My thoughts on J.T.Y.J.N

After reading all reviews of ‘Jaane Tu Ya Jaane Na’, I had hardly expected to be surprised or ‘refreshed’ (as reviews stereotype the movie as ‘refreshing’) by the movie. But I did end up being surprised.

Hard to miss that this guy Abbas wrote ‘Main Hoon Na’… Because, the movie is skillfully interspersed with dramatic spoofy moments. I surely did not expect a spoof.

As I watched, the amatuer (self acclaimed) critic inside me kept churning severe judgements like “filmy college”, “Neurotic parents”, “spoofy storyline”, “Absence of back ground music … Makes the narration rather stage acting like”, “BORE”, “desperately tries to be cool” etc …And then bang! I noticed ‘Imran Khan’…

Someone that my friends(girls) immediately branded as ‘cute’. The guy does have something. He appears natural on screen. He isn’t as stiff as Neil or as rubbery as Ranbir or as dashing as Hrithik in KNPH.

He is almost like Jugal Hansraj with a lot more likeability.Right now its his onscreen personality as ‘Rats’ (Jai) which has made a mark.

There are chances that this particular personality that could have been established by mere mannerism which could get stale with exposure. But for sure he has a cool sense of comic timing.

I have got to add a few lines about ‘Genelia’. Most of our current Bollywood female leads lack the screen presence, charm and conviction this puny little girl has. Kudos to her.

I have watched a couple of her South Indian flicks. She is particularly special for Telugu film audience afer Bommarillu, through which she established her niche in playing the famous innocent and bubbly oddball character.

Her style of emoting can be funny/endearing at first but an overdose can irriate. Here she isn’t as odd as I had expected (thankfully).

Coming back to the movie, story wise wise, there isn’t anything new. Execution did not thrill me. I wouldn’t accept that it is ‘refreshing’ or very ‘entertaining’ as reviews say.

Looks like people are unfairly in a mood to accept this movie. Its good because nothing else is better seems to be the reason. And then there are psuedos who would rename anything with Aamir’s name in it to something good. :(

24 Comments

  1. satyam
    satyam
    July 17, 2008 at 6:28 AM

    “Looks like people are unfairly in a mood to accept this movie. Its good because nothing else is better seems to be the reason. And then there are psuedos who would rename anything with Aamir’s name in it to something good.”

    I am amused by your first sentence here! Let’s the people have been rather ‘unfair’ at many points. Should I start naming some films?!

    On your last sentence I guess the ‘pseudos’ have to learn some impartiality from SRK or Hrithik fans!

  2. Ravi
    Ravi
    July 17, 2008 at 6:48 AM

    Nice set of thoughts Nithya and you are spot on with respect to Genelia.

    I hope this is the last time I agree with you Nithya, otherwise I fear something is very wrong with me.

  3. jayshah
    jayshah
    July 17, 2008 at 7:00 AM

    I was really enjoying it until the last paragraph. It felt like a trap (I knew it) and I still fell for it. So much for my intellect :-)

    Oh well, I am going back to my tea and cupcakes party with all the other snobby people I associate myself with! LOL! The queen is my guest today, we will be discussing how great JTYJN was. And adding Aamir’s name to the list of honours next year to be knighted!

  4. Kunal27
    Kunal27
    July 17, 2008 at 7:07 AM

    Looks like somebody got a crush on Imran :P

    Apart from praising Imran and Genelia part…. I agree with everything you have written there.

  5. Achilles
    Achilles
    July 17, 2008 at 7:32 AM

    Good set of thoughts here.

  6. rockstar
    rockstar
    July 17, 2008 at 8:07 AM

    good write up

    “I have watched a couple of her South Indian flicks. She is particularly special for Telugu film audience afer Bommarillu, through which she established her niche in playing the famous innocent and bubbly oddball character”

    agree there she fits into college going girl perfectly

    she was good in tujhe meri kasam to

  7. rockstar
    rockstar
    July 17, 2008 at 8:27 AM

    nithi: just my personal opinion i thought her accent was a problem but again atleast she dubs her voice which even some of the new bollywood actresses don’t do , ya it will be difficult for haraman and ranbir to match siddharth

  8. satyam
    satyam
    July 17, 2008 at 8:34 AM

    Nithi_s: Ah.. you were actually referring to people you work with and not those on NG! It would require some intelligence to figure this out!

    On the rest I see that Abhishek’s ghost is haunting this discussion as well! I stand by the Guru comment incidentally!

