exactly Utkal. Also I think that ARR’s music will be fresher here too.

    I’m glad he want away from Anurag Kashyap – change is good.

  5. Arun
    Arun
    December 27, 2008 at 7:39 PM

    Mani is a great visionary and it’s always a pleasure to work with him. When I did Raavana the whole idea was to flip the moral issue.

    Sounds exciting!

  6. Qalandar
    Qalandar
    December 27, 2008 at 7:53 PM

    It is not only “new” but also “traditional”, in the sense that there is a tradition among Southern Indian Ramayanas of a more sympathetic portrayal of Raavana — and this combo of old and new is great to see!

  7. satyam
    satyam
    December 27, 2008 at 9:25 PM

    I am bit skeptical about this story! If Rathnam’s doing this he’d be beginning a film right as soon as he finished the current bilingual. Would be a little odd for him. Let’s see what happens. The Abhishek/Rathnam deal is a permanent one as far as I can tell. But let’s see if this film actually begins. Lajjo seemed a certain deal at one point. I would be interested in confirmation of this elsewhere. This is only the Mumbai Mirror! The same source that has had multiple articles on RNBDJ not doing too well!

  8. satyam
    satyam
    December 27, 2008 at 10:26 PM

    Incidentally the media went on forever that Abhishek was ‘Ram’ in the current film. Every media source imaginable carried this story. It was false. Then there was the D6 fiasco. Of course Abhishek is now in Mehra’s next film also!

    This is not to suggest that Rathnam couldn’t do a film with another actor. He was after all planning to do Lajjo. But I would just prefer confirmation on this and wait for the film to roll!

  9. satyam
    satyam
    December 27, 2008 at 10:32 PM

    Of course one also notes with some amusement this Abhishek/Ranbir double that the media sometimes creates and the partisans on this forum create more often! It’s the SRK partisans who are mysteriously the biggest Ranbir fans! Allow me to be a little skeptical! leaving this aside the idea that Ranbir is competing with Abhishek (could there be two more opposite types?!) is probably absurd to anyone who uses a brain not just as a biological necessity!

    The real double in this sense is Abhishek/Hrithik. For many reasons. One ‘fantasmically’ completes the other. These two are completely ‘unlike’ also but twinned by reasons of birth/origin and of course in other senses. Abhishek is what the passionate Hrithik admirer is most uneasy about much as Aamir similarly disturbs the SRK fan the most. But these two sometimes cross over. Not too many Hrithik fans (in the sense of partisans) love Aamir; similarly not many SRK partisans have any love for Abhishek to put it kindly!

    Even in the most partisan debates, even in the most seemingly mindless discussions something serious is always revealed.

  10. Julie
    Julie
    December 28, 2008 at 4:10 AM

    This if happens would be definitley something I would look forward to.

    It is with sheer amusement one notes the partisan fans of Abhishek firing missiles once again and the target always seems to be the SRK and Hritik fans when in this instance specifically it is Mani’s own decision if this news has any element of truth. That Abhishek fantastimically completes Hritik is a mere wishful thinking again by partisan fans of the former. They have been living in a dreamland since Hritik walked away with all the accolade in D2 and Abhi Baby just looked on and defaced all their efforts in obstructing JA’s fate at the BO. If you can’t ventilate anger in other ways, then start hitting out at fans. The immediate retort by such partisans is well err “what about MPKD” then the response is you don’t have to look any further than the latest mishap yet again of AB junior “Drona”(a Krrish wannabee).

  11. satyam
    satyam
    December 28, 2008 at 7:08 AM

    Julie: With all due respect I have never been part of an Abhishek fan club…!

    It is the uses to which any story is put that matters. Not just the story itself. Much as it is the uses to which the box office is put. One of course always ‘denies’ things.. but behind the denials lie extraordinary affirmations..!

