My thoughts on J.T.Y.J.N

After reading all reviews of ‘Jaane Tu Ya Jaane Na’, I had hardly expected to be surprised or ‘refreshed’ (as reviews stereotype the movie as ‘refreshing’) by the movie. But I did end up being surprised.

Hard to miss that this guy Abbas wrote ‘Main Hoon Na’… Because, the movie is skillfully interspersed with dramatic spoofy moments. I surely did not expect a spoof.

As I watched, the amatuer (self acclaimed) critic inside me kept churning severe judgements like “filmy college”, “Neurotic parents”, “spoofy storyline”, “Absence of back ground music … Makes the narration rather stage acting like”, “BORE”, “desperately tries to be cool” etc …And then bang! I noticed ‘Imran Khan’…

Someone that my friends(girls) immediately branded as ‘cute’. The guy does have something. He appears natural on screen. He isn’t as stiff as Neil or as rubbery as Ranbir or as dashing as Hrithik in KNPH.

He is almost like Jugal Hansraj with a lot more likeability.Right now its his onscreen personality as ‘Rats’ (Jai) which has made a mark.

There are chances that this particular personality that could have been established by mere mannerism which could get stale with exposure. But for sure he has a cool sense of comic timing.

I have got to add a few lines about ‘Genelia’. Most of our current Bollywood female leads lack the screen presence, charm and conviction this puny little girl has. Kudos to her.

I have watched a couple of her South Indian flicks. She is particularly special for Telugu film audience afer Bommarillu, through which she established her niche in playing the famous innocent and bubbly oddball character.

Her style of emoting can be funny/endearing at first but an overdose can irriate. Here she isn’t as odd as I had expected (thankfully).

Coming back to the movie, story wise wise, there isn’t anything new. Execution did not thrill me. I wouldn’t accept that it is ‘refreshing’ or very ‘entertaining’ as reviews say.

Looks like people are unfairly in a mood to accept this movie. Its good because nothing else is better seems to be the reason. And then there are psuedos who would rename anything with Aamir’s name in it to something good. :(

24 Comments

  1. satyam
    satyam
    July 17, 2008 at 6:28 AM

    “Looks like people are unfairly in a mood to accept this movie. Its good because nothing else is better seems to be the reason. And then there are psuedos who would rename anything with Aamir’s name in it to something good.”

    I am amused by your first sentence here! Let’s the people have been rather ‘unfair’ at many points. Should I start naming some films?!

    On your last sentence I guess the ‘pseudos’ have to learn some impartiality from SRK or Hrithik fans!

  2. Ravi
    Ravi
    July 17, 2008 at 6:48 AM

    Nice set of thoughts Nithya and you are spot on with respect to Genelia.

    I hope this is the last time I agree with you Nithya, otherwise I fear something is very wrong with me.

  3. jayshah
    jayshah
    July 17, 2008 at 7:00 AM

    I was really enjoying it until the last paragraph. It felt like a trap (I knew it) and I still fell for it. So much for my intellect :-)

    Oh well, I am going back to my tea and cupcakes party with all the other snobby people I associate myself with! LOL! The queen is my guest today, we will be discussing how great JTYJN was. And adding Aamir’s name to the list of honours next year to be knighted!

  4. Kunal27
    Kunal27
    July 17, 2008 at 7:07 AM

    Looks like somebody got a crush on Imran :P

    Apart from praising Imran and Genelia part…. I agree with everything you have written there.

  5. Achilles
    Achilles
    July 17, 2008 at 7:32 AM

    Good set of thoughts here.

  6. rockstar
    rockstar
    July 17, 2008 at 8:07 AM

    good write up

    “I have watched a couple of her South Indian flicks. She is particularly special for Telugu film audience afer Bommarillu, through which she established her niche in playing the famous innocent and bubbly oddball character”

    agree there she fits into college going girl perfectly

    she was good in tujhe meri kasam to

  7. rockstar
    rockstar
    July 17, 2008 at 8:27 AM

    nithi: just my personal opinion i thought her accent was a problem but again atleast she dubs her voice which even some of the new bollywood actresses don’t do , ya it will be difficult for haraman and ranbir to match siddharth

  8. satyam
    satyam
    July 17, 2008 at 8:34 AM

    Nithi_s: Ah.. you were actually referring to people you work with and not those on NG! It would require some intelligence to figure this out!