  9. satyam
    satyam
    July 17, 2008 at 8:45 AM

    By the way I don’t recall anyone going gaga over JTYJN over here. I certainly had this reaction with TZP and I devoted a long piece to it. On the other hand I found JTYJN enjoyable enough and wrote a brief comment on it. Yes, I have gone gaga over the box office because I am thrilled with the film’s success. And yes I am thrilled BECAUSE it’s AAMIR’s production and is a HUGE feather in his cap. This film has just about become an Aamir release (as if he had starred in it!). But also JTYJN is a genuine superhit/blockbuster. A 5-7 crore film making this kind of money, it’s a historic hit. It’s not like some of the year’s other hits/superhits that were questionable in terms of profitability (and I’m not talking Jannat here!).

  10. rockstar
    rockstar
    July 17, 2008 at 8:50 AM

    “Looks like people are unfairly in a mood to accept this movie. Its good because nothing else is better seems to be the reason. And then there are psuedos who would rename anything with Aamir’s name in it to something good.”

    agree to a little extent but again everyone will have different opinion on it isn’t it but its a fact to most of the directors have given their best product with aamir only

  11. satyam
    satyam
    July 17, 2008 at 8:55 AM

    Since Rks has closed the other thread let me respond briefly here:

    Mr Bond: yes I know which I why I did not take offense!

    Qalandar: Thanks.. it’s a point I often try to make..

    Jay: Agreed on your star son thing. Raj Kapoor as I pointed out is the biggest example. Of course it’s humorous to see a position being posited whereby it’s ok to get that first big break because of a connection but not any future ones! I wonder why Roshan then had to do a rescue job and reinvent his son with KMG and Krrish! Anyway don’t want to relaunch that thread here but this kind of split is bizarre to say the least.

  12. Rocky
    Rocky
    July 17, 2008 at 8:59 AM

    Jay , agree with Ravi, very nice thoughts on star sons.

  13. rks
    rks
    July 17, 2008 at 9:01 AM

    Nithi: Good thoughts.. I disagree with execution comment..I think that was the only part which saved the movie..Holistically, it is barely a decent movie..Then it tells us the the stuff we churn out of bollywood that a movie which is barely better than other is doing wonderful business.

    Jay: That was a good comment in other thread.

    Aside: I just cringe the way the fight started in other thread. We are adults, we need to give respect to others and expect some respect in return.

  14. Mr. Bond
    Mr. Bond
    July 17, 2008 at 9:19 AM

    Agreed rks, and I will try not to retaliate again but some people make personal attack just because you criticize a star (everyone has his/her opinion). I have hardly been commenting for months but have been following enough to know that certain members become too rude and resort to personal attack and I was already sick of it and lost my mind. I will be much more careful next time as I know its not worth it. I will also go back to my occasional commenting.

  15. jayshah
    jayshah
    July 17, 2008 at 9:32 AM

    nithi – so you liked Imran? Didn’t he remind you of Aamir in anyway?

  16. jayshah
    jayshah
    July 18, 2008 at 12:26 AM

    He reminded me of Aamir in one scene – the scene where he gets ready to fight early on, he starts to clap his hands and circle that guy, throws his hands round…but in general otherwise except for a bit of similarity in looks, there acting style are different…

    “Oh God! This guy is just a clone of Aamir”

    I’m it would have made your day…one is not enough for you, another one would have been great!

  17. utkal
    utkal
    July 18, 2008 at 12:46 AM

    My comments are aimed at all those who keep on harping about the story being nothing new. Come on guys, a film is not its ‘story’ just as a painting is not its subject. And what is making it a monster hot is not that ‘ it’s just about better than all the trash on offer’ but that fact that the audience is connecting with the film and that it feels really DIFFERENT. Many have said that the film is quite ORDINARY. That is it’s strength. It’s not trying to tell a big story a la RDB, or pull out a big melodrama a la DCH ( with a dying Dimple and all that.) And that’s what makes it refreshing. Young audiences all across the country can relate to the characters as real people and not some filmy characters. Its unpretentiousness is what charms you. Just the way HAHK with its ‘ no story/ and ‘ no directorial artistry’ did. But look closely and you will note how cleverly the ‘ordinariness’ has been achieved. How many critics or columnists here noticed that the film had only 3 and half songs choreographed? Or that Imran Khan wore his own clothes? Or how every actor from Naseer and Ratna to Prateek Babbar and the Khan brothers and Paresh Rawal have been so judiciously and optimally used. In fact the screen mother persona of Ratna is as refreshing today as the screen mother portrayed by Reema Lagu was in times of HAHK. That is the kind of generational shift that gives birth to monster hits and next-gen stars.