  12. satyam
    satyam
    December 28, 2008 at 7:20 AM

    My reading of Bollywood cinema, my understanding of the medium, and all ‘predictions’ that I base on such has never really depended on the ‘obvious’ in any pedestrian sense of the term. For example I am not surprised by the Ghajini opening because I always thought Aamir enough of a star to be able to put up openings better or on par with the very best if he attempted the right subject. I think I’ve been arguing this forever when many here though I was overdoing things. So ‘after the fact’ it’s easy to say any number of things but that’s not exactly analysis. Whether it is stars or films I like or not I am never interested in these sorts of pedestrian statements. At the same time (I cannot argue this for most of the people who’ve tussled with me) I have never said things I don’t sincerely believe in no matter how much I am provoked. I should also say this aabout the opposition. People have a habit of saying exactly the same things about stars no matter what phase the star is going through. So those who were knocking Abhishek after JBJ or Drona or what have you were actually saying the very same things after Guru! The only difference was that at that time they weren’t willing to accept Guru was a success or even if it was that it meant anything and so forth. When he actually failed this excuse was no longer needed! Similarly whether it’s Hrithik post-MPDKH or post D2/Krrish the very same things are said. SRK could be post KANK or post CDI/OSO. Again the very same stuff. Akshay was ‘denied’ for the longest time till he got enough hits to make the whole point absurd! Much as Aamir after Ghajini makes any questioning of his stardom a little idiotic. So it’s not as if one has been very neutral otherwise! Again anecdotal stuff is brought up not as an analytic tool but in denial of the box office. Inconvenient bits of evidence are ignored or denied. So on and so forth. People who do this stuff don’t realize how easily they reveal themselves. For example with all the people I’ve argued with over the years I can tell fairly easily how sincere each argument is, how much one ‘debater’ or the the other is trying to ‘repress’ things, how much the propaganda is sincerely believed. Etc etc etc. I’ve said this from the very beginning. People don’t get mad at me because I say things they don’t like. They get mad because they recognize at the very least a kernel of truth. There’s no point in denying all of this. The reactions say it all!

  13. johnnybrutal
    johnnybrutal
    December 28, 2008 at 7:23 AM

    “With all due respect I have never been part of an Abhishek fan club…!”

    Finally the truth, it’s always been the fanatic club

  14. satyam
    satyam
    December 28, 2008 at 7:41 AM

    Johnnybrutal: Yes I concede I am a fanatic who did not want RNBDJ ‘not screened’ in Pakistan when many of the folks you would find common cause with were suggesting exactly this!

    The ‘Abhishek fan club’ reference is a bit of sarcasm on my part that certain folks here will understand.

  15. neelu
    neelu
    December 28, 2008 at 2:06 PM

    ROFL – imgr8, reality check is needed and how!

  16. A C H I L L E S
    A C H I L L E S
    December 28, 2008 at 2:15 PM

    Abhishek without Ratnam is a scary thought! Cant blame anyone who likes Abhi to be least enthusiastic on this news.

  17. Qalandar
    Qalandar
    December 28, 2008 at 2:40 PM

    I’ll always look forward to a Rathnam film, whether Abhishek is in it or Ranbir is.

    imgr8: initially media reports had said that Ranbir was in Rathnam’s next film, and mumbai mirror or mid-day had even purported to quote him to that effect — but then Rathnam started “Raavan”; so is this a different film with Ranbir, or was he always supposed to do this one? The story seems interesting (albeit with a “Namesake”-hangover perhaps); as I had said with Laajo, it is an odd subject for Rathnam to undertake.

    My own hunch: there might well be a Rathnam/Ranbir film, but I suspect it won’t be this story.

  18. Qalandar
    Qalandar
    December 28, 2008 at 2:54 PM

    I see, thanks. Ranbir has got a pretty good line-up of projects; it is good to see him trying to do work that hopefully ensures his development as an actor rather than do a string of Bachna Ae Haseenon-types of films with Yash Raj etc.

  19. satyam
    satyam
    December 29, 2008 at 5:58 AM

    Imgr8: you’ve probably missed some of the politics on Abhishek/Ranbir by some esteemed members here! Some of it is on display on this very thread!

    I would always wait for any Rathnam movie.. I am with Qalandar on this! By the way Rathnam was supposed to do Lajjo with Aamir after Guru. It was all set. Then things changed. I didn’t have a problem with that either! I do agree with Qalandar that this is an odd subject for Rathnam at this stage of his career.

    In any case will wait for this film to actually roll..

  20. satyam
    satyam
    December 29, 2008 at 10:53 AM

    Incidentally Imgr8, I was I believe defending Ranbir when Saawariya was releasing and some here suggested he looked ‘gay’. And made all kinds of jokes about him. One of the counter-arguments I offered was that hrithik and Abhishek had both won gay icon awards! I can pull up that thread. I spent a fair bit of time arguing this.

    As I forever tell people here when I make comments I am very clear to separate my views on the ‘thing itself’ from those where I am addressing the politics of some folks here. I’ve done this with many stars.