    On the rest I see that Abhishek’s ghost is haunting this discussion as well! I stand by the Guru comment incidentally!

  9. satyam
    satyam
    July 17, 2008 at 8:45 AM

    By the way I don’t recall anyone going gaga over JTYJN over here. I certainly had this reaction with TZP and I devoted a long piece to it. On the other hand I found JTYJN enjoyable enough and wrote a brief comment on it. Yes, I have gone gaga over the box office because I am thrilled with the film’s success. And yes I am thrilled BECAUSE it’s AAMIR’s production and is a HUGE feather in his cap. This film has just about become an Aamir release (as if he had starred in it!). But also JTYJN is a genuine superhit/blockbuster. A 5-7 crore film making this kind of money, it’s a historic hit. It’s not like some of the year’s other hits/superhits that were questionable in terms of profitability (and I’m not talking Jannat here!).

  10. rockstar
    rockstar
    July 17, 2008 at 8:50 AM

    “Looks like people are unfairly in a mood to accept this movie. Its good because nothing else is better seems to be the reason. And then there are psuedos who would rename anything with Aamir’s name in it to something good.”

    agree to a little extent but again everyone will have different opinion on it isn’t it but its a fact to most of the directors have given their best product with aamir only

  11. satyam
    satyam
    July 17, 2008 at 8:55 AM

    Since Rks has closed the other thread let me respond briefly here:

    Mr Bond: yes I know which I why I did not take offense!

    Qalandar: Thanks.. it’s a point I often try to make..

    Jay: Agreed on your star son thing. Raj Kapoor as I pointed out is the biggest example. Of course it’s humorous to see a position being posited whereby it’s ok to get that first big break because of a connection but not any future ones! I wonder why Roshan then had to do a rescue job and reinvent his son with KMG and Krrish! Anyway don’t want to relaunch that thread here but this kind of split is bizarre to say the least.

  12. Rocky
    Rocky
    July 17, 2008 at 8:59 AM

    Jay , agree with Ravi, very nice thoughts on star sons.

  13. rks
    rks
    July 17, 2008 at 9:01 AM

    Nithi: Good thoughts.. I disagree with execution comment..I think that was the only part which saved the movie..Holistically, it is barely a decent movie..Then it tells us the the stuff we churn out of bollywood that a movie which is barely better than other is doing wonderful business.

    Jay: That was a good comment in other thread.

    Aside: I just cringe the way the fight started in other thread. We are adults, we need to give respect to others and expect some respect in return.

  14. Mr. Bond
    Mr. Bond
    July 17, 2008 at 9:19 AM

    Agreed rks, and I will try not to retaliate again but some people make personal attack just because you criticize a star (everyone has his/her opinion). I have hardly been commenting for months but have been following enough to know that certain members become too rude and resort to personal attack and I was already sick of it and lost my mind. I will be much more careful next time as I know its not worth it. I will also go back to my occasional commenting.

  15. jayshah
    jayshah
    July 17, 2008 at 9:32 AM

    nithi – so you liked Imran? Didn’t he remind you of Aamir in anyway?

  16. jayshah
    jayshah
    July 18, 2008 at 12:26 AM

    He reminded me of Aamir in one scene – the scene where he gets ready to fight early on, he starts to clap his hands and circle that guy, throws his hands round…but in general otherwise except for a bit of similarity in looks, there acting style are different…

    “Oh God! This guy is just a clone of Aamir”

    I’m it would have made your day…one is not enough for you, another one would have been great!

  17. utkal
    utkal
    July 18, 2008 at 12:46 AM

    My comments are aimed at all those who keep on harping about the story being nothing new. Come on guys, a film is not its ‘story’ just as a painting is not its subject. And what is making it a monster hot is not that ‘ it’s just about better than all the trash on offer’ but that fact that the audience is connecting with the film and that it feels really DIFFERENT. Many have said that the film is quite ORDINARY. That is it’s strength. It’s not trying to tell a big story a la RDB, or pull out a big melodrama a la DCH ( with a dying Dimple and all that.) And that’s what makes it refreshing. Young audiences all across the country can relate to the characters as real people and not some filmy characters. Its unpretentiousness is what charms you. Just the way HAHK with its ‘ no story/ and ‘ no directorial artistry’ did. But look closely and you will note how cleverly the ‘ordinariness’ has been achieved. How many critics or columnists here noticed that the film had only 3 and half songs choreographed? Or that Imran Khan wore his own clothes? Or how every actor from Naseer and Ratna to Prateek Babbar and the Khan brothers and Paresh Rawal have been so judiciously and optimally used. In fact the screen mother persona of Ratna is as refreshing today as the screen mother portrayed by Reema Lagu was in times of HAHK. That is the kind of generational shift that gives birth to monster hits and next-gen stars.