  18. satyam
    satyam
    July 18, 2008 at 9:14 AM

    Utkal: A good set of comments here..

Page 1 of 1

Post Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

securecheckoutz pharmacy donde comprar misoprostol sertralina efectos a largo plazo del tiotropium bromide inhalation powder generic drugs something better then viagra be pharmacy order brand viagra online can i buy cytotec over the counter anti viral drugs over the counter order risperdal online fertility drugs for sale zantac coupons samples mexico pharmacy online drugstore propecia for womens hair loss trichologist viagra with online prescription adhd medicine without a prescription canadian high quality pharmacy new cialis tizanidine 4mg side effects prednisone eye drops requip starter pack instructions supreme suppliers sagar avenue discount viagra lowest prices xanax alprazolam dosage mupirocin cream 2 uses zyban smoking cessation cilis wiarga levitra micardis coupons canada buy cialis in israel ibs meds online no prescription mometasone cream for poison ivy viagra super force 100mg 100mg order periactine from indian ditropan medication use provera medicine usedprovigil cialis 20 mg estados unidos what happens when you take viagra eurax lotion side effects can i drink beer and take flomax ranitidine zantac eq lopid gemfibrozil 600 mg triam hctz 75 50 mg rythmol medications walgreens careers apply online generic viagra and cialis ciprotab 500 norvasc protect generic name minocin 100mg vermox side effects where to buy bystolic out of country order generic cialis online cheap generic cialis india xenical 120 roche without prescription femara fertility success stories history of leconfield castle hydroxyzine hcl 10mg information how strong is viagra 100mg www cialis venta ohio abilify 10 mg can you use fucidin cream for thrush online pharmacy slimex liquid viagra for women bevispas 135mg caffeine zovirax ointment acyclovir what is kenacomb otic ointment thalidomide multiple myeloma side effects nhs omeprazole side effects flonase vs nasonex symptoms online pharmasists thailand cicloferon aciclovir cream periostat for rosacea florinef side effects latisse coupon 2014 ketorolaco tramadol precose dosage calculations provera period started early phexin dropsend prostata agrandada tratamiento natural voltaren gel prices ketazol cream motorcycle events raymeds pharmacy schools letrozole buy what is ropinirole medication generic viagras clobex spray coupon/online buy cefixime buy meloxicam tadalafil pay with paypal misoprostol for miscarriage side effects buylowdrugs canada flag pheromones in humans buy codeine cough syrup tennessee ginseng prices 2012 diflucan 150 mg en espanol florinef 0.1 mg medication prednisone no script canadian viagra paypal checkout difference between xenical and lesofat philippines non rx ed drugs vicodin withdrawal symptoms blood pressure is high levitra dosage medication trimetabol dosage for benadryl alli pills canada atorlip 20 all day chemist retin a ativan lorazepam drugs side effects cipa canadian approved pharmacies buy thyroxine online uk skelaxin 800 mg metaxalone vs flexeril acquista viagra senza ricetta combat viagra side effects viagra online china to china rx canada pharmacy 365 priligy romania pret bentyl 20 mg side effects buy cialis paypal payment viagra medicine for men side effects of accutane in teenagers samonas realty greenland nh over the counter warfarin clomid uk seller toprol xl 50mg sertraline hcl 100mg zoloft overnight pharmacy 4u order dose of azithromycin for rosacea acyclovir purchase online buy liquid viagra online cheapest place to get propecia vibrox capsules viagra professional a vendre fluoxetine prozac side effects in children vigra vegetal espanol how to use vigora amoxicillen buy online duphaston 10mg tabletki fentanyl patch side effects difficulty swallowing lexapro weight gain lexapro withdrawal benicar medication assistance esquina carlos gardel tango show buenos aires bentyl for ibs best over the counter erection pill comune santa luce without a prescription brand viagra risnia 3 geleia de jabuticaba rhinathiol syrup for children metoprolol er 25 mg recall viagra indian market flomaxtra australia weather periostat 20mg and gum disease ordering clozaril online prednisone without prescriptions xenical international purchases online pharm tech degree augmentin dosage for children ear infection digoxina dosis de amor frases de futbol when will alli be back for sale aricept 5mg side effects midamor diuretics zyprexa for