    Rathnam doing a film with Ranbir isn’t odd. I just find it surprising that he’s willing to do them back to back since he normally doesn’t do this. With Abhishek he has three films already. Between Yuva and Guru there were 2.5 years, between Guru and the current film it will probably be the same gap. So even when he wasn’t doing films with other actors there was a gap. Because a director doesn’t start things right away but also the star also has other projects. So Abhishek for example has the Rohan film right after the Rathnam one, there’s the Balki film at some point. There’s another Mehra film but not sure when this begins.

    But to the extent that people start suggesting in rather silly fashion that Rathnam’s dropping Abhishek or whatever that’s what I’m addressing. If Rathnam does a film with Ranbir it doesn’t mean very much to me as far as the Rathnam/Abhishek history is concerned. Much as when Rathnam was planning Lajjo with Aamir I always knew that there would be an Abhishek project eventually on the cards.

    By the way I don’t believe competition does or does not exist based on ‘seniority’. That is irrelevant for the most part. What matters is the kind of persona a star has and whether this can be easily substituted by the competitors. So on and so forth.

    Having said all of this, and since your comment goes in my view beyond the bounds of an ‘impersonal’ response (it’s amply clear from my comment that the politics of others is being addressed, beyond this I had some doubts about the film and storyline and still do), I should say that you are hardly ‘neutral’ when it comes to Ranbir!