  18. satyam
    satyam
    July 18, 2008 at 9:14 AM

    Utkal: A good set of comments here..

Page 1 of 1

Post Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

vicodin withdrawal symptoms how long does it last viagra pills cost nimesulide tablets alpalide nexium generic equivalent buy mifepristone mercury pharmacy philippines viagra hk endometrin without prescription xenical weight loss stories finpecia tablets usp finasteride online paypal online viagra sales canada advantage car rental phone number retin a cream 0.1 for sale real viagra pills omnicef for utis buy buspar cheap elomet ointment mometasone furoate cream cipro antibiotics side effects buy viagra in lanzarote lexapro weight gain lexapro withdrawal mexican pharcharmy online buy clonazepam online dermasone 0.05 cream allopurinol drug reactions furolin medicine dictionary cialis walmart singulair allergy medicine side effects cialis active over the counter fafipa vestibular hydroxyzine for dogs dosage zineryt cena de navidad cheap cialis not generic hydrodiuril dosage diltiazem hydrochloride extended release capsules cheapest prozac online cialis 40mg professional for sale octreotide acetate side effects cheap retin a is revatio genericrevia where can i get viagra fast ciprotab 2500 proviron mesterolone cycle over the counter femara atacand medication for high blood pressure priligy hong kong buy over the counter zofran cialis 50 mg supreme suppliers viagra nexium otc pharmacy online usa have clomiphene sulfasalazine azulfidine side effects ciprobay antibiotic side effects online viagra review female viagra sildenafil protonix side effects protonix 40 mg elimite permethrin bed bugs androgel coupon tindamax tinidazole side effects periactin for sale lortab 7.5 mg picture buy sildenafil revatio mentat himalaya prospect cialis for slae cheap dth 24b kamal kunj s v road vicodin overdose symptoms side effects yasminelle ulotka biedronka mometasone cream used for raloxifene hormone therapy for breast cancer trileptal medication for children buy flunitrazepam online hytrin side effects doctor naproxen sodium side effects tabletten gegen hautpilz was tun buspar without a prescription fluoxetine hcl 10mg pricing ciplafield eas req status bar thuoc renapril 5mg valium allegra d side effects medication nimesulide side effects nsaids xalatan no prescription haloperidol 5 mg tablet mexican pharmacies online cheap biorezonanta magnetica forum zyprexa for anxiety and depression citrate of magnesia how long does it take to work propranolol 40mg doxycap antibiotics for bronchitis cafergot from mexico buy xenical over the counter homeopathic medicine vigora 5000 purchasing clonidine leponex clozapine dose lagatrim tablets for kids nitrazepam dosage of aspirin progesterone suppositories side effects marcumar medication identification ditropan xl 10mg side effects adderall weight loss before and after acheter viagra original en ligne lynoral tablets for kids citalopram canada pharmacy american made and shipped viagra levitra walmart will marijuana affect cialis dosage for zyban to quit smoking domperidone dosage gastroparesis purchase cialis daily azithromycin 600 for sale northern canadian pharmacy online cialis without a prescription valium side effects in elderly purchase viagra online pay with check viagra 500mg price pfizer patient assistance program phone number levoxyl vs synthroid viagra kaufen mit mastercard blycolin groepsaccommodatie isoptin sr 240 mg proviron side effects hair loss albuterol inhaler side effects doctor ventolin from canada cenveo envelope locations alfuzosin hcl 10mg viagra kaufen in deutschland silagra without prescription can you really order cialis online danazol uses for men accutane prescriptions buy clomiphene in uk nexium esomeprazole 20mg in uk where to purchase arjuna sotalol medication for heart avelox dosing for uti jasmine rice with coconut milk retin a without a prescription zyloprim 100 mg para que sirve canadian meds pharmacy aldara cream side effects on skin how much is adderall without insurance evista drug for osteoporosis levofloxacin and alcohol use lamisil tablets price cheapest cialis 5mg cheapest place to buy viagra online viagra ordine telefonico flovent hfa 44mcg where to buy luvox pills glyprin aspirin 40 viagra pills for 99 dollars cialis free trials estradiol valerate estrogens erection problems natural remedies virectin reviews side effects clindamycin hcl 300 mg uses cheap viagra or levitra indocin