anxiety reviews kamagra online pharmacy uk paypal lasix medication pills like viagra viagra 100 rezeptfrei bestellen buying viagra in usa cost of crestor at walmart fluoxetine 10mg cap ropinirole drug class cailis mechanical davie morphine band cure for pain tadalafil 20mg jasmine guy married doxepin medication for hives exelon myhrbenefits amiloride hcl used nizagara pills cheap online nolvadex buy risperdal no prescription contact customer ed levitra generika kaufen medameds reviews on garcinia how to buy viagra online from canada myambutol ethambutol toxicity benicar hct 20 12.5 mg cialis kaufen billig kamagra 100 mg on line stromectol dose for pinworm lortab 10 325 cefaclor 250 mg suspension lasix furosemide diuretic cialis lilly vendors on line usa lowest price on generic viagra tablet product buy viagra usa himcolin himalaya indomethacin 25mg shelf life lotensin buy china canada pharmacy no rx accepts paypal harga misoprostol amiloride hctz side effects cheap dog meds canada nexium otc vs prescription tylenol arthritis acetaminophen pfizer animal health products can you take revatio for erectile dysfunction clopidogrel side effects breathing problems cialis online ca eprex liturgia de las horas vigrx plus before and after metallica black album release date cialis tablete cena tantalum happy hour generic cialis online europe order amoxicillin from mexico cheap 20mg nolvedex buy abortion pill online now lipvas tablets for sale medicine viagra best sellers catalog viagra best prices online xenical online cheap parcopa discontinued perfumes plavix buy online secnidazole indications for blood crestor price viamedic com vfw store phone cheap orlistat 120mg doxycycline hyclate generic viagra vs viagra cialis 5 mg 28 compresse costo how januvia is developing in india viagra usa online pharmacy 1drugstore online warning signs best prices for motillum amikacin side effects combivent inhalation aerosol coupons viagra online kaufen billig levitra aus holland advair patient assistance program levothroid side effects levothyroxine sodium starcef 200 buying viagra bucharest viagra generic wemon generic estrace pills indian viagra tablet names phenergan dm 6.25 order canadian drugs cash on delivery warfarin and alcohol interactions tabletten oynanan oyunlar oyna walgreens take care clinic jobs rimadyl side effects medications for dogs orlistat cheapest medameds medco health diane ladd on alice samonas realty portsmouth nh cabgolin 0 251 lipitor vs crestor cost retin a micro gel haldol side effects review prostata inflamada causas where to buy real finasterides cheapest canada drugs online pharmacy amoxicillin dosage chart for cats buy sildenafil citrate online onelinepharmacy netherlands gupisone 20 side effects verapamil online drug store does viagera help women stromectol side effects in humans yagara for sale indocin dosage forms generic sublingual viagra 50mg why isnt viagra generic viagra in farmaciea doxinyl medication for anxiety flexidol relax accion terapeutica bolilor captopril capoten side effects salzarex tadalafil tablets effexor and weight gain taking omeprazol igual que cytotec fosamax osteonecrosis blood test catapres from mexico pharmacies cialis online mastercard asthma treatment canadian medstore secure tabs authentic drug store como saber si funciona cytotec pillule viagra quebec pravachol without prescription hoodia tea weight loss eyeglasses no rx pharmacy technician misoprostol pharmacy imitrex dosage and administration anything otc like viagra or cialis regenon retard pramipexole dihydrochloride buy cheap doxycycline what is mavidol sl cephalexin for dogs dosage duration cardizem cd generic buy chlonidine overnight proviron side effects mesterolone proviron tadalafil manufactured in usa canada octreotide infusion protocol buy strong viagra uk 64 eprex liturgia de las horas oficio viagra c20 levitra canadian pharmacy serophene success stories cytotec abortion side effects viagra perdorimi snorting metformin where to buy cheap cialis levitra reviews cialis kaufen 10mg ventoline pour homme xenical 120mg no prescription cialis from india tadalafil india viagra nizagara ingredients amphetamine salts 20mg coupon septra ds 800 160 walgreens employee website prednisone online pharmacy testosterone gel androgel reviews canadian pills store garlic clove conversion viagra livraison rapide vardenafil hcl 20mg tab cost torsemide medication for dogs brand viagra online from mexico cytoxan manufacturers levitra overnight us amoxicillin for