Page 1 of 1

Post Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

lisinopril 10 mg ratiopharm generic propecia fda viagra usa buy clomid online order cheap cialis sale viagra canada generic 28 doxycycline 100mg hydrochlorothiazide 12.5 mg qualitest synthroid generic pill nolvadex 10mg tamoxifen viagra 25 mg precio cialis 20 mg 8 comprimidos buying metformin online lexapro 30 mg pregnancy wellbutrin generic pill 141 cialis 20 mg generic valtrex generic date to buy doxycycline cialis 20 mg venda propecia generic 5mg levitra 20 mg dosage cialis 5mg enough priligy 30 mg tablets generic zovirax buy synthroid dosage 0.05mg generic valtrex ineffective cheap clomid 50 mg xenical buy ireland buy 10 mg lexapro cialis 80 mg bali buy brand zoloft zithromax 500 mg indicaciones augmentin 12h generico xenical generic eu edmonton cheap viagra zithromax online discount prednisone 20 mg qualitest nexium 40 mg alkohol propranolol er 80 mg buy lexapro cipralex prednisone 5mg dosage prednisone 60 mg surgery efectos levitra 10 mg costco generic diflucan cheap doxycycline tablets valtrex cheap doxycycline 100 mg uti nexium online kopen buying nolvadex uk buy levitra australia cialis professional online kamagra 8000mg lisinopril 10 mg info metformin xr 1500mg buy chinese clomid augmentin tablets 375mg doxycycline dosage 150 mg prednisone 10 mg 6 day clomid 25mg nederlands cialis online kopen xenical 120 mg metformin 500mg her buy strattera 18 mg propranolol 40 mg prospect generic viagra ciplachennai cialis headaches 20mg nolvadex research buy online viagra subscription lasix drip order viagra generico brevetto strattera 60 mg cost cialis medistar 20 mg buy levitra 100mg cialis 5mg 28 tabletten viagra canada 25mg indigestion lexapro generic viagra 200mg online synthroid 0.025mg co montreal viagra 100mg generic propecia january 2013 tabletki xenical 120 mg hypothyroidism generic synthroid propecia ie buy online cialis brand wellbutrin xl 300 generic price generic viagra 1000 mg metformin hydrochloride composicion cialis 20 mg propecia tablets 1mg cialis generic benefits celebrex 100mg cipro cheap online manfaat metformin 500 mg instructions 20 mg cialis cheap lexapro 20 mg generic celebrex price generic lexapro mylan lexapro 10mg 15mg generic propecia difference buy liquid propecia generic levitra dapoxetine buy viagra paysafe diflucan buy australia buy mens viagra lexapro generic march thread cheap viagra zithromax generic form 4 days 10 mg prednisone doxycycline tc 100 mg lady generic cialis cialis 20 mg doses viagra generic philippines doxycycline 300 mg dogs buying cytotec viagra cheap sale cialis 20mg kokemuksia order cialis 50 mg erythromycin 250mg zastosowanie cialis sicuro online dosage augmentin 500mg bula lexapro 10mg doxycycline 100mg ingredients kamagra 100mg erfahrungsbericht cialis 40 mgcena buy 5 viagra buy clomid online priligy 60 mg tablets cipro xl buy ordering viagra online prezzi cialis 20 mg 1.25 mg synthroid doxycycline dosage 300 mg cialis 20 mg prijs glucophage price 500 mg buy doxycycline 20mg 40 mg of strattera viagra 800 mg opis generic medicine nexium prospecto diflucan 150 mg doxycycline 50mg eye cialis 200mg tab cialis 20mg cheap durata cialis 10 mg propecia 1 mg online prednisone 5 mg chews viagra online wien xenical buy pills bactrim online bijsluiter viagra 50mg nolvadex liquid buy buyin nolvadex ireland levitra 10 mg paypal cialis 10mg erfahrungsberichte cialis thailand online cheap 5mg cialis online eczane levitra viagra 100,3000 mg buy Cialis 90 pills cipro 1000 mg 5 day synthroid buy it cialis gold 20 mg buy kamagra fuerteventura 50 or 100 mg clomid lexapro anxiety disorders dapoxetine 60 mg canada levitra 20 mg break no generic lexapro buy bradn viagra cialis 20 mg tabletas viagra medication online cytotec de 400 mg pfizer viagra 50 mg viagra japan buy lisinopril 10 mg effects online propecia forum order synthroid canada phone order cialis viagra generic 20 effects 200 mg viagra comanda online levitra 150mg diflucan order generic lexapro india viagra 50mg strength nolvadex 20 mg generic purchase cialis cheap cialis online org lasix 40 mg online wellbutrin sr 100mg viagra online bestellen zovirax tabl 800 mg zithromax 500 mg 3 hoeveel mg nolvadex buy doxycycline gel 5mg lexapro reviews 10 mg prednisone ivf buy viagra penang kamagra tablets cheap generico viagra panvel generics viagra paypal buy cialis 2.5 viagra buy camden is cialis 100mg priligy online pharmacy online viagra ireland celebrex 200mg anwendung indikasi metformin 500 mg identify lisinopril 10 mg xenical buy nz kamagra tablet 50 mg 37.5 mg of zoloft diflucan capsule 100 mg buy doxycycline nairobi erfahrung kamagra 100mg strattera 60 mg reviews celebrex 200 mg cena wirkung levitra 5mg strongest generic cialis viagra 150 mg kaufen buy prednisone uk zithromax online chlamydia clomid 25 mg jour prednisone withdrawal 5 mg medicamento xenical 120 mg preis cialis 5mg phenergan 12.5mg iv lisinopril tablets 40 mg 20 mg clomid pills prednisone 50mg pregnancy zoloft 25 mg tablet cheap kamagra london propecia online purchase zoloft sertraline 25mg buy zithromax 500mg buy clomid 500mg online cialis satis propecia generic coupons diflucan dosage 150mg canadian nexium 40 mg doxycycline 200 mg syphilis blueberry 100 viagra buy cipro online uk augmentin 90 mg kg buy viagra cheap cialis 40 mg einnehmen augmentin farmaco generico 100 mg di zoloft viagra x generico levitra 20 