for preterm labor dose trazodone sleep desyrel medication increasing testosterone by diet stediril online sildenafil ranbaxy buy fluoxetine 20 mg xalatan eye drops pravachol to lipitorprazosin no script zoloft cialis tablete cena minomycin information systems can you buy cialis in dubai cramping after taking letrozole for fertility order prednisone without rx elavil information for sleep asthma attack symptoms online viagra prescription quanto costa il cialis best price for viagra 100mg generic cialis paypal omeprazole medication class estrace side effects lortab 10 325 bactrim ds without script cialis 5mg prix best price ed medications crestor vs lipitor 2012 insulin resistance diet plan order alli diet pills online no prescription clavamox for cats arcoxia 60mg price pyridium drug classification is propecia right for you viagra sites that are real tamsulosin 0.4 mg for kidney stones betneval lotion making floxin ear drops side effects wellbutrin side effects weight loss salibet ointment lipvas tablets for sale zantac 150 dosage directions domperidone breastfeeding reviews feldene medication pharmacies america cialis cyprus valium vs xanax for sleep propranolol hydrochloride adverse effects cephalexin 500mg side effects leponex drug study vardenafil hcl 10mg generic verapamil 240 mg er capsules coumadin side effects warfarin antepsin without prescription buspar side effects and interactions order viagra c o d and pay later therapy dogs international pramipexole 0.25 mg rls generic viagra spain sildenafil 100mg 30 pills rocket launcher buy antibiotics uk non perscription valtrex entocort ec samples buy plavix on line no prescription free generic viagra samples fanegada conversion fahrenheit buy metronidazole lisan awc canadian pharmacies imiquimod 5 cream packet nifedipine topical side effects medication cheap quick cialis rimadyl 25mg dogs dosage donepezil 5 mg tablets feldene gel uk budesonide inhalation brand name woman viagra doxyval 20 en pharmacie lidoderm patch 5 12 hours overnight cialis in us diazepam for dogs with seizures internet drugstore raymeds complaints about doctors vigra price orlistat weight loss aid ampicillin sulbactam brand name salbutamol on line doxycycline side effects headache tadalafil soft gel capsule sertralina efectos a largo plazo de la atomoxetine mechanism of action cafergot order 30 pills cheap erection pills singulair dosage for children cialis for daily use cost 338 betneval lotion valium vs xanax dosage altace 10 mg dose keflex antibiotic information cephalexin vermox side effects doctor can i buy podofilox over the counter quinine tonic water 39 vigara order brand name synthroid adipex weight loss reviews vosteran removal instructions flexeril and pregnancy chloramphenicol 250 mg contrave diet pill coupon benazepril hctz 10 12.5 side effectsbenfotiaminbestherbal can cialis be purchased next day viagra usa zyban patient reviews casodex bicalutamide 50mg seroquel side effects constipation budesonide drug cost at walgreens e20 tablet for premature ejactulation nitrazepam dosage for melatonin generic viagra wikipedia diflucan and alcohol tijuana pharmacy prices amoxil 875 for sinus infection pastile e 200 cheap cialis from india levitra vs cialis reviews non drowsy benadryl cialis gratui polarmeds reviews on fifty zolpidem 10mg side effects alli capsules cheap clomiphene androfin reviews atrovent inhaler peanut allergy nexium 40mg doxycycl hyc sildenafil 50 mg prices salbutamol nebulizer medication drug study cialis5mg sold on line albendazole without prescription sildenafil cialis perlutex cat stevens amantadina clordenamine pfizer viagra price in india cialis with dapoxetine 80mg vibramycin syrup advair coupons $20 advair coupon pfizer viagra sales atorlip 20 mg adderall duetact medication interaction how much is nexium at walmart best price cialis 20mg usa canada sildenafil tablets where can i buy cheap viagra sertraline mexico venta de cialis black cialis 800 mg best prices proviron 25mg schering trazodone for insomnia and anxiety advantage real estate michigan buy seroquil legally canadian pharmacy no prescriptions sinequanone paris dresses ramipril medication 10 mg bevispas side effects prazosin medication for cats canada pharmacies cialis colospan 10 mg hydrocodone ciallis or viagra olanzapine for sale from canada coumadin vitamin k foods to avoid coumadin diet non prescription celebrex alternatives free viagra samples from pfizer avodart coupon free sildenafil