NAACHGAANA
My thoughts on J.T.Y.J.N
Phoenix | July 17, 2008, 6:18 AM | 24 comments | 440 views


After reading all reviews of ‘Jaane Tu Ya Jaane Na’, I had hardly expected to be surprised or ‘refreshed’ (as reviews stereotype the movie as ‘refreshing’) by the movie. But I did end up being surprised.

Hard to miss that this guy Abbas wrote ‘Main Hoon Na’… Because, the movie is skillfully interspersed with dramatic spoofy moments. I surely did not expect a spoof.

As I watched, the amatuer (self acclaimed) critic inside me kept churning severe judgements like “filmy college”, “Neurotic parents”, “spoofy storyline”, “Absence of back ground music … Makes the narration rather stage acting like”, “BORE”, “desperately tries to be cool” etc …And then bang! I noticed ‘Imran Khan’…

Someone that my friends(girls) immediately branded as ‘cute’. The guy does have something. He appears natural on screen. He isn’t as stiff as Neil or as rubbery as Ranbir or as dashing as Hrithik in KNPH.

He is almost like Jugal Hansraj with a lot more likeability.Right now its his onscreen personality as ‘Rats’ (Jai) which has made a mark.

There are chances that this particular personality that could have been established by mere mannerism which could get stale with exposure. But for sure he has a cool sense of comic timing.

I have got to add a few lines about ‘Genelia’. Most of our current Bollywood female leads lack the screen presence, charm and conviction this puny little girl has. Kudos to her.

I have watched a couple of her South Indian flicks. She is particularly special for Telugu film audience afer Bommarillu, through which she established her niche in playing the famous innocent and bubbly oddball character.

Her style of emoting can be funny/endearing at first but an overdose can irriate. Here she isn’t as odd as I had expected (thankfully).

Coming back to the movie, story wise wise, there isn’t anything new. Execution did not thrill me. I wouldn’t accept that it is ‘refreshing’ or very ‘entertaining’ as reviews say.

Looks like people are unfairly in a mood to accept this movie. Its good because nothing else is better seems to be the reason. And then there are psuedos who would rename anything with Aamir’s name in it to something good. :(

About the author:
Has 33 Articles

24 COMMENTS
  1. satyam

    “Looks like people are unfairly in a mood to accept this movie. Its good because nothing else is better seems to be the reason. And then there are psuedos who would rename anything with Aamir’s name in it to something good.”

    I am amused by your first sentence here! Let’s the people have been rather ‘unfair’ at many points. Should I start naming some films?!

    On your last sentence I guess the ‘pseudos’ have to learn some impartiality from SRK or Hrithik fans!

  2. nithi_s

    Huh! When was I impartial to an SRK movie? I have hated a lot of them and I have expressed that in a lot of my posts.

  3. nithi_s

    :) Let me explain …

    I wouldn’t call it unfair when people praised TZP … But here the same people who usually draw high standards for movies to please them, seem to be going ga-ga over this average one.

    I actually did not mean ‘psuedos’ as Aamir fans in this site … But those special people who think they are intelligent and watch movies just to make a coffee table conversation that goes like ‘Hey, I watched this movie produced by Aamir.. Its really refreshing’ etc … whom I often bump in to at office.

    Other points mentioned applies to you more than anybody else in this site. Everybody knows your impartiality in stating that Abhishek’s Guru performance to the most significant male lead performance after Agnipath etc … and other such statements …

  4. Ravi

    Nice set of thoughts Nithya and you are spot on with respect to Genelia.

    I hope this is the last time I agree with you Nithya, otherwise I fear something is very wrong with me.

  5. jayshah

    I was really enjoying it until the last paragraph. It felt like a trap (I knew it) and I still fell for it. So much for my intellect :-)

    Oh well, I am going back to my tea and cupcakes party with all the other snobby people I associate myself with! LOL! The queen is my guest today, we will be discussing how great JTYJN was. And adding Aamir’s name to the list of honours next year to be knighted!

  6. Kunal27

    Looks like somebody got a crush on Imran :P

    Apart from praising Imran and Genelia part…. I agree with everything you have written there.

  7. nithi_s

    Jayshah,
    :) The last line was a last minute addition.

  8. rockstar

    good write up

    “I have watched a couple of her South Indian flicks. She is particularly special for Telugu film audience afer Bommarillu, through which she established her niche in playing the famous innocent and bubbly oddball character”

    agree there she fits into college going girl perfectly

    she was good in tujhe meri kasam to

  9. nithi_s

    Gee. Thanks rockstar. I found Genelia decent in ‘Mere Paap Pehle Aap’ too. She was bst fit for her rol in Bommarilu. Heard she is going to star with Harman in its hindi remake. I haven’t seen LS2050, but I am sure Harman is gonna screw it up. Ranbir or Imran could do justice to the role.

