Why are you guilty..?

http://www.changethatsrightnow.....=3975:1428

Someone needs this

Yes, that’s sad but true.

Good point by Sunny. Its natural thing for a fan of a star or a hater of a star, to do set different standards for different actors.

Ideally at least in a site like NG, we need more movie buffs than crazy fans or crazy haters. But as always, NG reviews get skewed with celebrity obsessions and compulsions.

Who is pretentious? Who is snooty?

“Better than “Look, me no panty” types”!!!

Why such extremely distasteful comments always get wah-wah response from the male crowd in NG???

so you are a salman fan – now whatever respect i had for you has vanished..lol. I hope you have a good sense of humor like shetty or you are as gorgeous as Deeps, coz those are the only factors that can salvage Salman fans
btw – where are you from?

Rohit, damn you..at least let us edit our comments if not someone else’s posts. Sheekss!!

Aargh. This is far more worser than Heyy Babby comedy.

Shetty gaaru nowadays have been hooked by Bhojpuri flicks off late even since he came to know about Sallu.

As I keep following its trend on Bhojpuri flicks, he regulary seeks an update.

Gangotri is the next bhojpuri blockbuster that stars Amitabh opposite his heroine(Salman in an esp appearance as salmani begum) and Katrina Kaif plays the role of Gangotri, who form the third triangle in this love stroy epic.

Nitesh–are you on a ‘chaar dham’ ki yaatra or something? Why does Shetty garu keep asking you about Gangotri?

How was GANGOTRI?

LOL @ Shettybhai’s comment!

Cmon Nitesh, you can do better

A.Shah

so jesse – are you going to chastize ms sakshi for these comments or just bcoz she calls you sweetie – you rolleth over….
as far as giving a …. is concerned, people living in …. houses should not throw …..

>Coming from you, that is a compliment

you bet, its the worst review for a while. so it does get the WTF award from me

Sandy: Looking forward to your SAWARIYA review!

A.Shah

“For me Main hoon naa was the ultimate masala movie from SRK…”–Nitesh that holds true for me too , and i’m just about to watch MHN as we speak!

Jesse – Thanks Sweetie but you know I actually don’t give a fart to what others think. When I write a review or more aptly, my thoughts on a film…I only think about myself. So yeah…others can go and take a doopaki in the samundar near SRK’s house, for all I care.

Abzee – You have no idea, it was such joy to use the word “bundal” after so long.

Fari aunty, Sandy, Nithya, Shruthi, Sash, Kavita kaul, Nitesh….

“how can you not like it with deeps looking so gorgeous”

Bend over, Relax

Shetty- How many female members does NG have? Quite frankly, we are just slightly better than the male universe of Matrubhoomi. We seriously need more female members around NG. Whatever happend to SMR?

Coming from you, that is a compliment

Better than “Look, me no panty” types

spoken like a true hrithik roshan fan. I thought what little we saw of Dhoom 5 was better than D2…lol

whats with the Bold font ach – itna bura laga kya

srk boss – please do some CDI type movies instead of hamming like there is no tomorrow!

I however have absolutely no doubt that OSO will be a hit but then compared to other SRK’s masala film, OSO is below Main Hoon Naa.

For me Main hoon naa was the ultimate masala movie from SRK…

I liked SRK’s part in OSO but thought Farha Khan’s limitations were exposed when she was dealing with the reincarnation bit.

Sandy, you are the most vociferous supporter of OSO leaving behind Som and Beld….

Aisa bhi kya that OSO mein….???? Did you really enjoy OSO?

Your review and words seems to make OSO look better than even JWM….which in my opinion is far more entertaining along with Bhool Bhulaiya and Heyy Babyy.

Glad to know that!

Jesse: This is downright slanderous! Show me one piece I have written as a post that makes such offhand statements. Please see my Mangal Pandey post and check the pains I have taken to present my points. Ditto Lajo, Ditto Mani Ratnam.

http://www.naachgaana.com/2007/10/26/mangal-pandey-the-legend-the-lie/

http://www.naachgaana.com/2007.....ic-choice/

My integrity means everything to me and I have never indulged in such vengeful, hitting-below the belt criticism in any case. I may have been ferocious in my defence or criticism but never once have I done what you are accusing me of.

If you will bother yourself a bit to read teh above posts, you will see I have offered ample verifiable evidence for each of my points of criticism.

jeese:no i didn’t mean you.there are some who tries to question the credibility of the critics when they have liked a film of srk.i dont think same thing happens with other actor’s movies.did anyone say BR does not know how to review a film when he gave a very good review to JBJ which many disliked the movie?did anyone attack guys like Akshay,qalandar when they did not like OSO?i think one should talk about himself/herself rather than passing judgement on the credibility and honesty of others which Sakshi has done in her review.

No offense Sandy, but isn’t this EXACTLY what you do when it comes Mani Ratnam, MP, etc?

but i never seen anyone complaining about and raising these issues relating to other big films.why is the credibillity of critics always underthe scanner when it comes to movies like CDI and OSO just becausse you did not like the movie?

such a disgraceful statement.i dont understand why some try to make some senseless inferences when their views dont match to others.if you dont like the movie, thats fine but atleast dont try to get judgemental of others who liked the movie.if every critics can be bought so easily and their views are biased, then i guess every producers will try to do that and get some glowing reviews for their films.it just does not work that way.if we cant take the critics as credible enough, then why would someone like to know our thoughts on movies as we are also humanbeings and can be biased too?

This is such a presumptious statement. I liked OSO and gave it a good review (just like many others), does this mean we’ve been bought?