kaufen ohne rezept lipvas cipla india search rhine pharmacy duramycin for gonorrhea buy atorvastatin 20mg ivermectin for horses used on dogs frumil lse medicinenet art main script buy flagyl 400 mg shipping nitrofurantoin buy online mebendazole dosage eprex liturgia de las horas laudes viagra best price online viagra without script cholesterol lowering diets and recipes cephalexin 500mg capsule antibiotic avelox generic equivalent hyzaar 50 12.5 and viagra cialas 800 mg can i use eurax cream for thrush euroclinix opinieland liquid cialis for sale zithrogen 500 million advantage flea control coupons what viagra is best best price viagra 100mg costco viagra for sell buspar medication reviews pramipexole dihydrochloride 1mg viagra no prescription checking account chlamydia discharge men furolin dosage berifen medicinal plant xenial india retin a canada blopress 8mg risperdal lawsuit attorneys medameds rapidshare files septra ds 800 160 infatrim obat apa buy codeine cough syrup buying cialis in montreal flovent diskus 50mcg drugstore cowboy full movie buylowdrugs canada pharmacy cheap viagra in uk risperdal without prescription diabecon ingredients for lasagna buy clonidine uk euroclinix reviews on 50 what is prandin 2mg forpravachol differin gel 0.3 savings page plavix manufacturer assistance progreso mexico pharmacy nitroglycerin ointment buy at store boots promo code trental 400mg cr zofran dosage for children with stomach virus proscar 5mg cost buy medical pill buy lipitor levomax 500 uputstvo brand levitra 20mg cheap crestor bill without prescription vega 100mg metrogel 1 online direct pharmacy usa viagra fast delivery no prescription diarex polishing pads best ed pill over the counter provera side effects breast tenderness atacand candesartan cilexetil tablets rythmol side effects medication trusted cialis suppliers best over the counter viagra motrin dosage by weight advair coupons $50.00 off 2014 sifrol pramipexole buy inderal from canada no prescription arimidex cheap cataflam side effects vicodin addiction symptoms drug proventil inhaler medication price online pharmacy singapore order viagra online vicodin overdose treatment buy generic clomid clotrimazole and betamethasone cream for ringworm salzarex thyroxine t4 antibiotics online paypal pravastatin and grapefruit juice bisoprolol 5mg tab propecia price australia buy cialis amazon online pharmacies for viagra singulair allergy medicine side effects for children cheap generic viagra co uk amantadine medication side effects januvia medication side effects irbesartan 150 mg tablets buying accutane online 2013 buy zoloft on line famciclovir side effects pacific care pharmacy online dutasteride avodart for sale kemadrin drug grathazon 0 5 mg suhagra 50 advantages of solar mirapex er side effects verapamil er 240 mg atomoxetine strattera weight loss xanax alprazolam dosage amounts clavupen gutis maximus buy diflucan canada piadas do tiririca flexeril information online buy viagra ae atacand on sale octreotide drip protocol motilium tablets uses cialis en venta aggrenox medication what is it for tempo dazione del viagra sandoz without a prescription brand viagra cialis manufacturer coupon eli lilly cymbalta coupons magnesium supplements for kids anxiety in children with adhd doxycycline monohydrate 100mg for acne biaxin xl 500mg side effects cefixime 400 mg uk motilium for sale tamoxifen citrate for sale no prescription needed for levitra prometrium 100mg what does cialis cost at walgreens temovate cream 0 05 uses for vinegar my order status info low dose viagara from canada keflex and breastfeeding safety ativan side effects dose avodart side effects dutasteride non rx canada mirtazapine for dogs appetite cialis safe order liquidex bodybuilding competitions mebendazole dosage for adults femara drug assistance trimetabol sirop de artar furacin nitrofurazone fanegada conversion factorsfaridexon epratenz dox potassium deficiency symptoms women motilium drug super kamagra zyvox side effects in elderly mirtazapine for cats with renal failure ed drugs online from canada indian viagras viagara in three days phexin bd tablets at walmart viagra on line best price reviews levitra free shipping prilosec otc side effects headache amerimedrx discount airfare amerimedrx complaints against dentists cardizem side effects with cats www cialis venta ohio accutane results after 3 weeks reductil 1 dollar 99 cents omeprazole medication zentel albendazole 0.2g lady era tablets