  10. rockstar

    nithi: just my personal opinion i thought her accent was a problem but again atleast she dubs her voice which even some of the new bollywood actresses don’t do , ya it will be difficult for haraman and ranbir to match siddharth

  11. satyam

    Nithi_s: Ah.. you were actually referring to people you work with and not those on NG! It would require some intelligence to figure this out!

    On the rest I see that Abhishek’s ghost is haunting this discussion as well! I stand by the Guru comment incidentally!

  12. satyam

    By the way I don’t recall anyone going gaga over JTYJN over here. I certainly had this reaction with TZP and I devoted a long piece to it. On the other hand I found JTYJN enjoyable enough and wrote a brief comment on it. Yes, I have gone gaga over the box office because I am thrilled with the film’s success. And yes I am thrilled BECAUSE it’s AAMIR’s production and is a HUGE feather in his cap. This film has just about become an Aamir release (as if he had starred in it!). But also JTYJN is a genuine superhit/blockbuster. A 5-7 crore film making this kind of money, it’s a historic hit. It’s not like some of the year’s other hits/superhits that were questionable in terms of profitability (and I’m not talking Jannat here!).

  13. rockstar

    “Looks like people are unfairly in a mood to accept this movie. Its good because nothing else is better seems to be the reason. And then there are psuedos who would rename anything with Aamir’s name in it to something good.”

    agree to a little extent but again everyone will have different opinion on it isn’t it but its a fact to most of the directors have given their best product with aamir only

  14. satyam

    Since Rks has closed the other thread let me respond briefly here:

    Mr Bond: yes I know which I why I did not take offense!

    Qalandar: Thanks.. it’s a point I often try to make..

    Jay: Agreed on your star son thing. Raj Kapoor as I pointed out is the biggest example. Of course it’s humorous to see a position being posited whereby it’s ok to get that first big break because of a connection but not any future ones! I wonder why Roshan then had to do a rescue job and reinvent his son with KMG and Krrish! Anyway don’t want to relaunch that thread here but this kind of split is bizarre to say the least.

  15. Rocky

    Jay , agree with Ravi, very nice thoughts on star sons.

  16. rks

    Nithi: Good thoughts.. I disagree with execution comment..I think that was the only part which saved the movie..Holistically, it is barely a decent movie..Then it tells us the the stuff we churn out of bollywood that a movie which is barely better than other is doing wonderful business.

    Jay: That was a good comment in other thread.

    Aside: I just cringe the way the fight started in other thread. We are adults, we need to give respect to others and expect some respect in return.

  17. Mr. Bond

    Agreed rks, and I will try not to retaliate again but some people make personal attack just because you criticize a star (everyone has his/her opinion). I have hardly been commenting for months but have been following enough to know that certain members become too rude and resort to personal attack and I was already sick of it and lost my mind. I will be much more careful next time as I know its not worth it. I will also go back to my occasional commenting.

  18. jayshah

    nithi – so you liked Imran? Didn’t he remind you of Aamir in anyway?

  19. nithi_s

    rks,

    Execution might have saved the movie. Yet it did not impress me very much. :) Actually I think what saved the movie was performance from the youngsters involved.

    About giving respect, I’d try.

    jayshah,

    Imran reminded me of Aamir during the initial spoofy scene where everyone mourns the death of the cat ‘Radha’. For sometime I thought, “Oh God! This guy is just a clone of Aamir”. Some Aamir fans would have liked the similarity, but I did not like it. Understandable I guess.

  20. jayshah

    He reminded me of Aamir in one scene – the scene where he gets ready to fight early on, he starts to clap his hands and circle that guy, throws his hands round…but in general otherwise except for a bit of similarity in looks, there acting style are different…

    “Oh God! This guy is just a clone of Aamir”

    I’m it would have made your day…one is not enough for you, another one would have been great!

  21. utkal

    My comments are aimed at all those who keep on harping about the story being nothing new. Come on guys, a film is not its ‘story’ just as a painting is not its subject. And what is making it a monster hot is not that ‘ it’s just about better than all the trash on offer’ but that fact that the audience is connecting with the film and that it feels really DIFFERENT. Many have said that the film is quite ORDINARY. That is it’s strength. It’s not trying to tell a big story a la RDB, or pull out a big melodrama a la DCH ( with a dying Dimple and all that.) And that’s what makes it refreshing. Young audiences all across the country can relate to the characters as real people and not some filmy characters. Its unpretentiousness is what charms you. Just the way HAHK with its ‘ no story/ and ‘ no directorial artistry’ did. But look closely and you will note how cleverly the ‘ordinariness’ has been achieved. How many critics or columnists here noticed that the film had only 3 and half songs choreographed? Or that Imran Khan wore his own clothes? Or how every actor from Naseer and Ratna to Prateek Babbar and the Khan brothers and Paresh Rawal have been so judiciously and optimally used. In fact the screen mother persona of Ratna is as refreshing today as the screen mother portrayed by Reema Lagu was in times of HAHK. That is the kind of generational shift that gives birth to monster hits and next-gen stars.

  22. satyam

    Utkal: A good set of comments here..

LEAVE YOUR COMMENT

Back to Top