cats for sale pharmacie en ligne maroc kamagra on sale tramadol hcl 50 mg tablet picture viagra online from canada mesterolone bodybuilding supplements levitra orodispersible viagra capsule alfuzosin uroxatral generic oxytrol india buy buspar cheap trental 400 mg pentoxifylline doxitab 100 mg tramadol pharm online obestat meridiano vagiral ovulos acromona viagra canada overnight shipping over counter prednisone nifedipine for preterm labor side effects street value of meloxicam can you buy cialis over the counter norstan inc pleasant prairie wi 53158 caffeine pills walgreens pyridium 200mg tid cialis 80mg florinef dose valium and alcohol death buy esomeprazole eurax cream tavor ohne rezept zanaflex side effects tizanidine viagra without a doctor prescription from india bevispas tablets on sale buy metformin xr curacne wikipedia english buy antibiotics online mail kumaden co jp sildenafil bull 100 cyclivex 200mg progesterone estradiol blood test range buy retin a in canada diflucan for thrush dosage evista medication generic abana insurance houston ambien dosage information prevacid vs nexium prilosec what happens if i take two cialis mircette side effects mood sale vrdrug online pharmacy amerimedrx complaints venlafaxine side effects 37.5 aciclovir for sale free cialis sample pack norstan communications mn losartan side effects mayo clinic synthroid vs levothyroxine sodium fosamax lawsuit bisphosphonates apple flavored ivermectin for horses dicyclomine bentyl side effects atosil dosierung diclofenac buy fentanyl uk ciales puerto rico pictures of ponce lasuna garlic butter dosage quinine sulfate leg cramps grathazon kaplet technology cialis super active 20mg drugstore cowboy full movie furosemide without prescription in uk is 4000 mg of atenelol fatal cuvarlix pharmaniaga tizanidine 4mg tab dr. reddys side effects adderall weight loss before and after pictures canada pharmacy pay with paypal diarex magnum dust collector viagra samples for women clonidine 0.1mg patch side effectsclopidogrel fincar finasteride online canada cheap irbesartan hct typical viagra prices red 7 pill benazepril medications comprar viagra en estados unidos viagra professional amazon clindamycin side effects antibiotic algodones pharmacy hoodia weight loss drink costco where can i buy nitroglycerin ointment mtabs reviews fiftymyambutol abana himalaya product epratenz dox los paratextosparoxetine costco pharmacy price list 2014 buy ritalin no prescription uk kamagra forums buy inderal from canada pulmicort respules benicar side effects high blood pressure cialis and viagra professional diflucan dosage for vaginal yeast infection buy lexapro online 24 hour delivery azulfidine sulfasalazine dosage for ulcerative colitis purchase valium without a prescription elavil weight gain loss diclofenac potassium 50mg atomoxetine order online atenolol side effects medication sumycin tetracycline hydrochloride metronidazole for dogs side effects vigora 100 tablets information in hindi ketorolac 10mg street value cheap dapoxatine noroxin dosages elimite no prescription celebrex canada ciprofloxacin 500 mg buy cefadroxil 500 mg for bronchitis rhinathiol promethazine syrup for infants advantage car rental discount code omeprazole medication class pfizer closing stock price today fanegada definition of respect sildenafil citrate 100mg tablets pastillas disgrasil lidocaine patch 5 coupons buying nizagara on line seroquel medication classification euroclinix reviews on 50 diazepam 10mg tablets doctor adventures suprax 200 mg 5 ml suspension amazon bactroban comprar viagra online canada buy cafergot clomiphene citrate 50 mg price acura viagra ciprotab 2500 does arimidex and weight gain viagra charlotte nc berifen 100 srca micardis telmisartan dose cephalexin and alcohol keflex paxil withdrawal settlement acheter alli acheter viagra generique pas cher buy doxicycline hyclate online salep agne manfaat fibadel 5 vermox side effects doctor lasix water pills canadian pharmacy mexitil contraindications for nitroglycerin prednisone dose pack buy finasteride 5mg online canadian pharmacy tylenol alfuzosin hcl 10mg buy clomid online no prescription uk viara generic pay with american express cockapoo dogs for sale in il cafergot available in canada viagra tablet can use in cooldrinks name brand cialis online tylenol with codeine lumigan side effects lumigan cefa tabs without prescription glipizide and metformin side effects premarin 0 625 mg ranbaxy pharmaceuticals products does cialis professional work