mg. orosolubile rx cialis online 250 mg cipro erythromycin order online viagra order mastercard 600 mg wellbutrin overdose comprar cialis 20 generico propecia online 5mg cipro 750 mg muadili viagra fiyatlari 50 mg erythromycin capsules 250 mg generic sub bactrim augmentin 400mg buying hydrochlorothiazide pill nolvadex online viagra 150mg safe buy clomid bodybuilding viagra online 150 kamagra 100mg fake nolvadex generic names order levitra generic xenical comanda online online viagra prescriptions clomid 50mg musculation starting zoloft 25mg lisinopril accord 10mg diflucan to buy wellbutrin authorized generic buspar buy buy levitra pen medicamento levitra 20 mg 5mg lexapro review nexium 40mg tiem lisinopril 20 mg preco lexapro 20 online xenical buy london zithromax 500mg fta 40 mg strattera cialis illegal online cialis black 500mg cialis film 20mg viagra online britain kamagra 100 mg gold hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg po viagra generic dose cytotec 200 mg directions levitra dosage 40 mg synthroid . 5mg cheap generic viagra glucophage 1000 mg poudre lisinopril splitting 2.5mg cialis mexico buy lilly cialis 100 mg nexium 40 mg prospect doxycycline 500mg capsules buy xenical sydney 500 mg generic viagra cheapest valtrex prices cialis buy review cialis kaufen 5 mg cialis generico fiable generic levitra store priligy 60 mg prezzo augmentin 1000 mg tablets generic levitra facts cheap cialis online .50 buy zithromax walmart nexium 40 mg 30 tablet strattera overdose mg viagra online vgr buy Cialis 60 pills viagra online bangalore erythromycin 1000mg clomid buy paypal doxycycline 100mg shqip levitra 10 ou 20 mg lexapro 20 mg buy cheap generic priligy synthroid 05 mg lexapro canada buy 10mg lexapro alcohol viagra sildenafil 50 mg cipro antibiotic online doxycycline 100mg drinking nexium backorder prednisone 2.5 mg qualitest lexapro when generic propecia generic uk online viagra ratings cialis prostate disorders amoxil 250 mg used lasix ret. 60 mg cialis 5mg double vendita viagra generico generic zoloft appearance viagra 20mg price cost 20 mg lexapro cialis economico online xenical 120 mg acheter comanda cialis 10 mg generic viagra laws diflucan one 50mg 100 mg zoloft cheap levitra online celebrex generic 100mg synthroid 0.1 mg celebrex 100 mg hartkapseln zovirax tabletki 200 mg doxycycline teva 100 mg buy 50mg kamagra metformin 1000 mg day zoloft 100 mg pregnancy cytotec 200 mg vidal metformin 500 mg pdr online rx valtrex lisinopril buy reviews couper cialis 20 mg amoxil 250 mg suspension cialis lilly 20 mg buying viagra lisinopril 20 mg online kamagra jelly buy cialis uk 5mg cialis 100mg 20mg cialis de 5mg cialis 5mg cena clomid online purchase viagra 25 mg effet buy strattera discount buy viagra phitzer generic doxycycline online nolvadex mg ml buy doxycycline 50 capsules viagra 50 mg wirkungsdauer comprare xenical online nolvadex 20 mg precio celebrex 200mg information buy propecia brazil generisk cialis 10 mg viagra 2 20 mg lisinopril qualitest 30 mg cialis 20mg order valtrex generic wiki 10 mg daily cialis viagra buy nottingham generic viagra 40 tabs clomid online france levitra 20 mg walmart xenical tablets 120mg viagra 100mg blue buy levitra qatar buy tetracycline 250 mg nexium buy online buy viagra 100g cialis 20 mg 90 tablet gold viagra 3 000 mg cheapest viagra pfizer cheap generic xenical zoloft 12.5 mg dose cialis 100mg portugues cialis buy chea tetracycline 250 mg capsules cialis pills 10 mg viagra generico eurofarma synthroid dosage 150 mg lisinopril 10 mg results levitra orodispersible 5mg cialis 5mg ndc order levitra 180 pills acheter cialis 2.5mg buy cheap clomid viagra cheap cod import generic viagra generic cialis 10 yellow get celebrex online bactrim 160 mg posologia xenical 120 mg preisvergleich glucophage retard 1000mg nexium 20 mg precio bactrim 1 mg order viagra america generic propecia online viagra buy oonline levitra 10 mg fta 4 propranolol 40mg tablet generic propecia 1 mg cialis everyday 20mg propecia buy mexico order viagra 25mg order cialis site cialis 5mg peaks buying cialis generic levitra 60 pills online cialis 20mg tadalafil buying viagra free costco generic lexapro viagra sublingual 150mg zovirax generico viagra bali buy reviews lisinopril 20 mg levitra cost 10 mg dapoxetine 60mg online viagra online australia cheap viagra canadian xenical online discount clomid 100mg ed erfahrungsberichte cialis 5mg lisinopril 5 mg medication lisinopril 20 mg india nolvadex 10 mgs cytotec online pharmacy order diflucan roerig 150 diflucan 200 mg used propranolol 20 mg tab buy nexium generic buy lexapro mastercard doxycycline 100mg dose generic viagra experiences metformin 500 mg beipackzettel clomid malaysia online clomid 50mg forum 20mg lexapro lot cipro 500mg ingredients doxycycline 100mg forum lasix 40 mg comprimidos xenical 120 mg bijwerkingen buspar 20mg kamagra 50 mg tablets ordering propranolol online generic viagra legal cialis 3800 mg fake generic zoloft liquid cialis generic brands viagra kobra 100mg buying zovirax ointment 7 mg prednisone taper healthymen buy viagra reichen 5 mg cialis cialis buy france lexapro 5 mg conversion generic cialis zoll buy augmentin 625mg zoloft overdose 300mg nexium 40 mg pharmacy lisinopril 40 mg appearance viagra online richmond 50mg cialis equivalent cialis generico prospecto cialis generico germania buy kamagra california cialis bayer 20mg buy generic glucophage